The purpose of pretrial incarceration is not punishment. Yet, research demonstrates that pretrial detention elicits similar consequences as punishment. The goal of this study is to advance theory and policy discussions by enumerating the experiences and harms that emerge during pretrial detention and how closely they align with punishment. The analyses use the National Inmate Survey, 2011–2012 to compare the experiences of those held in pretrial detention to those incarcerated in jail or prison after a conviction. Individuals in pretrial detention report more disorderly environments than people in prisons, but also report more access to external social support and better views of staff legitimacy. The self-reported experiences of people in pretrial detention and those in jail as punishment are generally indistinguishable. The results provide considerable support for the argument that pretrial detention is inextricably punitive and, especially at its current scale, likely undermines system objectives of justice and public safety.
AndersonCNCochranJCMontesAN (2021) The pains of pretrial detention: Theory and research on the oft-overlooked experiences of pretrial jail stays. In: Scott-HaywardCSCoppJEDemuthS (eds) Handbook on pretrial justice. New York: Routledge, 13–35.
2.
ApelRSweetenG (2010) The impact of incarceration on employment during the transition to adulthood. Social Problems57: 448–479.
3.
BalesWDPiqueroAR (2012) Racial/ethnic differentials in sentencing to incarceration. Justice Quarterly29: 742–773.
4.
BlackwellMIacusSKingG, et al. (2009) Cem: Coarsened exact matching in Stata. The Stata Journal: Communications on Statistics and Stata9: 524–546.
5.
Brunton-SmithIMcCarthyDJ (2016) Prison legitimacy and procedural fairness: A multilevel examination of prisoners in England and Wales. Justice Quarterly33: 1029–1054.
6.
ChengKK (2012) Pressures to plead guilty: Factors affecting plea decisions in Hong Kong’s magistrates’ courts. British Journal of Criminology53: 257–275.
7.
CochranJCMearsDPBalesWD (2017) Who gets visited in prison? Individual- and community-level disparities in inmate visitation experiences. Crime Ilinquency63: 545–568.
8.
ComfortM (2008) Doing Time Together: Love and Family in the Shadow of the Prison. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.
9.
ComfortM (2016) "A twenty-hour-a-day-job”: the impact of frequent, low-level criminal justice involvement on family life. The ANNALS of the American Academy of Political and Social Science665: 63–79.
10.
CseteJ (2010) Consequences of injustice: Pretrial detention and health. International Journal of Prisoner Health6: 3–14.
11.
DemuthS (2003) Racial and ethnic differences in pretrial release decisions and outcomes: A comparison of Hispanic, Black, and White felony arrestees. Criminology; An Interdisciplinary Journal41: 873–908.
12.
DemuthSSteffensmeierD (2004) The impact of gender and race/ethnicity in the pretrial release process. Social Problems51: 222–242.
13.
DigardLSwavolaE (2019) Justice Denied: The Harmful Lasting Effects of Pretrial Detention. New York, NY: Vera Institute of Justice.
14.
DiIulioJ (1987) Governing Prisons: A Comparative Study of Correctional Management. New York: Free Press.
15.
DobbieWGoldinJYangCS (2018) The effects of pretrial detention on conviction, future crime, and employment: Evidence from randomly assigned judges. American Economic Review108: 201–240.
16.
DragoFGalbiatiRVertovaP (2011) Prison conditions and recidivism. American Law and Economics Review13: 103–130.
17.
EuvrardELeclercC (2017) Pre-trial detention and guilty pleas: Inducement or coercion?Punishment & Society19: 525–542.
18.
FeeleyMM (1979) The Process is the Punishment. New York: Russell Sage Foundation.
19.
FishmanJF (1923) Crucibles of Crime: The Shocking Story of the American Jail. Monclair: Patterson Smith.
20.
FreemanSSeymourM (2010) Just waiting”: The nature and effect of uncertainty on young people in remand custody in Ireland. Youth Justice10: 126–142.
21.
GouletteNWooldredgeJ (2019) Collateral effects of pretrial detention. In: HuebnerBMFrostNA (eds) Handbook on the Consequence of Sentencing and Punishment Decisions. New York: Routledge, 271–289.
22.
HaynieDLWhichardCKreagerDA, et al. (2018) Social networks and health in a prison unit. Journal of Health and Social Behavior59: 318–334.
23.
