The seriousness of storytelling: What constraints to professional news routines reveal about the state of journalistic autonomy in local television newsrooms

Abstract

This study follows the advice of scholars James Carey and Barbie Zelizer in that it takes journalism seriously. The seriousness comes from the concern that modern corporate approaches to news production are contributing to the erosion of the professional status of journalists with restrictions to storytelling routines serving as one example of this issue. Using a multiple case study method, this research presents 180 hours of newsroom observations and interviews with 62 news professionals to identify some of the constraints to local television news storytelling routines, further illuminating the struggle between market-driven news production and journalistic autonomy.

Keywords

Journalistic autonomy local television news newsroom ethnography norms and routines storytelling

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Altheide

Schneider

(2013) Qualitative Media Analysis. Thousand Oaks, CA: SAGE.

Altschull

(1997) Boundaries of journalistic autonomy. In: Social Meanings of News: A Text-Reader, pp. 259–268. Available at: http://www.gbv.de/dms/ilmenau/toc/220630240.PDF

Anderson

(2011) Between creative and quantified audiences: Web metrics and changing patterns of newswork in local US newsrooms. Journalism 12(5): 550–566.

Belt

Just

(2008) The local news story: Is quality a choice? Political Communication 25(2): 194–215.

Berkowitz

(1991) Assessing forces in the selection of local television news. Journal of Broadcasting & Electronic Media 35(2): 245–251.

Berkowitz

(1997) Social Meaning of News: A Text Reader. London: SAGE.

Bird

Dardenne

(1988) Myth, chronicle and story. In: Carey

(ed.) Media, Myths and Narratives: Television and the Press. London: SAGE, pp. 67–86.

Bivens

(2015) Affording immediacy in television news production: Comparing adoption trajectories of social media and satellite technologies. International Journal of Communication 9: 191–209.

Breed

(1955) Newspaper ‘opinion leaders’ and processes of standardization. Journalism Quarterly 32(3): 277–328.

10.

Briggs

(2012) Journalism Next: A Practical Guide to Digital Reporting and Publishing. Thousand Oaks, CA: SAGE.

11.

Busterna

(1988) Television station ownership effects on programming and idea diversity: Baseline data. Journal of Media Economics 1(2): 63–74.

12.

Carey

(2008) Communication as Culture, Revised Edition: Essays on Media and Society. London: Routledge.

13.

Casella

(2013) Breaking news or broken news? Reporters and news directors clash on ‘black hole’ live shots. Journalism Practice 7(3): 362–376.

14.

Champagne

(2005) The ‘double dependency’: The journalistic field between politics and markets. In: Benson

(ed.) Bourdieu and the Journalistic Field. Cambridge: Polity Press, pp. 48–63.

15.

Cleary

Bloom

(2011) Gatekeeping at the portal: An analysis of local television websites’ user-generated content. Electronic News 5(2): 93–111.

16.

Cottle

(2000) New(s) times: Towards a ‘second wave’ of news ethnography. The European Journal of Communication Research 25(1): 19–41.

17.

Dick

(2014) Interactive infographics and news values. Digital Journalism 2(4): 490–506.

18.

Dotson

(2015) Make It Memorable: Writing and Packaging TV News with Style. Chicago, IL: Bonus Books, Inc.

19.

Gans

(1979) Deciding What News: A Study of CBS Evening News, NBC Nightly News, Newsweek, and Time. New York: Pantheon Books.

20.

Gottfried

Shearer

(2017) Americans’ online news use is closing in on TV news use. Fact Tank: News in the Numbers. Available at: http://www.pewresearch.org/fact-tank/2017/09/07/americans-online-news-use-vs-tv-news-use/

21.

Grabe

Zhou

Lang

, et al. (2000) Packaging television news: The effects of tabloid on information processing and evaluative responses. Journal of Broadcasting & Electronic Media 44(4): 581–598.

22.

Green

(2008) Transportation theory. In: Donsbach

(ed.) International Encyclopedia of Communication. Hoboken, NJ: Wiley-Blackwell, pp. 5170–5175.

23.

Grossman

(1997) Why local TV news is so awful. Columbia Journalism Review 36(4): 21.

24.

Hamilton

(2004) All the News that’s Fit to Sell: How the Market Transforms Information into News. Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press.

