This article focuses on the factors that are deemed important by magistrates and
psychologists in the prediction of dangerous or violent behaviour. Five case
studies, in which the risk of violence came into play, were presented to the
respondents (85 magistrates and 52 psychologists) with the aid of a self-compiled
questionnaire. The opinions of the legal practitioners and psychologists concerning
the risk of violence that was involved in each case study were tested on the basis
of two questions: (i) To what degree is the person in the case study a danger to the
community? and (ii) Which risk factors were decisive in respect of Question 1? There
was agreement between the two professional groups regarding risk factors. However,
in certain cases there was a difference between the two professional groups in
respect of the weight allocated to the specific risk factors (for example,
psychologists attached more value than the legal practitioners to age, race, gender,
the absence of a criminal record, the absence of remorse and drug addiction).
Another insight-giving finding was that the opinions of the psychologists concerning
risk factors are more substantially supported by existing research than those of magistrates.
Allan, A.
and
D.A. Louw
(2001)
‘Lawyers’ Perception of Psychologists Who do Forensic Work’
, South African Journal of Psychology31(2):
12-20
.
2.
American Psychiatric Association
(1994) Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental
Disorders—Fourth Edition (DSM-IV).
Washington, DC: American Psychiatric Association
.
3.
Andrews, D.A.
,
I. Zinger
,
R.D. Hoge
,
J. Bonta
,
P. Gendreau
and
F.T. Cullen
(1990)
‘Does Correctional Treatment Work: A Clinical Relevant and
Psychologically Informed Meta-analysis’
, Criminology28(3):
369-404
.
4.
Appelbaum, P.S.
,
P. Robbins
and
J. Monahan
(2000)
‘Violence and Delusions: Data from the McArthur Violence Risk
Assessment Study’
, American Journal of Psychiatry157(4):
566-572
.
5.
Ball, E.M.
,
D. Young
,
L.A. Dotson
,
L.T. Brothers
and
D. Robbins
(1994)
‘Factors Associated with Dangerous Behaviour in Forensic
Inpatients: Results from a Pilot Study’
, Bulletin of the American Academy of Psychiatry and the Law22(4):
605-620
.
6.
Barratt, E.S.
(1994) ‘Impulsiveness and
Aggression’, in
J. Monahan
and
H.J. Steadman
(eds) Violence and Mental Disorder: Developments in Risk
Assessment, pp. 61-79.
Chicago, IL: University Press
.
7.
Blackburn, R.
(2000a) ‘Risk Assessment and
Prediction’, in
J. McGuire
,
T. Mason
and
A. O’Kane
(eds) Behavior, Crime and Legal Processes: A Guide for Forensic
Practitioners, pp. 75-90.
Chichester: Wiley
.
8.
Blackburn, R.
(2000b) ‘Psychopathy and Personality Disorder in
Relation to Violence’, in
C.R. Hollin
(ed.) Clinical Approaches to Violence (2nd edn), pp.
195-220.
Chichester: Wiley
.
9.
Blomhoff, S.
,
S. Seim
and
S. Friss
(1990)
‘Can Predictions of Violence Among Psychiatric Inpatients be Improved?’
, Hospital and Community Psychiatry41(7):
771-775
.
10.
Bonta, J.
,
M. Law
and
R.K. Hanson
(1998)
‘The Prediction of Criminal and Violent Recidivism Among Mentally
Disordered Offenders: A Meta-analysis’
, Psychological Bulletin123(2):
123-142
.
11.
Buchanan, A.
,
A. Reed
,
S. Wessely
,
P. Garety
,
D. Grubin
and
G. Dunn
(1993)
‘Acting on Delusions. II: The Phenomenological Correlates of
Acting on Delusions’
, British Journal of Psychiatry163:
771-781
.
12.
Bush, D.
and
K.R. White
(1985)
‘Questionnaire Distribution: A Method that Significantly Improved
Return Rates’
, Psychological Reports56(2):
427-430
.
13.
Cornell, D.G.
,
C.S. Peterson
and
H. Richards
(1999)
‘Anger as a Predictor of Aggression Among Incarcerated Adolescents’
, Journal of Consulting and Clinical Psychology67(1):
108-115
.
14.
Douglas, K.S.
,
D.N. Cox
and
C.D. Webster
(1999)
‘Violence Risk Assessment: Science and Practice’
, Legal and Criminological Psychology4(2):
149-184
.
15.
Douglas, K.S.
and
S.D. Hart
(2002) ‘Psychosis as a Risk Factor in Violence: A
Quantitative Review of the Rresearch’. Manuscript under review.
16.