HeatonPMaysonSStevensonM (2017) The downstream consequences of misdemeanor pretrial detention. Stanford Law Review69: 711–794.
24.
HochstetlerAMurphyDSSimonsRL (2004) Damaged goods: exploring predictors of distress in prison inmates. Crime & Delinquency50: 436–457.
25.
IrwinJ (1985) The Jail: Managing the Underclass in American Society. Berkeley, CA: University of California Press.
26.
IrwinJ (2004) The New Penology: Disposal of the New Dangerous Class. Los Angelas, CA, USA: Oxford University Press.
27.
KelloughGWortleyS (2002) Remand for plea: Bail decisions and plea bargaining as commensurate decisions. The British Journal of Criminology42: 186–210.
28.
KirkDSWakefieldS (2018) Collateral consequences of punishment: A critical review and path forward. Annual Review of Criminology1: 171–194.
29.
Kohler-HausmannI (2018) Misdemeanorland. Princeton, NJ, USA: Princeton University Press.
30.
KreagerDASchaeferDRBouchardM, et al. (2016) Toward a criminology of inmate networks. Justice Quarterly33(6): 1000–1028.
31.
LermanAEGreenALDominguezP (2021) Pleading for justice: Bullpen therapy, pre-trial detention, and plea bargains in American Courts. Crime & Delinquency68(2): 159–182.
32.
LieblingA (1999) Prison suicide and prisoner coping. Crime and Justice26: 283–249.
33.
LieblingAArnoldH (2012) Social relationships between prisoners in a maximum security prison: Violence, faith, and the declining nature of trust. Journal of Criminal Justice40: 413–424.
34.
ListwanSJColvinMHanleyD, et al. (2010) Victimization, social support, and psychological well-being: A study of recently released prisoners. Criminal Justice and Behavior37: 1140–1159.
35.
ListwanSJSullivanCJAgnewR, et al. (2013) The pains of imprisonment revisited: The impact of strain on inmate recidivism. Justice Quarterly30: 144–168.
36.
LoefflerCENaginDS (2022) The impact of incarceration on recidivism. Annual Review of Criminology5: 15.1–15.20.
37.
LoughranDSHeatonP (2013) Post-traumatic stress disorder and the earnings of military reservists. Rand Health Quarterly3: 3.
38.
LyonsCJPettitB (2011) Compounded disadvantage: Race, incarceration, and wage growth. Social Problems58: 257–280.
39.
MartinezBPPetersenNOmariM (2020) Time, money, punishment: Institutional racial-ethnic inequalities in pretrial detention and case outcomes. Crime & Delinquency66: 837–863.
40.
MassogliaMRemsterB (2019) Linkages between incarceration and health. Public Health Reports134: 8S–14S.
41.
MattickH (1974) The contemporary jails of the United States: An unknown and neglected area of justice. In: GlaserD (ed) Handbook of Criminology. Chicago: Rand McNally, 777–848.
42.
MayDCApplegateBKRuddellR, et al. (2014) Going to jail sucks (and it doesn’t really matter who you ask). American Journal of Criminal Justice39: 250–266.
43.
MearsDPBrownJMCochranJC, et al. (2021) Extended solitary confinement for managing prison systems: Placement disparities and their implications. Justice Quarterly38: 1492–1518.
44.
MearsDPCochranJCSiennickSE (2012) Prison visitation and recidivism. Justice Quarterly29: 888–918.
45.
MenefeeMR (2018) The role of bail and pretrial detention in the reproduction of racial inequalities. Sociology Compass12: e12576.
46.
MontesACochranJAndersonC (2022) Private versus public incarceration: Incarcerated individuals’ experiences and perceptions of environmental quality. Crime & Delinquency69(13-14): 2765–2797.
47.
MyersNM (2016) Eroding the presumption of innocence: Pre-trial detention and the use of conditional release on bail. The British Journal of Criminology57: 664–683.
48.
OleskiMS (1997) The effect of indefinite pretrial incarceration on the anxiety level of an urban jail population. Journal of Clinical Psychology33: 1006–1008.
49.
OmariMPetersenN (2020) Institutionalizing inequality in the courts: decomposing racial and ethnic disparities in detention, conviction, and sentencing. Criminology; An Interdisciplinary Journal58: 678–713.
50.
PageJScott-HaywardCS (2022) Bail and pretrial in the United States: A field of possibility. Annual Review of Criminology5: 91–113.
