A content analysis of 6525 randomly sampled political news stories from national, regional and weekly newspapers in six western countries between 1960 and today examines to which degree discursively defined reporting styles correspond to conceptual typologies of media systems and historical classifications of journalistic traditions. Univariate and multivariate analyses of three key indicators (opinion-orientation, objectivity, negativity) reveal three approaches to newsmaking: a US-led model of rational news analysis, an Italian-led model of polarized reporting, and a Germanic model of disseminating news with views. Merging a historically informed institutionalist approach with systematic content analysis, the study’s main contribution to comparative communication research is to clarify our understanding of divergent models of journalism, contextualize existing media-system typologies, and revise assumptions about the affiliation of individual systems to certain models.
AalbergTVan AelstPCurranJ (2010) Media systems and the political information environment: A cross-national comparison. International Journal of Press/Politics15(3): 255–271.
2.
BennettWL (2005) News – the Politics of Illusion, 6th edn.New York: Pearson Longman.
3.
BensonR (2004) Bringing the sociology of media back in. Political Communication21(3): 275–292.
4.
BensonR (2009) What makes news more multiperspectival? A field analysis. Poetics37(5–6): 402–418.
5.
BensonR (2010) What makes for a critical press? A case study of French and U.S. immigration news coverage. International Journal of Press/Politics15(1): 3–24.
6.
BensonRHallinDC (2007) How states, markets and globalization shape the news: The French and U.S. national press, 1965–1997. European Journal of Communication22(1): 27–48.
7.
BensonRBlach-OrstenMPowersMWilligIZambranoSV (2012) Media systems online and off: Comparing the form of news in the United States, Denmark and France. Journal of Communication62(1): 21–38.
8.
BrüggemannMKleinen-von KönigslöwK (2009) Let’s talk about Europe. Why Europeanization shows a different face in different newspapers. European Journal of Communication24(1): 27–48.
9.
ChalabyJK (1996) Journalism as an Anglo-American invention: A comparison of the development of French and Anglo-American journalism, 1830s–1920s. European Journal of Communication11(3): 303–326.
CookTE (1998) Governing with the News. The News Media as a Political Institution. Chicago, IL: University of Chicago Press.
12.
CookTE (2006) The news media as a political institution: Looking backward and looking forward. Political Communication23(2): 159–171.
13.
DimitrovaDVStrömbäckJ (2012) Election news in Sweden and the United States: A comparative study of sources and media frames. Journalism13(5): 604–619.
14.
DonsbachW (1995) Lapdogs, watchdogs and junkyard dogs. Media Studies Journal9(Fall): 17–30.
15.
DonsbachWKlettB (1993) Subjective objectivity. How journalists in four countries define a key term of their profession. Gazette51(1): 53–83.
16.
FerreeMMGamsonWAGerhardsJRuchtD (2002) Shaping Abortion Discourse. Democracy and the Public Sphere in Germany and the United States. New York: Cambridge University Press.
17.
FranklinBMurphyD (1998) Making the Local News. Local Journalism in Context. London: Routledge.
18.
HallinDC (1984) The media, the war in Vietnam and political support: A critique of the thesis of an oppositional media. Journal of Politics46(1): 2–24.
19.
HallinDC (2008) The challenges of comparing media systems. Daniel Hallin interviewed by Hallvard Moe and Helle Sjøvaag. Journal of Global Mass Communication1(3–4): 132–141.
20.
HallinDCManciniP (2004) Comparing Media Systems: Three Models of Media and Politics. New York: Cambridge University Press.
21.
HallinDCManciniP (2012a) Comparing media systems: A response to critics. In: EsserFHanitzschT (eds) Handbook of Comparative Communication Research. London: Routledge, 207–220.
22.
HallinDCManciniP (2012b) Conclusion. In: HallinDCManciniP (eds) Comparing Media Systems beyond the Western World. New York: Cambridge University Press, 278–304.
23.
HumphreysP (2011) A political scientist’s contribution to the comparative study of media systems in Europe: A response to Hallin and Mancini. In: JustNPuppisM (eds) Trends in Communication Policy Research. New Theories, New Methods, New Subjects. Bristol: Intellect, 141–158.
24.
KatzensteinP (1985) Small States in World Markets: Industrial Policy in Europe. Ithaca, NY: Cornell University Press.
25.
