(In)authenticity work: Constructing the realm of inauthenticity through Thomas Kinkade

Abstract

Although we know that authenticity work can add value to cultural products, little research explores efforts to claim the inauthenticity of products in commercial markets. The question arises, how does the critical reception of a popular culture phenomenon employ a form of authenticity work to determine the cultural products eligible – or ineligible – for the status of “authentic?” This research seeks to answer this question through a comprehensive content analysis of 328 documents from 1998 to 2012 related to the late artist Thomas Kinkade. We put forth the term inauthenticity work to explain how cultural intermediaries defined cultural products as antithetical to authenticity. Even in the face of immense commercial success, intermediaries constructed Kinkade’s work as exemplifying inauthenticity, defining his work as mass produced, insincere, escapist, and oppositional to high art. Such inauthenticity work reveals that even if there is greater variance in cultural products eligible for authentication, intermediaries uphold culture boundaries through critically maintaining a cultural realm of inauthenticity.

Keywords

Authenticity work inauthenticity Thomas Kinkade cultural intermediaries cultural products

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Adorno

(1997) Aesthetic Theory, Minneapolis, MN: University of Minnesota Press.

Altbeker P (2008) Film. Business Day Edition (South Africa), 21 November, p. 11.

Anthony

(2012) Racialized authentication: Constructing representations of the Florida Highwaymen. The Sociological Quarterly 53(3): 394–421.

Anthony

Schrock

(2014) Maintaining art-world membership: Self-taught identity work of the Florida Highwaymen. Social Currents 1(1): 74–90.

Baudrillard

(1994) Simulacra and Simulation, Ann Arbor, MI: University of Michigan Press.

Baumann

(2002) Marketing, cultural hierarchy, and the relevance of critics: Film in the United States, 1935–1985. Poetics 30: 243–262.

Becker

(1982) Art Worlds, Berkeley, CA: University of California Press.

Beckman R (2008) “Kinkade” sheds more than light. Washington Post, 27 November, p. C01.

Bendix

(2009) In Search of Authenticity: The Formation of Folklore Studies, Madison, WI: University of Wisconsin Press.

10.

Benjamin

(2008) The Work of Art in the Age of Mechanical Reproduction, London: Penguin Classics.

11.

Berg

(2009) Qualitative Research Methods for the Social Sciences, 7th edn. Boston, MA: Allyn & Bacon.

12.

Beverland

(2005) Crafting brand authenticity: The case of luxury wines. Journal of Management Studies 42(5): 1003–1029.

13.

Bourdieu

(1993) The Field of Cultural Production, New York: Columbia University Press.

14.

Calnescu

(2003) Five Faces of Modernity, Durham, NC: Duke University Press.

15.

Camilli D (2008) Artist Kinkade’s memo is a turkey, too. The Gazette (Montreal), 20 November, p. D4.

16.

Campbell D (2002) Arts, land of the twee, Thomas Kinkade is America’s biggest-selling artist. The Guardian (London), 8 July, G2, p. 12.

17.

Charmaz

(2006) Constructing Grounded Theory, London: Sage.

18.

Colin M (2002) Another lovely day in the land of Kinkade, Painter Thomas Kinkade isn’t starving in a garret for his art. The Globe and Mail (Canada), 21 October, p. R3.

19.

DeCarlo T (1999) Landscapes by the carload, art or kitsch? New York Times, 7 November, Section 2, p. 51.

20.

della Cava MR (2002) Thomas Kinkade, profit of light. USA Today, 12 March, p. 1D.

21.

Deneer

(2009) Forging distinct paths towards authentic identity: Outsider art, public interaction, and identity transition in an informal market context. Journal of Contemporary Ethnography 38(2): 169–200.

22.

DiMaggio

(1987) Classification in art. American Sociological Review 52(4): 440–455.

23.

Downes L (2006) The 185 tequilas of Alida Yougez. New York Times, 8 January, Section 14WC, p. 11.

24.

