The American criminal legal system is characterized by deeply entrenched racial and ethnic disparities. Given that aggregate criminal legal system outcomes are a function of decisions made by police, prosecutors, judges, and other local actors, it is reasonable to expect that localized punishment decisions are contingent on the racial and ethnic dynamics within a community. However, there is a dearth of research examining the impact of community characteristics on pretrial case-processing outcomes. The current study explores the impact of county-level minority composition and segregation on pretrial decision-making. Drawing from a sample of 31,974 felony defendants across 64 large urban counties, we examine the relationships between community racial and ethnic composition and segregation on release on recognizance, bail denial, and bail amount decisions. Our findings reveal that minority composition and segregation directly influence court case processing, and they operate in contrasting ways across different decision points. The findings underscore the importance of community characteristics above and beyond individual-level factors in determining pretrial decisions.
AaltonenMMacdonaldJMMartikainenP, et al. (2013) Examining the generality of the unemployment–crime association. Criminology51(3): 561–594.
2.
AllportGW (1954) The Nature of Prejudice. Cambridge, MA: Addison-Wesley.
3.
BaumerEP (2013) Reassessing and redirecting research on race and sentencing. Justice Quarterly30(2): 231–261.
4.
BaumerEPMartinKH (2013) Social organization, collective sentiment, and legal sanctions in murder cases. American Journal of Sociology119(1): 131–182. The University of Chicago Press.
5.
BeckmanLWangX (2022) Revisiting the minority threat perspective: Examining the main and interactive effects of segregation on sentencing severity. Justice Quarterly39(4): 745–771.
6.
BlalockHM (1967) Toward a Theory of Minority-Group Relations. New York, NY: John Wiley and Sons. Available at: https://cir.nii.ac.jp/crid/1130000793701086720 (accessed 30 October 2023).
7.
BlumerH (1958) Race prejudice as a sense of group position. Pacific Sociological Review1(1): 3–7.
8.
BoboLHutchingsVL (1996) Perceptions of racial group competition: Extending Blumer’s theory of group position to a multiracial social context. American Sociological Review61(6): 951–972.
9.
BoydCLNelsonMJ (2017) The effects of trial judge gender and public opinion on criminal sentencing decisions. Vanderbilt Law Review70: 1819–1843.
10.
BrittCL (2000) Social context and racial disparities in punishment decisions. Justice Quarterly17(4): 707–732.
11.
CasillasCJEnnsPKWohlfarthPC (2011) How public opinion constrains the US Supreme Court. American Journal of Political Science55(1): 74–88.
CharlesCZ (2003) The dynamics of racial residential segregation. Annual Review of Sociology29(1): 167–207.
14.
ChiricosTMcEntireRGertzM (2001) Perceived racial and ethnic composition of neighborhood and perceived risk of crime. Social Problems48(3): 322–340.
15.
DavisAJ (2007) Arbitrary Justice: The Power of the American Prosecutor. New York, NY: Oxford University Press.
16.
DemuthS (2003) Racial and ethnic differences in pretrial release decisions and outcomes: A comparison of hispanic, black, and white felony arrestees. Criminology41(3): 873–908.
17.
DhamiMK (2005) From discretion to disagreement: Explaining disparities in judges’ pretrial decisions. Behavioral Sciences & the Law23(3): 367–386.
18.
DonnellyEA (2022) Neighborhoods, criminal incidents, race, and sentencing: Exploring the racial and social context of disparities in incarceration sentences. The British Journal of Criminology62(1): 145–164.
19.
DonnellyEAAsieduCO (2020) Neighborhood context and racial/ethnic disparities in judicial processing. Sociology Compass14(9): e12822.
20.
DuxburySW (2021) Who controls criminal law? Racial threat and the adoption of state sentencing law, 1975 to 2012. American Sociological Review86(1): 123–153.
21.
EitleDD’AlessioSJStolzenbergL (2002) Racial threat and social control: a test of the political, economic, and threat of black crime hypotheses. Social Forces81(2): 557–576.
22.
