The anonymous Syrian film collective Abounaddara has posted a new short video on Vimeo and distributed it via social media every Friday since April 2011, the beginning of the Syrian popular uprising. Working with limited equipment, no regular funding, and under very dangerous conditions, Abounaddara has termed its work ‘emergency cinema’, recalling one of the group’s vital influences, Walter Benjamin, who envisioned artistic collectives as potentially effective responses to political violence. This article demonstrates how Abounaddara’s work subverts international and national media coverage of the Syrian conflict by consciously employing what Benjamin described as an artisanal form of storytelling. The author illustrates how and why Abounaddara’s concept of ‘the right to the image’ is politically vital and ethically complex, arguing for its relevance within the broader context of global digital images of state and police violence rousing debates about representation, media ethics, and the circulation of graphic images.
Abounaddara (2017a) Dignity has never been photographed. documenta14, 24March.
2.
Abounaddara (2017b) Something is rotten. documenta 14, 2March.
3.
AlexanderE (1994) Can you be black and look at this? Reading the Rodney King Video(s). Public Culture7(1): 77–94.
4.
AllanS (2013) Citizen Witnessing: Revisioning Journalism in Times of Crisis. London: Polity.
5.
American Artist (2016) A declaration of the dignity image. The New Inquiry, 13September.
6.
AmiralayO (2007) ‘Documentary, history and memory’, Di/Visions, Culture and Politics of the Middle East, EUME-HKW Conference. Interview originally in French, translation by the author.
7.
Andén-PapadopoulosK (2013) The media work of Syrian diaspora activists. International Journal of Communication7: 2185–2206.
8.
Anonymous (2014) Beheading video stirs debate on social media censorship. NPR, 26August.
9.
AzoulayA (2008) The Civil Contract of Photography. New York: Zone Books.
10.
BakerC (2016) The E-snuff of Alton Sterling and Philando Castile. Los Angeles Review of Books, 8July.
11.
BarakehK (2014) Artistic responses to the violence in Syria. In: HalasaM, et al. (eds) Syria Speaks: Art and Culture from the Frontline. London: Saqi Books, 157–164.
12.
BarakehK (2018) The untitled images. Cinema Journal57(4): 142–145.
13.
BarbasS (2012) The laws of image. New England Law Review47: 23–92.
14.
BarthesR (1983) Camera Lucida: Reflections on Photography. New York: Hill and Wang.
15.
BaumanJ (2014) The iconic Boston bombing photograph isn't about my legs – it’s about a rescue. The Guardian, 14April.
16.
BayoumiM (2015) The civil war in Syria is invisible – but this anonymous film collective is changing that. The Nation, 29June.
17.
BeckU (2006) The Cosmopolitan Vision. London: Polity.
BelloG (2015) Mohammad Ali Atassi: Syria in its own image. Guernica, 16February.
20.
BenhabibS (2004) The Rights of Others: Aliens, Residents and Citizens (The John Seeley Memorial Lectures). Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
21.
BenjaminW (1921) Critique of violence. In: Selected Writings, Vol. 1, 1913–1926. Cambridge, MA: Belknap Press of Harvard University Press.
22.
BenjaminW (1968a) Ninth thesis on the philosophy of history. In: Illuminations. New York: Schocken.
23.
BenjaminW (1968b) The storyteller: Reflections on the works of Nikolai Leskov. In: ArendtH (ed.) Illuminations. New York: Vintage.
24.
BenjaminW (2008[1936]) The Work of Art in the Age of Its Technological Reproducibility and Other Writings on Media. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.
25.
BlayZ (2016) Alton Sterling, Philando Castile, and the indignity of black death. Huffington Post, 7July.
26.
BoëxC (2012) Emergency cinema, an interview with Syrian collective Abounaddara. Books and Ideas, 5October.
27.
BoucherB (2017) Dana Schutz responds to the uproar over her Emmett Till painting at the Whitney Biennial. Artnet News, 23March.
28.
BucherNR (2017) Mokdad’s 300 Miles: The dilemma of activist documentaries. Syria Untold, 28April.
29.
ButlerJ (2004) Precarious Life: The Powers of Mourning and Violence. New York: Verso.
