Singapore and Hong Kong are two geographically small economic powerhouses in Asia. In recent years both cities have been attempting to develop their tourism economies by communicating their unique cultural heritages to global tourists. While heritage culture-based tourism practice may help conserve a destination's cultural heritage, its development accelerates the change of the local society; and in the process the authenticity of the cultural heritage of the destination may be lost. This paper presents a comparative analysis of the efforts adopted by Singapore and Hong Kong to communicate their cultural heritages through the tourism developments. It focuses on three questions: (1) Do the inherent contradictions between conservation and change associated with tourism development constitute threats or resources for heritage tourism development? (2) What are the major issues in the process of portraying the past in the present for heritage tourism development? (3) What implications may be drawn, by studying these issues, for the tourism industries in their planning, conservation and promotion efforts to develop heritage tourism?
BeyersB.W. (1992) ‘Producer services’, Progress in Human Geography16, 573–583.
2.
BocockR. (1993) ‘Consumption’, Routledge, London.
3.
BoorstinD. (1964) ‘The Image: A Guide to Pseudo-events in America’, Harper and Row, New York.
4.
BousenC. (1999) ‘Twin success stories: Hong Kong and Singapore’, Maritime Asia, April, 1.
5.
ChangMilneT.C.FallonS.D.PohlmannC. (1996) ‘Urban heritage tourism: The global-local nexus’, Annals of Tourism Research, 23, 284–305.
6.
ChangT.C.YeohB. (1999) ‘New Asia — Singapore: Communicating local cultures through global tourism’, Geoforum, 30, 101–202.
7.
CheungS. (1999) ‘The meanings of a heritage trail in Hong Kong’, Annals of Tourism Research, 26, 570–588.
8.
ChunA. (1987) ‘The land revolution in twentieth century rural Hong Kong’, Bulletin of the Institute of Ethnology in Academia Sinica, 16, 1–10.
9.
CohenE. (1979) ‘A phenomenology of tourist experiences’, Journal of the British Sociological Association, 13, 179–201.
10.
CohenE. (1988) ‘Authenticity and commoditization in tourism’, Annals of Tourism Research, 15, 371–386.
11.
DelyserD. (1999) ‘Authenticity on the ground: Engaging the past in a California ghost town’, Annals of the Association of American Geographers, 89, 602–632.
12.
DixG. (1991) ‘Past indicative, future imperfect: Planning and conservation in an urban environment’, in ‘The future of Hong Kong's Past’ (conference on development and heritage conservation 10–11 October 1991). Hong Kong Convention and Exhibition, Hong Kong.
13.
DrennanP.M. (1992) ‘Gateway cities: The metropolitan sources of US producer service exports’, Urban Studies, 29, 217–235.
14.
FowlerP. (1989) ‘Heritage: A postmodernist perspective’, in UzzellD. (ed) ‘Heritage Interpretation: The Natural and Built Environment’, Belhaven, London.
15.
GoeldnerC. (1992) ‘Travel trends in the United States and Canada’, Business Research Division, University of Colorado, Boulder.
16.
GoldJ. (1994) ‘Locating the message: Place promotion as image communication’, in GoldJ.WardS. (eds) ‘Place Promotion: The Use of Publicity and Marketing to Sell Towns and Regions’, John Wiley & Sons, Toronto.
17.
GreenwoodD. (1982) ‘Cultural authenticity’, Cultural Survival Quarterly, 6, 27–28.
18.
HabibullahK. (1998) ‘The tourism explosion: Policy decisions facing Singapore’, in TylerD.GuerrierY.RobertsonM. (eds), ‘Managing Tourism in Cities: Policy, Process and Practices’, John Wiley & Sons, Chichester.
19.
HallM.McArthurS. (1993) ‘Heritage Management in New Zealand and Australia’, Oxford University Press, Oxford.
20.
HarveyD. (1989) ‘The Condition of Postmodernity’, Basil Blackwell, Oxford.
21.
HeeleyJ. (1989) ‘Heritage and tourism’, in HebentonS. (ed.) ‘Heritage, Tourism and Leisure’, The Planning Exchange, Glasgow.
22.
HeideggerM. (1962) ‘Being and Time’, Harper & Row, New York.
23.
HendersonJ. (2000) ‘Attracting tourists to Singapore's Chinatown: A case study in conservation and promotion’, Tourism Management, 21, 525–534.
24.
HendersonJ. (2002) ‘Built heritage and colonial cities’, Annals of Tourism Research, 29, 254–257.
HitchcockM.KingV.ParnwellM. (eds) (1993) ‘Tourism in Southeast Asia’, Routledge, London.
27.
Hong Kong Antiquities and Monument Office (1992) ‘The heritage of Hong Kong’, Government Printer, Hong Kong.
28.
Hong Kong Antiquities and Monument Office (2000) ‘Report of the Antiquities Advisory Board 1997 and 2000’, HKAMO, Hong Kong.
29.
Hong Kong Special Administrative Region (SAR) Government (2000) ‘Policy address — Tourism: Policy objective for Economic Services Bureau’, Hong Kong SAR Government, Hong Kong.
30.
