This study explores the relationship between host community residents'
attitudes about the environment and the benefits and costs of various types of
tourism development. Factor cluster analysis based on participant scores on the
new environmental paradigm scale revealed that the residents comprised three
groups: Conservationists; Anthropocentrics; and Optimists. The Conservationists
supported the development of ecotourism but were less supportive of and saw
fewer benefits from the development of other forms of tourism than the other two
groups. This group appears to be most concerned about the amount of abuse nature
can withstand. Implications for tourism planners and developers are
discussed.
AccuryA.
T. (1990)
‘Environmental attitude and environmental
knowledge’, Human Organization,
49, 4,
300–304.
2.
AdamsC.
(1993) ‘Environmentally sensitive
predictors of boat traffic loading on inland
waterways’, Leisure Studies,
12, 1,
71–79.
3.
AlbrechtD.ButenaG.HoibergE.NowakP.
(1982) ‘The new environmental paradigm
scale’, Journal of Environmental
Education, 13,
39–43.
4.
AllenL.
R.HaferH. R.LongP. T.PerdueR.
R. (1993)
‘Rural residents' attitudes toward recreation
and tourism development’, Journal of Travel
Research, 31, 4,
27–33.
5.
AllenL.
R.LongP.T.PerdueR. R.KieselbachS.
(1988) ‘The impact of tourism development
on residents' perceptions of community life’,
Journal of Travel Research, 27,
1, 16–21.
ApJ.
(1992) ‘Residence perceptions on tourism
impacts’, Annals of Tourism
Research, 19, 4,
665–690.
8.
ApJ.CromptonJ.
L. (1993)
‘Residents' strategies for responding to
tourism impacts’, Journal of Travel
Research, 32, 1,
47–50.
9.
AyalaH.
(1996) ‘Resort ecotourism: A paradigm for
the 21st century’, The Cornell Hotel and
Restaurant Administration Quarterly, 37,
5, 46–53.
10.
AyalaH.
(1998) ‘Panama's ecotourism-plus
initiative: The challenge of making history’,
The Cornell Hotel and Restaurant Administration Quarterly,
39, 5,
68–79.
11.
BadgerA.
(1992) ‘Tourism
concern’, World Leisure and
Recreation, 34, 2,
42–44.
12.
BelisleF.
J.HoyD.
R. (1980)
‘The perceived impact of tourism by residents, a case
study in Santa Marta, Columbia’, Annals of
Tourism Research, 7,
83–101.
13.
BooE.
(1990) ‘Ecotourism: The Potentials and
Pitfalls’, World Wildlife
Fund, Washington,
DC.
14.
BotleinM.McGowanM. L.DiGrionB.
N. (1991) ‘A
sustainable development in rural communities’, Travel and
Tourism Research Association Conference Proceedings,
409–415.
15.
BroughamJ.
E.ButlerR.
W. (1981)
‘A segmentation analysis of resident attitudes to the
social impact of tourism’, Annals of Tourism
Research, 8,
569–590.
16.
ButlerR.
W. (1975)
‘Tourism as an agent of social
change’ in HelleinerF.
(ed.) ‘Tourism as a Factor in National and Regional
Development’, Occasional Paper No.4,
Department of Geography, Trent University,
Peterborough, Ontario,
85–90.
17.
ButtelF.
H. (1979)
‘Age and environmental concern: A multivariate
analysis’, Youth and Society,
10, 3,
237–56.
18.
CookeK.
(1982) ‘Guidelines for socially
appropriate tourism development in British Columbia’,
Journal of Travel Research, 21,
1, 22–28.
19.
CrosleyJ.LeeB.
(1994) ‘Ecotourists and mass tourists: A
difference in benefits sought’, Travel and Tourism Research
Association 25th Annual Conference Proceedings,
22–30.
20.
DavisD.AllenJ.CosenzaR.
M. (1988)
‘Segmenting local residents by their attitudes,
interests and opinions toward tourism’,
Journal of Travel Research, 27,
3, 2–8.
