Presentation factors affecting reading behaviour in readers of newspaper media: an eye-tracking perspective

Abstract

This paper examines reading behaviour in readers of printed and online newspaper media. The aim is to identify how much reading behaviour is dependent on various presentation factors, and how this dependence and its magnitude are related to output media. The work is based on review and analysis of empirical studies, primarily those employing methods using eye-tracking. The results show that some factors, such as text-based elements, size and placement, are an important guide to salience in both media. Images, on the other hand, have mostly been found not to elicit major visual attention online, affecting, for example, how ads are perceived. Reading behaviour is, however, a complicated process, and eye-tracking research does not consistently point in one direction.

Keywords

eye-tracking media new media newspaper newspaper content newspaper structure online news presentation styles reading behaviour

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Andersson

(2006) ‘Besökarens blick blockerar rörlig röra på webben’ (The user’s gaze blocks moving mess on the web) Cap&Design 1. URL (consulted March, 2010): http://www.idg.se/2.1085/1.72710

Barthelson

(2002) ‘Reading Behaviour in Online News Reading’ Master’s thesis, Dept of Cognitive Science, Lund University, Sweden. URL (consulted June 2011): http://lup.lub.lu.se/luur/download?func=downloadFile&recordOId=1329001&fileOId=1329002

Bayles

M.E.

(2002) ‘Designing Online Banner Advertisements: Should We Animate?’ Paper presented at the ACM CHI 2002 Conference on Human Factors in Computing Systems Conference, Minneapolis, 20–25 April.

Bucher

H-J.

Schumacher

(2006) ‘The Relevance of Attention for Selecting News Content: An Eye-tracking Study on Attention Patterns in the Reception of Print and Online Media’, Communications 31(3): 347–368.

de Waal

Schönbach

Lauf

(2004) ‘Online Newspapers: A Substitute for Print Newspapers and Other Information Channels?’, paper presented at 6th World Media Economics Conference, Montréal, May.

Cooke

(2003) ‘Information Acceleration and Visual Trends in Print, Television, and Web News Sources’, Technical Communication Quarterly 12(2): 155–182.

Drén

(2005) ‘Annonser i nättidningar: Kvalitet och placering i målorienterad sökning’ (Advertisements in online newspapers – quality and placement in goal oriented search), Master’s thesis, Cognitive Science, Lund University, Sweden. URL (consulted June 2011): http://lup.lub.lu.se/luur/download?func=downloadFile&recordOId=1328886&fileOId=1328887

Drèze

Hussherr

F-X.

(2003) ‘Internet Advertising: Is Anybody Watching?’ Journal of Interactive Marketing 17(4): 8–23.

Duchowski

A.T.

(2003) Eye Tracking Methodology: Theory and Practice. London: Springer-Verlag.

10.

Fidler

(2000) ‘Newspaper in 2020: Paper vs. Digital Delivery and Display Media’, Future of Print Media Journal 1–5.

11.

Garcia

M.R.

(2005) ‘The Impact of the Compact’, A Garcia Media White Paper 1.0.

12.

Garcia

M.R.

Stark

(1991) Eyes on the News. St Petersburg, FL: The Poynter Institute for Media Studies.

13.

Graber

D.A.

(1988) Processing the News: How People Tame the Information Tide. White Plains, NY: Longman Inc.

14.

Hansen

J.P.

(1994) Analyse af læsernes informationsprioritering (Analysis of the readers’ information prioritires), Forskningscenter Riso/.

15.

Hedman

(2003) ‘Läsning av nyhetssidor på nätet’ (Reading of news on the net), Master’s thesis, Dept of Information Science, Uppsala University, Sweden.

16.

Holmberg

(2004) ‘Eye Movement Patterns and Newspaper Design Factors: An Experimental Approach’, Master’s thesis, Cognitive Science, Lund University Sweden. URL (consulted June 2011): http://lup.lub.lu.se/luur/download?func=downloadFile&recordOId=1328870&fileOId=1328871

17.

Holmberg

Holmqvist

(2005) Tidningsläsares visuella beteende: Eyetracking på Norrköpings tidningar 2004-2005 (Visual behaviour in readers of newspapers: Eye tracking at Norrköpings Tidningar 2004–2005). Lund: Cognitive Studies, Lund University.

18.