Hong Kong Tourism Board (HKTB) (1999a) ‘International market research study 1999’, HKTB, Hong Kong.
31.
HKTB (1999b) ‘Essential Hong Kong: The official Hong Kong guide’, HKTB, Hong Kong.
32.
HKTB (1999c) ‘Hong Kong's Heritage — A History of 6,000 years: Cultural Sequence Chart’, HKTB, Hong Kong.
33.
HKTB (2000a) ‘A Statistical Review of Hong Kong tourism’, HKTB, Hong Kong.
34.
HKTB (2000b) ‘Essential Hong Kong: The Official Hong Kong Guide’, HKTB, Hong Kong.
35.
HopkinsJ. (1998) ‘Signs of the post-rural: Marketing myths of a symbolic countryside’, Geografiska Annaler, 80, 65–81.
36.
KliegerP. (1990) ‘Close encounters: Intimate tourism in Tibet’, Cultural Survival Quarterly, 14, 38–42.
37.
KwongK. (1997) ‘Policy Recommendations’, The University of Hong Kong Press, Hong Kong.
38.
MeagherM. (1991) ‘Canadian environmental marketing programs: How to walk the balance link in making good environment into good business’, The Canadian Green Marketing Alert, 1, 7–10.
39.
MacCannellD. (1973) ‘Staged authenticity: Arrangements of social space in tourist settings’, American Journal of Sociology, 79, 589–603.
40.
MacCannellD. (1976) ‘The Tourist: A New Theory of the Leisure Class’, Macmillan, London.
41.
MoscardoG. (1996) ‘Mindful visitors: Heritage and tourism’, Annals of Tourism Research, 23, 376–397.
42.
McIntoshA. (1999) ‘Into the tourist's mind: Understanding the value of the heritage experience’, Journal of Travel & Tourism Marketing, 8, 41–64.
43.
McIntoshA.PrenticeR. (1999) ‘Affirming authenticity: Consuming cultural heritage’, Annals of Tourism Research, 26, 589–612.
44.
MillerD. (1995) ‘Consumption as the vanguard of history: A polemic by way of introduction’, in MillerD. (ed.) ‘Acknowledging Consumption: A Review of New Studies’, Routledge, New York.
45.
NuryantiW. (1996) ‘Heritage and postmodern tourism’, Annals of Tourism Research, 23, 249–260.
46.
PearceD. (1993) ‘Comparative studies in tourism research’, in PearceD.ButlerR. (eds), ‘Tourism Research: Critiques and Challenges’, Routledge, London.
47.
PearceP. (1988) ‘The Ulysses Factor’, Springer-Verlag, New York.
48.
PearceP.CaltabinaoM. (1983) ‘Inferring travel motivation from travellers' experiences’, Journal of Travel Research, 22, 16–20.
49.
RelphE. (1976) ‘Place and Placelessness’, Pion, London.
50.
RichardsG. (1996) ‘Production and consumption of European cultural tourism’, Annals of Tourism Development, 23, 261–283.
51.
RyanC. (1997) ‘The chase of a dream, the end of a play’, in RyanC. (ed.) ‘The Tourist Experience: A New Introduction’, Cassell, London.
52.
SayerD. (1989) ‘Interpretation: A key to tourism and conservation expansion in developing countries’, in UzzellD. (ed.) ‘Heritage Interpretation: The Natural and Built Environment’, Belhaven, London.
53.
Singapore Tourism Board (STB) (1998) ‘Survey of Overseas Visitors to Singapore’, STB, Singapore.
54.
STB (2000a) ‘Tourism Focus June 2000’, STB, Singapore.
55.
STB (2000b) ‘Fact Sheet: Performance of the Tourism Sector as at December 2000’, STB, Singapore.
SquireS. (1994) ‘Accounting for cultural meanings: The interface between geography and tourism studies re-examined’, Progress in Human Geography, 18, 1–16.
SwainM. (1990) ‘Commoditizing ethnicity in Southwest China’, Cultural Survival Quarterly, 14, 26–29.
61.
SwainM. (1993) ‘Women producers of ethnic arts’, Annals of Tourism Research, 20, 32–51.
62.
SwainM. (1995) ‘A comparison of state and private artisan production for tourism in Yunnan’, in LewA.YuL. (eds) ‘Tourism in China: Geographic, political, and economic perspectives’, Westview Press, Boulder.
63.
TeoP.HuangS. (1995) ‘Tourism and heritage conservation in Singapore’, Annals of Tourism Research, 22, 589–615.
64.
TeoP.HuangS. (2000) ‘Singapore: Tourism development in a planned context’, in HallM.PageS. (eds) ‘Tourism in South and Southeast Asia: Issues and Cases’, Butterworth Heinemann, Oxford.
65.
TownerJ. (1985) ‘The grand tour: A key phase in the history of tourism’, Annals of Tourism Research, 12, 297–333.
66.
UrryJ. (1990) ‘The Tourist Gaze: Leisure and Travel in Contemporary Societies’, Sage Publications, London.
WightP. (1994) ‘Environmentally responsible marketing of tourism’, in CaterE.LowmanG. (eds) ‘Ecotourism: A Sustainable Option?’, John Wiley & Sons Ltd, West Sussex, England.