21.
DillmanD.
A. (1978)
‘Mail and Telephone Surveys: The Total Design
Method’, John Wiley and
Sons, Pullman,
WA.
22.
DillmanD.
A.ChristensenJ.
A. (1972)
‘The public value for pollution
control’ in BurchW.
(ed) ‘Social Behavior, Natural Resources and the
Environment’, Harper and
Row, New York,
237–256.
23.
DowlingR.
(1998) ‘Global ecotourism report on
“World Ecotour 1997”, the First World Congress and Exhibition
on Ecotourism, Rio de Janeiro, Brazil, 15–18 December
1997’, Tourism Management,
19, 5,
481–483.
24.
DoxeyG.
V. (1975)
‘A causation theory of visitor-resident irritants;
methodology and research inferences’, Travel and Tourism
Research Association Sixth Annual conference Proceedings, San Diego, California,
195–198.
25.
DrakeS.
(1991) ‘Local participation in ecotourism
projects’ in WhelanT.
(ed.), ‘Nature Tourism: Managing for the
Environment’, Island Press,
Washington, DC,
132–163.
26.
DunlapR.
E. (1975)
‘The impact of political orientation on environmental
attitudes and actions’, Environment and
Behavior, 7,
428–454.
27.
DunlapR.Van
LiereK.
(1978) ‘The new environmental paradigm: A
proposed measuring instrument and preliminary
results’, Journal of Environmental
Education, 9,
10–19.
28.
DunlapR.Van LiereK.MertigA. G.CattonW.
R.Jr.HowellR.
E. (1992)
‘Measuring endorsement of an ecological worldview: A revised
NEP scale’ presented at the annual meeting of the Rural
Sociological Society.
GajrajA.
(1988) ‘A regional approach to
environmentally sound tourism development’,
Tourism Recreation Research, 13,
2, 5–9.
31.
GaylordC.
G. (1990)
‘International cooperation in environmental
education’ in MillerM.
L.AuyongJ.
(eds) ‘Environmental Conservation, Vol II’,
17, (NCRI-T-91-010),
394–399.
32.
GellerJ.LasleyP.
(1985) ‘The new environmental paradigm
scale: A reexamination’, Journal of
Environmental Education, 17,
9–12.
33.
GurungH.
(1992) ‘Environmental education in Nepal:
A mechanism for resource conservation’, World
Leisure and Recreation, 34, 2,
18–22.
34.
HairJ.
F.Jr.AndersonR.E.TathamR.L.BlackW.C.
(1992) ‘Multivariate Data
Analysis’, Macmillan,
New York.
35.
HansmanE.KidD.GilbertE.
(1974) ‘Man's impact on a newly
formed reservoir’, Hydrobiologia,
45,
185–197.
36.
HiertaE.
(1994) ‘Rescuing the
reef’, National Parks,
68, 11–12,
32–37.
37.
JurowskiC.
(1995) ‘An examination of preferences and
evaluations of visitors based on environmental attitudes: Biscayne Bay
National Park’, Journal of Sustainable
Tourism, 3, 2,
73–86.
38.
JurowskiC.
(1998) ‘A study of community sentiments
in relation to attitudes toward tourism development’,
Tourism Analysis, 3, 1,
17–24.
39.
JurowskiC.UysalM.NoeF.
(1993) ‘U.S. Virgin Islands National
Park: A factor-cluster segmentation study’,
Journal of Travel and Tourism Marketing,
1, 4,
3–31.
40.
JurowskiC.UysalM.WilliamsD.
R. (1997)
‘A theoretical analysis of host community resident
reactions to tourism’, Journal of Travel
Research, 36, 2,
3–11.
41.
JurowskiC.WalkerG.
(1995) ‘Personal values and environmental
attitudes effect on pleasure trip preferences’, 26th Annual
TTRA Conference Proceedings, Acapulco, Mexico,
193–202.
42.