30.
ButlerJ (2011) Precarious life and the obligations of cohabitation. Talk at Nobel Museum, Stockholm.
31.
CampbellD (2004) Horrific blindness: Images of death in contemporary media. Journal for Cultural Research8(1): 55–74.
32.
ChouliarakiL (2006) The Spectatorship of Suffering. London: Sage.
33.
CobbJ (2016) Three terrible days of violence. The New Yorker, 8July.
34.
CreswellR (2016) Voices from a different Syria. New York Review of Books Daily, 21March.
35.
DeanJ (2010) Blog Theory. Cambridge: Polity.
36.
DebordG (1983) The Society of the Spectacle. London: Rebel Press.
37.
DerridaJ (2000) The Instant of My Death/Demeure. Stanford, CA: Stanford University Press.
38.
Didi-HubermanG (2003) Images in Spite of All: Four Photographs from Auschwitz. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.
39.
DorkZ (2018) La Syrie en images: de la banalisation de l’horreur à l’horreur du banal. AOC.media, 23April.
40.
EvansBGirouxH (2015) Disposable Futures: The Seduction of Violence in the Age of Spectacle. San Francisco: City Lights.
41.
FoucaultM (1994[1974]) ‘Anti-Rétro’, Interview with Michel Foucault. Cahiers du cinema 251–252, July–August: 5–15. Republished in: DefertD, et al. (eds) Michel Foucault, Dits et écrits2. Paris: Gallimard, 646–660.
42.
FoxJ and the Abounaddara Film Collective (2018) Representational regimes: A conversation with the Abounaddara film collective. World Records Journal1(10).
43.
FrankP (2017) A white artist’s painting of Emmett Till sparks protest, controversy and a viral hoax, Huffington Post, 28March.
44.
GayR (2016) Alton Sterling and when black lives stop mattering. The New York Times, 6July.
45.
GowingN (2009) Skyful of lies and black swans. Challenges Paper, Reuters Institute for the Study of Journalism, Oxford.
46.
GreenbergerA (2017) The painting must go: Hannah Black pens open letter to the Whitney about controversial biennial work. ArtNews, 21March.
47.
GregoryS (2015) Ubiquitous witnesses: Who creates the evidence and the live(d) experience of human rights violations?Information, Communication & Society18(11): 1378–1392.
48.
GrønstadA (2019) Invisibility and the ethics of erasure: Khaled Barakeh’s ‘The Untitled Images’. In: Invisibility in Visual and Material Culture. London: Palgrave Macmillan, 111–124.
49.
GürselZD (2016) Image Brokers: Visualizing World News in the Age of Digital Circulation. Oakland: University of California Press.
50.
HalasaMOmareenZMahfoudN (eds) (2014) Syria Speaks: Art and Culture from the Frontline. London: Saqi Books.
51.
HallS (ed.) (1997) Culture, Media and Identities: Representation, Cultural Representations and Signifying Practices. Thousand Oaks, CA: Sage.
52.
HarkinJ, et al. (2012) Deciphering User-Generated Content in Transition Societies: A Syria Coverage Case Study. Washington, DC: Center for Global Communication Studies, Annenberg School for Communication, Internews Center for Innovation and Learning.
53.
HelmA (2017) More Americans killed by police in 2017, but Trump dominates headlines. The Root, 4 April. Available at: http://www.killedbypolice.net (accessed 19 October 2019).
54.
HeverlyR (2011) One piece of the puzzle: A private right to your image in the digital age. I/S: A Journal of Law & Policy for the Information Society. Albany Law School Research Paper No. 4: 1–20.
55.
HobbsA (2016) The power of looking, from Emmett Till to Philando Castile. The New Yorker, 5August.
56.
JafaACamptT (2017) Love is the message, the plan is death. Eflux Journal81, April.
57.
JoerckC (2015) Liwaa Yazji discusses her filmHaunted (Maskoon). Union Docs Center for Documentary Art, 9 December.
58.
KalthoumZ (2017) Taste of cement. Interview, Visions du Réel.
59.
KenaanH (2013) The Ethics of Visuality: Levinas and the Contemporary Gaze. London: Bloomsbury.