Farquharson V (2004) Sentimental with a capital ‘S.’ National Post (Canada), 29 September, p. AL5.

25.

Fine

(2004) Everyday Genius: Self-Taught Art and the Culture of Authenticity, Chicago, IL: University of Chicago Press.

26.

Flegenheimer M (2011) #TRENDING N.Y.C. New York Times, 3 July, p. 3.

27.

Galupo S (2005) Second helpings of startdom. Washington Times, 24 June, p. D01.

28.

Gamson

Croteau

Hoynes

et al. (1992) Media images and the social construction of reality. Annual Review of Sociology 18: 373–393.

29.

Garner D (2011) Book Review: A Taste of Olive Oil’s Growers, Cooks and Crooks. International Herald Tribune, 13 December, p. 13.

30.

Gaytán

(2008) From sombreros to sincronizadas: Authenticity, ethnicity, and the Mexican restaurant industry. Journal of Contemporary Ethnography 37(3): 314–341.

31.

Gaytán MS (2014) The transformation of tequila: From hangover to highbrow. Journal of Consumer Culture 17(1): 62–84.

32.

Glynn

Lounsbury

(2005) From the critics’ corner: Logic blending, discursive change and authenticity in a cultural production system. Journal of Management Studies 42(5): 1031–1055.

33.

Grayson

Martinec

(2004) Consumer perceptions of iconicity and indexicality and their influence on assessments of authentic market offerings. Journal of Consumer Research 31(2): 296–312.

34.

Grazian

(2005 [2003]) Blue Chicago: The Search for Authenticity in Urban Blues Clubs, Chicago, IL: University of Chicago Press.

35.

Greenberg

(1945) Avant-garde and kitsch. In: Rosenberg

White

(eds) Mass Culture: The Popular Arts in America, New York: The Free Press, pp. 98–107.

36.

Hanquinet

Roose

Savage

(2014) The eyes of the beholder: Aesthetic preferences and the remaking of cultural capital. Sociology 48(1): 111–132.

37.

Hauser

(1982) The Sociology of Art, Chicago, IL: University of Chicago Press.

38.

Hernando Times (2001) High fives. St. Petersburg Times (Florida), 28 February, p. 4.

39.

Judkis M (2012) Thomas Kinkade’s polarizing legacy: How will the “Painter of Light” be remembered? In: The Style Blog. Washington Post, 7 April. Available at: http://www.washingtonpost.com/blogs/style-blog/post/thomas-kinkades-polarizing-legacy-how-will-the-painter-of-light-be-remembered/2012/04/07/gIQAov1G2S_blog.html (accessed 15 October 2014).

40.

Kates

(2004) The dynamics of brand legitimacy: An interpretive study in the gay men’s community. Journal of Consumer Research 31(2): 455–464.

41.

Kennicott P (2004) Divided they stand, in a quarreling country in an election year, the arts cleave us in the lurch. Washington Post, 12 September, p. N01.

42.

Kersten

(2014) National cultural repertoires of evaluation in a global age: Film discourse in France, the Netherlands, the United Kingdom, and the United States. European Sociological Review 30(6): 717–727.

43.

Koontz

(2010) Constructing authenticity: A review of trends and influences in the process of authentication in consumption. Sociology Compass 4(11): 977–988.

44.

La Ferla R (2006) 20 years on the branding of Warhol. International Herald Tribune, 28 October, p. 8.

45.

Lamont

(2012) Toward a comparative sociology of valuation and evaluation. Annual Review of Sociology 38: 201–221.

46.

Lehrer J (2009) Our inner artist. Washington Post, 11 January, p. BW08.

47.

Leigh

Peters

Shelton

(2006) The consumer quest for authenticity: The multiplicity of meanings within the MG subculture of consumption. Journal of the Academy of Marketing Science 34(4): 481–493.

48.

Leland J (2001) Subdivided and licensed, there's no place like art. New York Times, 4 October, p. 1.

49.

Lena

Pachucki

(2013) The sincerest form of flattery: Innovation, repetition, and status in an art movement. Poetics 41(3): 236–264.

