Americans, above all poor Black Americans, are subject to extraordinary levels of police violence, incarceration, and penal control—levels that exist nowhere else in the developed world. This article outlines a comparative, structural explanation of America's extraordinary penal state, pointing to the structural arrangements and historical processes that created it and keep it in place; describing how these political and economic structures differ from those of other nations; and indicating how the macro-structures of political economy interact with community-level processes of social ordering and informal social control to shape street-level practices of crime, policing, and punishment. The article goes beyond the existing “political economy and punishment” literature by broadening the explicandum to include America's extraordinary levels of criminal and police violence; by describing the interaction of social and penal controls; by detailing the negative social indicators associated with America's peculiar political economy; and by highlighting causal factors such as social control deficits, state capacity limitations, and the effect of neighborhood disorganization and danger on the actions of criminal justice officials.
AlbrechtJ (2004) Youth justice in Germany. Youth Crime and Youth Justice: Cross-National Perspectives Crime and Justice31: 443–493.
2.
AlesinaAGlaeserEL (2004) Fighting Poverty in the US and Europe: A World of Difference. New York: Oxford University Press.
3.
AlexanderM (2010) The New Jim Crow: Mass Incarceration in the Age of Colorblindness. New York: The New Press.
4.
ArcherR (2007) Why Is There No Labor Party in the United States?Princeton: Princeton University Press.
5.
BaldwinP (2009) The Narcissism of Minor Differences: How America and Europe Are Alike. New York: Oxford University Press.
6.
BantingKKymlickaW (eds) (2017) The Strains of Commitment: The Political Sources of Solidarity in Diverse Societies. New York: Oxford University Press.
7.
BayleyD (1994) Police for the Future. New York: Oxford University Press.
8.
BeckettK (2022) Ending Mass Incarceration: Why It Persists and How to Achieve Meaningful Reform. New York: Oxford University Press.
9.
BeckettKWesternB (2001) Governing social marginality: welfare, incarceration, and the transformation of state policy. Punishment & Society3(1): 43–59.
10.
BoboLDJohnsonD (2004) A taste for punishment: black and white Americans’ views on the death penalty and the war on drugs. Du Bois Review1(1): 151–180.
11.
BoutellierH (2001) A letter from The Netherlands – on safety, criminal law and humanism. Crime Prevention and Community Safety3: 71–79.
12.
BrearleyHC (1932) Homicide in the United States. Chapel Hill: University of North Carolina Press.
13.
BrooksR (2021) Tangled Up in Blue: Policing the American City. New York: Penguin Books.
14.
Burn-MurdochJ (2023, May 12) Collapsing social trust is driving American gun violence. Financial Times.
15.
CampbellMCSchoenfeldH (2013) The transformation of America’s penal order: A historicized political sociology of punishment. American Journal of Sociology118(5): 1375–1423.
CordaARoviraMHenleyA (2023) Collateral consequences of criminal records from the other side of the pond: how exceptional is American penal exceptionalism. Criminology and Criminal Justice23(4): 519–527.
25.
CurrieE (2020) A Peculiar Indifference: The Neglected Toll of Violence on Black America. New York: Metropolitan Books.
26.
DemleitnerNV (2018) Collateral Sanctions and American Exceptionalism: A Comparative Perspective. In: ReitzKR (eds) American Exceptionalism in Crime and Punishment. New York: Oxford University Press, pp. 487–525.
27.
DesmondM (2023) Poverty, By America. New York: Crown.
28.
DownesDHansenK (2006) Welfare and Punishment in Comparative Perspective. In: ArmstrongSMcAraL (eds) Perspectives on Punishment. Oxford: Oxford University Press, pp. 133–154.
29.
DurkheimE (1973) Two laws of penal evolution. Economy and Society2(3): 285–308.
30.
EllenIG (2001) Sharing America’s Neighborhoods: The Prospects for Stable Racial Integration. Cambridge: Harvard University Press.
31.
EllisMJ (2012) The origins of the elected prosecutor. Yale Law Journal121(6): 1528–1569.
32.
EnnsPK (2016) Incarceration Nation: How the United States Became the Most Punitive Democracy in the World. New York: Cambridge University Press.
33.
EnosRD (2017) The Space Between Us: Social Geography and Politics. New York: Cambridge University Press.
FajnzylberPLedermanDLoayzaN (2002) Inequality and violent crime. Journal of Law & Economics45(1): 1–39.
