Understanding the use of punishment becomes increasingly important as imprisonment
rates in many nations have fluctuated irrespective of crime rates. Controlling for
violent crime, inequality, modernization, and economic stress, this research
examined three diverse hypotheses about the sources of imprisonment in a sample of
100 nations. Consistent with expectations, nations that retained use of the death
penalty had a greater use of imprisonment. More surprising was the finding of a
clear and consistent relationship between imprisonment and countries with common law
legal systems, as well as newly independent nation-states. Finally, this study
reveals a significant – although inconsistent – association
between population heterogeneity and imprisonment. While punishment research has
often focused upon the relationships between economic variables and imprisonment,
these findings suggest that theories of formal social control will remain incomplete
until the roles of political, cultural, and structural conditions are fully understood.
Albrecht, Hans-Jorg
(1997)
‘Ethnic minorities, crime and criminal justice in Germany’
, Crime and Justice: A Review of Research21:
31–100
.
2.
Amnesty International
(1999) Race drives use of death penalty in the U.S. judicial
system, new Amnesty International report finds. Available at: http://www.amnestyusa.org/news/1999/usa05181999.html.
3.
Amnesty International
(2003) The death penalty. Available at: http://web.amnesty.org/pages/deathpenalty-countries-eng.
4.
Archer, Dane and Rosemary Gartner
(1984) Violence and crime in cross-national
perspective.
New Haven, CT: Yale University Press
.
5.
Arvanites, Thomas M.
and
Martin A. Asher
(1998)
‘State and county incarceration rates: The direct and indirect
effects of race and inequality’
, American Journal of Economics and Sociology57(2):
207–221
.
6.
Barclay
,
Gordon
,
Cynthia Tavares
and
Arsalaan Siddique
(2001) International comparisons of criminal justice
statistics, 1999.
London: Great Britain Home Office Research and
Statistics Directorate
.
7.
Beckett, Katherine
and
Bruce Western
(2001)
‘Governing social marginality: Welfare, incarceration and the
transformation of state policy’
, Punishment & Society3(1):
43–59
.
8.
Bennett, Richard
(2004)
‘Comparative criminology and criminal justice research: The state
of our knowledge’
, Justice Quarterly21(1):
1–22
.
9.
Bennett, Richard R.
and
James P. Lynch
(1990)
‘Does a difference make a difference: Comparing cross-national
crime indicators’
, Criminology28(1):
153–181
.
10.
Black, Donald J.
(1993) The social structure of right and wrong.
San Diego, CA: Academic Press
.
11.
Box, Steven
and
Chris Hale
(1982)
‘Economic crisis and the rising prisoner population in England
and Wales’
, Crime and Social Justice17(1):
20–35
.
12.
Braithwaite, John
(1989) Crime, shame and reintegration.
New York: Cambridge University Press
.
13.
Broadhurst, Roderick
(1997)
‘Aborigines and crime in Australia’
, Crime and Justice: A Review of Research21:
407–468
.
14.
Caplow, Theodore
and
Jonathan Simon
(1999)
‘Understanding prison policy and population trends’
, Crime and Justice: A Review of Research26:
63–120
.
15.
Carroll, Leo
and
Mary Beth Doubet
(1983)
‘US social structure and imprisonment: A comment’
, Criminology21(3):
449–456
.
16.
Central Intelligence Agency
(1999) The world factbook.
Herndon, VA: Batsford Brassey
.
17.
Chiricos, Theodore G.
and
Miriam A. DeLone
(1992)
‘Labour surplus and punishment: A review and assessment of theory
and evidence’
, Social Problems39(4):
421–446
.
18.
Christie, Nils
(1993) Crime control as industry: Towards ghettos western style?London: Routledge
.
19.
De Cruz, Peter
(1999) Comparative law in a changing world.
London: Cavendish Publishing
.
20.
Deflem, Mathieu
and
Amanda J. Swygart
(2001) ‘Comparative criminal
justice’, in
M.A. DuPont-Morales
,
Michael K. Hooper
and
Judy H. Schmidt
(eds) Handbook of criminal justice administration, pp.