Douglas, K.S.
,
K.R.P. Ogloff
and
T.L. Nicholls
(1997)
‘The Role of Personality Disorders in Community Violence among
Civil Psychiatric Patients’
, Paper presented at the Fifth International Congress of the
Disorders of Personality, Vancouver, B.C., June. Symposium Moderator: C.D. Webster.
17.
Douglas, K.S.
and
C.D. Webster
(1999) ‘Predicting Violence in Mentally and
Personality Disordered Iindividuals’, in
R. Roesch
,
S.D. Hart
and
J.R.P. Ogloff
(eds) Psychology and Law: The State of the Discipline, pp.
175-239.
New York: Plenum
.
18.
Elbogen, E.B.
(2002)
‘The Process of Violence Risk Assessment: A Review of Descriptive Research’
, Aggression and Violent Behavior7(6):
591-604
.
19.
Elbogen, E.B.
,
C.C. Mercado
,
M.J. Scalora
and
A.J. Tomkins
(2002)
‘Perceived Relevance of Factors for Violence Risk Assessment: A
Survey of Clinicians’
, International Journal of Forensic Mental Health1(1):
37-47
.
20.
Estroff, S.E.
and
C. Zimmer
(1994) ‘Social Networks, Social Support, and
Violence among Persons with Severe, Persistent Mental
Illness’, in
J. Monahan
and
H.J. Steadman
(eds) Violence and Mental Disorder: Developments in Risk
Assessment, pp. 259-295.
Chicago, IL: Chicago University Press
.
21.
Estroff, S.E.
,
C. Zimmer
,
W.S. Lachiotte
and
J. Benoit
(1994)
‘The Influence of Social Networks and Social Support on Violence
by Persons with Serious Mental Illness’
, Hospital and Community Psychiatry45(7):
669-679
.
22.
Farrington, D.P.
(1994) ‘Childhood, Adolescent and Adult Features
of Violent Males’, in
L.R. Huesmann
(ed.) Aggressive Behavior: Current Perspectives, pp.
215-240.
New York: Plenum
.
23.
Farrington, D.P.
(2001) ‘Predicting Adult Official and
Self-Reported Violence’, in
G.F. Pinard
and
L. Pagani
(eds) Clinical Assessment of Dangerousness—Empirical
Contributions, pp. 66-87.
Cambridge: Cambridge University Press
.
Freedman, M.D.
(2001)
‘False Prediction of Future Dangerousness’
, Journal of the American Academy of Psychiatry and the Law29(1):
89-95
.
26.
Gardner, W.
,
S.D. Lidz
,
E.P. Mulvey
and
E.C. Shaw
(1996)
‘A Comparison of Actuarial Methods for Identifying Repetitively
Violent Patients with Mental Illness’
, Law and Human Behavior20(1):
35-38
.
27.
Gendrau, P.
(1995)
‘Predicting Criminal Behaviour: What Works?’
, Paper presented at the annual meeting of the Canadian
Psychological Association, Charlottetown, Prince Edward
Island, Canada, June.
28.
Gondolf, E.W.
,
E.P. Mulvey
and
C.W. Lidz
(1991)
‘Psychiatric Admission of Family Violent Versus Nonfamily Violent Patients’
, International Journal of Law and Psychiatry14(1):
245-254
.
29.
Hare, R.D.
(1991) Manual for the Psychopathy Checklist-Revised.
Toronto: Multi-Health Systems
.
30.
Hare, R.D.
(1996)
‘Psychopathy: A Clinical Construct Whose Time has Come’
, Criminal Justice and Behavior23(1):
25-54
.
31.
Harris, G.T.
,
M.E. Rice
and
C.A. Cormier
(1991)
‘Psychopathy and Violent Recidivism’
, Law and Human Behavior15(6):
625-637
.
32.
Harris, G.T.
,
M.E. Rice
and
V.L. Quinsey
(1993)
‘Violent Recidivism of Mentally Disordered Offenders: The
Development of a Statistical Prediction Instrument’
, Criminal Justice and Behavior20(4):
315-335
.
33.
Hart, S.D.
,
R.D. Hare
and
A.E. Forth
(1994) ‘Psychopathy as a Risk Marker for
Violence: Development and Validation of a Screening Version of the Revised
Psychopathy Checklist’, in
J. Monahan
and
H.J. Steadman
(eds) Violence and Mental Disorder: Developments in Risk
Assessment, pp. 81-99.
Chicago, IL: Chicago University Press
.
34.
Haywood, T.W.
