The study explores uses of algorithmic techniques in journalists’ working environments and investigates newsroom managers’ negotiations of automation as innovation process aimed at ensuring partial or full replacement of human labour with technology. Drawing from 15 qualitative interviews with representatives of newsroom management from legacy news institutions in the United Kingdom, Germany and the United States, the study analyses their (cl)aims to maintain the newsroom as a stable, but dynamic working environment and reveals three dualist propositions when negotiating automation novelties – human journalistic agency stands in contrast to technology, skills are separated from newsworkers, and the creation of news contrasts with its presentation. The results show the interviewees re-articulate the dominance of human agency over technology, re-establish technological innovations as liberating newsworkers rather than subordinating them, and standardise news by re-evaluating the concept as both a civic bond and a commodity. Such considerations are detached from recent concerns about automation of human labour and closer to what we call algorithmic sublime, maintaining the newsroom management’s loyalty to both the professional values of journalism and the corporate goals of management.
BücherC (1901) Industrial Evolution. New York: Henry Holt & Co.
10.
BucherT (2017) Machines don’t have instincts. New Media & Society19(6): 918–933.
11.
BunceM (2017) Management and resistance in the digital newsroom. Journalism20(7): 890–905.
12.
CareyJ (1970) The mythos of the electronic revolution. The American Scholar39(3): 395–424.
13.
CarlsonM (2015) The robotic reporter. Digital Journalism3(3): 416–431.
14.
CarlsonM (2017) Automated journalism. In: FranklinBEldridgeSAII (eds) The Routledge Companion to Digital Journalism Studies. London: Routledge, pp. 226–234.
15.
ClerwallC (2014) Enter the robot journalist. Journalism Practice8(5): 519–531.
16.
CoddingtonM (2015) Clarifying journalism’s quantitative turn. Digital Journalism3(3): 331–348.
17.
CohenNS (2015) From pink slips to pink slime. The Communication Review18(2): 98–122.
18.
DavenportTKirbyJ (2016) Only Humans Need Apply. London: Harper Business.
19.
De Sola PoolI (1983) Technologies of Freedom. London: Belknap Press.
20.
DiakopoulosNKoliskaM (2017) Algorithmic transparency in the news media. Digital Journalism5(7): 809–828.
21.
DörrKNHollbuchnerK (2017) Ethical challenges of algorithmic journalism. Digital Journalism5(4): 404–419.
22.
Ferrer-ConillR (2017) Quantifying journalism?Television & New Media18(8): 706–720.
23.
FinkKSchudsonM (2014) The rise of contextual journalism, 1950s–2000s. Journalism15(1): 3–20.
24.
FordM (2015) The Rise of the Robots. London: Basic Books.
25.
GillespieT (2014) The relevance of algorithms. In: GillespieTBoczkowskiPJFootKA (eds) Media Technologies. Cambridge, MA: The MIT Press, pp. 167–194.
KarlsenJStavelinE (2014) Computational journalism in Norwegian newsrooms. Journalism Practice8(1): 34–48.
34.
LewisSCWestlundO (2016) Mapping the human-machine divide. In: WitschgeTAndersonCWDomingoD, et al. (eds) The SAGE Handbook of Digital Journalism. London: SAGE, pp. 354–369.
35.
LewisSCGuzmanALSchmidtTR (2019) Automation, journalism, and human–machine communication. Digital Journalism7: 409–427.
36.
LindenC-G (2017) Decades of automation in the newsroom. Digital Journalism5(2): 123–140.
37.
McCrackenG (1988) The Long Interview. London: SAGE.
MilosavljevićMVobičI (2019) Human still in the loop. Digital Journalism. Epub ahead of print 15May. DOI: 10.1080/21670811.2019.1601576.
41.
MontalTReichZ (2017) I, robot. You, journalist. Who is the author?Digital Journalism5(7): 829–849.
42.
MoscoV (2004) The Digital Sublime. Cambridge, MA: The MIT Press.
43.
NapoliPM (2014) On automation in media industries. Media Industries Journal1(1): 33–38.
44.
NegroponteN (1995) Being Digital. London: Vintage Books.
45.
ÖrnebringH (2010) Technology and journalism-as-labour. Journalism11(1): 57–74.
46.
PattonMQ (1990 [1980]) Qualitative Evaluation and Research Methods. Newbury Park, CA: SAGE.
47.
PaulussenS (2012) Technology and the transformation of news work. In: SiaperaEVeglisA (eds) The Handbook of Global Online Journalism. Oxford: Wiley-Blackwell, pp. 192–208.
