In 1873, the Comstock Act labeled contraceptive information and materials obscene and banned their distribution. The issue divided the United States then, and it divides the nation today. This essay examines 2000–2013 press coverage of contraception in the New York Times and the Los Angeles Times, two newspapers that have covered contraception since 1873. Press coverage reveals that contemporary efforts to regulate women’s bodies are cloaked in discussions about the Affordable Care Act, religious freedom, morality, and employer rights. Accepting the ideology that contraception is no longer a reproductive rights issue allowed the press to exclude women from the debate. In doing so, the power of political, social, and religious groups to control the contraception narrative and women’s lives is confirmed. The lived experience of women has evolved from 1873 when press coverage at least gave women a platform to speak about contraception. By 2013, this power appears to be lost.
AbcarianR (2012a) Birth control uproar. Los Angeles Times, 25March, p. 10.
2.
AbcarianR (2012b) Election 2012/The democratic convention. Los Angeles Times, 7September, p. U1.
3.
AbcarianR (2012c) Santorum seeks to clarify views on working women. Los Angeles Times, 13February, p. 7.
4.
BaerJA (2002) Historical and Multicultural Encyclopedia of Women’s Reproductive Rights in the United States. Westport, CT: Greenwood Press.
5.
BelluckP (2013) Drug agency lowers age for next-day birth control. New York Times, 1May, p. 10.
6.
BelluckPShearMD (2013) U.S. to appeal order lifting Morning-After Pill’s age limit. New York Times, 2May, p. 1.
7.
BirdEDardenneR (1997) Myth, chronicle and story: Exploring the narrative qualities of news. In: BerkowitzD (ed.) Social Meanings of News. Thousand Oaks, CA: SAGE, pp. 330–350.
8.
BoneJE (2010) When publics collide: Margaret Sanger’s argument for birth control and the rhetorical breakdown of barriers. Women’s Studies in Communication33: 15–33.
9.
BonnerE (2013) A flood of suits on the coverage of birth control. New York Times, 27January, p. 1.
10.
BrennenB (2008) From religiosity to consumerism: Press coverage of Thanksgiving, 1905–2005. Journalism Studies9(1): 21–37.
11.
BrodieJF (1994) Contraception and Abortion in Nineteenth-Century America. Ithaca, NY: Cornell University Press.
12.
BrodyJ (2000) The pill at 40: New uses for a drug that changed society. New York Times, 9May, p. F1.
13.
BuerkleC (2009) From women’s liberation to their obligation: The tensions between sexuality and maternity in early birth control rhetoric. Women and Language31(1): 27–34.
14.
CalmesJ (2012) Obama assails Romney on women’s health care. New York Times, 9August, p. 15.
15.
CarterCSteinerL (eds) (2004) Critical Readings: Media and Gender. Maidenhead: Open University Press.
CutterB (2003) Domestic Devils, Battlefield Angels: The Radicalism of American Womanhood. DeKalb, IL: Northern Illinois University Press.
20.
DaumM (2012a) Rush’s blind spot. Los Angeles Times, 8March, p. 19.
21.
DaumM (2012b) The line Limbaugh crossed. Los Angeles Times, 15March, p. 19.
22.
DavisE (1921) The History of the New York Times, 1851–1921. New York: New York Times.
23.
DewanSK (2002) Cardinal lobbies in Albany against bill for contraception coverage. New York Times, 13March, p. B5.
24.
DowdM (2012) Have you no shame, Rush?New York Times, 4March, p. SR1.
25.
Du GayPHallSJanesL. (1997) Doing Cultural Studies: The Story of the Sony Walkman. Thousand Oaks, CA: SAGE.
26.
DuncanI (2012) More suits are filed over birth control. Los Angeles Times, 22May, p. 7.
27.
EndresKL (1968) Strictly confidential: Birth-control advertising in a 19th century city. Journalism Quarterly63: 748–751.
28.
EngelmanPC (2011) A History of the Birth Control Movement in America. Santa Barbara, CA: Praeger.
29.
FaludiS (1992) Backlash: The Undeclared War against American Women. New York: Doubleday.
30.
FaludiS (2007) The Terror Dream: Fear and Fantasy in Post-9/11 America. New York: Metropolitan Books.
31.
FeldtG (2006) Margaret Sanger’s obscenity. New York Times, 15October, p. 15.
