This article compares national income tax reforms during the last 25 years. There were two competing models of income tax reform, ‘comprehensive’ and ‘dual’ income taxation, the latter of which was in many ways more successful. The reason lies in the structural constraints policy makers face. While taxation of capital income is very costly, creating incentives to lower marginal tax rates, the high overall tax burden on labour makes it difficult to reduce tax rates on labour incomes. These conflicting pressures point towards separate tax rate schedules for capital and labour, as is characteristic of dual income taxes. The analysis has implications for the role of income taxation in achieving social policy outcomes. Most importantly, while progressive taxation of capital income is constrained by high costs, policy makers willing to separate capital and labour income taxation can use the income tax to reduce the tax burden on low wages.
BMF (Bundesministerium der Finanzen [German Ministry of Finance]) (2003) Die wichtigsten Steuern im internationalen Vergleich. Bonn: BMF.
2.
Bordignon, M. , Giannini, S. and Panteghini, P. (2001) ‘Reforming Business Taxation: Lessons from Italy?’ , International Tax and Public Finance8(2): 191-210 .
3.
Boskin, M. J. and McLure, C. J. (eds) (1990) World Tax Reform: Case Studies of Developed and Developing Countries. San Francisco, CA: ICS Press .
4.
Brooks, S. G. and Wohlforth, W. C. (2000) ‘Power, Globalization and the End of the Cold War: Reevaluation a Landmark Case for Ideas’ , International Security25(3): 5-53 .
5.
Brooks, S. G. and Wohlforth, W. C. (2002) ‘From Old Thinking to New Thinking in Qualitative Research’ , International Security26(4): 93-111 .
6.
Bucovetsky, S. (1991) ‘Asymmetric Tax Competition’ , Journal of Urban Economics30(2): 167-181 .
7.
Chapman, R. (1992) ‘A Political Culture Under Pressure: The Struggle to Preserve a Progressive Tax Base for Welfare and the Positive State’ , Political Science44(1): 1-27 .
8.
Cnossen, S. (1988) ‘Overview’, in J. A. Pechman (ed.) World Tax Reform: A Progress Report (pp. 261-268). Washington, DC: The Brookings Institution .
9.
Cnossen, S. (1999) ‘Taxing Capital Income in the Nordic Countries: A Model for the European Union?’ , Finanzarchiv56(1): 18-50 .
10.
Cnossen, S. and Bovenberg, L. (2001) ‘Fundamental Tax Reform in the Netherlands’ , International Tax and Public Finance8(4): 467-480 .
11.
Conlan, T. J. , Wrightson, M. T. and Beam, D. R. (1990) Taxing Choices: The Politics of Tax Reform. Washington, DC: CQ Press .
12.
Dalsgaard, T. and Kawagoe, M. (2000) ‘The Tax System in Japan: A Need for Comprehensive Reform’, Economics Department Working Papers No. 231, OECD, Paris .
13.
De Long, J. B. and Summers, L. H. (1991) ‘Equipment Investment and Economic Growth’ , Quarterly Journal of Economics106(2): 445-502 .
14.
Det Økonomiske Råd (2001) ‘Danish Economy: Spring 2001 (English Summary)’, accessed 12 October 2002: http://www.dors.dk/rapp/dors086.htm
15.
Devereux, M. P. and Griffith, R. (1998) ‘Taxes and the Location of Production: Evidence from a Panel of US Multinationals’ , Journal of Public Economics68(2): 335-367 .
16.
Devereux, M. P. and Griffith, R. (2003) ‘Evaluating Tax Policy for Location Decisions’ , International Tax and Public Finance20(1): 107-126 .
17.
Ervik, R. (2000) ‘The Hidden Welfare State in Comparative Perspective: Tax Expenditures and Social Policy in Eight Countries’, PhD thesis, Department of Comparative Politics, University of Bergen, Norway.
18.
Eurostat (2004) Structures of the Taxation System in the European Union: Data 1995-2002. Luxembourg: Eurostat .
19.
Faria, A. G.A. (1995) ‘Reform in Market Economies and Economies in Transition: Principles and Experience’, in P. Shome (ed.) Tax Policy Handbook (pp. 275-278). Washington, DC: International Monetary Fund .
20.
Fullerton, D. (1994) ‘Tax Policy’, in M. Feldstein (ed.) American Economic Policy in the 1980s (pp. 165-208). Chicago, IL: University of Chicago Press .
21.
Ganghof, S. (2000) ‘Adjusting National Tax Policy to Economic Internationalization: Strategies and Outcomes’, in F. W. Scharpf and V. A. Schmidt (eds) Welfare and Work in the Open Economy. Volume II: Diverse Responses to Common Challenges (pp. 597-645). Oxford: Oxford University Press .
22.
