Is labour mobility in the European Union a threat to the strength of unions? We argue that the combination of cheap labour, workforce heterogeneity and low unionisation among labour immigrants is a potential challenge for unions. The challenge will be severe if immigration affects natives’ unionisation. We use Norwegian administrative data in a natural experiment framework to examine this claim. The 2004 European Union expansion led to a rapid increase in labour migration to the building and construction industry, but licensing demands protected some workers from the labour supply shock. We show negative labour market effects for workers exposed to labour immigration, but no effect on union membership. Our results question theories of unionisation and are relevant for research on immigration, political behaviour and collective action.
AcemogluDRobinsonJAVerdierT (2012) Can't we all be more like Scandinavians? Asymmetric growth and institutions in an interdependent world. NBER Working Paper No. 18441.
2.
AfonsoADevittC (2016)
Comparative political economy and international migration.Socio-Economic Review14(3): 591–613.
3.
AhlquistJS (2017)
Labor unions, political representation, and economic inequality.Annual Review of Political Science20: 409–432.
4.
AkerlofGA (1980)
A theory of social custom, of which unemployment may be one consequence.Quarterly Journal of Economics94(4): 749–775.
5.
AlecuADrangeI (2016) The Norwegian Occupational Regulations Database (NORD). Documentation Report.
6.
AlesinaAGlaeserESacerdoteB (2001)
Why doesn’t the United States have a European-style welfare state?Brookings Papers on Economic Activity2001(2): 187–277.
7.
AlesinaALa FerraraE (2000)
Participation in heterogeneous communities.Quarterly Journal of Economics115(3): 847–904.
8.
AlesinaALa FerraraE (2002)
Who trusts others?Journal of Public Economics85(2): 207–234.
9.
AltJIversenT (2017)
Inequality, labor market segmentation, and preferences for redistribution.American Journal of Political Science61(1): 21–36.
10.
AngristJDImbensGWRubinDB (1996)
Identification of causal effects using instrumental variables.Journal of the American statistical Association91(434): 444–455.
11.
AntónJIBöheimRWinter-EbmerR (2016) The effects of international migration on native workers' unionisation in Austria. IZA Discussion Paper Series No. 10446.
12.
AshenfelterOPencavelJH (1969)
American trade union growth: 1900–1960.Quarterly Journal of Economics83: 434–448.
13.
BarthEMoeneKOWillumsenF (2014)
The Scandinavian model—An interpretation.Journal of Public Economics117: 60–72.
14.
BartikTJ (1991) Who Benefits From State and Local Economic Development Policies?
Kalamazoo:
WE Upjohn Institute for Employment Research.
15.
BlanchflowerDGCrouchleyREstrinS, et al. (1990) Unemployment and the demand for unions. NBER Working Paper No. 3251.
16.
BolTDrangeI (2017)
Occupational closure and wages in Norway.Acta Sociologica60(2): 134–157.
17.
BoothAL (1985)
The free rider problem and a social custom model of trade union membership.Quarterly Journal of Economics100(1): 253–261.
18.
BorjasGJ (2003)
The labor demand curve is downward sloping: Reexamining the impact of immigration on the labor market.Quarterly Journal of Economics118(4): 1335–1374.
19.
BorjasGJ (2015)
Immigration and globalization: A review essay.Journal of Economic Literature53(4): 961–974.
20.
BradyD (2007)
Institutional, economic, or solidaristic? Assessing explanations for unionization across affluent democracies.Work and Occupations34(1): 67–101.
21.
BratsbergBRaaumO (2012)
Immigration and wages: Evidence from construction.The Economic Journal122(565): 1177–1205.
BratsbergBRaaumORøedM, et al. (2014)
Immigration wage effects by origin.Scandinavian Journal of Economics116(2): 356–393.
24.
BurgoonBFineJJacobyW, et al. (2010)
Immigration and the transformation of American unionism.International Migration Review44(4): 933–973.
25.
BusemeyerMR (2009)
From myth to reality: Globalisation and public spending in OECD countries revisited.European Journal of Political Research48(4): 455–482.
26.
ColantoneIStanigP (2018)
Global competition and Brexit.American Political Science Review112(2): 201–218.
27.
CoolsSFinseraasHRasmussenM (2018) The Immigrant-Native Gap in Union Membership: A Question of Time, Sorting or Culture?Working Paper.
28.
CowlesMGCaporasoJARisse-KappenT (2001) Transforming Europe: Europeanization and Domestic Change.
Ithaca:
Cornell University Press.
29.
Dagbladet (2011)
Ny strid splitter Høyre. May 3, 2011, dagbladet.no.
30.
DustmannCSchönberg UJanS (2017)
Labor supply shocks, native wages, and the adjustment of local employment.Quarterly Journal of Economics132(1): 435–483.