,
H.M. Krawitz
,
L.S. Grossman
,
J.L. Cavanaugh
,
J.M. Davis
and
D.A. Lewis
(1995)
‘Predicting the “Revolving Door” Phenomenon
among Patients with Schizophrenic, Schizoaffective, and Affective Disorders’
, American Journal of Psychiatry152(6):
856-861
.
35.
Hemphill, J.F.
,
R.D. Hare
and
S. Wong
(1998)
‘Psychopathy and Recidivism: A Review’
, Legal and Criminological Psychology3(1):
139-170
.
36.
Hollander, E.
and
D.J. Stein
(eds) (1995) Impulsivity and Aggression.
Toronto: Wiley
.
37.
Junginger, J.
(1990)
‘Predicting Compliance with Command Hallucinations’
, American Journal of Psychiatry147(2):
245-247
.
38.
Klassen, D.
and
W.A. O’Connor
(1994) ‘Demographic and Case History Variables
in Risk Assessment’, in
J. Monahan
and
H.J. Steadman
(eds) Violence and Mental Disorder. Developments in Risk Assessment. The
John D. and Catherine T. MacArthur Foundation Series on Mental Health and
Development, pp. 229-257.
Chicago, IL: University of Chicago Press
.
39.
Krakowski, M.
,
J. Jaeger
and
J. Volavka
(1988)
‘Violence and Psychopathology: A Longitudinal Study’
, Comprehensive Psychiatry29(2):
174-181
.
40.
Kropp, P.R.
,
S.D. Hart
,
C.D. Webster
and
D. Eaves
(1999) Manual for the Spousal Assault Guide (3rd
edn).
Toronto: Multi Health Systems
.
41.
Lattimore, P.K.
,
C.A. Visher
and
R.L. Linster
(1995)
‘Predicting Rearrest for Violence among Serious Youthful Offenders’
, Journal of Research in Crime and Delinquency32(1):
54-83
.
42.
Lidz, C.W.
,
E.P. Mulvey
and
W. Gardner
(1993)
‘The Accuracy of Predictions of Violence to Others’
, Journal of the American Medical Association269(8):
1007-1011
.
43.
Link., B.G.
,
H. Andrews
and
F.T. Cullen
(1992)
‘The Violent and Illegal Behavior of Mental Patients Reconsidered’
, American Sociological Review57(3):
275-292
.
44.
Link, B.G.
,
J. Monahan
,
A. Stueve
and
F.T. Cullen
(1999)
‘Real in their Consequences: A Sociological Approach to
Understanding the Association between Psychotic Symptoms and Violence’
, American Sociological Review64(2):
316-332
.
45.
Link, B.G.
and
A. Stueve
(1994) ‘Psychotic Symptoms and the
Violent/Illegal Behavior of Mental Patients Compared to Community
Controls’, in
J. Monahan
and
H.J. Steadman
(eds) Violence and Mental Disorder: Developments in Risk
Assessment, pp. 137-159.
Chicago, IL: Chicago University Press
.
46.
Litwack, T.R.
and
L.B. Schlesinger
(1987) ‘Assessing and Predicting Violence:
Research, Law and Applications’, in
A.K. Hess
and
I.B. Weiner
(eds) Handbook of Forensic Psychology, pp.
205-237.
New York: Wiley
.
47.
Litwack, T.R.
and
L.B. Schlesinger
(1999) ‘Dangerousness Risk Assessments:
Research, Legal, and Clinical Considerations’, in
A.K. Hess
and
I.B. Weiner
(eds) The Handbook of Forensic Psychology (2nd edn), pp.
171-211.
New York: Wiley
.
48.
Marzuk, P.M.
(1996)
‘Editorial. Violence, Crime, and Mental Illness: How Strong a Link?’
, Archives of General Psychiatry53(6):
481-486
.
49.
Maxfield, M.G.
and
C.S. Widom
(1996)
‘The Cycle of Violence Revisited 6 Years Later’
, Archives of Pediatrics and Adolescent Medicine150(4):
390-395
.
50.
McCord, J.
and
M.E. Ensminger
(1997)
‘Multiple Risks and Comorbidity in an African-American Population’
, Criminal Behavior and Mental Health7(4):
339-352
.
51.
McKillip, J.
and
D.C. Lockhart
(1984)
‘The Effectiveness of Cover-Letter Appeals’
, The Journal of Social Psychology122(1):
85-91
.
52.
McNiel, D.E.
,
R.L. Binder
and
T.K. Greenfield
(1988)
‘Predictors of Violence in Civilly Committed Acute Psychiatric Patients’
, American Journal of Psychiatry145(8):
965-970
.
53.
Melton, G.
