This article investigates whether colonialism is alive in contemporary German development cooperation (GDC) on obstetric care in Tanzania. Drawing on archives and interviews, it compares present-day interventions to German policy in ‘German East Africa’ (GEA) at the beginning of the 20th century. It argues that contemporary development cooperation can be considered colonial to a certain extent in that it is marked by a combination of racialization, developmentalism and trusteeship. However, colonial power today is fractured as German development professionals’ accounts of their work display a considerable degree of hesitancy and doubt. This article contributes to the knowledge on colonialism and development by discerning colonial power in the under-researched case of GDC as well as in the context of concrete policy and practice in a particular field of intervention.
AhrendtC.2012: Hebammenrolle, Kommunikation und pädagogische Hebammenaufgaben. [Role of midwives, communication, and pedagogical tasks of midwives]. In StiefelA., GeistC and HarderU., editors, Hebammenkunde: Lehrbuch für Schwangerschaft, Geburt, Wochenbett und Beruf [Midwifery: Textbook for Pregnancy, Birth, Childbed, and Profession]. Georg Thieme, 33–61.
2.
AllenD.R.2002: Managing motherhood, managing risk. Fertility and danger in West Central Tanzania. University of Michigan Press.
3.
AxenfeldK.1913: Vom Arbeitsfelde der Ärztlichen Mission [On the field of work for the Medical Mission]. Mitteilungen des Berliner Vereins für ärztliche Mission [Notes of the Berlin Association for Medical Mission] 6, 1–24. Federal German Archives: R1001/6038.
4.
BaylyC., RaoV., SzreterS. and WoolcockM., editors, 2011: History, historians and development policy. A necessary dialogue. Manchester University Press.
5.
BiccumA.2005: Development and the ‘new’ imperialism: A reinvention of colonial discourse in DFID promotional literature. Third World Quarterly, 26, 1005–20.
6.
BMZ. 2008: Sexual and reproductive health and rights, and population dynamics. BMZ.
7.
BriggsJ. and SharpJ.2004: Indigenous knowledges and development: A postcolonial caution. Third World Quarterly, 25, 661–76.
8.
Bundesinstitut für Bevölkerungsforschung. 2014: Müttersterblichkeit in Deutschland, 1892 bis 2012 [Maternal mortality in Germany, 1892 until 2012], http://www.bib-demografie.de/DE/ZahlenundFakten/08/Abbildungen/a_08_32_muettersterblichkeit_d_ab1892.html;jsessionid=897B9A5E46A10C9BC8B79527A204DA18.2_cid321?nn=3071458, last accessed on October2014.
9.
CIA World Factbook. 2014: Country comparison: Maternal mortality rate, https://www.cia.gov/library/publications/the-world-factbook/rankorder/2223rank.html last accessed on October2014.
10.
ColwellA.S.2001: Vision and revision: Demography, maternal and child health development, and the representation of native women in colonial Tanzania (PhD Thesis). University of Illinois.
11.
CowenM. and ShentonR.1996: Doctrines of development. Routledge.
12.
CrushJ.1994: Post-colonialism, de-colonization and geography. In GodlewskaA. and SmithN., editors, Geography and empire. Blackwell, 333–50.
13.
DernburgB.1907: Zielpunkte des Deutschen Kolonialwesens [Goals for German Colonial Matters]. Ernst Siegfried Mittler und Sohn.
14.
DeuserP.2010: Genderspezifische Entwicklungspolitiken und Bevölkerungsdiskurse. Das Konzept der ‘Sexuellen und Reproduktiven Gesundheit und Rechte’ aus postkolonialer Perspektive [Gender-speific development policies and population discourses. The concept of ‘Sexual and Reproductive Health and Rights’ from a postcolonial perspective]. Peripherie [Periphery] 30, 427–51.
15.
Deutsche Gesellschaft für Eingebornenschutz. 1914: Eingabe der deutschen Gesellschaft für Eingebornenschutz an den Reichstag und das Reichs-Kolonialamt [Petition by the Society for the Protection of the Natives to the Reichstag and the Imperial Colonial Office]. Koloniale Rundschau – Monatsschrift für die Interessen unserer Schutzgebiete und ihrer Bewohner, 3, 129–32.
16.
Deutscher Frauenverein für Krankenpflege in den Kolonien. 1909, August13: Schreiben an den Staatssekretär des Reichskolonialamtes [Letter to the State Secretary of the Imperial Colonial Office]. Federal German Archives: R1001/6032/13.
17.