25.

Henderson

(2012) Narratives in local television news editing. Electronic News 6(2): 67–80.

26.

IRE (2014) IRE Conference Kicks off with Record Attendance. Available at: www.ire.org/blog/ire-conference-blog/2014/06/25/welcome-2014-ire-conference

27.

Itti

Baldi

(2009) Bayesian surprise attracts human attention. Vision Research 49(10): 1295–1306.

28.

Jebril

de Vreese

van Dalen

, et al. (2013) The effects of human interest and conflict news frames on the dynamics of political knowledge gains: Evidence from a cross-national study. Scandinavian Political Studies 36(3): 201–226.

29.

Kaniss

(1991) Making Local News. Chicago, IL: The University of Chicago Press.

30.

Koliska

Chadha

(2018) Transparency in German newsrooms. Journalism Studies 19(16): 2400–2416.

31.

Kovach

Rosenstiel

(2014) The Elements of Journalism: What Newspeople Should Know and the Public Should Expect. New York: Three Rivers Press.

32.

Lacy

(1992) The financial commitment approach to news media competition. Journal of Media Economics 5(2): 5–21.

33.

Lang

(1989) Effects of chronological presentation of information on processing and memory for broadcast news. Journal of Broadcasting & Electronic Media 33(4): 441–452.

34.

Lang

(2000) The limited capacity model of mediated message processing. Journal of Communication 50(1): 46–70.

35.

Lang

Bolls

Potter

, et al. (1999) The effects of production pacing and arousing content on the information processing of television messages. Journal of Broadcasting & Electronic Media 43(4): 451–475.

36.

Lang

Potter

Grabe

(2003) Making news memorable: Applying theory to the production of local television news. Journal of Broadcasting & Electronic Media 47(1): 113–123.

37.

(2017) Contest over authority: Navigating native advertising’s impacts on journalism autonomy. Journalism Studies 20: 523–541.

38.

Lindlof

Taylor

(2017) Qualitative Communication Research Methods. Thousand Oaks, CA: SAGE.

39.

McChesney

(2012) Farewell to journalism? Time for a rethinking. Journalism Practice 6(5–6): 614–626.

40.

McHugh

(2014) Audio storytelling: Unlocking the power of audio to inform, empower and connect. Asia Pacific Media Educator 24(2): 141–156.

41.

McManus

(1994) Market-driven Journalism: Let the Citizen Beware? Thousand Oaks, CA: SAGE.

42.

Miller

(2018) Sinclair tops chart again, but fox new no. 2. TV News Check. Available at: tvnewscheck.com/article/114075/sinclair-tops-chart-again-but-fox-new-no-2/

43.

Mindich

(2000) Just the Facts: How ‘Objectivity’ Came to Define American Journalism. New York: NYU Press.

44.

Overbeck

Belmas

Shepard

(2015) Major Principles of Media Law, 2016. Toronto, ON, Canada: Nelson Education.

45.

Pantti

(2010) The value of emotion: An examination of television journalists’ notions on emotionality. European Journal of Communication 25(2): 168–181.

46.

Papper

(2017) RTDNA research: Salary survey. Available at: www.rtdna.org/article/rtdna_research_salary_survey_2017

47.

PEW (2007) Local TV news budgets by market size. Available at: https://www.journalism.org/numbers/local-tv-news-budgets-by-market-size/

48.

Phillips

(2015) Futures of journalists: Low-paid piecework or global brands? In: Vos

Heinderyckx

(eds) Gatekeeping in Transition. London: Routledge, pp. 79–96.

49.

Powers

(2009) The effect of ownership structure on news coverage in the United States. Observatorio, 8. Available at: http://obs.obercom.pt/index.php/obs/article/viewFile/220/230

50.

Reich

Godler

(2017) Being there? The role of journalistic legwork across new and traditional media. Journalism & Mass Communication Quarterly 94(4): 1115–1129.

51.

Revers

(2014) Journalistic professionalism as performance and boundary work: Source relations at the state house. Journalism 15(1): 37–52.

52.

Roeh

(1989) Journalism as storytelling, coverage as narrative. American Behavioral Scientist 33(2): 162–168.

53.