Ganghof, S. (2004) ‘Progressive Income Taxation in Advanced OECD Countries. Revisiting the Structural Dependence of the State on Capital’ , paper presented at the Annual Meeting of the American Political Science Association Chicago, 1-5 September.
23.
Ganghof, S. (forthcoming-a) Parties, Power and Progressivity: The Political Economy of Income Taxation in Open States. Colchester: ECPR Press .
24.
Ganghof, S. (forthcoming-b) ‘Tax Mixes and the Welfare State: The Danish Puzzle in Comparative Perspective’, Discussion Paper, Max Planck Insitute for the Study of Societies, Cologne .
25.
Ganghof, S. and Eccleston, R. (2004) ‘Globalization and the Dilemmas of Income Taxation in Australia’ , Australian Journal of Political Science39(4): 519-534 .
26.
Garrett, G. (1998) ‘Shrinking States? Globalization and National Autonomy in the OECD’ , Oxford Development Studies26(1): 71-97 .
27.
Genser, B. (1996) ‘Austria’s Steps towards a Dual Income Tax’, in L. Mutén , P. B. Sørensen , K. P. Hagen and B. Genser (eds) Towards a Dual Income Tax? (pp. 69-89). London: Kluwer Lax International .
28.
Goldstein, J. and Keohane, R. O. (1993) ‘Ideas and Foreign Policy: An Analytical Framework’, in J. Goldstein and R. O. Keohane (eds) Ideas and Foreign Policy. Beliefs, Institutions, and Political Change (pp. 3-30). Ithaca, NY: Cornell University Press .
29.
Hagen, K. P. and Sørensen, P. B. (1998) ‘Taxation of Income from Small Businesses: Taxation Principles and Tax Reforms in the Nordic Countries’, in P. B. Sørensen (ed.) Tax Policy in the Nordic Countries (pp. 28-71). Houndmills: Macmillan .
30.
Hall, P. A. (1993) ‘Policy Paradigms, Social Learning, and the State: The Case of Economic Policymaking in Britain’ , Comparative Politics25(3): 275-296 .
31.
Hardiman, N. (2001) ‘Taxing the Poor: The Politics of Income Taxation in Ireland’ , Policy Studies Journal28(4): 815-842 .
32.
Head, J. G. (1997) ‘Company Tax Structure and Company Tax Incidence’ , International Tax and Public Finance4(1): 61-100 .
33.
Heady, C. (2002) ‘Tax Policy in Developing Countries: What Can Be Learned from OECD Experience?’ , paper presented at the Seminar for Taxing Perspectives: A Democratic Approach to Public Finance in Developing Countries at the Institute of Development Studies, University of Sussex, 28-9 October.
34.
Hettich, W. and Winer, S. L. (1999) Democratic Choice and Taxation: A Theoretical and Empirical Analysis. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press .
35.
Hines, J. R., Jr (1999) ‘Lessons form Behavioral Responses to International Taxation’ , National Tax Journal52(2): 305-322 .
36.
Holmøy, E. and Vennemo, H. (1995) ‘A General Equilibrium Assessment of a Suggested Reform in Capital Income Taxation’ , Journal of Policy Modeling17(6): 531-556 .
37.
Howard, C. (1997) The Hidden Welfare State: Tax Expenditures and Social Policy in the United States. Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press .
38.
Huber, E. and Stephens, J. D. (1998) ‘Internationalization and the Social Democratic Model: Crisis and Future Prospects’ , Comparative Political Studies31(3): 353-397 .
39.
Kato, J. (2003) Regressive Taxation and the Welfare State: Path Dependence and Policy Diffusion. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press .
40.
KPMG (2003) ‘KPMG’s Corporate Tax Rate Survey - January 2003’, accessed 13 February 2004, http://www.in.kpmg.com/ctrs.html
41.
Lindert, P. H. (2004) Growing Public. Volume One: The Story. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press .
42.
Messere, K. (1993) Tax Policy Choices in OECD Countries. Amsterdam: IBFD Publications BV .
43.
Messere, K. , De Kam, F. and Heady, C. (2003) Tax Policy: Theory and Practice in OECD Countries. Oxford: Oxford University Press .
44.
Morinobu, S. (2004) ‘Capital Income Taxation and the Dual Income Tax’, accessed 30 August 2004: http://www.mof.go.jp/jouhou/soken/kenkyu/ron097.pdf
45.
Mutén, L. (1996) ‘Dual Income Taxation: Swedish Experience’, in L. Mutén , B. P. Sørensen , K. P. Hagen and B. Genser (eds) Towards a Dual Income Tax? (pp. 7-21). London: Kluwer Law International .
46.
Nannestad, P. and Green-Pedersen, C. (forthcoming) ‘Keeping the Bumblebee Flying: Economic Policy in the Welfare State of Denmark, 1973-99’, in E. Albäk , P. Eliason and A. S. Norgaard (eds) Managing the Danish Welfare State under Pressure: Towards a Theory of the Dilemmas of the Welfare State. Aarhus: Aarhus University Press .