51–68.
New York: Marcel Dekker
.
21.
Downes, David
(2001) ‘Mass incarceration in the United States
– A European perspective’, in
D. Garland
(ed.) Mass imprisonment in the United States, pp.
51–69.
Thousand Oaks, CA: SAGE Publications
.
22.
Durkheim, Emile
(1900/1983) ‘The evolution of
punishment’, in
S. Lukes
and
A. Scull
(eds) Durkheim and the law, pp.
102–132.
New York: St Martins Press
.
23.
Evans, Thomas D.
,
Randy L. Lagrange
and
Cecile L. Willis
(1996)
‘Theoretical development of comparative criminology: Rekindling
an interest’
, International Journal of Comparative and Applied Criminal Justice20(1):
15–29
.
24.
Garland, David
(1990) Punishment and modern society: A study in social
theory.
Oxford: Clarendon Press
.
25.
Garland, David
(2001) The culture of control: Crime and social order in
contemporary society.
Chicago, IL: University of Chicago Press
.
26.
Gertz, Marc G.
and
Laura B. Myers
(1992)
‘Impediments to cross-national research: Problems of reliability
and validity’
, International Journal of Comparative and Applied Criminal Justice16(1):
57–65
.
27.
Glenn, P.H.
(2000) Legal traditions of the world.
London: Oxford University Press
.
28.
Greenberg, David F.
(1989)
‘Imprisonment and unemployment: A comment’
, Journal of Quantitative Criminology5(2):
187–191
.
29.
Greenberg, David F.
(1999) ‘Punishment, division of labor, and
social solidarity’, in
William S. Laufer
and
Freda Adler
(eds) The criminology of criminal law, pp.
283–362.
New Brunswick, NJ: Transaction Publishers
.
30.
Greenberg, David F.
and
Valerie West
(2001)
‘State prison populations and their growth 1971–1991’
, Criminology39(3):
615–654
.
31.
Groves, W. Byron
and
Graeme Newman
(1989)
‘Against general theory in comparative research’
, Journal of International Law and Comparative Criminology13(1):
23–29
.
32.
Heiland, Hans-Gunther
and
Louise I. Shelley
(1992) ‘Civilization, modernization and the
development of crime and control’, in
Hans-Gunther Heiland
,
Lousie I. Shelley
and
Hisao Katoh
(eds) Crime and control in comparative perspectives, pp.
1–19.
Berlin: Walter de Gruyter
.
33.
Holmes, Malcolm D.
(2000)
‘Minority threat and police brutality: Determinants of civil
rights criminal complaints in U.S. municipalities’
, Criminology38(2):
343–368
.
34.
Interpol
(2003) International criminal statistics. Available at: http://www.interpol.int/Public/Statistics/ICS/default.asp.
35.
Jackson, Pamela I.
(1989) Minority group threat, crime and policing.
Westport, CT: Greenwood Press
.
36.
Jacobs, David
and
Ronald E. Helms
(1996)
‘Towards a political model of incarceration: A time series
examination of multiple explanations for prison admission rates’
, American Journal of Sociology102(2):
323–357
.
37.
Jacobs, David
and
Katherine Wood
(1999)
‘Interracial conflict and interracial homicide: Do political and
economic rivalries explain white killings of blacks or black killings of whites?’
, American Journal of Sociology105(1):
157–190
.
38.
Jacobs, David
and
Ronald E. Helms
(1999)
‘Collective outbursts, politics, and punitive resources: Toward a
political sociology of spending on social control’
, Social Forces77(2):
1497–1524
.
39.
Jacobs, David
and
Jason T. Carmichael
(2001)
‘The politics of punishment across time and space: A pooled time
series analysis of imprisonment rates’
, Social Forces80(1):
61–89
.
40.
Jacobs, David
and
Richard Kleban
(2003)
‘Political institutions, minorities, and punishment: A pooled
cross-national analysis of imprisonment rates’
, Social Forces80(4):
725–755
.