32.
FlamianoD (1998) The birth of a notion: Media coverage of contraception, 1915–1917. Journalism and Mass Communication Quarterly75(3): 560–671.
33.
FuentesA (2001) Birth control, from ‘womb veils’ to Lysol. New York Times, 12June, p. F7.
34.
GansHJ (1980) Deciding What’s News: A Study of CBS Evening News, NBC Nightly News, Newsweek and Time. New York: Vintage Books.
35.
GarnerAC (2014) Wicked or warranted? US press coverage of contraception 1873–1917. Journalism Studies. Epub ahead of print 2January. DOI: 10.1080/1461670X.2013.870390.
36.
GeertzC (1973) The Interpretation of Cultures. New York: Basic Books.
37.
GeigerK (2012) All sides rebuke Limbaugh. Los Angeles Times, 3March, p. 8.
38.
GeigerKLeveyNN (2012) New take on birth control. Los Angeles Times, 16February, p. 7.
39.
GirionL (2001) Judge orders coverage of birth control. Los Angeles Times, 13June, p. 1.
40.
GoodsteinL (2012) Bishops sue over contraception mandate. New York Times, 22May, p. 17.
41.
GordonL (1990) Woman’s Body, Woman’s Right: A Social History of Birth Control in America. New York: Penguin Books.
42.
GordonL (1997) Voluntary motherhood: The beginnings of feminist birth control ideas in the United States. In: AppleRDGoldenJ (eds) Mothers & Motherhood. Columbus, OH: Ohio State University Press, pp. 423–443.
43.
HajoCM (2010) Birth Control on Main Street: Organizing Clinics in the United States, 1916–1939. Urbana, IL: University of Illinois Press.
44.
HallS (1975) Introduction. In: SmithACH (ed.) Paper Voices: The Popular Press and Social Change. London: Catto and Windus, pp. 11–24.
45.
HarpD (2007) Desperately Seeking Women Readers. New York: Lexington Books.
46.
HartJR (1975) The information empire: A history of the Los Angeles Times from the advent of the multi-media communications corporation. MA Thesis, University of Wisconsin-Madison, Madison, WI.
47.
HernandezR (2001) Senators urge Bush to back family planning proposals. New York Times, 29July, p. 20.
48.
JoffeC (1986) The Regulation of Sexuality: Experiences of Family Planning Workers. Philadelphia, PA: Temple University Press.
49.
KhanA (2012) New policy urged on Plan B for teens. Los Angeles Times, 26November, p. 5.
50.
KitchC (2002) ‘A death in the American family’: Myth, memory, and national values in the media mourning of John F. Kennedy Jr. Journalism and Mass Communication Quarterly79: 294–309.
51.
KruvandM (2012) The pill at fifty: How the New York Times covered the birth control pill, 1960–2010. American Journalism29(4): 34–67.
52.
LandsbergM (2012) Catholics plan fight on coverage of birth control. Los Angeles Times, 4February, p. 2.
53.
LeveyNN (2009) Bush-era ‘conscience’ rule gets another look. Los Angeles Times, 27February, p. 10.
54.
LevyCJ (2002) Bishops sue state to block coverage for birth control. New York Times, 31December, p. B5.
55.
LobdellW (2005) Faithful furious over tactic. Los Angeles Times, 3August, p. B1.
56.
LobdellWWatanabeT (2003) Church may penalize politicians. Los Angeles Times, 29November, p. 14.
57.
Los Angeles Times (2001a) A double standard fails. Los Angeles Times, 15June, p. B16.
58.
Los Angeles Times (2001b) Birth control. Los Angeles Times, 7January, p. 6.
59.
Los Angeles Times (2001c) Budget politics. Los Angeles Times, 17April, p. B8.
60.
Los Angeles Times (2008) The wrong family plan. Los Angeles Times, 24September, p. 22.
61.
Los Angeles Times (2011) Covering contraceptives. Los Angeles Times, 24July, p. 25.
62.
Los Angeles Times (2012a) A religious exception?Los Angeles Times, 30May, p. 12.
63.
Los Angeles Times (2012b) Law defies U.S. on birth control. Los Angeles Times, 13September, p. 22.
64.
Los Angeles Times (2013) Girls of any age can buy emergency contraception. Los Angeles Times, 7June, p. 7.