EitleDTaylorJ (2008) Are hispanics the new ‘threat’? Minority group threat and fear of crime in Miami-dade county. Social Science Research37(4): 1102–1115.
23.
FearnNE (2005) A multilevel analysis of community effects on criminal sentencing. Justice Quarterly22(4): 452–487.
24.
FeldmeyerBCochranJC (2018) Racial threat and social control: A review and conceptual framework for advancing racial threat theory. In: UnneverJDGabbidonSLChouhyC (eds) Building a Black Criminology, Volume 24. New York, NY: Routledge, 283–316.
25.
FormanJJr (2017) Locking up Our Own: Crime and Punishment in Black America. New York, NY: Farrar, Straus and Giroux.
26.
FoxJ (2015) Applied Regression Analysis and Generalized Linear Models. Thousand Oaks, CA: Sage Publications.
27.
FreiburgerTLHilinskiCM (2010) The impact of race, gender, and age on the pretrial decision. Criminal Justice Review35(3): 318–334.
28.
FreiburgerTLMarcumCDPierceM (2010) The impact of race on the pretrial decision. American Journal of Criminal Justice35(1–2): 76–86.
29.
GoldkampJSGottfredsonMR (1979) Bail decision making and pretrial detention. Law and Human Behavior3(4): 227–249.
30.
GreenbergDFKesslerRCLoftinC (1985) Social inequality and crime control. The Journal of Criminal Law and Criminology (1973-)76(3): 684.
31.
GreenbergDFWestV (2001) State prison populations and their growth, 1971–1991. Criminology39(3): 615–654.
32.
HelmsRJacobsD (2002) The political context of sentencing: An analysis of community and individual determinants. Social Forces81(2): 577–604.
33.
HoodKSchneiderD (2019) Bail and pretrial detention: Contours and causes of temporal and county variation. RSF: The Russell Sage Foundation Journal of the Social Sciences5(1): 126–149.
34.
HuberGAGordonSC (2004) Accountability and coercion: Is justice blind when it runs for office?American Journal of Political Science48(2): 247–263.
35.
JohnsonBD (2006) The multilevel context of criminal sentencing: Integrating judge-and county-level influences. Criminology44(2): 259–298.
36.
KeenBJacobsD (2009) Racial threat, partisan politics, and racial disparities in prison admissions: A panel analysis. Criminology47(1): 209–238.
37.
KingRDLightMT (2019) Have racial and ethnic disparities in sentencing declined?Crime and Justice48(1): 365–437.
38.
KleinAWittesB (2011) Preventive detention in American theory and practice. Harvard National Security Journal2: 85–191.
39.
KramerJHUlmerJT (2002) Downward departures for serious violent offenders: Local court “corrections” to Pennsylvania’s sentencing guidelines. Criminology40(4): 897–932.
40.
KrivoLJPetersonRDKuhlDC (2009) Segregation, racial structure, and neighborhood violent crime. American Journal of Sociology114(6): 1765–1802.
41.
KurlychekMCJohnsonBD (2019) Cumulative disadvantage in the American criminal justice system. Annual Review of Criminology2(1): 291–319.
42.
LeachMABeanFD (2008) The structure and dynamics of Mexican migration to new destinations in the United States. In: MasseyDS (eds) New Faces in New Places: The Changing Geography of American immigration. New York, NY: Russell Sage Foundation, 51–74.
43.
LegewieJSchaefferM (2016) Contested boundaries: Explaining where ethnoracial diversity provokes neighborhood conflict. American Journal of Sociology122(1): 125–161.
44.
LehmannPSMeldrumRC (2024) Disparities in youth arrest across racial and ethnic subgroups. Youth Violence and Juvenile Justice22(1): 22–45.
45.
LeonardJS (1987) The interaction of residential segregation and employment discrimination. Journal of Urban Economics21(3): 323–346.
46.
LichterDTParisiDTaquinoMC, et al. (2010) Residential segregation in new hispanic destinations: Cities, suburbs, and rural communities compared. Social Science Research39(2): 215–230.