41.
Jasinski, Jerzy
(1976)
‘The punitiveness of criminal justice systems (a cross-national perspective)’
, The Police Sociological Bulletin1(1):
43–51
.
42.
Johnson, David T.
(2002) The Japanese way of justice: Prosecuting crime in
Japan.
New York: Oxford University Press
.
43.
Junger-Tas, Josine
(1997)
‘Ethnic minorities and justice in the Netherlands’
, Crime and Justice: A Review of Research21:
257–310
.
44.
Kane, Robert J.
(2003)
‘Social control in the metropolis: A community-level examination
of the minority group-threat hypothesis’
, Justice Quarterly20(2):
265–295
.
45.
Kangaspunta, Kristiina
,
Matti Joutsen
and
Natalia Ollus
(1998) Crime and criminal justice in Europe and North America
1990–1994.
Helsinki: HEUNI
.
46.
Kheng, Kok Yeoh
(2001) Towards an index of ethnic fractionalization.
Kuala Lumpur: Faculty of Economics and
Administration, University of Malaya
.
47.
Killias, Martin
(1986) ‘Power concentration, legitimation crisis
and penal severity’, in
W.B. Groves
and
G. Newman
(eds) Punishment and privilege, pp.
95–118.
New York: Harrow and Heston
.
48.
King, Roy D.
and
Mike Maguire
(1994)
‘Contexts of imprisonment: An international perspective’
, British Journal of Criminology34(1):
1–13
.
49.
Krain, Mathew
(1997)
‘State-sponsored mass murder: The onset and severity of genocides
and politicides’
, Journal of Conflict Resolution41(3):
331–360
.
50.
Laffargue, Bernard
and
Thierry Godefroy
(1989)
‘Economic cycles and punishment: Unemployment and imprisonment: A
time series study, France 1920–1985’
, Contemporary Crisis13(2):
371–404
.
51.
LaFree, Gary
(1998) Losing legitimacy: Street crime and the decline of
social institutions in America.
Boulder, CO: Westview Press
.
52.
LaFree, Gary
and
Kriss A. Drass
(2002)
‘Counting crime booms among nations: Evidence for homicide
victimization rates, 1956 to 1998’
, Criminology41(4):
769–801
.
53.
Lessan, Gloria T.
(1991)
‘Macro-economic determinants of penal policy: Estimating the
unemployment and inflation influences on imprisonment rate changes in the
United States, 1948–1985’
, Crime, Law and Social Change16(1):
177–198
.
54.
Liska, Allen E.
(1992) Social threat and social control.
New York: State University of New York Press
.
55.
Lynch, James P.
(1988)
‘A comparison of prison use in England, Canada, West Germany and
the United States: A limited test of the punitive hypothesis’
, The Journal of Criminal Law and Criminology79(1):
180–216
.
56.
Lynch, James P.
(1993)
‘A cross-national comparison of the length of custodial sentences
for serious crimes’
, Justice Quarterly10(4):
639–659
.
57.
Maguire, Edward R.
,
Gregory J. Howard
and
Graeme Newman
(1998)
‘Measuring the performance of national criminal justice systems’
, International Journal of Comparative and Applied Criminal Justice22(1):
31–59
.
58.
Mauer, Marc
(1995)
‘The international use of incarceration’
, The Prison Journal75(1):
113–123
.
59.
Mauer, Marc
(1998) Americans behind bars: U.S. and international use of
incarceration.
Washington, DC: The Sentencing Project
.
60.
Mauer, Marc
(1999) Race to incarcerate.
New York: The New Press
.
61.
Mayhew, Pat
and
Phillip White
(1997) The 1996 international crime victimisation
survey.
London: Great Britain Home Office Research and
Statistics Directorate
.
62.
Melossi, Dario
(1993)
‘Gazette of morality and social whip: Punishment, hegemony and
the case of the USA, 1970–92’
, Social & Legal Studies2(2):
259–279
.