36.
FitzpatrickD (2021, April 25) Split second decisions. New York Times.
37.
FongE (1996) A comparative perspective on racial residential segregation: American and Canadian experiences. Sociological Quarterly37(2): 199–226.
38.
FormanJ (2017) Locking Up Our Own. New York: Farrar, Straus, and Giroux.
39.
GarlandD (2001) The Culture of Control: Crime and Social Order in Contemporary Society. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.
40.
GarlandD (2010) Peculiar Institution: America’s Death Penalty in an Age of Abolition. Cambridge: Harvard University Press.
41.
GarlandD (2016) The Welfare State: A Very Short Introduction. New York: Oxford University Press.
42.
GarlandD (2021) Punishment and political economy in the work of Nicola Lacey. In: SolankeI (eds) On Crime, Society, and Responsibility in the Work of Nicola Lacey. Oxford: OUP, pp. 217–246.
43.
GarlandD (2023) The punishment-welfare relationship: History, sociology, and politics. In: LieblingAMarunaSMcAraL (eds) The Oxford Handbook of Criminology. 6th ed. Oxford: Oxford University Press, pp. 771–793.
44.
GarlandD (2025) Law & Order Leviathan: America's Extraordinary Regime of Policing and Punishment. Princeton, N.J.: Princeton University Press.
45.
GerstleGFraserS (eds) (1989) The Rise and Fall of the New Deal Order, 1930–1980. Princeton: Princeton University Press.
46.
GilensM (1999) Why Americans Hate Welfare: Race, Media, and the Politics of Antipoverty Policy. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.
47.
GillingD (2001) Community safety and social policy. European Journal on Criminal Policy and Reseaarch9: 381–400.
48.
GottschalkM (2006) The Prison and the Gallows: The Politics of Mass Incarceration in America. New York: Cambridge University Press.
49.
GottschalkM (2014) Caught: The Prison State and the Lockdown of American Politics. Princeton: Princeton University Press.
50.
GrinshteynEHemenwayD (2019) Violent death rates in the US compared to those of the other high-income countries, 2015. Preventative Medicine123: 20–26.
51.
HaagP (2016) The Gunning of America: Business and the Making of American Gun Culture. New York: Basic Books.
52.
HackerJSHertel-FernandezAPiersonP, et al. (2022) The American Political Economy: Politics, Markets, and Power. New York: Cambridge University Press.
53.
HarcourtB (2011) The Illusion of Free Markets. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.
54.
HirschfieldPJ (2023) Exceptionally lethal: American police killings in a comparative perspective. Annual Review of Criminology6: 471–498.
55.
HolmesS (2025) Flesh of our Flesh. Unpublished manuscript.
56.
HövermannAMessnerSF (2019) Institutional anomie theory across Nation States. In: PontellH (eds) Oxford research Encyclopedia of Criminology and Criminal Justice. New York and Oxford: Oxford University Press.
57.
HowardM (2017) Unusually Cruel: Prisons, Punishment, and the Real American Exceptionalism. New York: Oxford University Press.
58.
HummelsheimDHirtenlehnerHJacksonJ, et al. (2011) Insecurities and fear of crime: a cross-national study on the impact of welfare state policies on crime-related anxieties. European Sociological Review27(3): 327–345. \.
59.
JansonC-G (2004) Youth justice in Sweden. Crime and Justice31: 391–441.
60.
JayadevABowlesS (2006) Guard labor. Journal of Developmental Economics79(2): 328–348.
61.
JohnstonRWrightMSorokaS, et al. (2017) Diversity and solidarity: New evidence from Canada and the US. In: BantingKKymlickaW (eds) The Strains of Commitment. Oxford: Oxford University Press, pp. 152–176.
62.
Junger-TasJ (2004) Youth justice in the Netherlands. Crime and Justice31: 293–347.
KarabelJ (f.c.) Outlier Nation: The Epochal History of How America Became a Country Like No Other (manuscript with author).
67.
KellerB (2022) What’s Prison For? Punishment and Rehabilitation in the Age of Mass Incarceration. New York: Columbia Global Reports.
68.
KenworthyL (2014) Social Democratic America. New York: Oxford University Press.
69.
KleimanMAR (2009) When Brute Force Fails: How to Have Less Crime and Less Punishment. Princeton: Princeton University Press.
70.
KlinenbergE (2002) Heatwave: A Social Autopsy of Disaster in Chicago. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.
