The theoretical assumption of this paper is that when a foreign news item is defined
as ‘ours’, then journalists’ professional practices
become subordinate to national loyalty; when an item is
‘theirs’, journalistic professionalism comes into its own. Thus,
the article argues that there is an inverse relation between professional news
values and the national identity of the journalist and the journal’s
editors. Expressed as a rule, we would say that the more
‘national’ the report is, the less
‘professional’ it will be, i.e. the closer the reporters/editors
are to a given news event in terms of national interest, the further they are from
applying professional news values.
This claim is presented in the form of a flow diagram and is investigated using
qualitative content analysis of the coverage of four events in three different
countries (the USA, Britain and Israel). The four events, which were all presented
as foreign news, were defined as political violence based on an observational definition.
The theory which is empirically tested and presented in this article can help us to
understand the coverage of September 11, 2001 and its aftermath and the wars in
Afghanistan and Iraq, and further our understanding of how events were, and still
are, covered as foreign news in general, and, in particular, how political violence
is covered as foreign news.
Berkowitz, D.
and
H. Nossek
(2001)
‘Myths and News Narratives: Toward a Comparative Perspective of News’
, Ecquid Novi22:
41-56
.
2.
Caliendo, S. M.
,
M. P. Gibney
and
A. Payne
(1999)
‘All the News That Is Fit to Print? New York Times Coverage of
Human-Rights Violations’
, The Harvard International Journal of Press/Politics4(4):
48-69
.
3.
Carruthers, S. L.
(2000) The Media at War.
New York: St Martin Press
.
4.
Chang, T.
and
J. Lee
(1992)
‘Factors Affecting Gatekeepers’ Selection of Foreign
News: A National Survey of Newspaper Editors’
, Journalism Quarterly69:
554-561
.
5.
Cohen, A. A.
,
H. Adoni
and
C. Bantz
(1990) Social Conflict & Television News.
Newbury Park, CA: Sage
.
6.
Cohen, A. A.
,
H. Adoni
and
H. Nossek
(1993) ‘Television News and the Intifada: A
Comparative Study of Social Conflict’, in
A. A. Cohen
, and
G. Wolfsfeld
(eds) Framing the Intifada: People and Media, pp.
116-141.
Norwood, NJ: Ablex
.
7.
Cohen, A. A.
,
M. R. Levy
,
I. Roeh
and
M. Gurevitch
(1995) Global Newsrooms, Local Audiences: A Study of the
Eurovision News Exchange.
London: John Libbey
.
8.
Curran, J.
and
M. J. Park
(2000) ‘Beyond Globalization
Theory’, in
J. Curran
and
M. J. Park
(eds) De-Westernizing Media Studies, pp.
3-18.
London: Routledge
.
9.
Entman, R. M.
(1991)
‘Framing US Coverage of International News: Contrasts in
Narratives of the KAL and Iran Air Incidents’
, Journal of Communication41(4):
6-27
.
10.
Fenby, J.
(1986) The International News Services.
New York: Schoken
.
11.
Galtung, J.
and
M. H. Ruge
(1965)
‘The Structure of Foreign News’
, Journal of Peace Research2:
64-91
.
12.
Gans, H. J.
(1979) Deciding What’s News.
New York: Pantheon
.
13.
Gitlin, T.
(1980) The Whole World is Watching: Mass Media in the Making
and Unmaking of the New Left.
Berkeley: University of California Press
.
14.
Glasgow University Media Group
(1985) War and Peace News.
Milton Keynes/Philadelphia: Open University Press
.
15.
Golan, G.
and
W. Wanta
(2003)
‘International Elections on the US Network News: An Examination
of Factors Affecting Newsworthiness’
, Gazette: The International Journal for Communication Studies65:
25-40
.
16.
Gonzenbach, W. J.
,
M. D. Arant
and
R. L. Stevenson
(1992)
‘The World of US Network Television News: Eighteen Years of
International and Foreign News Coverage’
, Gazette: The International Journal for Communication Studies50:
53-72
.
17.
Grundmann, R.
,
D. Smith
and
S. Wright
(2000)
‘National Elites and Transnational Discourses in the Balkan War’
, European Journal of Communication15:
299-320
.