,
J. Petrila
,
N. Poythress
and
C. Slobogin
(1997) Psychological Evaluations for the Courts: A Handbook
for Mental Health Professionals and Lawyers (2nd edn).
New York: Guilford
.
54.
Menzies, R.
and
C.D. Webster
(1995)
‘Construction and Validation of Risk Assessments in a Six Year
Follow-up of Forensic Patients: A Tridimensional Analysis’
, Journal of Consulting and Clinical Psychology63(5):
766-778
.
55.
Monahan, J.
(1981) Predicting Violent Behavior: An Assessment of Clinical
Techniques.
Beverly Hills, CA: Sage Publications
.
56.
Monahan, J.
(1997) ‘Clinical and Actuarial Predictions of
Violence’, in
D. Faigman
,
D. Kaye
,
M. Saks
and
J. Sanders
(eds) Modern Scientific Evidence: The Law and Science of Expert
Testimony, (Vol. 1), pp. 300-318.
St Paul: West Publishing Company
.
57.
Monahan, J.
(2001) ‘Major Mental Disorder and Violence:
Epidemiology and Risk Assessment’, in
G.F. Pinard
and
L. Pagani
(eds) Clinical Assessment of Dangerousness—Empirical
Contributions, pp. 89-99.
Cambridge: Cambridge University Press
.
58.
Monahan, J.
(2003) ‘Violence Risk
Assessment’, in
A. Goldstein
(ed.) Handbook of Psychology (Vol. 11), pp.
527-540.
New York: Wiley
.
59.
Monahan J.
and
H.J. Steadman
(1994) ‘Toward a Rejuvenation of Risk Assessment
Research’, in
J. Monahan
and
H.J. Steadman
(eds) Violence and Mental Disorder: Developments in Risk
Assessment, pp. 1-17.
Chicago, IL: Chicago University Press
.
60.
Monahan, J.
,
H.J. Steadman
,
E. Silver
,
A. Appelbaum
,
P. Robbins
,
E.P. Mulvey
,
L. Roth
,
T. Grisso
and
S. Banks
(2001) Rethinking Risk Assessment: The McArthur Study of
Mental Disorder and Violence.
New York: Oxford University Press
.
61.
Motiuk, L.
(1996)
‘Targeting Employment Patterns to Reduce Offender Risk and Need’
, Forum on Corrections Research8(1):
22-24
.
62.
Mulvey, E.P.
(1994)
‘Assessing the Evidence of a Link between Mental Illness and Violence’
, Hospital and Community Psychiatry45(7):
663-668
.
63.
Novaco, R.W.
(1994) ‘Anger as a Risk Factor for Violence
among the Mentally Disordered’, in
J. Monahan
and
H.J. Steadman
(eds) Violence and Mental Disorder: Developments in Risk
Assessment, pp. 21-59.
Chicago, IL: Chicago University Press
.
64.
Ogloff, J.R.P.
and
K.S. Douglas
(1995) The Treatment of High Risk Offenders: A Literature
Review and Analysis. Completed under contract 19011-00-002.
Ottawa, Canada: Department of Justice
.
65.
Ogloff, J.R.P.
,
S. Wong
and
A. Greenwood
(1991)
‘Treating Criminal Psychopaths in a Therapeutic Community Program’
, Behavioral Sciences and the Law8(2):
81-90
.
66.
Prentky, R.A.
,
R.A. Knight
,
A.F.S. Lee
and
D.D. Cerce
(1995)
‘Predictive Validity of Lifestyle Impulsivity for Rapists’
, Criminal Justice and Behavior22(2):
106-128
.
67.
Quinsey, V.L.
,
G.T. Harris
,
G.T. Rice
and
C.A. Cormier
(1998) Violent Offenders: Appraising and Managing Risk.
Washington, DC: American Psychological Association
.
68.
Salekin, R.T.
,
R. Rogers
and
K.W. Sewell
(1996)
‘A Review and Meta-analysis of the Psychopathy Checklist and
Psychopathy Checklist—Revised: Predictive Validity of Dangerousness’
, Clinical Psychology: Science and Practice3(3):
203-215
.
69.
SAS Institute
(1985) SAS Users Guide: Statistics Version 5 Edition.
Cary: SAS Institute
.
70.
Serin, R.C.
and
N.L. Amos
(1995)
‘The Role of Psychopathy in the Assessment of Dangerousness’
, International Journal of Law and Psychiatry18(2):
231-238
.
71.
Shaffer, C.E.
,
W.F. Waters
and
S.G. Adams
(1994)
‘Dangerousness: Assessing Risk of Violent Behavior’
, Journal of Consulting and Clinical Psychology62(5):
1064-1068
.