71.
Kohler-HausmannI (2018) Misdemeanorland: Criminal Courts and Social Control in an Age of Broken Windows Policing. Princeton and Oxford: Princeton University Press.
KrüsselmannKAartenPLiemM (2021) Firearms and violence in Europe–A systematic review. PLoS ONE16(4): e0248955..
74.
KyvsgaardB (2004) Youth justice in Denmark. Crime and Justice31: 349–390.
75.
LaceyN (2008) The Prisoner’s Dilemma: The Political Economy of Punishment in Comparative Perspective. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
76.
LaceyNSoskiceD (2015) Crime, punishment and segregation in the United States: the paradox of local democracy. Punishment & Society17(4): 454–481.
77.
LaceyNSoskiceDCheliotisLSapphoX (eds) (2021) Tracing the Relationship between Inequality, Crime and Punishment: Space, Time and Politics. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
78.
LaceyNSoskiceDHopeD (2018) Understanding the determinants of penal policy: crime, culture, and comparative political economy. Annual Review of Criminology1: 195–217.
79.
Lappi-SeppalaT (2011) Explaining imprisonment in Europe. European Journal of Criminology8(4): 303–328.
80.
Lappi-SeppalaT (2018) American exceptionalism in comparative perspective: Explaining trends and variation in the use of incarceration. In: ReitzKR (eds) American Exceptionalism in Crime and Punishment. New York: Oxford University Press, pp. 195–271.
81.
LewisCUsmaniA (2022) The injustice of under-policing in America. American Journal of Law and Equality2: 85–106.
LittmanA (2021) Jails, sheriffs, and carceral policymaking. Vanderbilt Law Review74(4): 861–950.
84.
MannM (1993) The Sources of Social Power, vol 2. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
85.
MarkovitsD (2020) The Meritocracy Trap: How America’s Foundational Myth Feeds Inequality, Dismantles the Middle Class, and Devours the Elite. New York: Penguin Books.
86.
MarmorTMahawJHarveyP (1990) America’s Misunderstood Welfare State. New York: Basic Books.
87.
MarquandD (2004) Decline of the Public: The Hollowing-Out of Citizenship. Malden: Polity Press.
88.
MasseyDSDentonNA (1993) American Apartheid: Segregation and the Making of the Underclass. Cambridge: Harvard University Press.
89.
MessnerSFRaffalovichLESuttonGM (2010) Poverty, infant mortality, and homicide rates in cross-national perspective: assessments of criterion and construct validity. Criminology; An Interdisciplinary Journal48(2): 509–537.
90.
MillerLL (2008) The Perils of Federalism: Race, Poverty, and the Politics of Crime Control. New York: Oxford University Press.
91.
MillerLL (2015) What’s violence got to do with it? Inequality, punishment, and state failure in US politics. Punishment & Society17(2): 184–210.
92.
MinkG (1998) Welfare’s End. Ithaca, NY: Cornell University Press.
93.
MorgensternCHammerschickWRoganM (eds) (2024) European Perspectives on Pre-Trial Detention: A Means of Last Resort?New York: Routledge.
94.
MoroneJA (2003) Hellfire Nation: The Politics of Sin in American History. New Haven: Yale University Press.
95.
MoroneJA (2020) Republic of Wrath: How American Politics Turned Tribal, From George Washington to Donald Trump. New York: Basic Books.
96.
MuhammadKG (2019) The Condemnation of Blackness: Race, Crime, and the Making of Modern Urban America. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.
97.
MullerC (2021) Exclusion and exploitation: the incarceration of black Americans from slavery to the present. Science374(6565): 282–286.
98.
National Association of Assistant United States Attorneys, (2015) The dangerous myths of drug sentencing “reform”. Federal Sentencing Reporter28(1): 18–23.
99.
National Research Council, TravisJWesternBRedburnS (eds) (2014) The Growth of Incarceration in the United States: Exploring Causes and Consequences. Washington, D.C.: National Academies Press.
100.
O’FlahertyBSethiR (2019) Shadows of Doubt: Stereotypes, Crime, and the Pursuit of Justice. Cambridge: Harvard University Press.
101.
PageJ (2011) The Toughest Beat: Politics, Punishment, and the Prison Officers Union in California. New York: Oxford University Press.
PaskovMDewildeC (2012) Income inequality and solidarity in Europe. Research in Social Stratification and Mobility30(4): 415–432.
