The nexus between punishment and social welfare has been extensively studied at the macrolevel, both for single cases and across countries. However, we lack comparative studies at the individual level because the literatures on punitive and welfare attitudes have developed largely in isolation. This article for the first time provides comprehensive empirical evidence for the link at the micro-level. Using data covering 24,481 individuals in 22 countries from the European Social Survey's fourth wave, we test, first, whether individual punitive and welfare attitudes are empirically related and find evidence for a negative relationship. Second, when analyzing to what extent it is driven by common explanatory factors, we find that it holds even when controlling for the most relevant drivers or penal and welfare attitudes. Finally, we explore if context moderates this relationship. The more prosperous, equal, and safe a country is, the stronger the relationship between punitiveness and welfare attitudes becomes.
BarkerV (2009) The Politics of Imprisonment: How the Democratic Process Shapes the Way America Punishes Offenders. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
2.
BeckBGoldsteinA (2018) Governing through police? Housing market reliance, welfare retrenchment, and police budgeting in an era of declining crime. Social Forces96(3): 1183–1210.
3.
BeckettK (1997) Making Crime Pay: Law and Order in Contemporary American Politics. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
4.
BeckettKWesternB (2001) Governing social marginality: welfare, incarceration, and the transformation of state policy. Punishment & Society3(1): 43–59.
5.
BrownEKSociaKM (2017) Twenty-first century punitiveness: social sources of punitive American views reconsidered. Journal of Quantitative Criminology33(4): 935–959.
6.
CavadinoMDignanJ (2006) Penal policy and political economy. Criminology and Criminal Justice6(4): 435–456.
7.
De GiorgiA (2017) Re-thinking the Political Economy of Punishment: Perspectives on Post-Fordism and Penal Politics. London/New York: Routledge.
8.
DownesDHansenK (2006) Welfare and punishment in comparative context. In: ArmstrongSMcAraL (eds) Perspectives on punishment: the contours of control. Oxford: Oxford University Press, 133–154.
9.
EllwoodJWGuetzkowJ (2009) Footing the bill: causes and budgetary consequences of state spending on corrections. In: Raphael SStollMA (eds) Do Prisons Make Us Safer? The Benefits and Costs of the Prison Boom. New York: Russell Sage Foundation, 207–238.
10.
EnnsPK (2016) Incarceration Nation. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
11.
FarrallSGrayE (2024) The Politics of Crime, Punishment and Justice: Exploring the Lived Reality and Enduring Legacies of the 1980’s Radical Right. London/New York: Routledge.
12.
FarrallSJenningsW (2012) Policy feedback and the criminal justice agenda: an analysis of the economy, crime rates, politics and public opinion in post-war Britain. Contemporary British History26(4): 467–488.
13.
FordingRC (2001) The political response to black insurgency: a critical test of competing theories of the state. American Political Science Review95: 115–130.
14.
GarlandD (1985) Punishment and Welfare: A History of Penal Strategies. Aldershot: Gower.
15.
GarlandD (2001) The Culture of Control: Crime and Social Order in Contemporary Society. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
16.
GarlandD (2017) Punishment and welfare: social problems and social structures. In: LieblingAMarunaSMcAraL (eds) The Oxford handbook of criminology. Oxford: Oxford University Press, 77–97.
17.
GelmanAHillJ (2007) Data Analysis Using Regression and Multilevel/Hierarchical Models. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
18.
GrayEGrassoMFarrallS, et al. (2019) Political socialization, worry about crime and antisocial behaviour: an analysis of age, period and cohort effects. The British Journal of Criminology59(2): 435–460.
19.
GreenbergDFWestV (2001) State prison populations and their growth, 1971–1991. Criminology39(3): 615–654.
20.
GuetzkowJ (2020) Common cause? Policymaking discourse and the prison/welfare trade-off. Politics & Society48(3): 321–356.
21.
HallSCritcherCJeffersonT, et al. (2017 [1978]) Policing the Crisis: Mugging, the state and law and order. London: Bloomsbury Publishing.
22.
HummelsheimDHirtenlehnerHJacksonJ, et al. (2011) Social insecurities and fear of crime: a cross-national study on the impact of welfare state policies on crime-related anxieties. European Sociological Review27(3): 327–345.
23.
JenningsWFarrallSGrayE, et al. (2017) Penal populism and the public thermostat: crime, public punitiveness, and public policy. Governance30(3): 463–481.
24.
JohnsonWW (1996) Transcarceration and social control policy: the 1980s and beyond. Crime & Delinquency42(1): 114–126.
25.
JordanJ (2014) Religious belief, religious denomination, and preferences for redistribution: a comparison across 13 countries. West European Politics37(1): 19–41.