51.
PelvinH (2017) Doing uncertain time: Understanding the experiences of punishment in pretrial custody (Doctoral thesis). University of Toronto, Canada.
52.
PelvinH (2019) Remand as a cross-institutional system: Examining the process of punishment before conviction. Canadian Journal of Criminology and Criminal Justice61: 66–87.
53.
PetersonN (2020) Do detainees plead guilty faster? A survival analysis of pretrial detention and the timing of guilty pleas. Criminal Justice Policy Review31: 1015–1035.
54.
Prison Rape Elimination Act (2003) Public Law No. 108–79, 117 Stat. 972.
55.
RabinowitzM (2021) Incarceration without Conviction: Pretrial Detention and the Erosion of Innocence in American Criminal Justice. New York: Routledge.
56.
RobinsonLN (1945) The perennial jail problem. The Journal of Criminal Law and Criminology35: 369–374.
57.
RuddellRMaysGL (2007) Rural jails: Problematic inmates, overcrowded cells, and cash-strapped counties. Journal of Criminal Justice35: 251–260.
58.
SacksMSainatoVAAckermanAR (2015) Sentenced to pretrial detention: A study of bail decisions and outcomes. American Journal of Criminal Justice40: 661–681.
59.
SchnittkerJJohnA (2007) Enduring stigma: The long-term effects of incarceration on health. Journal of Health and Social Behavior48: 115–130.
60.
Scott-HaywardCSFradellaHF (2019) Punishing Poverty: How Bail and Pretrial Detention Fuel Inequalities in the Criminal Justice System. Oakland, CA: University of California Press.
61.
SmithMWSchnurrPPRosenheckRA (2005) Employment outcomes and PTSD symptom severity. Mental Health Services Research7: 89–101.
62.
SmithSSHuC (2021) Exploring the causal mechanisms linking pretrial detention and future penal system involvement. In: Scott-HaywardCSCoppJEDemuthS (eds) Handbook on Pretrial Justice. New York: Routledge, 88–109.
63.
SolomonALOsborneJWLLoBuglioSF, et al. (2008) Life after Lockup: Improving Reentry from Jail to the Community. Washington, DC: Urban Institute.
64.
StevensonMTMaysonSG (2021) Pretrial detention and the value of liberty. Virginia Public Law and Legal Theory Research Paper No. 2021–14.
65.
St. LouisS (2022) Bail denied or bail too high? Disentangling cumulative disadvantage by pretrial detention type. Journal of Criminal Justice82: Article 101971.
66.
SykesG (1958) The Society of Captives. Princeton: Princeton University Press.
67.
TomanEKCochranJCCochranJK (2018) Jailhouse blues: The adverse effects of pretrial detention on prison social order. Criminal Justice & Behavior45: 316–339.
68.
TurneyKConnerE (2019) Jail incarceration: A common and consequential form of criminal justice contact. Annual Review of Criminology2: 265–290.
69.
TurneyKWildemanC (2018) Maternal incarceration and the transformation of urban family life. Social Forces96: 1115–1182.
70.
UseemBKimballP (1989) States of Siege: US Prison Riots, 1971–1986. New York: Oxford University Press.
71.
VacheretMBrassardV (2015) Le vécu des justiciables. In: VacheretMPratesF (eds) La détention Avant Jugement au Canada: Une Pratique Controversée. Montréal: Presses de l’Université de Montréal, 125–143.
72.
WakefieldSAndersenLH (2020) Pretrial detention and the costs of system overreach for employment and family life. Sociological Science7: 342–366.
73.
WalkerSCHertingJR (2020) The impact of pretrial juvenile detention on 12-month recidivism: A matched comparison study. Crime & Delinquency66: 1865–1887.
74.
WesternB (2002) The impact of incarceration on wage mobility and inequality. American Sociological Review67: 526–546.
75.
ZengZMintonTD (2021) Jail inmates in 2019. Washington, DC: Bureau of Justice Statistics.
Supplementary Material
Please find the following supplemental material available below.
For Open Access articles published under a Creative Commons License, all supplemental material carries the same license as the article it is associated with.
For non-Open Access articles published, all supplemental material carries a non-exclusive license, and permission requests for re-use of supplemental material or any part of supplemental material shall be sent directly to the copyright owner as specified in the copyright notice associated with the article.