KarenP.MatherC.
(1985) ‘Tourism and environment in the
Mount Everest region’, Geographical
Review, 75, 1,
93–95.
43.
KeoghB.
(1990) ‘Resident recreationists'
perceptions and attitudes with respect to tourism
development’, Journal of Applied Recreation
Research, 15, 2,
71–83.
44.
KretchmanJ.
A.EgalesP.
(1990) ‘An analysis of the motives of
ecotourists in comparison to the general Canadian
population’, Sociology and Leisure,
13,
499–508.
45.
La PierreY.
L. (1994)
‘Illicit harvest’,
National Parks, 68,
5–6,
33–37.
46.
LeeC.LeeJ.HanS.
(1998) ‘Measuring the economic value of
ecotourism resources: The case of South Korea’,
Journal of Travel Research, 36,
4, 40–46.
47.
LeeD.
(1994) ‘Breaking the sound
barrier’, National Parks,
68, 7–8,
25–29.
48.
LiuJ. C.VarT.
(1986) ‘Resident attitudes toward tourism
impacts in Hawaii’, Annals of Tourism
Research, 13, 2,
193–219.
49.
LongP.
T.PerdueR. R.AllenL.
(1990) ‘Rural resident tourism
perceptions and attitudes by community level of
tourism’, Journal of Travel
Research, 28, 3,
3–9.
50.
LuzarE.
J.AssaneP.GanC. E. C.HenningB.
R. (1998)
‘Profiling the nature-based tourist: A multinomial
logit approach’, Journal of Travel
Research, 37, 1,
48–54.
51.
MalloyD.
C.FennelD.
A. (1998)
‘Ecotourism and ethics: Moral development and
organizational cultures’, Journal of Travel
Research, 36, 4,
47–57.
MathiesonA.WallG.
(1982) ‘Tourism: Economic, Physical, and Social
Impacts’, Longman,
London.
55.
McClarenD.
(1998) ‘Rethinking Tourism and Ecotravel: The
Paving of Paradise and What You Can Do to Stop It’,
Kumarioan Press, West
Hartford, CT.
56.
McNeelyJ.
A.ThorsellJ. W.Ceballos-LascurainH.
(1992) ‘Guidelines: Development of National
Parks and Protected Areas for Tourism’,
World Tourism Organization, Madrid and United Nations
Environment Programme,
Paris.
57.
MericH.
J.HuntJ.
(1998) ‘Ecotourists' motivations
and demographic characteristics: A case of North Carolina
travelers’, Journal of Travel
Research, 36, 4,
57–61.
58.
MercerD.
(1996)
‘Ecotourism’,
Geodate, 9, 1,
1–4.
59.
MilmanA.PizamA.
(1987) ‘Social impacts of tourism on
Central Florida’, Annals of Tourism
Research, 15,
191–204.
60.
MountfortG.
(1974) ‘The need for partnership: Tourism
and conservation’, Development
Forum, April, 6–7.
61.
MyersN.
(1975) ‘The silent
savannahs’, International Wildlife,
5, 5,
5–10.
62.
NorrisR.
(1994) ‘Ecotourism in the national parks
of Latin America’, National Parks,
68, 2,
33–37.
63.
PerdueR.
R.LongP. T.AllenL.
(1987) ‘Rural resident tourism
perceptions and attitudes’, Annals of Tourism
Research, 14,
420–429.
64.
PerdueR.
R.LongP. T.AllenL.
(1990) ‘Resident support for tourism
development’, Annals of Tourism
Research, 17,
586–599.
65.
PizamA.
(1978) ‘Tourism's impacts: The
social costs to the destination community as perceived by its
residents’, Journal of Travel
Research, 16, 4,
8–12.
66.
PrenticeR.
(1989) ‘Environmental analysis in
tourism’ in WittS.MontinhoL.
(eds), ‘Tourism Marketing and Management
Handbook’, Prentice Hall,
New York,
131–136.
67.
RicciutiE.
