Forward-leaning policing and stability maintenance: The politics of penal control in Xi's China

Abstract

This article seeks to address the intensification of incarceration in Xi's China. By situating the analysis of incarceration within the theory of penal politics, I ascribe the Chinese system of penal control to a purposeful and politically charged change in policing practices. Through what I call ‘forward-leaning policing’ (前倾式警务), China under the current leadership has co-opted the exercise of carceral power through more aggressive and proactive policing as an intensified response to an eclectic mix of developing social issues which threaten public order and political stability, emergent from China's transition to modernity. All the while, the country's community and social policy interventions have been inadequate in addressing the evolving ‘risks’ in Chinese society. Those two converging forces, together, pave the way for individuals to have increased contact with the justice system, as well as exposing them to a higher probability of falling within the remit of formal punishment, including imprisonment.

Keywords

penal control social stability incarceration policing China

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Bakken

(2014) Punishment in China. In: Cao

Sun

Hebenton

(eds) The Routledge Handbook of Chinese Criminology. London: Routledge, 338–48.

Bakken

(2023) Crime and Control in China: The Myth of Harmony. Cambridge: Polity.

Barker

(2006) The politics of punishing: Building a state governance theory of American imprisonment variation. Punishment & Society 8(1): 5–32.

Biddulph

(2007) Legal Reform and Administrative Detention Powers in China. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.

Biddulph

(2015) The Stability Imperative Human Rights and Law in China. Vancouver: UBC Press.

Biddulph

Nesossi

Sapio

, et al. (2017b) Detention and its reforms in the PRC. China Law and Society Review 2(1): 1–62.

Biddulph

Nesossi

Trevaskes

(2017a) Criminal Justice Reform in the Xi Jinping Era. China Law and Society Review 2(1): 63–128.

Carrington

Hogg

Sozzo

(2016) Southern criminology. British Journal of Criminology 56(1): 1–20.

Chen

(2018) Governance, Social Control and Legal Reform in China: Community Sanctions and Measures. Palgrave macmillan.

10.

Chen

(2019) Taking strategic initiative to prevent and defuse major risks http://cpc.people.com.cn/n1/2019/0619/c64102-31168768.html.

11.

Chen

(2002) Community and policing strategies: A Chinese approach to crime control. Policing and Society 12(1): 1–13.

12.

China Statistics Yearbook (2014, 2022) Beijing (in Chinese).

13.

Chinese Human Rights Defenders (2018) Criminal Arrest in Xinjiang Account for 21% of China’s Total in 2017. 21 July 2018. Available at https://www.nchrd.org/2018/07/criminal-arrests-in-xinjiang-account-for-21-of-chinas-total-in-2017/.

14.

Chong

(2019) ‘Cashless China: Securitization of everyday life through Alipay’s social credit system – Sesame Credit’. Chinese Journal of Communication 12(3): 290–307.

15.

Dai

Feng

(2021) The empirical analysis of regulating petty crimes and the choice of justice path. Journal of Southwest University of Political Science & Law 23(5): 40–51. (in Chinese).

16.

Dai

(2008) ‘Policing in the People’s Republic of China: a review of recent literature’. Crime, Law and Social Change 50: 211–227.

17.

Dikötter

(2002) Crime, Punishment and the Prison in Modern China. New York: Columbia University Press.

18.

Ding

Zhong

(2021) ‘Rethinking China’s social credit system: A long road to establishing trust in Chinese society’. Journal of Contemporary China 30(130): 630–644.

19.

Dubber

(2005) The Police Power: Patriarchy and the Foundations of American Government. New York: Columbia University Press.

20.

Duckett

(2020) Neoliberalism, Authoritarian politics and social policy in China. Development and Change 51(2): 523–539.

21.

Durkheim

(1973) Two laws of penal evolution. Economy and Society 2(3): 285–308.

22.

Durkheim

(1997) The Division of Labour in Society. New York: Simon and Schuster.

23.

Dutton

(1992) Policing and Punishment in China: From Patriarchy to the People. New York: Cambridge University Press.

24.

Feeley

(1980) The Process Is the Punishment: Handling Cases in a Lower Criminal Court. New York, NY: Russell Sage Foundation.

25.

Feeley

Simon

(1992) The new penology: Notes on the emerging strategy of corrections and its implications. Criminology 30(4): 449–474.

26.

Feng

(2013) Preserving stability and rights protection: Conflict or coherence? Journal of Current Chinese Affairs 42(2): 21–50.

27.

Foucault

(1977) Discipline and Punish: The Birth of the Prison. New York: Pantheon Books.

28.

(2018) The July 9th (709) crackdown on human rights lawyers: Legal advocacy in an authoritarian State. Journal of Contemporary China 27(112): 554–568.

29.

Garland

(2001) The Culture of Control: Crime and Social Order in Contemporary Society. New York: Oxford University Press.

30.

Garland

(2013) Penality and the penal state. Criminology 51(3): 475–517.

31.