60.
KeenanTZolghadrT (eds) (2013) The Human Snapshot. Feldmailen, Switzerland: LUMA Foundation.
KratzerMKratzerRKratzerB (2003) How newspapers decided to run disturbing 9/11 photos. Newspaper Research Journal 24(1).
63.
KreimerSF (2011) Pervasive image capture and the First Amendment: Memory, discourse, and the right to record. University of Pennsylvania Law Review159(2): 335–410.
64.
LevinasE (1994) Outside the Subject. Stanford, CA: Stanford University Press.
65.
LogeaisESchroederJ (1998) The French right of image: An ambiguous concept protecting the human persona. Loyola of Los Angeles Entertainment Law Review18: 511–542.
66.
LynchM (2011) After Egypt: The limits and promise of challenges to the authoritarian Arab State. Perspectives on Politics9(2): 301–310.
67.
LynchMFreelonDAdayS (2014) Syria’s Socially Mediated Civil War. Report, United States Institute of Peace, Washington, DC.
68.
MassieC (2014) To publish or not: James Foley video spotlights media’s tough call. Columbia Journalism Review, 22August.
69.
Mejcher-AtassiS (2014) Abounaddara’s take on images in the Syrian Revolution: A conversation between Charif Kiwan and Akram Zaatari. Jadaliyya, 8July.
70.
MitchellT (1992) Orientalism and the exhibitionary order. In: DirksN (ed.) Colonialism and Culture. Ann Arbor: University of Michigan Press.
71.
MitterS (2017) What does it mean to be black and look at this? A scholar reflects on the Dana Schutz controversy. Hyperallergic, 24March.
72.
MoellerS (1999) Compassion Fatigue: How the Media Sell Disease, Famine, War and Death. New York: Routledge.
73.
MohebbiS (2016) The right to one’s self image. In: BalsomEPelegH (eds) Documentary across Disciplines. Cambridge, MA: MIT Press.
74.
MohebbiS (2017) Shapes of the future: The internet in the Syrian civil war. In: KeenanT, et al. (eds) The Flood of Rights. New York: Sternberg Press.
75.
MrouéRNawfalZMartinC (2012) The pixelated revolution. TDR: The Drama Review56(3): 18–35.
76.
Muñoz-AlonsoL (2015) Syrian film collective Abounaddara withdraws from Venice Biennale claiming censorship. Artnet.com, 13May.
77.
MutuaM (1999) INGOs as political actors. American Society of International Law, Proceedings of the 93rd Annual Meeting, 210–211.
78.
MutuaM (2001) Savages, victims, and saviors. Harvard International Law Journal42(1): 201–245.
79.
PanttiM (2013) Seeing and not seeing the Syrian crisis: New visibility and the visual framing of the Syrian conflict in seven newspapers and their online editions. Journalism, Media and Cultural Studies: 1–22.
80.
PozorskiA (2018) Journalism’s falling man: On documentation and truth telling. Polysèmes 19, 30June.
81.
RancièreJ (2010[1999]) One image right can sweep away another, trans. S Corcoran. In: Chronicles of Consensual Times. London: Continuum.
82.
RentschlerC (2004) Witnessing: US citizenship and the vicarious experience of suffering. Media, Culture & Society26(2): 296–304.
83.
RifaiF (2017) Detainees: Osama al-Habali executed in Sednaya prison, sister says. Zaman al-Wasl, 25May.
84.
RohdeM, et al. (2016) Out of Syria: Mobile media in use at the time of civil war. International Journal of Human–Computer Interaction, 12April.
85.
RubinA (2016) Case against photographer over Paris massacre picture is dismissed. The New York Times, 20May.
86.
SaiF (2015) The limits of representation: The transformation of aesthetics in Syrian artistic and social discourse. La Rivista de Arablit V(9/10): 106–113.
87.
SaidE (1978) Orientalism. New York: Vintage.
88.
SawahWKawakibiS (2014) Activism in Syria: Between nonviolence and armed resistance. In: KhatibLLustE (eds) Taking to the Streets: The Transformation of Arab Activism. Baltimore, MD: Johns Hopkins University Press.
89.
