Shadowing is a qualitative research technique that has seldom been used and rarely
been discussed critically in the social science literature. This article has pulled
together all of the studies using shadowing as a research method and through
reviewing these studies has developed a threefold classification of different modes
of shadowing. This work provides a basis for a qualitative shadowing method to be
defined, and its potential for a distinctive contribution to organizational research
to be discussed, for the first time.
Ackroyd, S.
and
Hughes, J.
(1992) Data Collection in Context.
Harlow: Longman
.
2.
Argyris, C.
and
Schon, D.A.
(1996) Organizational Learning II.
Reading, MA: Addison-Wesley
.
3.
Arrington, K.
(2000)
‘Middle Grades Career Planning Programs’
, Journal of Career Development27(2):
103-109
.
4.
Bartz, D.E.
and
Calabrese, R.L.
(1991)
‘Enhancing Graduate Business School Programmes’
, Journal of Management Development10(1):
26-32
.
5.
Boland, R.J.
and
Tenkasi, R.
(1995)
‘Perspective Making and Perspective Taking in Communities of Knowing’
, Organization Science6(4):
350-372
.
6.
Bonazzi, G.
(1998)
‘Between Shock Absorption and Continuous Improvement: Supervisors
and Technicians in a Fiat “Integrated Factory”’
, Work Employment and Society12(2):
219-243
.
7.
Burgoyne, J.G.
and
Hodgson, V.E.
(1984) ‘An Experiential Approach to
Understanding Managerial Action’, in
J.G. Hunt
,
D-M. Hosking
,
C.A. Schriesheim
and
R. Stewart
(eds) Leaders and Managers: International Perspectives on Managerial
Behaviour and Leadership, pp. 163-178.
New York: Pergamon
.
8.
Carlson, S.
(1951) Executive Behaviour: A Study of the Workload and the
Working Methods of Managing Directors.
Stockholm: Strombergs
.
9.
Chapin, M.H.
and
Kewman, D.G.
(2001)
‘Factors Affecting Employment Following Spinal Cord Injury: A
Qualitative Study’
, Rehabilitation Psychology46(4):
400-416
.
10.
Cydulka, R.K.
,
Emerman, C.L.
and
Jouriles, N.J.
(1996)
‘Evaluation of Resident Performance and Intensive Bedside
Teaching During Direct Observation Academic’
, Emergency Medicine3(4):
345-351
.
11.
Dunnette, M.D.
(ed.) (1976) Handbook of Industrial and Organisational
Psychology.
Chicago, IL: Rand McNally
.
12.
Eager, C.
and
Oppenheim, C.
(1996)
‘An Observational Method for Undertaking User Needs Studies’
, Journal of Librarianship and Information Science28(11):
15-23
.
13.
Eddy, M.E.
and
Schermer, J.
(1999)
‘Shadowing: A Strategy to Strengthen the Negotiating Style of
Baccalaureate Nursing Students’
, Journal of Nursing Education38(8):
364-367
.
14.
Engestrom, Y.
(1987) Learning By Expanding: An Activity Theoretical
Approach To Developmental Research.
Helsinki: Orienta Konsultit
.
15.
Ericsson, K.A.
and
Simon, H.A.
(1993) Protocol Analysis: Verbal Reports as Data.
Cambridge, MA: MIT
.
16.
Fagella, K.
and
Horowitz, J.
(1997)
‘Plan Specific Activities for Student Visiting Day’
, HRM MagazineMarch:
110-112
.
17.
Fenton, N.
,
Deacon, D.
,
Bryman, A.
and
Birmingham, P.
(1997)
‘Sod Off and Find Us a Boffin: Journalists and the Social Science Conference’
, The Sociological Review45(1):
1-23
.
18.
Filstead, W.J.
(ed.) (1970) Qualitative Methodology: Firsthand Involvement
with the Social World.
Chicago, IL: Markham Publishing Co
.
19.
Forsblad, P.
(1984) ‘Observation for
What?’, in
J.G. Hunt
,
D-M. Hosking
,
C.A. Schriesheim
and
R. Stewart
(eds) Leaders and Managers: International Perspectives on Managerial
Behaviour and Leadership, pp. 200-203.
New York: Pergamon
.
20.
Guest, R.H.
(1955)
‘Foremen at Work: An Interim Report on Method’
, Human Organization14(2):
21-24
.
21.
Herr, E.L.
and
Watts, A.G.
(1988)
‘Work Shadowing and Work-Related Learning’
, Career Development Quarterly37(1):
78-86
.
22.
Hirsh, S.G.
(1999)
‘Children’s Relevance Criteria and Information Seeking
on Electronic Resources’
, Journal of the American Society for Information Science50(14):
1265-1283
.
23.
Hunt, J.G.
,
Hosking, D-M.
,
Schriesheim, C.A.
and
Stewart, R.
(eds) (1984) Leaders and Managers: International Perspectives
on Managerial Behaviour and Leadership.
New York: Pergamon
.
24.
Johnson, G.
,
Melin, L.
and
Whittington, R.
(2003)
‘Micro Strategy and Strategizing: Towards an Activity-based View’
, Journal of Management Studies40(1):
3-22
.
25.
Leftridge, D.W.
,
Mays, D.
,
MacAvery, J.
and
O’Connor, T.
(1992)
‘“Shadow-a-Nurse Program” Aids Recruitment’
, Nursing Management23(4):
76
.
