At a time when national discourse in the USA centers the need for professionalization, regulation, and surveillance, this article emphasizes the ways in which neoliberal logics harm those working in early childhood education in the USA. While stakeholders at every level debate proposed solutions to the early childhood education crisis, largely related to furthering regulation, this article brings forward the voices of those doing the work and rejects the idea that neoliberal logics will lead us collectively away from a situation that they created. Guided by the tenets of critical qualitative inquiry, I use narrative inquiry to explore the stories of early childhood educators working in an underfunded, undervalued field. In this article, I highlight two resonant themes that spanned the participants’ narratives, which are related to the impacts of scarcity and surveillance in early childhood education spaces. Based on my findings, I make the claim that early childhood education professionals are strained by increased regulation and surveillance amidst an already toxic prevalence of scarcity of various forms, and that shifts to further regulate the field should consider the voices of the people working in these spaces.
Ackerman DJ (2006) The costs of being a child care teacher: Revisiting the problem of low wages. Educational Policy20(1): 85–112.
2.
AilwoodJ (2017) Exploring the care in early childhood education and care. Global Studies of Childhood7(4): 305–310.
3.
AndrewY (2015) “I’m strong within myself”: Gender, class and emotional capital in childcare. British Journal of Sociology of Education36(5): 651–668.
4.
AndrewYNewmanB (2012) The value of childcare: Class, gender and caring labour. Contemporary Issues in Early Childhood13(3): 242–247.
5.
BackesEPAllenLR (2018) Transforming the Financing of Early Care and Education. Washington, DC: National Academies Press.
6.
BaumgartnerJCarsonRApavaloaieL, et al. (2009) Uncovering common stressful factors and coping strategies among child care providers. Child and Youth Care Forum38(5): 239–251.
7.
BeachJFernsC (2015) From child care market to child care system. Our Schools/Our Selves24(4): 53–61.
8.
BellowsLBassokDMarkowitzAJ (2021) Teacher turnover in early childhood education: Longitudinal evidence from the universe of publicly-funded programs in Louisiana. Report, Annenburg Institute at Brown University, Providence, RI, August.
9.
BlauD (2001) Child Care Problem: An Economic Analysis. New York: Russell Sage Foundation.
10.
BownKSumsionJ (2007) Voices from the other side of the fence: Early childhood teachers’ experiences with mandatory regulatory requirements. Contemporary Issues in Early Childhood8(1): 30–49.
11.
BruceEM (2008) Narrative inquiry: A spiritual and liberating approach to research. Religious Education103(3): 323–338.
12.
BulloughRVHall-KenyonKMMacKayKL, et al. (2014) Head Start and the intensification of teaching in early childhood education. Teaching and Teacher Education37: 55–63.
13.
CaineVEstefanAClandininDJ (2013) A return to methodological commitment: Reflections on narrative inquiry. Scandinavian Journal of Educational Research57(6): 574–586.
14.
CannellaGSLincolnYS (2016) Deploying qualitative methods for critical social purposes. Counterpoints433: 17–26.
15.
ChaseSE (2010) Narrative inquiry: Multiple lenses, approaches, voices. In: LuttrellW (ed.) Qualitative Educational Research: Readings in Reflexive and Transformative Practice. London: Routledge, pp. 208–236.
16.
ClandininDJ (2013) Engaging in Narrative Inquiry. Walnut Creek, CA: Left Coast Press.
17.
ConnellyFClandininD (1990) Stories of experience and narrative inquiry. Educational Researcher19(5): 2–14.
18.
CrawfordAVaughnKAGuttentagCL, et al. (2021) “Doing what I can, but I got no magic wand”: A snapshot of early childhood educator experiences and efforts to ensure quality during the COVID-19 pandemic. Early Childhood Education Journal49(5): 829–840.
19.
DaviesBBanselP (2007) Neoliberalism and education. International Journal of Qualitative Studies in Education20(3): 247–259.
EliasNMD’AgostinoMJ (2021) Care in crisis: COVID-19 as a catalyst for universal child care in the United States. Administrative Theory and Praxis43(2): 217–229.
22.
FriendlyMBeachJMohamedSS, et al. (2020) Moving from private to public processes to create child care services in Canada. Report, Child Care Resource and Research Unit, Toronto, ON, Canada, Fall.
23.
GallagherA (2018) The business of care: Marketization and the new geographies of childcare. Progress in Human Geography42(5): 706–722.
24.
Gallagher RobbinsKSchmitS (2020) Urgently address the child care crisis and invest in equitable child care and early learning for all. Report, Center for Law and Social Policy, Washington, DC, November.
25.
Hall-KenyonKMBulloughRVMacKayKL, et al. (2014) Preschool teacher well-being: A review of the literature. Early Childhood Education Journal42(3): 153–162.
26.
Harbach MJohnson (2015) Child care market failure. Utah Law Review2015(3): 659–719.
27.
JonesSRTorresVArminioJ (2014) Negotiating the Complexities of Qualitative Research in Higher Education: Fundamental Elements and Issues. 2nd ed.London: Routledge.
28.
JovanovicJFaneJ (2016) Learner engagement under the “regulatory gaze”: Possibilities for re-positioning early childhood pre-service teachers as autonomous professionals. Early Years36(2): 148–164.
29.
JovchelovitchSBauerMW (2000) Narrative Interviewing. London: LSE Research Online.