47.
LiskaAE (1992) Social Threat and Social Control. Albany, NY: SUNY Press.
48.
LiskaAEChamlinMB (1984) Social structure and crime control among macrosocial units. American Journal of Sociology90(2): 383–395.
49.
LynchM (2011) Mass incarceration, legal change, and locale: Understanding and remediating American penal overindulgence. Criminology & Public Policy10(3): 673–698.
50.
LyonsCJ (2007) Community (dis) organization and racially motivated crime. American Journal of Sociology113(3): 815–863.
51.
MarkertJ (2010) The changing face of racial discrimination: Hispanics as the dominant minority in the USA- A new application of power-threat theory. Critical Sociology36(2): 307–327.
52.
MasseyDSCondranGADentonNA (1987) The effect of residential segregation on black social and economic well-being. Social Forces66(1): 29–56.
53.
MasseyDSDentonNA (1993) American Apartheid: Segregation and the Making of the Underclass. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.
54.
MeyerSG (2000) As Long as They Don’t Move next Door: Segregation and Racial Conflict in American Neighborhoods. Lanham, MD: Rowman & Littlefield.
55.
NelsonMJ (2014) Responsive justice? Retention elections, prosecutors, and public opinion. Journal of Law and Courts2: 117–152.
56.
Nicholson-CrottyS (2004) The impact of sentencing guidelines on state-level sanctions: An analysis over time. Crime & Delinquency50(3): 395–411.
57.
OuelletteHMApplegateBK (2023) Local incarceration as social control: A national analysis of social, economic, and political determinants of jail use in the United States. American Journal of Criminal Justice48(3): 547–571.
58.
ParkerKFStultsBJRiceSK (2005) Racial threat, concentrated disadvantage and social control: Considering the macro-level sources of variation in arrests. Criminology43(4): 1111–1134.
59.
PetersonRDKrivoLJ (1993) Racial segregation and black urban homicide. Social Forces71(4): 1001–1026.
60.
PettigrewTFTroppLR (2006) A meta-analytic test of intergroup contact theory. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology90(5): 751.
61.
PiatkowskaSJMessnerSF (2022) Group threat, same-sex marriage, and hate crime based on sexual orientation. Justice Quarterly39(4): 802–824.
62.
PickettJT (2019) Public opinion and criminal justice policy: Theory and research. Annual Review of Criminology2(1): 405–428.
63.
PinchevskyGMSteinerB (2016) Sex-based disparities in pretrial release decisions and outcomes. Crime & Delinquency62(3): 308–340.
64.
ReavesBA (2013) Felony Defendants in Large Urban Counties, 2009 Statistical Tables. Washington, D.C.: US Department of Justice, Bureau of Justice Statistics.
65.
RothsteinR (2017) The Color of Law: A Forgotten History of How Our Government Segregated America. New York, NY: Liveright Publishing.
66.
SajaiaZ (2007) FASTGINI: Stata Module to Calculate Gini Coefficient with Jackknife Standard Errors. Chestnut Hill, MA: Statistical Software Components. Available at: https://econpapers.repec.org/software/bocbocode/s456814.htm (accessed 25 January 2024).
67.
SchlesingerT (2005) Racial and ethnic disparity in pretrial criminal processing. Justice Quarterly22(2): 170–192.
68.
ShihadehESFlynnN (1996) Segregation and crime: The effect of black social isolation on the rates of black urban violence. Social Forces74(4): 1325–1352.
69.
SkeemJScurichNMonahanJ (2020) Impact of risk assessment on judges’ fairness in sentencing relatively poor defendants. Law and Human Behavior44(1): 51–59.
70.
SpitzerS (1975) Toward a Marxian theory of deviance. Social Problems22(5): 638–651.
71.
SteffensmeierDUlmerJKramerJ (1998) The interaction of race, gender, and age in criminal sentencing: The punishment cost of being young, black, and male. Criminology36(4): 763–798.
72.
St. LouisS (2024) The pretrial detention penalty: A systematic review and meta-analysis of pretrial detention and case outcomes. Justice Quarterly41(3): 347–370.