SeggermanAD (2019) Modernism on the Nile: Art in Egypt between the Islamic and the ContemporaryDurham: University of North Carolina Press.
90.
SekulaA (1978) Dismantling modernism, reinventing documentary (notes on the politics of representation). The Massachusetts Review19(4): 859–883.
91.
ShirkyC (2009) Here Comes Everybody. New York: Penguin
92.
ShirkyC (2011) The political power of social media. Foreign Affairs: 28–41.
93.
ShohatEStamR (1994) Unthinking Eurocentrism: Multiculturalism and the Media. New York: Routledge.
94.
SikkinkK (2011) The Justice Cascade: How Human Rights Prosecutions Are Changing World Politics. New York: WW Norton & Co.
95.
SontagS (1977) On Photography. New York: Picador.
96.
SontagS (2003) Regarding the Pain of Others. New York: Picador.
97.
SontagS (2004) Regarding the torture of others, The New York Times, 23May.
98.
SteyerlH (2009) In defense of the poor image. e-flux #10.
99.
Syrian Network for Human Rights (2017) Media activist died due to torture in Syrian regime Saydnaya Prison, 23May.
100.
TaylorJFA (1998) Body Horror: Photojournalism, Catastrophe and War (Critical Image). New York: New York University Press.
101.
ToorA (2016) Photojournalist faces criminal charge over image of Paris attack victim. The Verge, 19May.
102.
VandevoordtR (2016) Covering the Syrian conflict: How Middle East reporters deal with challenging situations. Media, War & Conflict9(3): 306–324.
103.
VirilioP (1999) Politics of the Very Worst. Cambridge, MA: MIT Press.
104.
Wahl-JorgensenKPantiiM (2013) Ethics of global disaster reporting: Journalistic witnessing and objectivity. In WardSJA (ed.) Global Media Ethics: Problems and Perspectives. New York: Wiley, 191–213.
105.
WallMZahedSE (2015) Embedding content from Syrian citizen journalists: The rise of the collaborative news clip. Journalism16(2): 163–180.
106.
WarrenJ (2016) New York Daily News editor didn’t think twice about running graphic photo. Poynter.org, 7July.
107.
WedeenL (1999) Ambiguities of Domination: Politics, Rhetoric, and Symbols in Contemporary Syria. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.
108.
WilliamsS (2016) How does a steady stream of images of black death affect us?NBCNews.com, 11July.
109.
WilliamsT (2016) Study supports suspicion that police are more likely to use force on blacks. The New York Times, 7July.
110.
ZabalaS (2017) Why Only Art Can Save Us. New York: Columbia University Press.
111.
ZelizerB (2010) About to Die: How News Images Move the Public. New York: Oxford University Press.
112.
Abounaddara (2013a) Respectons le droit à l’image pour le peuple syrien. Libération, 22January.
113.
Abounaddara (2013b) En Syrie, refusons la fable d'un Orient compliqué. Le Monde, 25September.
114.
Abounaddara (2014a) Cellphone war reporting dumbs down the truth. Newsweek, 12July.
115.
Abounaddara (2014b) Ne réduisons pas les Syriens aux images diffusées par la télé. Le Monde, 21October.
116.
Abounaddara (2014c) Syrie: La guerre au temps du télévampirisme. Libération, 14December.
117.
Abounaddara (2015) A bas les héros de la révolution syrienne!Libération, 12January.
118.
Abounaddara (2016) Regarding the spectacle. The Nation, 2December.
119.
AdamiE (2016) How do you watch a revolution? Notes from the 21st century. Journal of Visual Culture15(1): 69–84.
120.
Andén-PapadopoulosK (2014) Citizen camera-witnessing: Embodied political dissent in the age of mediated mass self-communication. New Media & Society16(5): 753–769.
121.
AyadC (2013) Le collectif Abou Naddara: Les images dans la révolution syrienne. CRÉER. Arte, 14March.
122.
AzoulayA (2011) A civil state of emergency. Artforum, December.
123.
AzoulayAOphirA (2009) The order of violence. In: The Power of Inclusive Exclusion: Anatomy of Israeli Rule in the Occupied Territories. New York: Zone Books.
124.