26.
Luthans, F.
,
Rosenkrantz S.A.
, and
Hennessey H.W.
(1985)
‘What Do Successful Managers Really Do? An Observation Study of
Managerial Activities’
, The Journal of Applied Behavioural Science21(3):
255-270
.
27.
Martinko, M.J.
and
Gardner, W.L.
(1985)
‘Beyond Structured Observation: Methodological Issues and New Directions’
, Academy of Management Review10(4):
676-695
.
28.
McDonald, S.
(forthcoming) ‘Shadowing, Interviewing and Participant
Observation Compared: Implications for Management Research’.
29.
McKechnie, L.E.F.
(2000)
‘Ethnographic Observation of Preschool Children’
, Library and Information Science Research22(1):
61-76
.
30.
McKenzie, L.
(1992)
‘Critical Thinking in Health Care Supervision’
, Health Care Supervision10(4):
1-11
.
31.
Mintzberg, H.
(1970)
‘Structured Observation as a Method to Study Managerial Work’
, Journal of Management Studies7(1):
87-104
.
32.
Mintzberg, H.
(1973) The Nature of Managerial Work.
New York: Harper and Row
.
33.
Mintzberg, H.
(1994)
‘Rounding Out the Manager’s Job’
, Sloan Management Review36(1):
11-26
.
34.
Noël, A.
(1989)
‘Strategic Cores and Magnificent Obsessions: Discovering Strategy
Formation Through Daily Activities of CEOs’
, Strategic Management Journal10:
33-49
.
35.
Noordegraaf, M.
and
Stewart, R.
(2000)
‘Managerial Behaviour Research in Private and Public Sectors:
Distinctiveness, Disputes and Directions’
, Journal of Management Studies37(3):
427-443
.
36.
Norton, S.C.
and
Field, K.F.
(1998)
‘Career Placement Project: A Career Readiness Program for
Community College Students with Disabilities’
, Journal of Employment Counselling35(1):
40-44
.
37.
O’Neill, H.E.
and
Kubany, A.J.
(1959)
‘Observation Methodology and Supervisory Behaviour’
, Personnel Psychology12:
85-95
.
38.
Orton, R.
,
Marcella, R.
and
Baxter, G.
(2000)
‘An Observational Study of the Information Seeking Behaviour of
Members of Parliament in the United Kingdom’
, ASLIB Proceedings52(6):
207-217
.
39.
Paskiewicz, L.S.
(2002)
‘The Shadowing Experience: Valuing the Link Between Faculty
Practice and Student Learning’
, Journal of Professional Nursing18(4):
238-242
.
40.
Perlow, L.A.
(1998)
‘Boundary Control: The Social Ordering of Work and Family Time in
a High-tech Corporation’
, Administrative Science Quarterly43(2):
328-357
.
41.
Perlow, L.A.
(1999)
‘The Time Famine: Toward a Sociology of Work Time’
, Administrative Science Quarterly44(1):
57-81
.
42.
Polite, V.C.
,
McClure, R.
and
Rollie, D.L.
(1997)
‘The Emerging Reflective Urban Principal - The Role of Shadowing Encounters’
, Urban Education31(5):
466-489
.
43.
Rancour, P.
(1996)
‘Introducing Medical Students to Psycho-Oncology’
, Psycho-oncology5(1):
55-57
.
44.
Saine D.R.
and
Hicks, C.I.
(1987)
‘Shadowing Program to Increase Student Awareness of Hospital
Pharmacy Practice’
, American Journal of Hospital Pharmacy44(7):
1614-1617
.
45.
Shipman, M.D.
(1997) The Limitations of Social Research, 4th
edition.
London: Addison Wesley Longman Ltd.
46.
Smith, D.E.
(1987) The Everyday World as Problematic.
Toronto: University of Toronto Press
.
47.
Snow, C.C.
and
Thomas, J.B.
(1994)
‘Field Research Methods in Strategic Management: Contributions to
Theory Building and Testing’
, Journal of Management Studies31(4):
457-480
.
48.
Snyder N.
and
Glueck W.F.
(1980)
‘How Mangers Plan - The Analysis of Managers’ Activities’
, Long Range Planning13:
70-76
.
49.
Stanley, N.
,
Manthorpe, J.
,
Bradley, G.
and
Alaszewski, A.
(1998) ‘Researching Community Care Assessments:
A Pluralistic Approach’, in
J. Cheetham
and
M. Kazi
(eds) The Working of Social Work, pp. ???.
London: Jessica Kingsley
.
50.
Stewart, R.
(1967) Managers and their Jobs: A Study of the Similarities
and Differences in the Ways Managers Spend their Time.
Basingstoke: Macmillan
.
51.
Quoted in
R. Stewart
(2003)
‘Woman in a Man’s World’
, The Leadership Quarterly14:
197-204
.
52.
Vukic, A.
and
Keddy, B.
(2002)
‘Northern Nursing Practice in a Primary Health Care Setting’
, Journal of Advanced Nursing40(5):
542-548
.
53.
Walker, C.R.
,
Guest, R.H.
and
Turner, A.N.
(1956) The Foreman on the Assembly Line.
Boston, MA: Harvard University Press
.
54.
Weick, K.E.
(1974)
‘Review of “The Nature of Managerial Work” by
Henry Mintzberg’
, Administrative Science Quarterly19(1):
111-118
.