104.
PhelpsM (2020) Mass probation from macro to micro: tracing the expansion and consequences of community supervision. Annual Review of Criminology3: 261–279.
PutnamRD (2015) Our Kids: The American Dream in Crisis. New York: Simon & Schuster Paperbacks.
107.
RamsayD (2023) When Crack was King: A People’s History of a Misunderstood Era. New York: One World.
108.
ReardonSFOwensA (2014) 60 Years after brown: trends and consequences of school segregation. Annual Review of Sociology40: 199–218.
109.
ReitzK (ed) (2018) American Exceptionalism in Crime and Punishment. New York: Oxford University Press.
110.
RosenfeldRMessnerSF (2013) Crime and the Economy. Los Angeles: Sage.
111.
RothR (2009) American Homicide. Cambridge: Harvard University Press.
112.
RuckerJMRichesonJA (2021) Toward an understanding of structural racism: implications for criminal justice. Science374(6565): 286–290.
113.
SampsonRWilliamWJKatzH (2018) Reassessing “toward a theory of race, crime, and urban inequality”. Du Bois Review15(1): 14–34.
114.
SampsonRJ (2019) Neighborhood effects and beyond: explaining the paradoxes of inequality in the changing American metropolis. Urban Studies56(1): 3–32.
115.
SampsonRJRaudenbushSW (2001) Disorder in Urban Neighborhoods––Does It Lead to Crime?National Institute of Justice, Research in Brief1–6.
116.
SampsonRJRaudenbushSWEarlsF (1997) Neighborhoods and violent crime: a multilevel study of collective efficacy. Science277(5328): 918–924.
117.
SampsonRJWilsonWJ (1995) Toward a Theory of Race, Crime, and Urban Inequality. In: HaganJPetersonR (eds) Crime and Inequality. Stanford: Stanford University Press pp. 37–54.
118.
SavelsbergJJ (1994) Knowledge, domination, and criminal punishment. American Journal of Sociology99(4): 911–943.
119.
SavolainenJ (2000) Inequality, welfare state, and homicide: further support for the institutional anomie theory. Criminology; An Interdisciplinary Journal38(4): 1021–1042.
SharkeyP (2018) Uneasy Peace: The Great Crime Decline, The Renewal of City Life, and the Next War on Violence. New York: W. W. Norton & Company.
126.
Sierra-ArévaloM (2021) American policing and the danger imperative. Law & Society Review55(1): 70–103.
127.
Sierra-ArévaloM (2024) The Danger Imperative: Violence, Death, and the Soul of Policing. New York: Columbia University Press.
128.
SimonJ (1993) Poor Discipline: Parole and the Social Control of the Underclass, 1890–1990. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.
129.
SimonJ (2007) Governing Through Crime: How the War on Crime Transformed American Democracy and Created a Culture of Fear. New York: Oxford University Press.
130.
SimonS (2024) Before the Badge: How Academy Training Shapes Police Violence. New York: NYU Press.
131.
SklanskyDA (2021) A Pattern of Violence: How the Law Classifies Crime and What It Means for Justice. Cambridge: Harvard University Press.
132.
SkoganWG (1990) Disorder and Decline: Crime and the Spiral of Decay in American Neighborhoods. Berkely and Los Angeles: University of California Press.
133.
SkoganWG (2023) Stop & Frisk and the Politics of Crime in Chicago. New York: Oxford University Press.
134.
SmeedingTMRainwaterLBurtlesG (2001) U.S. Poverty in a Cross-National Context. In: DanzigerSHHavemanRH (eds) Understanding Poverty. Cambridge: Harvard University Press, pp. 162–192.
135.
SoiferHvom HauM (2008) Unpacking the strength of the state: the utility of state infrastructural power. Studies in Comparative International Development43: 219–230.
136.
StansburyASummersL (2020) The Declining Worker Power Hypothesis: An explanation for the recent evolution of the American economy. NBER Working Papers 27193, National Bureau of Economic Research Inc.
WeigendT (2016) No news is good news: criminal sentencing in Germany since 2000. In: TonryM (eds) Crime and justice vol 45. Chicago, IL: University of Chicago Press, pp. 83–106.
153.
WesternB (2009) Punishment and Inequality in America. New York: Russell Sage Foundation.
154.
WesternB (2018) Homeward: Life in the Year After Prison. New York: Russell Sage Foundation.