50.

Lowenthal

(1950) Historical perspectives of popular culture. In: Rosenberg

White

(eds) Mass Culture: The Popular Arts in America, New York: The Free Press, pp. 46–58.

51.

MacDonald

(1953) A theory of mass culture. In: Rosenberg

White

(eds) Mass Culture: The Popular Arts in America, New York: The Free Press, pp. 59–73.

52.

MacLean D (2002) Schmaltz indeed. National Post (Canada), 11 October, p. A17.

53.

Milmo C (2001) Kinkade, king of kitsch, coming to a home near you. The Independent (London), 5 May, p. 11.

54.

Moore J (2008) If there’s money for pigs, there’s money for arts. National Post (Canada), 22 April, p. A16.

55.

Mosquera

(1986) Bad taste in good form. Social Text 15: 54–64.

56.

Negus

(2002) The work of cultural intermediaries and the enduring distance between production and consumption. Cultural Studies 16(4): 501–515.

57.

O’Brien E (1999) The painter of light, that’s the trademark that artist Thomas Kinkade has applied to himself and his work. Philadelphia Inquirer, 4 June, p. E01.

58.

Perry G (2006) How art appreciates – It’s a class act. The Times (London), 1 March, p. 16.

59.

Peterson

(1997) Creating Country Music, Chicago, IL: University of Chicago Press.

60.

Peterson

(2005) In search of authenticity. Journal of Management Studies 41(5): 1083–1098.

61.

Peterson RA and Kern R (1996) Changing highbrow taste: From snob to omnivore. American Sociological Review 61(5): 900–907.

62.

Rappolt M (2008) Market news: Who are art’s top 100? Daily Telegraph (London), 14 October, p. 24.

63.

Ritzer

(2012) The McDonaldization of Society, Los Angeles, CA: Sage.

64.

Rosenberg

(1957) Mass culture in America. In: Rosenberg

White

(eds) Mass Culture: The Popular Arts in America, New York: The Free Press, pp. 3–12.

65.

Ross

(1989) No Respect, Intellectuals and Popular Culture, New York: Routledge.

66.

Schmutz

(2009) Social and symbolic boundaries in newspaper coverage of music, 1955–2005: Gender and genre in the US, France, Germany, and the Netherlands. Poetics 37: 298–314.

67.

Schmutz

Faupel

(2010) Gender and cultural consecration in popular music. Social Forces 89(2): 685–708.

68.

Storey J and Kleinhenz L (2002) God is in the detail. Independent on Sunday (London), 24 February, pp. 18–19.

69.

Sunday Times (2010) Sunday Times Rich List, 25 April.

70.

Sturges F (2003) Radio: Pick of the day. Independent (London), 2 January, p. 17.

71.

Taylor C (2008) ‘I know what I like’: And if that's a jack vettriano, beryl cook or rolf harris, then so be it. meet the art lovers who are defying the critics – and proud of it. The Guardian (London), 26 July, p. 36.

72.

Tedman

(2010) Origins of kitsch. Rethinking Marxism 22(1): 56–67.

73.

Thompson S (2000) Fancy frames, windows aglow and a trademark. St. Petersburg Times, 6 May, p. 1B.

74.

Van Venrooij

Schmutz

(2010) The evaluation of popular music in the United States, Germany and the Netherlands. Cultural Sociology 4(3): 395–421.

75.

Weeks L (2008) Feelings? Whoa, whoa, whoa, whoa, now! Washington Post, 30 March, p. M01.

76.

Wherry A (2002) Selling schmaltz, Thomas Kinkade’s lush gardens and cozy cottages have made him the most collected artist in the U.S. But will Canadians fall for him too? National Post (Canada), 10 October, p. AL1.

77.

Wherry

(2006) The social sources of authenticity in global handicraft markets evidence from northern Thailand. Journal of Consumer Culture 6(1): 5–32.

78.

Yardley J (2000) Book World. Washington Post, 24 December, p. X02.