DusselE.1995: The invention of the Americas: Eclipse of ‘the other’ and the myth of modernity. Continuum, New York.
18.
DyerR.1997: White: Essays on race and culture. Routledge.
19.
DziedzicD. and RenköwitzU.1999: Zur Kulturgeschichte der Gebärhaltung [On the cultural history of birth positions]. In Metz-BeckerM., editor, Hebammenkunst gestern und heute. Zur Kultur des Gebärens durch drei Jahrhunderte [The Art of Midwifery in Past and Present. On the Culture of Birthing across Three Centuries], Jonas, 57–69.
20.
Eriksson BaazM.2005: The paternalism of partnership: A postcolonial reading of development politics. Zed Books.
21.
FeldmannH.1923: Die Erhaltung und Vermehrung der Eingeborenen-Bevölkerung [Preservation and reproduction of the native population]. Abhandlungen aus dem Gebiet der Auslandskunde. Ergebnisse der Eduard-Woermann-Preisaufgabe [Essays from the Field of Foreign Affairs. Results of the Eduard Woermann Contest Task], L. Friederichsen & Co, 83–148.
22.
FoucaultM.1980: Power/knowledge. Selected interviews and other writings, 1972–1977. GordonC., editor, Pantheon Book.
23.
Gouverneur von Deutsch-Ostafrika. 1909, October11: Anregung des Frauen-Vereins, ein Wöchnerinnenheim für farbige Frauen in Dar zu errichten [Suggestion by the Women’s Association to construct a maternity home for coloured women in Dar]. Federal German Archives: R1001/6032/13.
24.
Gutiérrez RodríguezE.2010: Migration, domestic work and affect. A decolonial approach on value and the feminization of labour. Routledge.
25.
HallS.1996: When was ‘the post-colonial’? Thinking at the limit. In ChambersI. and CurtiL., editors, The post-colonial question: Common skies, divided horizons. Routledge, 242–60.
26.
HeronB.2007: Desire for development. whiteness, gender, and the helping imperative. Wilfrid Laurier University Press.
27.
IsaacJ.C.1992: Beyond the three faces of power. A realist critique. In WartenbergT.E., editor, Rethinking power. State University of New York Press, 32–54.
28.
IttameierC.1923: Die Erhaltung und Vermehrung der Eingeborenen-Bevölkerung [Preservation and reproduction of the native population]. Abhandlungen aus dem Gebiet der Auslandskunde. Ergebnisse der Eduard-Woermann-Preisaufgabe [Essays from the Field of Foreign Affairs. Results of the Eduard Woermann Contest Task]. L. Friederichsen & Co, 1–82.
29.
KapoorI.2008: The postcolonial politics of development. Routledge.
30.
KebedeM.2004: African development and the primacy of mental decolonization. African Development, 19, 107–29.
31.
KontziK.2015: Postkoloniale Perspektiven auf ‘weltwärts’. Ein Freiwilligendienst in weltbürgerlicher Absicht [Postcolonial Perspectives on ‘weltwärts’. A Volunteer Service with Cosmopolitan Intent]. Nomos. KoponenJ.1994:Development for exploitation: German colonial policies in Mainland Tanzania, 1884–1914. LIT.
32.
KothariU.1996: Development Studies and post-colonial theory(IDPM Discussion Paper Series 46.). IDPM.
33.
KothariU.2006: An agenda for thinking about ‘race’ in development. Progress in Development Studies, 6, 9–23.
34.
KothariU.2011: Commentary: History, time and temporality in development discourse. In BaylyC., RaoV., SzreterS. and WoolcockM., editors, History, historians and development policy: A necessary dialogue. Manchester University Press, 65–70.
35.
LangwickS.2011: Bodies, politics, and African healing: The matter of maladies in Tanzania. Indiana University Press.
36.
MajorS.2003: Zur Geschichte der außerklinischen Geburtshilfe in der DDR [On the History of Out-of-Hospital Midwifery in the GDR] (PhD Thesis). Humboldt-Universität zu Berlin.
37.
MbembeA.2001: On the postcolony. University of California Press.
38.
McEwanC.2009: Postcolonialism and development. Routledge.
39.
Medizinalreferat in Daressalam. 1914: Familien-Nachwuchsstatistik über die Eingeborenen von Deutsch-Ostafrika [Statistics of family offspring of natives in German East African]. Deutsches Kolonialblatt. Amtsblatt für die Schutzgebiete in Afrika und in der Südsee [German Colonial Gazette. Official Register for the Protectorates in Africa and in the South Seas]25, 440–57.
