Shadow rapporteurs play an important role in developing the European Parliament’s collective policy positions and in defending them in inter-institutional negotiations. This study sheds light on the ‘how’ and ‘why’ of shadow rapporteur selection. Qualitative insights from practitioner interviews and a quantitative analysis of shadow rapporteur data from the 7th European Parliament (2009–2014) indicate that the appointment process is primarily one of bottom-up self-selection by group members based on their policy interests. The party group leadership, in the form of group coordinators, plays an important coordinating role when there is competition for a shadow rapporteurship. However, the role of group coordinators is more akin to a third-party arbiter of competing demands than a mechanism of top-down control by the leadership, as suggested by principal-agent theory.
BakkerRde VriesCEdwardsE, et al. (2015)
Measuring party positions in Europe: the Chapel Hill expert survey trend file, 1999–2010. Party Politics21(1): 143–152.
2.
BenedettoG (2005)
Rapporteurs as legislative entrepreneurs: the dynamics of the codecision procedure in Europe’s Parliament. Journal of European Public Policy12(1): 67–88.
3.
ChiouFYHermansenSSLHøylandB (2019)
Delegation of committee reports in the European Parliament. European Union Politics (online first).
4.
ChiruM (2019)
Loyal soldiers or seasoned leaders? The selection of committee chairs in the European Parliament. Journal of European Public Policy (online first).
5.
CorbettRJacobsFShackletonM (2011) The European Parliament.
London:
John Harper Publishing.
6.
CostelloRThomsonR (2011)
The nexus of bicameralism: Rapporteurs’ impact on decision outcomes in the European Union. European Union Politics12(3): 337–357.
7.
DanielWT (2015) Career Behaviour and the European Parliament.
Oxford:
Oxford University Press.
8.
DanielWTThierseS (2018)
Individual determinants for the selection of group coordinators in the European Parliament. Journal of Common Market Studies56(4): 939–954.
9.
EpsteinDO’HalloranS (1995)
A theory of strategic oversight: Congress, lobbyists, and the bureaucracy. Journal of Law, Economics, and Organization11(2): 227–255.
10.
GilliganTWKrehbielK (1987)
Collective decisionmaking and standing committees: an informational rationale for restrictive amendment procedures. Journal of Law, Economics, and Organization3(2): 287–335.
11.
HägeFM (2011a)
Choice or circumstance? Adjusting measures of foreign policy similarity for chance agreement. Political Analysis19(3): 287–305.
12.
HägeFM (2011b)
Politicising Council decision-making: the effect of European Parliament empowerment. West European Politics34(1): 18–47.
13.
HägeFMRingeN (2019)
Rapporteur-shadow rapporteur networks in the European Parliament: the strength of small numbers. European Journal of Political Research58(1): 209–235.
14.
HausemerP (2006)
Participation and political competition in committee report allocation: under what conditions do MEPs represent their constituents?European Union Politics7(4): 505–530.
15.
HermansenSSL (2018)
(Self-)selection and expertise among decision-makers in the European Parliament.Journal of Legislative Studies24(1): 148–172.
16.
HixSNouryARolandG (2006)
Dimensions of politics in the European Parliament. American Journal of Political Science50(2): 494–520.
17.
HixSNouryARolandG (2007) Democratic Politics in the European Parliament.
Cambridge:
Cambridge University Press.
18.
HøylandB (2006)
Allocation of codecision reports in the fifth European Parliament. European Union Politics7(1): 30–50.
19.
HurkaSKaedingMObholzerL (2015)
Learning on the job? EU enlargement and the assignment of (shadow) rapporteurships in the European Parliament. Journal of Common Market Studies53(6): 1230–1247.
20.
JensenTWinzenT (2012)
Legislative negotiations in the European Parliament. European Union Politics13(1): 118–149.
21.
JudgeDEarnshawD (2011)
Relais actors and co-decision first reading agreements in the European Parliament: the case of the advanced therapies regulation. Journal of European Public Policy18(1): 53–71.
22.
KaedingM (2004)
Rapporteurship allocation in the European Parliament: information or distribution?European Union Politics5(3): 353–371.
23.
KaedingM (2005)
The world of committee reports: rapporteurship assignment in the European Parliament. Journal of Legislative Studies11(1): 82–104.
24.
KreppelA (2002) The EP and Supranational Party System: A Study in Institutional Development.
Cambridge:
Cambridge University Press.
25.
LinLI (1989)
A concordance correlation coefficient to evaluate reproducibility. Biometrics45(1): 255–268.
26.
MamadouhVRaunioT (2003)
The committee system: powers, appointments and report allocation. Journal of Common Market Studies41(2): 333–351.
27.
MarksGHoogheLNelsonM, et al. (2006)
Party competition and European integration in the east and west: different structure, same causality. Comparative Political Studies39(2): 155–175.
28.
ObholzerLHurkaSKaedingM (2019)
Party group coordinators and rapporteurs: discretion and agency loss along the European Parliament’s chains of delegation. European Union Politics20(2): 239–260.
29.
RingeN (2005)
Policy preference formation in legislative politics: structures, actors, and focal points. American Journal of Political Science49(4): 731–745.
30.
RingeN (2010) Who Decides, and How? Preferences, Uncertainty, and Policy Choice in the European Parliament.
Oxford:
Oxford University Press.
31.
Ripoll ServentAPanningL (2019)
Preparatory bodies as mediators of political conflict in trilogues: The European Parliament’s shadows meetings. Politics and Governance7(3): 303–315.
32.
Roederer-RynningCGreenwoodJ (2015)
The culture of trilogues. Journal of European Public Policy22(8): 1148–1165.
33.
TreibOSchlipphakB (2019)
Who gets committee leadership positions in the European Parliament? Evidence from the 2014 selection process.European Union Politics 20(2): 219--238.
34.
WhitakerR (2011) The European Parliament’s Committees: National Party Influence and Legislative Empowerment.
Abingdon:
Routledge.
35.
WhitakerR (2019)
A case of ‘you can always get what you want’? Committee assignments in the European Parliament. Parliamentary Affairs72(1): 162–181.
36.
WilsonSLRingeNvan ThommeJ (2016)
Policy leadership and re-election in the European Parliament. Journal of European Public Policy23(8): 1158–1179.
37.
YordanovaN (2011)
Inter-institutional rules and division of power in the European Parliament: Allocation of consultation and co-decision reports. West European Politics34(1): 97–121.
38.
YordanovaN (2013) Organising the European Parliament.
Colchester:
ECPR Press.
39.
YoshinakaAMcElroyGBowlerS (2010)
The appointment of rapporteurs in the European parliament. Legislative Studies Quarterly35(4): 457–486.
Supplementary Material
Please find the following supplemental material available below.
For Open Access articles published under a Creative Commons License, all supplemental material carries the same license as the article it is associated with.
For non-Open Access articles published, all supplemental material carries a non-exclusive license, and permission requests for re-use of supplemental material or any part of supplemental material shall be sent directly to the copyright owner as specified in the copyright notice associated with the article.