18.
Gurevitch, M.
,
M. R. Levy
and
I. Roeh
(1991) ‘The Global Newsroom: Convergences and
Diversities in the Globalization of Television News’, in
P. Dahlgren
and
C. Sparks
(eds) Communication and Citizenship: Journalism and the Public
Sphere, pp. 195-216.
London: Routledge
.
19.
Hallin, D. C.
(1989) The Uncensored War: The Media and Vietnam.
Berkeley: University of California Press
.
20.
Harcup, T.
and
D. O’Neill
(2001)
‘What is News? Galtung and Ruge Revisited’
, Journalism Studies2:
261-280
.
21.
Herman, E. S.
and
N. Chomsky
(2002) Manufacturing Consent.
New York: Pantheon Books
.
22.
Kaid, L. L.
,
B. Harville
,
J. Ballotti
and
M. Wawrzyniak
(1993) ‘Telling the Gulf War Story: Coverage in
Five Papers’, in
B. S. Greenberg
and
W. Gantz
(eds) Desert Storm and the Mass Media, pp.
86-98.
Cresskill, NJ: Hampton Press
.
23.
Kelly, M. J.
and
H. T. Mitchell
(1984)
‘Transnational Terrorism and the Western Elite Press’
, Political Communication and Persuasion1(3):
269-296
.
24.
Liebes, T.
(1992)
‘Our War/Their War: Comparing the Intifada and the Gulf War on
U.S. and Israeli Television’
, Critical Studies in Mass Communication9(1):
44-55
.
25.
Livingstone, S.
(1997) ‘Clarifying the CNN Effect: An Examination
of Media Effects According to Military Intervention’, Research
Paper R-18.
Cambridge, MA: The Joan Shorenstein Center for
Press/Politics, John F. Kennedy School of Government, Harvard University
.
26.
Nossek, H. (1990) ‘Terrorism and the Media’, doctoral
dissertation, Hebrew University, Jerusalem.
27.
Nossek, H.
(1994)
‘The Narrative Role of the Holocaust and the State of Israel in
the Coverage of Salient Terrorist Events in the Israeli Press’
, Journal of Narrative and Life History4:
119-134
.
28.
Nossek, H.
(2000)
‘Foreign News and the Construction of Reality: Between the
Mondial and Mondo Cane’
, paper presented at the Conference on International News in the
21st Century, March. Leicester, UK:
Centre for Mass Communication Research.
29.
Nossek, H.
and
H. Adoni
(1996)
‘The Social Implications of Cable Television: Restructuring
Connections with Self and Social Groups’
, International Journal of Public Opinion Research8:
51-69
.
30.
Nossek, H.
and
Adoni, H.
(forthcoming) ‘The Global Village, the Nation State and the
Ethnic Community: Audiences of Communication and Boundaries of
Identity’, in
M. Blondheim
and
R. Watson
(eds) The Toronto School of Communication Theory: International
Perspectives.
Jerusalem: Magnes, Hebrew University Press
.
31.
Nossek, H.
,
D. Berkowitz
and
D. Gavrilos
(2003)
‘Journalism as Social Practice in Crisis: Restoring Identity
Through Mythical Newswork’
, paper presented at the ICA Annual Conference,
San Diego, CA.
32.
Oliver, P. E.
and
G. M. Maney
(2000)
‘Political Process and Local Newspaper Coverage of Protest
Events: From Selection Bias to Triadic Interaction’
, American Journal of Sociology106:
463-505
.
33.
Paterson, C. A.
(1999)
‘Agency Source Influence on Television Foreign Reporting: Case of
Mururoa and Tahiti’
, Asia Pacific Media Educator7:
16-36
.
34.
Picard, R.
(1993) Media Portrayals of Terrorism.
Iowa: Iowa State University Press
.
35.
Roeh, I.
(1994) Acheret al Tikshoret (Different Media).
Israel: Reches
. (In Hebrew.)
36.
Roeh, I.
and
A. A. Cohen
(1992)
‘One of the Bloodiest Days: A Comparative Analysis of Open and
Closed Television News’
, Journal of Communication42(2):
42-55
.