40.
MemmiA.2000: Racism. University of Minnesota Press.
41.
MignoloW.2002: The geopolitics of knowledge and the colonial difference. South Atlantic Quarterly, 101, 57–96.
42.
MudimbeV.Y.1988: The invention of Africa: Gnosis, philosophy, and the order of knowledge. Indiana University Press.
43.
National Bureau of Statistics and ICF Macro. 2010: Tanzania demographic and health survey 2009–2010. ICF Macro.
44.
NoxoloP.2006: Claims: A postcolonial geographical critique of ‘partnership’ in Britain’s development discourse. Singapore Journal of Tropical Geography, 27, 254–69.
45.
PeiperO.1910: Schwangerschaft, Geburt und Wochenbett bei den Suaheli von Kilwa [Pregnancy, birth and childbed of the Swahili of Kilwa]. Archiv für Schiffs- und Tropenhygiene [Archive for Marine and Tropical Hygiene]14, 461–69.
46.
PeiperO.1920: Geburtenhäufigkeit, Säuglings- und Kinder-Sterblichkeit und Säuglingsernährung im früheren Deutsch-Ostafrika [Birth rates, infant and child mortality, and infant feeding in former German East Africa]. In Abteilung I des Ministeriums, editor, Veröffentlichungen aus dem Gebiete der Medizinalverwaltung [Publications from the Field of the Medical Administration]. Richard Schoetz, 371–412.
47.
PowerM.2006: Anti-racism, deconstruction and ‘overdevelopment’. Progress in Development Studies, 6, 25–39.
48.
QuijanoA.2000: Coloniality of power, eurocentrism, and Latin America. Nepantla: Views from South, 1, 533–80.
49.
RamK. and JollyM., editors, 1998: Maternities and modernities: Colonial and postcolonial experiences in Asia and the Pacific. Cambridge University Press.
50.
Reichs-Kolonialamt, editor, 1913: Medizinal-Berichte über die Deutschen Schutzgebiete für das Jahr 1910/11 [Medical Reports on the German Protectorates for the Year 1910/11]. Ernst Siegfried Mittler und Sohn.
51.
Reichs-Kolonialamt1915: Medizinal-Berichte über die Deutschen Schutzgebiete für das Jahr 1911/12. Ernst Siegfried Mittler und Sohn.
52.
RodenwaldtE.1912: Eingeborene Hebammen in Anecho, Togo, Westafrika [Native midwives in Anecho, Togo, West Africa]. Deutsche Medizinische Wochenschrift [German Medical Weekly]38, 273–75.
53.
ScottJ.C.1990: Domination and the arts of resistance: Hidden transcripts. Yale University Press.
54.
SlaterD. and BellM.2002: Aid and the geopolitics of the post-colonial: Critical reflections on new labour’s overseas development strategy. Development and Change, 33, 335–60.
55.
SzászN., StiefelA. and TschernkoM.2012: Geschichte des Hebammenberufs [History of the midwifery profession]. Hebammenkunde: Lehrbuch für Schwangerschaft, Geburt, Wochenbett und Beruf [Midwifery: Textbook for Pregnancy, Birth, Childbed, and Profession]. Georg Thieme, 2–15.
56.
TGPSH. 2008: History of the German technical cooperation in the health sector – Tanzania, http://www.tgpsh.or.tz/about-tgpsh/history-german-technical-cooperation-in-tanzania-health-sector.html, last accessed on November2008.
57.
VaughanM.1991: Curing their ills. Colonial power and African illness. Stanford University Press.
58.
Van de WalleN.2009: The institutional origins of inequality in Sub-Saharan Africa. Annual Review of Political Science. 12, 307–27.
59.
WainwrightJ.2008: Decolonizing development. Colonial power and the maya. Blackwell.
60.
WalterB.1992: Von Gottes Treue getragen. Die Missions-Benediktinerinnen von Tutzing – Band II: Gottes Treue verkünden. Wegbereitung für die Kirche in Ostafrika [Supported by God’s Faithfulness. The Missionary Benedictines from Tutzing – Volume II: Announcing God’s Faithfulness. Paving the Way for the Church in East Africa]. EOS
61.
WhiteS.2006: The ‘gender lens’: A racial blinder?Progress in Development Studies, 6, 55–67.
62.
WoolcockM., SzreterS. and RaoV.2011: How and why does history matter for development policy?Journal of Development Studies, 47, 70–96.
63.
World Health Organization. 2005: The World Health Report 2005. WHO.