31.
EmmeneggerPCarejaR (2012) From dilemma to dualization: Social and migration policies in the ‘reluctant countries of immigration’. In: PatrickESiljaHBrunoP, et al. (eds) The Age of Dualization.
Oxford:
Oxford University Press.
32.
FergusonJP (2016)
Racial diversity and union organizing in the United States, 1999es,tyILR Review69(1): 53–83.
33.
FinseraasHRøedMSchøneP (2017)
Labor market competition with immigrants and political polarization.Quarterly Journal of Political Science12(3): 347–373.
34.
GarrettG (1998)
Global markets and national politics: Collision course or virtuous circle?International Organization52(4): 787–824.
35.
GarrettGLangeP (1986)
Performance in a hostile world: Economic growth in capitalist democracies, 1974th inWorld Politics38(4): 517–545.
36.
GerringJ (2007)
Is there a (viable) crucial-case method?Comparative Political Studies40(3): 231–253.
37.
GerringJ (2008) Case selection for case-study analysis: Qualitative and quantitative techniques. In: JanetBSHenryEBDavidC (eds) Oxford Handbook of Political Methodology.
Oxford:
Oxford University Press.
38.
HainmuellerJ (2012)
Entropy balancing for causal effects: A multivariate reweighting method to produce balanced samples in observational studies.Political Analysis20(1): 25–46.
39.
IbsenCLToubølJJensenDS (2017)
Social customs and trade union membership: A multi-level analysis of workplace union density using micro-data.European Sociological Review33(4): 504–517.
40.
KingDRuedaD (2008)
Cheap labor: The new politics of “bread and roses” in industrial democracies.Perspectives on Politics6(2): 279–297.
41.
KorpiW (2006)
Power resources and employer-centered approaches in explanations of welfare states and varieties of capitalism: Protagonists, consenters, and antagonists.World Politics58(2): 167–206.
42.
KorpiWShalevM (1979)
Strikes, industrial relations and class conflict in capitalist societies.British Journal of Sociology30(2): 164–187.
43.
KristiansenG (2014)
Innledning om sosial dumping og arbeidslivskriminalitet.Speech to LO Congress, 2014.
44.
LeeCS (2005)
International migration, deindustrialization and union decline in 16 affluent OECD countries, 1962tries,Social Forces84(1): 71–88.
45.
MahoneyJGoertzG (2004)
The possibility principle: Choosing negative cases in comparative research.American Political Science Review98(4): 653–669.
46.
McCartyNPooleKRosenthalH (2006) Polarized America: The Dance of Ideology and Unequal Riches.
Cambridge:
MIT Press.
47.
NaylorRCrippsM (1993)
An economic theory of the open shop trade union.European Economic Review37(8): 1599–1620.
48.
Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development (2013) Employment Outlook 2013.
Paris:
Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development.
49.
RodrikD (1997) Has Globalization Gone Too Far?
Washington, DC:
Institute for International Economics.
50.
RuhsM (2017)
Free movement in the European Union: National institutions vs common policies?International Migration55: 22–38.
51.
SchnabelC (2013)
Union membership and density: Some (not so) stylized facts and challenges.European Journal of Industrial Relations19(3): 255–272.
52.
SchnabelCWagner J (2005)
Determinants of trade union membership in West Germany: Evidence from micro data, 1980–2000.Socio-Economic Review3(1): 1–24.
53.
Schulze-ClevenTWeishauptJT (2015)
Playing normative legacies: Partisanship and employment policies in crisis-ridden Europe.Politics & Society43(2): 269–299.
54.
StephensJD (1979) The Transition From Capitalism to Socialism.
London:
Macmillian.
55.
StepnerM (2013) BINSCATTER: Stata module to generate binned scatterplots. Working Paper.
56.
StichnothHVan der StraetenK (2013)
Ethnic diversity, public spending, and individual support for the welfare state: A review of the empirical literature.Journal of Economic Surveys27(2): 364–389.
57.
Verdens Gang (2011) NHO vil ha færre innvandrere. May 10, 2014, vg.no.
58.
VisserJ (2002)
Why fewer workers join unions in Europe: A social custom explanation of membership trends.British Journal of Industrial Relations40(3): 403–430.
59.
WallersteinM (1989)
Union organization in advanced industrial democracies.American Political Science Review83(2): 481–501.
Supplementary Material
Please find the following supplemental material available below.
For Open Access articles published under a Creative Commons License, all supplemental material carries the same license as the article it is associated with.
For non-Open Access articles published, all supplemental material carries a non-exclusive license, and permission requests for re-use of supplemental material or any part of supplemental material shall be sent directly to the copyright owner as specified in the copyright notice associated with the article.