72.
Sjöstedt, G.
and
M. Grann
(2002)
‘Risk Assessment: What is being Predicted by Actuarial Prediction Instruments?’
, International Journal of Forensic Mental Health1(2):
179-183
.
73.
Steadman, H.J.
,
J. Monahan
,
P.S. Appelbaum
,
T. Grisso
,
L.H. Roth
,
P.C. Robbins
and
D. Klassen
(1994) ‘Designing a New Generation of Risk
Assessment Research’, in
J. Monahan
and
H.J. Steadman
(eds) Violence and Mental Disorder: Developments in Risk
Assessment, pp. 297-318.
Chicago, IL: Chicago University Press
.
74.
Steadman, H.J.
,
E.P. Mulvey
,
J. Monahan
,
P.C. Robbins
,
P.S. Appelbaum
,
T. Grisso
,
L.H. Roth
and
E. Silver
(1998)
‘Violence by People Discharged from Acute Psychiatric Inpatient
Facilities and by Others in the Same Neighbourhoods’
, Archives of General Psychiatry55(5):
393-401
.
75.
Steadman, H.
,
E. Silver
,
J. Monahan
,
P. Robbins
,
E. Mulvey
,
T. Grisso
,
L. Roth
and
S. Banks
(2000)
‘A Classification Tree Approach to the Development of Actuarial
Violence Risk Assessment Tools’
, Law and Human Behavior24(1):
83-100
.
Stueve, A.
and
B.G. Link
(1997)
‘Violence and Psychiatric Disorders: Results from an
Epidemiological Study of Young Adults in Israel’
, Psychiatric Quarterly68(4):
327-342
.
78.
Swanson, J.W.
(1994) ‘Mental Disorder, Substance Abuse, and
Community Violence: An Epidemiological Approach’, in
J. Monahan
and
H.J. Steadman
(eds) Violence and Mental disorder: Developments in Risk
Assessment, pp. 106-136.
Chicago, IL: Chicago University Press
.
79.
Swanson, J.
,
S. Estroff
,
M. Swartz
,
R. Borum
,
W. Lachiotte
,
C. Zimmer
and
R. Wagner
(1997)
‘Violence and Severe Mental Disorder in Clinical and Community
Populations: The Effects of Psychotic Symptoms, Comorbidity, and Lack of Treatment’
, Psychiatry60(1):
1-22
.
80.
Swanson, J.W.
,
C.E. Holzer
,
V.K. Ganju
and
R.T. Jono
(1990)
‘Violence and Psychiatric Disorder in the Community: Evidence
from the Epidemiologic Catchment Area Surveys’
, Hospital and Community Psychiatry41(7):
761-770
.
81.
Tabachnick, B.
and
L.S. Fidell
(1996) Using Multivariate Statistics.
New York: Harper Collins
.
82.
Tarter, R.E.
,
L. Kirisci
,
M. Vanyukov
,
J. Cornelius
,
K. Pajer
,
G. Shoal
and
P.R. Giancola
(2002)
‘Predicting Adolescent Violence: Impact of Family History,
Substance Use, Psychiatric History, and Social Adjustment’
, American Journal of Psychiatry159(9):
1541-1547
.
83.
Virkkunnen, M.
,
M. Eggert
,
R. Rawlings
and
M. Linnoila
(1996)
‘A Prospective Follow-up Study of Alcoholic Violent Offenders and
Fire Setters’
, Archives of General Psychiatry53(6):
523-529
.
84.
Webster, C.D.
,
S.J. Hucker
,
U. McMaster
and
H. Bloom
(2002)
‘Transcending the Actuarial Versus Clinical Polemic in Assessing
Risk for Violence’
, Criminal Justice and Behavior29(5):
659-665
.
85.
Webster, C.D.
and
M.A. Jackson
(eds) (1997) Impulsivity: Theory, Assessment, and
Treatment.
New York: Guilford
.
86.
Wertham, F.
(1978) ‘The Catathymic
Crisis’, in
I.L. Kutash
,
L.B. Kutash
and
L.B. Schlesinger
(eds) Violence: Perspective on Murder and Aggression, pp.
90-105.
San Francisco, CA: Jossey-Bass
.
87.
Widiger, T.A.
and
T.J. Trull
(1994) ‘Personality Disorders and
Violence’, in
J. Monahan
and
H.J. Steadman
(eds) Violence and Mental Disorder: Developments in Risk
Assessment, pp. 203-226.
Chicago, IL: Chicago University Press
.