(1976) ‘Mountains
besieged’, International Wildlife,
6, 6,
24–35.
68.
RitchieJ. R.
B. (1988)
‘Consensus policy formulation in
tourism’, Tourism Management,
9, 3,
199–216.
69.
RossG.
F. (1992)
‘Resident perceptions of the impact of tourism on an
Australian city’, Journal of Travel
Research, 30, 3,
13–17.
70.
RothmanR.
A. (1978)
‘Residents and transients: Community reaction to
seasonal visitors’, Journal of Travel
Research, 16, 3,
8–13.
SheldonP.J.VarT.
(1984) ‘Resident attitudes to tourism in
North Wales’, Tourism Management,
5, 1,
40–47.
73.
SilverbergK.BackmanS.BackmanK.
(1996) ‘A preliminary investigation into
the psychographics of nature-based travelers to the southeastern United
States’, Journal of Travel Research,
35, 2,
2–21.
74.
SimonsP.
(1988) ‘Après ski le
deluge’, New Scientist,
14, 49–52.
75.
SirakayE.McLellanR.
W. (1998)
‘Modeling tour operators' voluntary compliance
with ecotourism principles: A behavioral approach’,
Journal of Travel Research, 36,
3, 42–55.
76.
SmithG.
(1990) ‘A new species of
tourists’, Americas,
42, 6,
16–20.
TisdellC.
(1996) ‘Ecotourism, economics and the
environment: Observations from China’,
Journal of Travel Research, 34,
4, 11–19.
80.
TylerC.
(1989) ‘Killing the
goose’, Geographical Magazine,
61, 10,
38–43.
81.
TyrrellT.
J.SpauldingI.
A. (1984)
‘A survey of attitudes toward tourism growth in Rhode
Island’, Hospitality Education and Research
Journal, 8,
22–33.
82.
UmS.CromptonJ.
L. (1987)
‘Measuring residents' attachment levels in a
host community’, Journal of Travel
Research, 26, 2,
27–29.
83.
US Government Printing Office
(1979) ‘Compilation of Selected Acts Concerning
National Parks and Recreation Related Matters’, prepared for
the use of the Committee on Interior and Insular Affairs, House of
Representatives. US Government Printing Office,
Washington, DC, 81.
84.
UysalM.JurowskiC.NoeF.McDonaldC.
(1994) ‘Environmental attitude by trip
and visitor characteristics’, Tourism
Management, 15, 4,
284–294.
85.
Van LiereK.
D.DunlapR.
E. (1980)
‘The social bases of environmental concern: A review
of hypotheses, explanation and empirical evidence’,
Public Opinion Quarterly, 44,
181–199.
86.
VarT.KendalK. W.TarakciogluE.
(1985) ‘Residents' attitudes
toward tourists in a Turkish resort town’,
Annals of Tourism Research, 12,
652–658.
87.
WangC.MitoP.
S. (1997)
‘Environmental impacts of tourism on U.S. National
Parks’, Journal of Travel Research.
35, 4,
31–36.
88.
WheellerB.
(1991) ‘Tourism's troubled times:
Responsible tourism is not the answer’,
Tourism Management, 12, 2,
91–94.
WightP.
(1996) ‘North American ecotourism
markets: Motivations, preferences, and destinations’,
Journal of Travel Research, 35,
1, 3–10.
91.
World Tourism Organization (WTO)
(1994) ‘Travel Summary’,
World Tourism Organization,
Madrid, Spain.
92.
YonglongL.
(1996) ‘Eco-tourism industry development
— An alternate to sustainable use of
landscape’, Journal of Environmental
Sciences, 8, 3,
298–307.
93.
YoonY.
(1998) ‘Determinants of Urban Residents
Perceived Tourism Impacts: A Study on the Williamsburg and Virginia beach
Areas’, unpublished MS thesis, Department of
Hospitality and Tourism Management, Virginia Polytechnic Institute and State
University, Blacksburg,
VA.