47.
NOU (Norges Offentlige Utredninger) (1984) Personbeskatning. Skattekommisjonens Vurderinger av og Forslag til System for Personbeskatning [Reports of the Government Commissions]. Oslo .
48.
OECD (2000) OECD Economic Surveys: New Zealand. Paris: OECD .
49.
OECD (2001) Tax and the Economy: A Comparative Assessment of OECD Countries. Paris: OECD .
50.
OECD (2004) Statistical Compendium. Paris: OECD .
51.
Pechman, J. A. (ed.) (1988) World Tax Reform: A Progress Report. Washington, DC: Brookings .
52.
Sandford, C. (1993) Successful Tax Reform: Lessons from an Analysis of Tax Reform in Six Countries.Fersfield, UK: Fiscal Publications .
53.
Schwartz, H. (1991) ‘Can Orthodox Stabilization and Adjustment Work? Lessons from New Zealand 1984-90’ , International Organization45(2): 221-256 .
54.
Schwartz, H. (2000) ‘Internationalization and Two Liberal Welfare States: Australia and New Zealand’, in F. W. Scharpf and V. A. Schmidt (eds) Welfare and Work in the Open Economy. Diverse Responses to Common Challenges (pp. 69-130). Oxford: Oxford University Press .
55.
Shome, P. (1999) ‘Taxation in Latin America: Structural Trends and Impact of Administration’, IMF Working Paper WP/99/19, IMF, Washington, DC .
56.
Slemrod, J. (1990) ‘Optimal Taxation and Optimal Tax Systems’ , Journal of Economic Perspectives4(1): 157-178 .
57.
Slemrod, J. (2000) ‘The Labyrinth of Capital Gains Tax Policy: A Guide for the Perplexed’ , Journal of Economic Literature38(3): 657-659 .
58.
Sørensen, P. B. (1988) ‘Wealth Taxation, Income Taxation, and Saving’, Blue Mimeo 163, University of Copenhagen, Institute of Economics .
59.
Sørensen, P. B. (1993) ‘Recent Tax Reform Experiments in Scandinavia’, in L. Stetting , K. E. Svendsen and E. Yngaard (eds) Global Change and Transformation (pp. 357-376). Copenhagen: Munksgaard International Publishers .
60.
Sørensen, P. B. (1998a) ‘Recent Innovations in Nordic Tax Policy: From the Global Income Tax to the Dual Income Tax’, in P. B. Sørensen (ed.) Tax Policy in the Nordic Countries (pp. 1-27). London: Macmillan .
61.
Sørensen, P. B. (ed.) (1998b) Tax Policy in Nordic Countries. Basingstoke: Macmillan .
62.
Steinmo, S. (2003) ‘The Evolution of Policy Ideas: Tax Policy in the 20th Century’ , British Journal of Politics and International Relations5(2): 206-236 .
63.
Stephens, R. (1993) ‘Radical Tax Reform in New Zealand’ , Fiscal Studies14(3): 45-63 .
64.
Stotsky, J. (1995) ‘Summary of IMF Policy Advice’, in P. Shome (ed.) Tax Policy Handbook (pp. 279-284). Washington, DC: International Monetary Fund .
65.
Summers, L. , Gruber, J. and Vergara, R. (1993) ‘Taxation and the Structure of Labor Markets: The Case of Corporatism’ , The Quarterly Journal of Economics108(2): 385-411 .
66.
Swank, D. (1998) ‘Funding the Welfare State: Globalization and the Taxation of Business in Advanced Market Economies’ , Political Studies46(4): 671-692 .
67.
Swank, D. (2003) ‘Tax Policy in an Era of Internationalization: An Assessment of a Conditional Diffusion Model of the Spread of Neoliberalism’ , paper presented at the International Diffusion of Political and Economic Liberalization Conference, Weatherhead Center for International Affairs, Harvard University, 3-4 October.
68.
Swank, D. and Steinmo, S. (2002) ‘The New Political Economy of Taxation in Advanced Capitalist Democracies’ , American Journal of Political Science46(3): 642-655 .
69.
Tanzi, V. and Zee, H. (2000) ‘Tax Policy for Emerging Markets: Developing Countries’ , National Tax Journal53(2): 299-322 .
70.
Van den Noord, P. (2000) ‘The Tax System in Norway: Past Reforms and Future Challenges’, OECD Economics Department Working Papers No. 244, OECD, Paris .
71.
Wilensky, H. (2002) Rich Democracies: Political Economy, Public Policy, and Peformance. Berkeley: University of California Press .
72.
World Bank (2003) World Development Indicators. Washington, DC: World Bank .