Holmberg

Holsanova

Holmqvist

(2006) ‘Using Eye Movement Measures to Describe Readers’ Visual Interaction with Newspapers’. Peer reviewed paper in the conference proceedings EARLI SIG 2, Text and Graphics Comprehension, 30 of August–1 September 2006, University of Nottingham.

19.

Holmqvist

Wartenberg

(2005) The Role of Local Design Factors for Newspaper Reading Behaviour: An Eye-tracking Perspective, LUCS 127. Lund: Lund University Cognitive Studies. URL (consulted June 2011): http://www.lucs.lu.se/LUCS/127/LUCS.127.pdf

20.

Holsanova

Holmqvist

(2004) ‘Med blick på nätnyheter: Ögonrörelsestudier av läsning av nätbaserade tidningar’ (Looking at the net news: Eye tracking studies of reading of net-based newspapers), in Holmberg

C-G.

Svensson

(eds) Mediakulturer: hybrider och förvandlingar, pp. 1–23. Stockholm: Carlssons Förlag AB.

21.

Holsanova

Holmqvist

Holmberg

(2008a) ‘Läsning i gamla och nya medier’ (Reading on new and old media), in Domeij

(ed.) Tekniken bakom språket, pp. 144–67. Stockholm: Nordstedts Akademiska Förlag.

22.

Holsanova

Holmberg

Holmqvist

(2008b) ‘Reading Information Graphics: The Role of Spatial Contiguity and Dual Attention Guidance’, Applied Cognitive Psychology 22: 1–12.

23.

Ihlström

Åkesson

(2004) ‘Genre Characteristics: A Front Page Analysis of 85 Swedish Online Newspapers’, paper presented at the 37th Hawaii Conference on System Sciences 2004, Big Island, January.

24.

Josephson

(1996) ‘Questioning the Power of Color’, Visual Communication Quarterly 3(1): 4–12.

25.

Josephson

Holmes

M.E.

(2002) ‘Visual Attention to Repeated Internet Images: Testing the Scanpath Theory on the World Wide Web’, paper presented at the 2002 symposium on eye-tracking research and applications, New Orleans, March.

26.

Khattak

(2005) ‘The Bottom Line of Broadsheet-to-Compact Format Change’, International Newspaper Marketing Association 1: 1–25.

27.

Knox

(2007) ‘Visual-verbal communication on online newspaper home pages’, Visual Communication 6 (1): 19–53.

28.

Kress

van Leeuwen

(2006) Reading Images: The Grammar of Visual Design, 2nd edn. London: Routledge.

29.

Küpper

(1990) Recording of Visual Reading Activity Research into Newspaper Reading Behaviour, URL (consulted January 2012): http://www.mendeley.com/research/recording-visual-reading-activity-research-newspaper-reading-behaviour/

30.

Leckner

(2007) ‘Is the Medium the Message? The Impact of New Media on the Newspaper Concept’, PhD dissertation, Dept of Media Technology, School of Computer Science and Communication, Royal Institute of Technology, Stockholm.

31.

Leckner

(2011) Manuscript submitted for publication.

32.

Lemken

(1999) ‘Ebook – the missing link between paper and screen’, paper presented at the Conference on Human Factors in Computing Systems, Pittsburgh, May.

33.

Lewenstein

Edwards

Tatar

DeVigal

(2000) Poynter Eyetrack Study. Stanford University and The Poynter Institute.

34.

Lundberg

(2002) ‘Läsaren och tidningen’ (The reader and the newspaper), Ingress Media Report. Stockholm: Tidningsutgivarna.

35.

Lundberg

(2004) ‘Shaping Electronic News Genre Perspectives on Interaction Design’, PhD dissertation, Dept of Computer and Information Science HMI, Linköping University, Sweden.

36.

Lundqvist

Holmqvist

(2001) ‘Bigger is Better: How Size of Newspaper Advertisement and Reader Attitude Relate to Attention and Memory’, paper presented at European Conference on Eye Movement 11, Turku, August.

37.

Melin

(1999) ‘Gör illustrationen vad vi tror?’ (Does the illustration do what we think?), Nordicom Information 21(1–2): 52–60.

38.

Nordicom (2007) ‘Mediesverige: statistik och analys’ (Media in Sweden: Statistics and analysis), Carlsson

Facht

(eds), Kungälv: Nordicom Göteborg University.