30.
KimJ-H (2008) A romance with narrative inquiry: Toward an act of narrative theorizing. Curriculum and Teaching Dialogue10(1–2): 251–267.
31.
KimJ-H (2016) Understanding Narrative Inquiry: The Crafting and Analysis of Stories as Research. New York: SAGE.
32.
KlopperH (2008) The qualitative research proposal. Curationis31(4): 62–72.
33.
Laliberte RudmanDAldrichRM (2017) Discerning the social in individual stories of occupation through critical narrative inquiry. Journal of Occupational Science24(4): 470–481.
34.
LashMMcMullenM (2008) The child care trilemma: How moral orientations influence the field. Contemporary Issues in Early Childhood9(1): 36–48.
35.
LloydEPennH (2014) Child care markets in an age of austerity. European Early Childhood Education Research Journal22(3): 386–396.
36.
LuttrellW (2010) “Good enough” methods for life-story analysis. In: LuttrellW (ed.) Qualitative Educational Research: Readings in Reflexive and Transformative Practice. London: Routledge, pp. 258–278.
37.
MacCrimmonKLakindA (2017) The deprofessionalization of family child care providers: Wisconsin’s YoungStar system. Global Studies of Childhood7(4): 346–356.
38.
MadridSDunn-KenneyM (2010) Persecutory guilt, surveillance and resistance: The emotional themes of early childhood educators. Contemporary Issues in Early Childhood11(4): 388–401.
39.
McLeanCAustinLJEWhitebookM, et al. (2021) Early Childhood Workforce Index—2020. Report, University of California, Berkeley, CA.
40.
Michigan League for Public Policy (2020) Child Care in Michigan. https://mlpp.org/child-care-in-michigan/
41.
MoloneyMSimsMRotheA, et al. (2019) Resisting neoliberalism: Professionalisation of early childhood education and care. International Journal of Elementary Education8(1): 1–10.
42.
MossP (2009) There are alternatives! Markets and democratic experimentalism in early childhood education and care. In: Working Papers in Early Childhood Development, no. 53. The Hague: Bernard van Leer Foundation, pp. 7–28.
43.
NavarroV (2007) Neoliberalism as a class ideology; or, the political causes of the growth of inequalities. International Journal of Health Services37(1): 47–62.
44.
NoresMBarnettWS (2014) Access to high quality early care and education: Readiness and opportunity gaps in America. Report, Center on Enhancing Early Learning Outcomes, New Brunswick, NJ, May.
45.
OosterhoffOOenema-MostertCMinnaertA (2020) Constrained or sustained by demands? Perceptions of professional autonomy in early childhood education. Contemporary Issues in Early Childhood21(2): 138–152.
46.
OsgoodJ (2006) Deconstructing professionalism in early childhood education: Resisting the regulatory gaze. Contemporary Issues in Early Childhood7(1): 5–14.
47.
PasquePASalazar PérezM (2015) Centering critical inquiry: Methodologies that facilitate critical qualitative research. In: CanellaGSSalazar PérezPAPasquePA (eds) Critical Qualitative Inquiry: Foundations and Futures. London: Routledge, pp. 139–170.
48.
PressFWoodrowC (2005) Commodification, corporatisation and children’s spaces. Australian Journal of Education49(3): 278–291.
RobbinsCK (2012) Racial consciousness, identity, and dissonance among white women in student affairs graduate programs. PhD Thesis, University of Maryland, College Park, MD.
51.
Roberts-HolmesGMossP (2021) Neoliberalism and Early Childhood Education: Markets, Imaginaries and Governance. London: Routledge.
52.
RobertsALeVSchaackD, et al. (2018) Michigan early care and education workforce study: 2018. Report, Butler Institute for Families, Graduate School of Social Work, University of Denver, Denver, CO.
53.
SalterL (2017) Research as resistance and solidarity: “Spinning transformative yarns”—a narrative inquiry with women going on from abuse and oppression. Journal of Family Therapy39(3): 366–385.
TravisDJLeeAFaulknerM, et al. (2014) Cultivating a thriving child care workforce: A theory-driven qualitative analysis. Community, Work and Family17(3): 325–345.
58.
U.S. Bureau of Labor and Statistics (2020) Household Data Annual Averages. Employed Persons by Detailed Occupation, Sex, Race, and Hispanic or Latino Ethnicity. https://www.bls.gov/cps/cpsaat11.pdf
59.
VandenbroeckM (2021) Foreword. In: Robert-HolmesGMossP (eds) Neoliberalism and Early Childhood Education: Markets, Imaginaries and Governance. London: Routledge, pp. xii–xiv.
WengrafT (2001) Qualitative Research Interviewing. New York: SAGE.
62.
WhitebookMHowesCPhillipsD (1990) Who cares? Child care teachers and the quality of care in America. Final Report, National Child Care Staffing Study, Center for the Study of Child Care Employment, University of California, Berkeley, CA.
63.
WhitebookMMcLeanCAustinLJ, et al. (2018) Early Childhood Workforce Index—2018. Report, Center for the Study of Child Care Employment, University of California, Berkeley, CA.
64.
WhitebookMPhillipsDHowesC (2014) Worthy work, STILL unlivable wages: The early childhood workforce 25 years after the National Child Care Staffing Study. Report, Center for the Study of Child Care Employment, University of California, Berkeley, CA, 1 November.