Messner, Steven
and
Richard Rosenfeld
(1997)
‘Political restraint of the market and levels of criminal
homicide: A cross-national application of institutional-anomie theory’
, Social Forces75(4):
1393–1416
.
65.
Michalowski, Raymond J.
and
Susan M. Carlson
(1999)
‘Unemployment, imprisonment and social structures of
accumulation: Historical contingency in the Rusche–Kirchheimer hypothesis’
, Criminology37(2):
217–250
.
66.
Miller, Jerome
(1996) Search and destroy: African-American males in the
criminal justice system.
New York: Cambridge University Press
.
67.
Neapolitan, Jerome L.
(1998)
‘Cross-national variation in homicides: Is race a factor?’
, Criminology36(1):
139–156
.
68.
Neapolitan, Jerome L.
(2001)
‘Examination of cross-national variation in punitiveness’
, International Journal of Offender Therapy and Comparative Criminology45(6):
691–710
.
69.
Nelken, David
(1994) The future of criminology.
Thousand Oaks, CA: Sage Publications
.
70.
Neuman, W. Lawrence
and
Ronald J. Berger
(1988)
‘Competing perspectives on cross-national crime: An evaluation of
theory and evidence’
, Sociological Quarterly29(2):
281–313
.
71.
Newman, Graeme
(1999) Global report on crime and justice.
New York: Oxford University Press
.
72.
Pease, Ken
(1994)
‘Cross-national imprisonment rates: Limitations of method and
possible conclusions’
, British Journal of Criminology34(1):
116–130
.
73.
Piven, Francis Fox
and
Richard Cloward
(1993) Regulating the poor.
New York: Vintage Books
.
74.
Pratt, Travis C.
and
Timothy W. Godsey
(2002)
‘Social support and homicide: A cross-national test of an
emerging criminological theory’Journal of Criminal Justice30(6):
589–601
.
75.
Reichel, Phillip L.
(2002) Comparative criminal justice systems: A topical
approach.
Upper Saddle River, NJ: Prentice Hall
.
76.
Roberts, Julian V.
and
Anthony Doob
(1997)
‘Race, ethnicity and crime in Canada’
, Crime and Justice: A Review of Research21:
469–522
.
77.
Ruddell, Rick
(2004) America behind bars: Trends in imprisonment,
1952–2000.
New York: LFB Scholarly Publishing
.
78.
Ruddell, Rick
and
Martin G. Urbina
(2004)
‘Minority threat and punishment: A cross-national analysis’
, Justice Quarterly21(4).
79.
Ruggiero, Vincenzo
,
Mick Ryan
and
Joe Sim
(1995) Western European penal systems:
A critical anatomy. Thousand Oaks, CA: Sage
.
80.
Rummel, Rudolph J.
(1994) Death by government.
New Brunswick, NJ: Transactions Publishers
.
81.
Rusche, Georg
(1933/1978)
‘Labour market and penal sanction: Thoughts on the sociology of
criminal justice’
, Crime and Social Justice (Fall–Winter):
2–8
.
82.
Rusche, Georg
and
Otto Kirchheimer
(1939/1968) Punishment and social structure.
New York: Russell and Russell
.
83.
Savelsberg, Joachim J.
(1994)
‘Knowledge, domination and criminal punishment’
, American Journal of Sociology99(4):
911–943
.
84.
Shelley, Louise I.
(1981) Crime and modernization:
The impact of industrialization and urbanization on crime.
Carbondale, IL: Southern Illinois University
.
85.
South, Nigel
and
Robert P. Weiss
(1998) ‘Crime, punishment and the
“state of prisons” in a changing world’,
in
Robert P. Weiss
and
Nigel South
(eds) Comparing prison systems: Toward a comparative and international
penology, pp. 1–18.
Amsterdam: Gordon and Breach Publishers
.
86.
Sparks, Richard
(2003) ‘State punishment in advanced capitalist
countries’, in
Thomas Bloomberg
and
Stanley Cohen
(eds) Punishment and Social Control, pp.
19–44.