Ryfe

(2009) Broader and deeper: A study of newsroom culture in a time of change. Journalism 10(2): 197–216.

54.

Schaefer

Martinez

III (2009) Trends in network news editing strategies from 1969 through 2005. Journal of Broadcasting & Electronic Media 53(3): 347–364.

55.

Schudson

(2001) The objectivity norm in American journalism. Journalism 2(2): 149–170.

56.

Schudson

(2003) The Sociology of News, Contemporary Societies. New York: W.W. Norton.

57.

Schudson

(2005) News as stories. In: Rothenbuhler

Coman

(eds) Media Anthropology. Thousand Oaks, CA: SAGE, pp. 121–128.

58.

Scott

Gobetz

(1992) Hard news/soft news content of the national broadcast networks, 1972–1987. Journalism Quarterly 69(2): 406–412.

59.

Shook

Larson

DeTarsio

(2015) Television and Field Reporting. Boca Raton, FL: CRC Press.

60.

Silcock

(2007) Every edit tells a story sound and the visual frame: A comparative analysis of videotape editor routines in global newsrooms. Visual Communication Quarterly 14(1): 3–15.

61.

Skovsgaard

(2014) Watchdogs on a leash? The impact of organizational constraints on journalists’ perceived professional autonomy and their relationship with superiors. Journalism 15(3): 344–363.

62.

Slattery

Hakanen

Doremus

(1996) The expression of localism: Local TV news coverage in the new video marketplace. Journal of Broadcasting & Electronic Media 40(3): 403–413.

63.

Smith

(2009) Consolidation and news content: How broadcast ownership policy impacts local television news and the public interests. Journalism & Communication Monographs 10(4): 387–453.

64.

Tandoc

Jr. (2014) Journalism is twerking? How web analytics is changing the process of gatekeeping. New Media & Society 16(4): 559–575.

65.

Tandoc

Jr. (2015) Why web analytics click: Factors affecting the ways journalists use audience metrics. Journalism Studies 16(6): 782–799.

66.

Tandoc

Jr. Vos

(2015) The journalist is marketing the news: Social media in the gatekeeping process. Journalism Practice 10(8): 950–966.

67.

Tompkins

(2017) Aim for the Heart: Write, Shoot, Report and Produce for TV and Multimedia. Washington, DC: CQ Press.

68.

Tuchman

(1978) Making News: A Study in the Construction of Reality. New York: The Free Press.

69.

Undurraga

(2017) Making news, making the economy: Technological changes and financial pressures in Brazil. Cultural Sociology 11(1): 77–96.

70.

Vos

(2019) Journalists’ endangered professional status. Journalism 20(1): 122–125.

71.

Walsh

(1988) Trade unions and the media. International Labour Review 127: 205.

72.

White

(1950) The ‘gate keeper’: A case study in the selection of news. Journalism Quarterly 27(4): 383–390.

73.

Yan

Napoli

(2006) Market competition, station ownership, and local public affairs programming on broadcast television. Journal of Communication 56(4): 795–812.

74.

Yanich

(2010) Does ownership matter? Localism, content, and the federal communications commission. Journal of Media Economics 23(2): 51–67.

75.

Yanich

(2014) Duopoly light? Service agreements and local TV. Journalism & Mass Communication Quarterly 91(1): 159–176.

76.

Yin

(2017) Case Study Research and Applications: Design and Methods. Thousand Oaks, CA: SAGE.

77.

Young

(2000) Modeling media markets: How important is market structure? Journal of Media Economics 13(1): 27–44.

78.

Zaller

(2003) A new standard of news quality: Burglar alarms for the monitorial citizen. Political Communication 20(2): 109–130.

79.

Zelizer

(2004) Taking Journalism Seriously: News and the Academy. Thousand Oaks, CA: SAGE.

80.

Zeller

Hermida

(2015) When tradition meets immediacy and interaction. The integration of social media in journalists’ everyday practices. Sur le journalisme, About journalism, Sobre jornalismo 4(1): 106–119.

81.

Zettl

(1999) Sight, Sound, Motion: Applied Media Aesthetics. Belmont, CA: Wadsworth Publishing Company.

82.

Zhou

(2004) Effects of visual intensity and audiovisual redundancy in bad news. Media Psychology 6(3): 237–256.