39.

Nordicom (2009) Mediebarometern 2008 (The media barometer 2008). Kungälv: Nordicom Göteborg University.

40.

Outing

Ruel

(2004) ‘What We Saw Through their Eyes’, Eyetrack III, URL (consulted January 2012): http://psj.franklincollege.edu/Broadcast%20&%20Web%20Media%20Resources/Eyetrack%20Web%20Study.pdf

41.

Pan

Granka

L.A.

Hembrooke

H.A.

Feusner

M.K.

Gay

G.K.

Newman

J.K.

(2004) ‘The Determinants of Web Page Viewing Behaviour: An Eye-Tracking Study’. Paper presented at 2004 Symposium on Eye tracking Research and Applications, San Antonio, 22–24 March.

42.

Quinn

Stark

Edmonds

(2007) Eyetracking the News: A Study of Print and Online Reading. New York: The Poynter Institute.

43.

Schumacher

(2007) ‘Size Matters: Comparing the Reception of Design and Visual Language of Newspapers in Tabloid and Broadsheet Format (Extended abstract)’, paper presented at the 2007 ICA Conference, San Francisco, May.

44.

Seelig

M.I.

(2008) ‘An Updated Look at Trends in Content and Web Page Design in News Web Sites’, Electronic News 2(2): 86–100.

45.

Stenfors

Holmqvist

(1999) ‘The Strategic Control of Gaze Direction when Avoiding Internet Ads’, poster presentation at the European Conference on Eye Movements 10, Utrecht, September.

46.

Sternvik

(2004) Ögonrörelsestudier och dagstidningsläsning (Eye-tracking and daily newspaper reading), Working report 20. Göteborg: Dept of Journalism and Mass Communication, Göteborg University.

47.

Sternvik

(2005a) ‘Tabloidiseringen: en kompakt tidningstrend (Tabloidisation: A compact newspaper trend)’, in Holmberg

Weibull

(eds) Lyckan kommer, lyckan går. Göteborg: Som-institutet Göteborg University.

48.

Sternvik

(2005b) ‘Form och innehållstrender i dagspressen: Dagens Nyheter under 1900-talet’ (Trends in format and content of daily newspapers: Dagens Nyheter during the 20th century), Presshistorisk årsbok 2005. Stockholm: Presshistoriska föreningen.

49.

Sternvik

(2009) Attityder till formatförändringen: då och nu (Attitudes towards the format change, now and then) (PM 77). Göteborg: The Newspaper Research Programme, Göteborg University.

50.

Tewksbury

Althaus

S.L.

(2000) ‘Difference in Knowledge Acquisition among Readers of the Paper and Online Version of a National Newspaper’, Journalism and Mass Communication Quarterly 77(3): 457–479.

51.

Toms

E.G.

Campbell

D.G.

(1999) ‘Genre as Interface Metaphor: Exploiting Form and Function in Digital Environments’, paper presented at the 32nd Hawaii International Conference on System Sciences, Hawaii, January.

52.

Viviani

(1990) ‘Eye Movements in Visual Search: Cognitive, Perceptual, and Motor Control Aspects’, in Kowler

(ed.) Eye Movements and their Role in Visual and Cognitive Processes, pp. 353–93. Amsterdam: Elsevier.

53.

Wartenberg

Holmqvist

(2005) Daily Newspaper Layout: Designers’ Predictions of Readers’ Visual Behaviour: A Case Study, LUCS 126. Lund: Dept. of Cognitive Studies Lund University. URL (consulted June 2011): http://www.lucs.lu.se/LUCS/126/LUCS.126.pdf

54.

Widman

Lundqvist

(2001) ‘DN vs SvD och Metro: Läsning av annonser i DN och i Metro/SvD: Manligt och kvinnligt läsande’ (Reading advertisements in DN and Metro/SvD, Unpublished report, Stockholm: Dagens Nyheter.

55.

Widman

Polansky

S.H.

(1990) ‘Annonsläsning: En ögonrörelseundersökning av DN-läsare’ (Reading of advertisements: an eye-tracking study of DN readers). Unpublished report. Stockholm: Dagens Nyheter.

56.

Zambarbieri

Carnigilia

Robino

(2008) ‘Eye Tracking Analysis in Reading Online Newspapers’, Journal of Eye Movement Research 2(4): 1–8.