37.
Rosengren, K. E.
(1974)
‘International News: Methods, Data and Theory’
, Journal of Peace Research11:
145-156
.
38.
Servaes, J.
(1991)
‘European Press Coverage of the Granada Crisis’
, Journal of Communication41(4):
28-41
.
39.
Shamir, J.
(1988)
‘Israeli Elite Journalism: Views on Freedom and Responsibility’
, Journalism Quarterly63:
589-594
.
40.
Shoemaker, P. J.
(1991) Gatekeeping.
Newbury Park, CA: Sage
.
41.
Simmons, B. K.
and
D. N. Lowry
(1990)
‘Terrorists in the News, as Reflected in Three News Magazines, 1980-1988’
, Journalism Quarterly67:
692-696
.
42.
Sprintzak, E.
(1995) Alimut Politit be’Israel (Political Violence
in Israel).
Jerusalem: Jerusalem Institute
.
43.
Sreberny, A.
and
R. Stevenson
(1999) ‘Comparative Analysis of International
News Flow: An Example of Global Media Monitoring’, in
K. Nordenstreng
and
M. Griffin
(eds) International Media Monitoring, pp.
55-72.
Cresskill, NJ: Hampton Press
.
44.
Sreberny-Mohammadi, A.
(1991) ‘The Global and the Local in
International Communication’, in
G. Curran
and
M. Gurevitch
(eds) Mass Media and Society, pp. 118-138.
London: Edward Arnold
.
45.
Stevenson, R. L.
and
R. R. Cole
(1984a) ‘Issues in Foreign
News’, in
R. L. Stevenson
and
D. L. Shaw
(eds) Foreign News and the New World Information Order, pp.
5-20.
Iowa: Iowa State University Press
.
46.
Stevenson, R. L.
and
R. R. Cole
(1984b) ‘Patterns of Foreign
News’, in
R. L. Stevenson
and
D. L. Shaw
(eds) Foreign News and the New World Information Order, pp.
37-62.
Iowa: Iowa State University Press
.
47.
Stevenson, R. L.
and
G. D. Gaddy
(1984) ‘“Bad News” and the
Third World’, in
R. L. Stevenson
and
D. L. Shaw
(eds) Foreign News and the New World Information Order, pp.
88-97.
Iowa: Iowa State University Press
.
48.
Tarrow, S.
(1983) ‘Struggling to Reform: Social Movements and
Policy Change During Cycles of Protest’, Occasional Paper No.
15, Western Societies Program.
Ithaca, NY: Cornell University
.
49.
Tunstall, J.
(1977) The Media are American. Anglo-American Media in the
World.
London: Constable
.
50.
Van Belle, D. A.
(2000)
‘New York Timesand Network TV News Coverage of Foreign Disasters:
The Significance of the Insignificant Variables’
, Journalism & Mass Communication Quarterly77:
50-70
.
51.
Wei, W.
,
D. Weaver
and
O. V. Johnson
(1996)
‘Professional Roles of Russian and U.S. Journalists: A
Comparative Study’
, Journalism & Mass Communication Quarterly73:
534-548
.
52.
Weimann, G.
and
H. B. Brosius
(1991)
‘The Newsworthiness of International Terrorism’
, Communication Research18:
333-354
.
53.
Weimann, G.
and
C. Winn
(1994) The Theater of Terror: Mass Media and International
Terrorism.
New York & London: Longman
.
54.
Westerståhl, J.
and
F. Johansson
(1994)
‘Foreign News: News Values and Ideologies’
, European Journal of Communication9:
71-89
.
55.
Wilkinson, P.
(2000) Terrorism Versus Democracy: The Liberal State
Response.
Portland, OR: Frank Cass
.
56.
Wu, H. D.
(2000)
‘Systemic Determinants of International News Coverage: A
Comparison of 38 Countries’
, Journal of Communication50(2):
110-130
.
57.
Youicchi, I.
(1995)
‘A Study of Psychological Factors of International Information
Flows: News and TV Programs’
, paper presented at the International Association for Media and
Communication Research Conference, June,
Portoroz, Slovania.