New York: Aldine de Gruyter
.
87.
Stark, Rodney
(2004) Doing sociology: A global perspective.
Belmont, TN: Wadsworth
.
88.
Steffensmeier, Darrell
and
Stephen Demuth
(2000)
‘Ethnicity and sentencing outcomes in U.S. federal courts: Who is
punished more harshly?’
, American Sociological Review65(5):
705–721
.
89.
Stern, Vivien
(1998) A sin against the future: Imprisonment in the
world.
Boston, MA: Northeastern University Press
.
90.
Stern, Vivien
(1999)
‘Alternatives to prison in developing countries: Some lessons
from Africa’
, Punishment & Society1(2):
231–241
.
91.
Sutton, John R.
(2000)
‘Imprisonment and social classification in five common-law
democracies, 1955–1985’
, American Journal of Sociology106(2):
350–386
.
92.
Sutton, John R.
(2004)
‘The political economy of imprisonment among affluent western
democracies, 1960–1990’
, American Sociological Review69(2):
170–189
.
93.
Sztompka, Piotr
(1990) ‘Conceptual frameworks in comparative
inquiry: Divergent or convergent?’, in
Martin Albrow
and
Elizabeth King
(eds) Globalization, knowledge and society: Readings from international
sociology, pp. 47–58.
Thousand Oaks, CA: Sage Publications
.
94.
Taggart, William A.
and
Russell G. Winn
(1993)
‘Imprisonment in the American states’
, Social Science Quarterly74(4):
736–749
.
95.
Tonry, Michael
(1995) Malign neglect: Race, crime and punishment in
America.
New York: Oxford University Press
.
96.
Tonry, Michael
(1997)
‘Ethnicity, crime, and immigration’
, Crime and Justice: A Review of Research21:
1–30
.
97.
Tournier, Pierre
(1997)
‘Nationality, crime and criminal justice in France’
, Crime and Justice: A Review of Research21:
523–551
.
98.
United Nations
(2002a) The yearbook of the United Nations.
New York: United Nations
.
99.
United Nations
(2002b) Human development report.
New York: United Nations
.
100.
United Nations
(2004) Human development report 2004 – Cultural
liberty in today’s diverse world.
New York: United Nations
.
101.
Urbina, Martin G.
(2003) Capital punishment and Latino offenders: Racial and
ethnic differences in death sentences.
New York: LFB Scholarly Publishing
.
102.
Vagg, Jon
(1993)
‘Context and linkage: Reflections on comparative research and
internationalism in criminology’
, British Journal of Criminology33(4):
541–554
.
103.
Wacquant, Loic
(1999)
‘Suitable enemies: Foreigners and immigrants in the prisons of Europe’
, Punishment & Society1(2):
215–222
.
104.
Walker, Samuel
,
Cassia Spohn
and
Miriam A. DeLone
(2003) The color of justice: Race, ethnicity and crime in
America.
Belmont: Wadsworth
.
105.
Walmsley, Roy
(2002) World prison population list –
Third edition.
London: Great Britain Home Office Research
Development and Statistics Directorate
.
106.
Walmsley, Roy
(2003) World prison population list –
Fourth edition.
London: Great Britain Home Office Research
Development and Statistics Directorate
.
107.
Weiss, Robert P.
and
Nigel South
(1998) Comparing prison systems: Toward a comparative and
international penology.
Amsterdam: Gordon and Breach
.
108.
Wiatr, Jerzy J.
(1971)
‘Problems of theory and methodology in Cross-national comparative research’
, Indian Journal of Politics5(1):
1–18
.
109.
Young, Warren
and
Mark Brown
(1993)
‘Cross-national comparisons of imprisonment’
, Crime and Justice: A Review of Research17:
1–49
.
110.
Zimring, Franklin E.
and
Gordon Hawkins
(2004) ‘Democracy and the limits of punishment:
A preface to prisoners’ rights’, in
Michael Tonry
(ed.) The Future of Imprisonment, pp.
157–178.
New York: Oxford University Press
.