73.
StolzenbergLD’AlessioSJEitleD (2013) Race and cumulative discrimination in the prosecution of criminal defendants. Race and Justice3(4): 275–299.
74.
StultsBJBaumerEP (2007) Racial context and police force size: Evaluating the empirical validity of the minority threat perspective. American Journal of Sociology113(2): 507–546.
75.
SuttonJR (2013) Structural bias in the sentencing of felony defendants. Social Science Research42(5): 1207–1221.
76.
TaylorMC (1998) How white attitudes vary with the racial composition of local populations: Numbers count. American Sociological Review63(4): 512–535.
77.
UlmerJT (2012) Recent developments and new directions in sentencing research. Justice Quarterly29(1): 1–40.
78.
UlmerJTJohnsonB (2004) Sentencing in context: A multilevel analysis. Criminology42(1): 137–178.
79.
UlmerJTKurlychekMCKramerJH (2007) Prosecutorial discretion and the imposition of mandatory minimum sentences. Journal of Research in Crime and Delinquency44(4): 427–458.
80.
ValentyLOSylviaRD (2004) Thresholds for tolerance: The impact of racial and ethnic population composition on the vote for California propositions 187 and 209. The Social Science Journal41(3): 433–446.
81.
VogelMLentzTSSteenbeekW (2023) Contested neighborhood boundaries and intergroup and intragroup violence. Crime & Delinquency70(11): 2906–2931.
82.
VogelMMessnerSF (2024) Group threat and social control: Who, what, where, and when. Annual Review of Criminology7(1): 39–58.
83.
WacquantL (2001) Deadly symbiosis: When ghetto and prison meet and mesh. Punishment & Society3(1): 95–133.
84.
WangXMearsDP (2010) A multilevel test of minority threat effects on sentencing. Journal of Quantitative Criminology26(2): 191–215.
85.
WangXMearsDP (2015) Sentencing and state-level racial and ethnic contexts. Law & Society Review49(4): 883–915.
86.
WeidnerRRFraseRS (2003) Legal and extralegal determinants of intercounty differences in prison use. Criminal Justice Policy Review14(3): 377–400.
87.
WeidnerRRFraseRSSchultzJS (2005) The impact of contextual factors on the decision to imprison in large urban jurisdictions: A multilevel analysis. Crime & Delinquency51(3): 400–424.
88.
WelchKPayneAAChiricosT, et al. (2011) The typification of hispanics as criminals and support for punitive crime control policies. Social Science Research40(3): 822–840.
89.
WilliamsDRCollinsC (2001) Racial residential segregation: A fundamental cause of racial disparities in health. Public Health Reports116(5): 404–416.
90.
WilliamsJHCampbellM (2021) Exploring the time-varying determinants of state spending on corrections. Journal of Quantitative Criminology37(3): 671–692.
91.
WilliamsJHRosenfeldR (2016) The impact of neighborhood status on imprisonment for firearm offenses. Journal of Contemporary Criminal Justice32(4): 383–400.
92.
WilliamsJHVaughnPE (2024) Cheap on punishment: Examining the impact of prison population racial demographics on state-level corrections spending. Justice Quarterly41(4): 597–618.
93.
WilliamsMR (2016) From bail to jail: The effect of jail capacity on bail decisions. American Journal of Criminal Justice41(3): 484–497.
94.
WooldredgeJ (2007) Neighborhood effects on felony sentencing. Journal of Research in Crime and Delinquency44(2): 238–263.
95.
WooldredgeJ (2012) Distinguishing race effects on pre-trial release and sentencing decisions. Justice Quarterly29(1): 41–75.
96.
WooldredgeJFrankJGouletteN, et al. (2015) Is the impact of cumulative disadvantage on sentencing greater for black defendants?Criminology & Public Policy14(2): 187–223.
97.
ZvonkovichJUlmerJT (2023) Segregation and group threat: Specifying Hispanic-white punishment disparity. Social Problemsspad 032: 1–21.
