Mandated prevention in child welfare: Considerations from a framework shaping ethical inquiry

Abstract

• Summary: This article outlines a framework for approaching ethical dilemmas arising from the development, evaluation and implementation of child welfare policies. As such, it is relevant to policy-makers, social researchers and social workers. The central tenets of the framework are developed by drawing on ideas from moral philosophy and critical social theory. These ideas are presented as axioms, theorems and corollaries, a format which has been employed in the social sciences to offer a rational justification for a set of claims.

• Findings: This process of reasoning leads to four principle axioms that are seen to shape the ethical scrutiny of social policy: 1) problematizing knowledge; 2) utilizing structured forms of inquiry to enhance understanding; 3) engendering enabling communication with those affected by the ethical concern; and 4) enhancing self-awareness.

• Applications: The four axioms are then applied, by way of example, to the current and contentious, ‘third way’ policy of mandated prevention in child welfare, where the aim is to obviate deleterious outcomes in later life. It is argued that the framework can be applied beyond this specific concern to other pressing, ethical challenges in child welfare.

Keywords

child welfare ethics mandated prevention moral philosophy social theory

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Baldwin, N. , plus signatories. (2006). Social Exclusion Plan: Response. The Guardian, 25 September, p. 33.

Barnes, M. ( 2008). Passionate participation: Emotional experiences and expressions in deliberative forums. Critical Social Policy, 28(4), 461-481.

Bauman, Z. ( 1993). Postmodern ethics. London: Polity Press.

Benhabib, S. ( 1992). Situating the self: Gender, community and postmodernism in contemporary ethics. New York: Routledge.

Blair, T. ( 2006). Our sovereign value: Fairness. Speech given to the Rowntree Foundation, York, 5 September, retrieved from: www.number10.gov.uk/output/Page10037.asp .

Bourdieu, P. ( 1977). Outline of a theory of practice. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.

Brezo, J. , Paris, J. , Vitaro, F. , Herbert, M. , Tremblay, R. , & Turecki, G. ( 2008). Predicting suicide attempts in young adults with histories of childhood abuse. The British Journal of Psychiatry, 193(2), 134-139.

Donzelot, J. ( 1979). The policing of families. London: Pantheon Books.

Gilligan, C. ( 1982). In a different voice: Psychological theory and women’s development. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.

10.

Habermas, J. ( 1990). Moral consciousness and communicative action. Cambridge: Polity Press.

11.

Hendrick, H. ( 2003). Child welfare: Historical dimensions, contemporary debate . Bristol: The Policy Press.

12.

HM Government. (2006) Reaching out: An action plan on social exclusion. London: Cabinet Office.

13.

Hewitt, M. ( 1993). Social movements and social need. Critical Social Policy, 13(3), 52-74.

14.

Hoggett, P. ( 2000). Emotional life and the politics of welfare. Basingstoke: Macmillan.

15.

Honneth, A. ( 1995). The struggle for recognition: The moral grammar of social conflicts. Cambridge: Policy Press .

16.

Jones-Finer, C. ( 2004). Emotional life and the politics of welfare. Basingstoke: Macmillan.

17.

Kahneman, D. , Slovic, P. , & Tversky, A. ( 1982). Judgement under uncertainty: Heuristics and biases. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.

18.

Kant, I. ( 1964). Groundwork of the metaphysics of morals. New York: Harper & Row.

19.

Leonard, M. ( 2005). Children, childhood and social capital: Exploring the links. Sociology, 39(4), 605-622.

20.

Linzer, N. ( 1999). Resolving ethical dilemmas in social work practice. London: Allyn & Bacon.

21.

Lonne, B. , Parton, N. , Thompson, J. , & Harries, M. ( 2009). Reforming child protection. London : Routledge.

22.

Lukes, S. ( 2005). Power: A radical view. Basingstoke : Macmillan.

23.

McAuley, C. , Knapp, M. , Beecham, J. , McCurry, N. , & Sleed, N. ( 2004). Young families under stress: Outcomes and costs of Home Start support. York: Joseph Rowntree .

24.

McLaughlin, J. , & Pinkerton, J. ( 1995). Ethical dilemmas in practice: Some thoughts on the Children (NI) Order. Child Care in Practice, 1(4), 23-32.

25.

Mead, G. ( 1967). Mind, self and society. Chicago, IL : Chicago University Press.

26.

Munro, E. ( 2007). Confidentiality in a preventive child welfare system . Ethics and Social Welfare, 1(1), 41-55.

27.

Osmo, R. ( 2001). A conceptual tool: Making social workers’ assumptions explicit. Social Work Education, 20(2), 209-217.

28.

Peters, R. , & Barlow, J. ( 2003). Systematic review of instruments designed to predict child maltreatment during antenatal and postnatal periods. Child Abuse Review, 12, 416-439.

29.

Rawls, J. ( 1971). A theory of justice. Cambridge, MA : Belknap Press.

30.

Rossides, D. ( 1998). Social theory: Its origins, history and contemporary relevance. New York: General Hall, Inc.

31.

Slote, M. ( 2007). The ethics of care and empathy. London : Routledge.

32.

Spratt, T. ( 2008). The changing landscape of social care: Implications for working with individual clients. In M. Calder (Ed.), The carrot of the stick (pp. 12-25). London : Russell House Publishing.

33.

Spratt, T. ( 2009). Identifying families with multiple problems: Possible responses from child and family social work to current policy developments . British Journal of Social Work, 39, 435-450.

34.

Taylor, D. ( 2006). Critical policy evaluation and the question of values: A psychosocial approach. Critical Social Policy, 26, 243-267.

35.

Taylor, J. , Baldwin, N. , & Spencer, N. ( 2008). Predicting child abuse and neglect: Ethical, theoretical and methodological challenges. Journal of Clinical Nursing , 17(9), 1193-1200.

36.

Thompson, S. , & Hoggett, P. ( 1996). Universalism, selectivity and particularism. Critical Social Policy, 16, 21-42.

37.

Weiss, I. , Gal, J. , & Katan, J. ( 2006). Social policy for social work: A teaching agenda. British Journal of Social Work, 36(5), 789-806.

38.

Williams, F. ( 2001). In and beyond New Labour: Towards a new political ethics of care. Critical Social Policy, 21(4), 467-493.