26.
KarstedtSEndtrichtR (2022) Crime and punishment: public opinion and political law-and-order rhetoric in Europe 1996–2019. The British Journal of Criminology62(5): 1116–1135.
27.
KornhauserR (2015) Economic individualism and punitive attitudes: a cross-national analysis. Punishment & Society17(1): 27–53.
28.
LaceyN (2008) The Prisoners’ Dilemma: Political Economy and Punishment in Contemporary Democracies. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
29.
Lappi-SeppäläT (2008) Trust, welfare, and political culture: explaining differences in national penal policies. Crime and Justice37(1): 313–387. http://www.jstor.org/stable/10.1086/525028 .
LiskaAE (1997) Modeling the relationships between macro forms of social control. Annual Review of Sociology23(1): 39–61.
32.
MillerLL (2008) The Perils of Federalism: Race, Poverty, and the Politics of Crime Control. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
33.
MillerLL (2016) The Myth of Mob Rule: Violent Crime and Democratic Politics. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
34.
MillerLL (2019) The Politics of Community Crime Prevention: Operation Weed and Seed in Seattle. London/New York: Routledge.
35.
OeschD (2006) Coming to grips with a changing class structure: an analysis of employment stratification in Britain, Germany, Sweden and Switzerland. International Sociology21(2): 263–288.
36.
PetersenMBSznycerDCosmidesL, et al. (2012) Who deserves help? Evolutionary psychology, social emotions, and public opinion about welfare. Political Psychology33(3): 395–418.
37.
PickettJTMearsDPStewartEA, et al. (2013) Security at the expense of liberty: a test of predictions deriving from the culture of control thesis. Crime & Delinquency59(2): 214–242.
38.
PrattJErikssonA (2014) Contrasts in Punishment: An explanation of Anglophone excess and Nordic Exceptionalism. London/New York: Routledge.
39.
ReitzKR (ed) (2017) American Exceptionalism in Crime and Punishment. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
40.
RubinAT (2011) Punitive penal preferences and support for welfare: applying the ‘governance of social marginality’thesis to the individual level. Punishment & Society13(2): 198–229.
41.
RuedaDStegmuellerD (2016) The externalities of inequality: fear of crime and preferences for redistribution in Western Europe. American Journal of Political Science60(2): 472–489.
42.
SimonJ (2007) Governing Through Crime: How the War on Crime Transformed American Democracy and Created a Culture of Fear. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
43.
SmallDALernerJS (2008) Emotional policy: personal sadness and anger shape judgments about a welfare case. Political Psychology29(2): 149–168.
44.
StuckyTDHeimerKLangJB (2005) Partisan politics, electoral competition and imprisonment: an analysis of states over time. Criminology43(1): 211–248.
45.
SuttonJR (2000) Imprisonment and social classification in five common-law democracies, 1955–1985. American Journal of Sociology106(2): 350–386.
46.
SuttonJR (2004) The political economy of imprisonment in affluent western democracies, 1960-1990. American Sociological Review69(2): 170–189.
47.
SuttonJR (2013) The transformation of prison regimes in late capitalist societies. American Journal of Sociology119(3): 715–746.
48.
TuttleJ (2018) Specifying the effect of social welfare expenditures on homicide and suicide: a cross-national, longitudinal examination of the stream analogy of lethal violence. Justice Quarterly35(1): 87–113.
49.
VienoARoccatoMRussoS (2013) Is fear of crime mainly social and economic insecurity in disguise? A multilevel multinational analysis. Journal of Community & Applied Social Psychology23(6): 519–535.
50.
VisserMScholteMScheepersP (2013) Fear of crime and feelings of unsafety in European countries: macro and micro explanations in cross-national perspective. The Sociological Quarterly54(2): 278–301.
51.
WacquantL (2009) Punishing the Poor: The Neoliberal Government of Social Insecurity. Durham: Duke University Press.
52.
WenzelburgerG (2015) Parties, institutions and the politics of law and order: how political institutions and partisan ideologies shape law-and-order spending in twenty western industrialized countries. British Journal of Political Science45(3): 663–687.
53.
WenzelburgerG (2018) Political economy or political systems? How welfare capitalism and political systems affect law and order policies in twenty western industrialised nations. Social Policy and Society17(2): 209–226.
Supplementary Material
Please find the following supplemental material available below.
For Open Access articles published under a Creative Commons License, all supplemental material carries the same license as the article it is associated with.
For non-Open Access articles published, all supplemental material carries a non-exclusive license, and permission requests for re-use of supplemental material or any part of supplemental material shall be sent directly to the copyright owner as specified in the copyright notice associated with the article.