KuhnR (2007) Journalism in France. In: AndersonPJWardG (eds) The Future of Journalism in Advanced Democracies. Aldershot: Ashgate, 243–258.
26.
LandisJRKochGG (1977) The measurement of observer agreement for categorical data. Biometrics33(1): 159–174.
27.
LengauerGEsserFBerganzaR (2012) Negativity in political news: A review of concepts, operationalizations and key findings. Journalism12(2): 179–202.
28.
LijphartA (1999) Patterns of Democracy. New Haven, CT: Yale University Press.
29.
ManciniP (2000) Political complexity and alternative models of journalism: The Italian Case. In: CurranJParkMJ (eds) De-westernizing Media Studies. London: Routledge, 264–278.
30.
ManciniP (2005) Is there a European model of journalism? In: De BurghH (ed.) Making Journalists: Diverse Models, Global Issues. London: Routledge, 77–93.
31.
ManciniP (2007) Journalism in Italy. In: AndersonPJWardG (eds) The Future of Journalism in Advanced Democracies. Aldershot: Ashgate, 229–242.
32.
NorrisP (2009) Comparing political communications: Common frameworks or Babelian confusion?Government and Opposition44(3): 321–340.
33.
NorrisP (2011) Political communication. In: CaramaniD (ed.) Comparative Politics, 2nd edn.Oxford: Oxford University Press, 353–370.
34.
PattersonTE (1993) Out of Order. New York: Vintage.
35.
PeterJ (2003) Country characteristics as contingent conditions of agenda setting: The moderating influence of polarized elite opinion. Communication Research30(6): 683–712.
36.
PolettiMBrantsK (2010) Between partisanship and cynicism: Italian journalism in a state of flux. Journalism11(3): 329–346.
37.
PolumbaumJ (2010) Comparative models of journalism. In: SterlingCH (ed.) Encyclopedia of Journalism. Los Angeles, CA: Sage, 338–342.
38.
RoesslerP (2012) Comparative content analysis. In: EsserFHanitzschT (eds) Handbook of Comparative Communication Research. London: Routledge, 459–468.
39.
SchudsonM (2001) The objectivity norm in American journalism. Journalism2(2): 149–170.
40.
SheaferTWolfsfeldG (2009) Party systems and oppositional voices in the news media. International Journal of Press/Politics14(2): 146–165.
41.
SiebertFPetersonTSchrammW (1956) Four Theories of the Press. Urbana: University of Illinois Press.
42.
SparrowBH (1999) Uncertain Guardians: The News Media as a Political Institution. Baltimore, MD: Johns Hopkins University Press.
43.
StrömbäckJAalbergT (2008) Election news coverage in democratic corporatist countries. A comparative study of Sweden and Norway. Scandinavian Political Studies31(1): 91–106.
44.
StrömbäckJDimitrovaDV (2006) Political and media systems matter: A comparison of election news coverage in Sweden and the U.S. Harvard International Journal of Press/Politics11(4): 131–147.
45.
StrömbäckJLuengoOG (2008) Polarized pluralist and democratic corporatist models. A comparison of election news coverage in Spain and Sweden. International Communication Gazette70(6): 547–562.
46.
TuchmanG (1978) Making news: A Study in the Construction of Reality. New York: Free Press.
47.
TunstallJ (1977) The Media Are American. New York: Columbia University Press.
TunstallJ (2008) The Media Were American. New York: Oxford University Press.
50.
UmbrichtAEsserF (2013) Changing political news? Long-term trends in American, British, French, Italian, German and Swiss press reporting. In: KuhnRKleis NielsenR (eds) Political Journalism in Transition: Western Europe in a Comparative Perspective. London: I.B. Tauris.
51.
Van DalenAAlbaekEDe VreeseC (2011) Suspicious minds: Explaining political cynicism among political journalists in Europe. European Journal of Communication26(2): 147–162.
52.
WesslerHSkorekMKleinen-von KönigslöwKHeldMDobrevaMAdolphsenM (2010) Comparing media systems and media content: Online newspapers in ten Eastern and Western European countries. In: Dobek-OstrowskaBGlowackiMJakubowiczKSükösdM (eds) Comparative Media Systems: European and Global Perspectives. Budapest: Central European University Press, 233–260.
53.
WilliamsK (2005) European Media Studies. London: Hodder Arnold.