BatchenGE, et al. (2012) Picturing AtrocityLondon: Reaktion.
125.
BaumanJ (2014) The iconic Boston bombing photograph isn't about my legs – it’s about a rescue. The Guardian, 14April.
126.
BédaridaC (2014) Syrie: Les visages des sans-noms. Mouvement, May–June.
127.
BenjaminW (1968) Illuminations. New York: Schocken Books.
128.
BenjaminW (1999[1927–1939]) Arcades Project. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.
129.
BergerJ (1980) Understanding a photograph. In: TrachtenbergA (ed.) Classic Essays on Photography. New Haven, CT: Leete’s Island Books.
130.
BoltanskiL (1999) Distant Suffering Morality, Media, and Politics. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
131.
BramleyEV (2014) Behind the scenes with Syria’s emergency cinema. The Guardian, 26March.
132.
Buck-MorssS (1989) The Dialectics of Seeing: Walter Benjamin and the Arcades Project. Cambridge, MA: MIT Press.
133.
CadavaE (1998) Words of Light: Theses on the Photography of History. Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press.
FarleyAP (1997) The black body as fetish object. Oregon Law Review76: 457–486.
137.
JuhaszA (2016) How do I (not) look? Live feed video and viral black death. JSTOR Daily, 20July.
138.
KhatibL (2012) Image Politics in the Middle East: The Role of the Visual in Political Struggle. New York: Taurus.
139.
KifnerJ (2001) A pictorial guide to hell: Stark images trace the Balkans’ descent and a photographer’s determination. New York Times, 24January.
140.
LinfieldS (2010) The Cruel Radiance. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.
141.
McLaganM (2003) Human rights, testimony and transnational publicity. The Scholar and Feminist Online 2(1) – Public Sentiments – Summer.
142.
McLaganMMcKeeY (eds) (2012) Sensible Politics: The Visual Politics of Nongovernmental Activism. New York: Zone Books.
143.
MeisM (2013) Mobile death videos in protest movements: Cases from Iran and Syria on television: Balancing privacy and voyeurism. Thanatos2(2): 1–18.
144.
MeisM (2017) When is a conflict a crisis? On the aesthetics of the Syrian civil war in a social media context. Media, War & Conflict10(1): 69–86.
145.
MirzoeffN (2011) The right to look. Critical Inquiry37(3): 473–496.
146.
NicholsB (1981) Ideology and the Image. Bloomington: Indiana University Press.
147.
NicholsB (1991) Representing Reality: Issues and Concepts in Documentary. Bloomington: Indiana University Press.
148.
NobleSU (2014) Teaching Trayvon: Race, media, and the politics of spectacle. The Black Scholar44(1): 12–29.
149.
OffCDouglasJ (2014) Abounaddara: Syria's anonymous filmmakers at New York’s New Museum. CBC Radio, 31July.
150.
PetersJD (2001) Witnessing. Media Culture & Society23: 707–724.
151.
ReiterEH (2002) Personality and patrimony: Comparative perspectives on the right to one’s image. Tulane Law Review76(3): 673–726.
152.
RubenfeldJ (1989) The right to privacy. Harvard Law Review102(4): 737–807.
153.
SalamandraC (2004) A New Old Damascus: Authenticity and Distinction in Urban Syria. Bloomington: Indiana University Press.
154.
SliwinskiS (2011) Human Rights in Camera. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.
155.
SonK-M (2013) Walter Benjamin’s politics of experience. Constellations20(4): 615–629.
156.
StrochlicN (2014) Syria’s underground film club: Anonymous ‘emergency cinema,’ no dead bodies. The Daily Beast, 29June.
157.
Van de VallR (2003) Touching the face: The ethics of visuality between Levinas and a Rembrandt self-portrait. In: FaragoCZwijnenbergR (eds) Compelling Visuality: The Work of Art In and Out of History. Minneapolis: Minnesota University Press.
158.
VignalL (2014) Destruction-in-progress: Revolution, repression and war planning in Syria (2011 onwards). Built Environment40(3): 326–341.
159.
WhiteH (1980) The value of narrativity in the representation of reality. Critical Inquiry7(1): 5–27.