Garland

(2016) The Welfare State: A Very Short Introduction. New York: Oxford University Press.

32.

Garland

(2020) Penal controls and social controls: Toward a theory of American penal exceptionalism. Punishment & Society 22(3): 321–352.

33.

Göbel

(2020) Social resistance and social stability maintenance in the Xi Jinping Era. In: Zhao

(eds) Chinese Society in the Xi Jinping Era. Singapore: World Scientific Publishing.

34.

Greitens

Lee

Yazici

(2020) Counterterrorism and preventive repression. International Security 44(3): 9–47.

35.

Guo

Zhang

(2015) ‘Religion and social stability: China’s religious policies in the age of reform’. Third World Quarterly 36(11): 2183–2195.

36.

Haggerty K

(2006) Tear down the walls: On demolishing the panopticon. In: Lyon

(eds) Theorizing Surveillance: The Panopticon and beyond. Portland, OR: Willan Publishing, 23–45.

37.

Zhang

Qian

(2022) COVID-19 and social inequality in China: the local–migrant divide and the limits of social protections in a pandemic. Policy and Society 41(2): 275–290.

38.

Hebenton

Cao

(2019) Capital punishment in China: Public opinion, politics and governance. American Review of China Studies 20(2): 1–18.

39.

Huang

(2012) ‘Re-legalization or de-legalization? Netizens’ participation in criminal justice practices in China’. British Journal of Criminology 52(4): 724–743.

40.

Husak

(2008) Overcriminalization: The Limits of the Criminal Law. Oxford: Oxford University Press.

41.

Iturralde

(2021) The political economy of punishment and the penal state in Latin America. In: Lacey

Soskice

Cheliotis

Xenakis

(eds) Tracing the Relationship between Inequality, Crime and Punishment: Space, Time and Politics. Oxford: Oxford University Press, 163–198.

42.

Jiang

Kuang

(2018) Hukou status and sentencing in the wake of internal migration: The penalty effect of being rural-to-urban migrants in China. Law & Policy 40(2): 196–215.

43.

Jiang

Liu

(2022) Penal welfare or penal sovereignty? A political sociology of recent formalization of Chinese community corrections. Punishment & Society 24(4): 501–528.

44.

Kung

(2006) ‘National identity and ethno-religious identity: A critical inquiry into Chinese religious policy, with reference to the Uighurs in Xinjiang. Religion, State and Society 34(4): 375–391.

45.

Lewis

(2011) ‘Leniency and severity in China’s death penalty debate’. Columbia Journal of Asian Law 24(2): 303–332.

46.

(2018) Punishment in Contemporary China: Its Evolution, Development and China. New York: Routledge.

47.

(2021) In the name of prevention? Policing ‘social dangerousness’ through arrest in China. Social & Legal Studies 34(4): 581–604.

48.

(2022) Unravelling the mystery of parole in China. British Journal of Criminology 62(4): 896–913.

49.

(2023) Risk, political security and extra-judicial penality under Xi. Theoretical Criminology 27(4): 638–659.

50.

(2014) High rates of prosecution and conviction in China: The use of passive coping strategies. International Journal of Law, Crime and Justice 42(3): 271–285.

51.

Liang

(2005) Severe strike campaign in transitional China. Journal of Criminal Justice 33(4): 387–399.

52.

Liang

(2020) COVID-19 and health code: How digital platforms tackle the pandemic in China. Social Media + Society 6(3): 1–4.

53.

Lin

Shen

Sun

, et al. (2022) Policing pandemic in China: investigating the roles of organizational adjustment, procedural justice, and police trustworthiness on public compliance. Police Practice and Research. DOI: 10.1080/15614263.2022.2127717.

54.

Lin

Shen

(2016) ‘Reforms to China’s pretrial detention system: the role of the procuratorate’. International Journal of Law, Crime and Justice 44: 183–211.

55.

(2022) The strategy of crime control in the era of petty crimes. Political Science and Law 1: 51–66. (in Chinese).

56.

Lubman S (2014) Arrested, Detained: A Guide to Navigating China’s Police Powers. 12 August 2014. Available at https://www.wsj.com/articles/BL-CJB-23571.

57.

McBride

(2007) Punishment and Political Order. Ann Arbor: University of Michigan Press.

58.

Mou

(2020) The Construction of Guilt in China: An Empirical Account of Routine Chinese Injustice. Oxford: Hart Publishing.

59.

Newburn

(1997) Youth, crime and justice: rediscovering devolution, discretion, and diversion. In: Maguire

Morgan

Reiner

(eds) Oxford Handbook of Criminology. Oxford: Oxford University Press, 806–837.

60.

Pils

(2014) China’s Human Rights Lawyers: Advocacy and Resistance. London: Routledge.

61.

Potter

Wang

(2021) Governmental responses to terrorism in autocracies: Evidence from China. British Journal of Political Science 52(1): 358–380.

62.

Pratt

(2007) Penal Populism. London: Taylor & Francis.