65.
LueckTJ (2006) State court rules against Catholic Church on insurance. New York Times, 20October, p. B4.
66.
LumsdenLL (2007) Anarchy meets feminism: A gender analysis of Emma Goldman’s Mother Earth, 1906–1917. American Journalism24(3): 31–54.
67.
McKinleyJC (2001) Egan to head to Albany to fight coverage of contraceptives in women’s health bill. New York Times, 21February, p. B5.
68.
MascaroLHennesseyK (2012) Birth-control fight turns into campaign and fundraising tool. Los Angeles Times, 9February, p. 7.
69.
New York Times (2004) The President and women. New York Times, 9May, p. 12.
70.
New York Times (2005a) A victory for women. New York Times, 24June, p. 22.
71.
New York Times (2005b) Governor Pataki and women’s rights. New York Times, 19July, p. 20.
72.
New York Times (2011a) A new battle over contraception. New York Times, 6November, p. 10.
73.
New York Times (2011b) The war on women. New York Times, 26February, p. 18.
74.
New York Times (2013a) Birth control and religious freedom. New York Times, 9February, p. 18.
75.
New York Times (2013b) Colorado: Legal setback for contraception mandate. New York Times, 28June, p. 19.
76.
PearR (2011) Panel calling for free-contraceptive coverage. New York Times, 20July, p. 1.
77.
PearR (2012a) Birth control mandate to apply to self-insuring religious groups. New York Times, 17March, p. 14.
78.
PearR (2012b) Senate rejects step targeting coverage of contraception. New York Times, 2March, p. 1.
79.
PearR (2012c) U.S. denies exemption sought by Church on coverage for contraceptives. New York Times, 21January, p. 17.
PoindexterPMerazSWeissAS (eds) (2008) Women, Men and News. New York: Routledge.
82.
PottsM (2012) A game-changer again. Los Angeles Times, 20February, p. 15.
83.
RabinRC (2013) Contraception and the courts. New York Times, 9April, p. D5.
84.
RakowLFKranichK (1991) Woman as sign in television news. Journal of Communication41(1): 8–25.
85.
RakowLFWackwitzLA (eds) (2004) Feminist Communication Theory. Thousand Oaks, CA: SAGE.
86.
RauJ (2005) Bills target pharmacists who say ‘no’. Los Angeles Times, 5April, p. B1.
87.
ReedJ (1978) From Private Vice to Public Virtue: The Birth Control Movement and American Society Since 1830. New York: Basic Books.
88.
RognessKZFoustCR (2011) Beyond rights and virtues as foundation for women’s agency: Emma Goldman’s rhetoric of free love. Western Journal of Communication75(2): 148–167.
89.
RosenbaumD (2000) Expansion of medical benefits puts Vermont in the vanguard. New York Times, 19June, p. 12.
90.
SavageDG (2008) Broader medical refusal rulemaygo far beyond abortion. Los Angeles Times, 2December, p. 1.
91.
SavageDG (2013) Judges split over religion, birth control. Los Angeles Times, 9February, p. 8.
92.
SenguptaS (2001a) Egan takes Church’s issues to Albany. New York Times, 14March, p. B1.
93.
SenguptaS (2001b) Legislature still divided over women’s health bill. New York Times, 29January, p. B5.
94.
ShearMD (2013) Obama backs birth control rule change. New York Times, 3May, p. 16.
95.
SimonS (2006) The birth control divide. Poor and uneducated women have higher rates of unplanned pregnancy. But why?Los Angeles Times, 26June, p. F1.
96.
StromS (2004) Catholic group is told to pay for birth control. New York Times, 2March, p. 14.
97.
ThurerS (1994) The Myths of Motherhood: How Culture Reinvents the Good Mother. Boston, MA: Houghton Mifflin.
98.
ToneA (1997) Controlling Reproduction: An American History. Wilmington, DE: Scholarly Resources.
99.
WeismanJ (2012) Women figure anew in Senate’s latest battle. New York Times, 15March, p. 1.
100.
WhitakerA (1917) To be or not to be. Los Angeles Times8March, p. II4.
101.
WilliamsR (1977) Marxism and Literature. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
ZelizerB (1992) Covering the Body: The Kennedy Assassination, the Media, and the Shaping of Collective Memory. Chicago, IL: University of Chicago Press.