63.

Ramsay

(2012) The Insecurity State: Vulnerable Autonomy and the Right to Security in the Criminal Law. Oxford University Press.

64.

Roberts

Stalans

Indermaur

, et al. (2002) Penal Populism and Public Opinion: Lessons from Five Countries. Oxford: Oxford University Press.

65.

Roberts

(2020) The War on the Uyghurs: China's Internal Campaign Against a Muslim Minority. Princeton: Princeton University.

66.

Rosenzweig

(2016) State, society and justice debate. In: Sapio

Trevaskes

Biddulph

Nesossi

(eds) Justice: The China Experience. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.****

67.

Scoggins

(2021) Policing China: Street-Level Cops in the Shadow of Protest. New York: Cornell University.

68.

Seeds

(2017) Bifurcation nation: American penal policy in late mass incarceration. Punishment & Society 19(5): 590–610.

69.

Sheptycki

(2020) The politics of policing a pandemic panic. Australian & New Zealand Journal of Criminology 53(2): 157–173.

70.

Statista Research Department (2022) Number of Crimes Registered in China in 2016 and 2021, by Type. 21 December 2022. Available at https://www.statista.com/statistics/224776/number-of-crimes-in-china-by-type/.

71.

Statista Research Department (2023) Countries with the Largest Number of Prisoners as of December 2022. 23 August 2023. Available at https://www.statista.com/statistics/262961/countries-with-the-most-prisoners/.

72.

Tam

Hasmash

(2015) Navigating uncertainty: The survival strategies of religious NGOs in China. Journal of Civil Society 11(3): 283–299.

73.

The Supreme People’s Procuratorate, The Annual Work Report (2001, 2023) Beijing (in Chinese).

74.

Trevaskes

(2010) The shifting sands of punishment in China in the era of “Harmonious Society”. Law & Policy 32(3): 332–361.

75.

Trevaskes

(2016) Creative Death Penalty Reform in China: The Case of Drug Transportation. Law & Policy 38(2): 143–161.

76.

Wacquant

(2009) Punishing the Poor: The Neoliberal Government of Social Insecurity. Durham: Duke University Press.

77.

Walmsley

(2021) World Prison Population List, 13th edition London: Home Office.

78.

Wang

(2020) Politics of crime control: How campaign-style law enforcement sustains authoritarian rule in China. British Journal of Criminology 60(2): 422–443.

79.

Wang

Minzner

(2015) The rise of the Chinese security state. The China Quarterly 222: 339–359.

80.

Wong

(1998) ‘A Reflection on Police Abuse of Power in the People’s Republic of China’. Police Quarterly 1(2): 87–112.

81.

(2022) For Xi Jinping, the economy is no longer the priority. Journal of Democracy https://www.journalofdemocracy.org/for-xi-jinping-the-economy-is-no-longer-the-priority/.

82.

(2020) ‘On the effect of the Chinese version of speedy trial and plea bargaining pilot programs: observation from DUI cases in Fujian Province. Crime, Law and Social Change 74: 457–484.

83.

(2022) Hold High the Great Banner of Socialism with Chinese Characteristics and Strive in Unity to Build a Modern Socialist Country in All Respects. Report to the 20th National Congress of the Communist Party of China. 16 October 2022.

84.

Xinhua (2021) The Supreme People’s Procuratorate: Adequately and Correctly Applying the Criminal Justice Policy Of ‘Arrest Less and Prosecute Cautiously’. 3 December 2021. Available at http://www.news.cn/politics/2021-12/03/c_1128129205.htm.

85.

Xiong

(2016) Reviewing pretrial detention on the basis of evidence gathering – empirical research on City A. Journal of Eastern China University of Political Science and Law 2: 141–155. (in Chinese).

86.

(2014) Urbanization and inevitable migration: Crime and migrant workers. In: Cao

Sun

Hebenton

(eds) Routledge Handbook of Chinese Criminology. London: Routledge, 209–223.

87.

(2018) Legitimization imperative: the production of crime statistics in Guangzhou, China. Journal of British Criminology 58: 155–176.

88.

Wang

(2017) The Debate on the expansion and control of police powers in China. Sichuan Police College Journal 4: 17–22. (in Chinese).

89.

Yuan

(2022) Zero COVID in China: what next? Lancet 399(10338): 1856–1857.

90.

Zalman

(2017) False convictions: A systemic concern in China and the World. China Review 17(1): 153–177.

91.

Zhang

(2015) Income inequality and access to housing: Evidence from China. China Economic Review 36: 261–271.

92.

Zhang

(2017) Discussing the integration of prison punishment and community corrections. Journal of Beijing Police College 3: 83–9. (in Chinese).

93.

Zhang

(2021) Police discretion and restorative justice in China: stories from the street-level police. International Journal of Offender Therapy and Comparative Criminology 65(4): 498–520.

94.

Zhong

(2009) Community policing in China: old wine in new bottles. Police Practice and Research 10(2): 157–169.