Skin tone discrimination—or colorism—is an additional marginalization barrier that People of Color must navigate. Black women, especially those with darker complexions, are often discursively constructed as the antithesis to Western beauty standards—standards that commonly prioritize White femininity as the beauty benchmark. Studies on the beauty influencer economy reveal that Black women remain at a disadvantage in the beauty hierarchy. This study uses a survey experiment to explore how skin tone impacts perceptions of attractiveness and competence among viewers of digital beauty content. Surveying African Americans (N = 576), primarily Black Women (n = 524), we found that beauty influencers with darker skin tones are rated as less attractive and less competent. Participants also revealed that they would be less likely to click on the videos of darker skinned beauty influencers in comparison to influencers with lighter brown and medium brown skin tones. These results suggest that, among Black women viewers, preferences for beauty content is skin tone dependent. Because view counts are a significant metric in influencer marketability, viewing disparities along the lines of skin tone have the potential to widen the gap among Black influencers, creating disproportionate opportunities for success within an already marginalized population.
AbramsJABelgraveFZWilliamsCD, et al. (2020) African American adolescent girls’ beliefs about skin tone and colorism. Journal of Black Psychology46(2–3): 169–194.
2.
BanksTL (2014) A darker shade of pale revisited: disaggregated Blackness and colorism in the “post-racial” Obama era. In: NorwoodK (ed.) Color Matters. New York: Routledge, pp. 95–117.
3.
BatesDMächlerMBolkerB, et al. (2015) Fitting linear mixed-effects models using lme4. Journal of Statistical Software67: 1–48.
4.
BishopS (2019) Managing visibility on YouTube through algorithmic gossip. New Media & Society21(11–12): 2589–2606.
5.
BishopS (2021) Influencer management tools: algorithmic cultures, brand safety, and bias. Social Media + Society7(1): 20563051211003066.
6.
BlissM (2020) Under the radar: older women YouTubers and algorithmic influence. Feminist Media Studies20(5): 745–747.
7.
BondSCashTF (1992) Black beauty: skin color and body images among African-American college women 1. Journal of Applied Social Psychology22(11): 874–888.
8.
Bonilla-SilvaEDietrichDR (2008) The Latin Americanization of racial stratification in the US. In: HallRE (ed.) Racism in the 21st Century: An Empirical Analysis of Skin Color. New York: Springer, pp. 151–170.
9.
Bonilla-SilvaERayV (2009) When Whites love a Black leader: race matters in Obamerica. Journal of African American Studies13: 176–183.
10.
ChildsKM (2022) “The shade of it all”: how Black women use Instagram and YouTube to contest colorism in the beauty industry. Social Media + Society8(2): 20563051221107634.
11.
ChircoPBuchananTM (2022) Dark faces in white spaces: the effects of skin tone, race, ethnicity, and intergroup preferences on interpersonal judgments and voting behavior. Analyses of Social Issues and Public Policy22(1): 427–447.
ChristinALuY (2024) The influencer pay gap: platform labor meets racial capitalism. New Media & Society26(12): 7212–7235.
14.
CollinsPH (1990) Black Feminist Thought: Knowledge, Consciousness, and the Politics of Empowerment. London: Routledge.
15.
DaraniMMAghaieS (2025) Recommender systems impact on platform’s content and outcomes: the role of providers and algorithm designs. Journal of Research in Interactive Marketing19(6): 917–935.
16.
DeliovskyK (2008) Normative White femininity: race, gender and the politics of beauty. Atlantis: Critical Studies in Gender, Culture & Social Justice33(1): 49–59.
17.
DixonTLMaddoxKB (2005) Skin tone, crime news, and social reality judgments: priming the stereotype of the dark and dangerous Black criminal 1. Journal of Applied Social Psychology35(8): 1555–1570.
18.
DuffyBE (2017) (Not) Getting Paid to Do What You Love: Gender, Social Media, and Aspirational Work. New Haven, CT: Yale University Press.
19.
DuffyBEMeisnerC (2023) Platform governance at the margins: social media creators’ experiences with algorithmic (in)visibility. Media, Culture & Society45(2): 285–304.
20.
DuffyBEPinchASannonS, et al. (2021) The nested precarities of creative labor on social media. Social Media + Society7(2): 20563051211021368.
21.
EllingtonTN (2015) Social networking sites: a support system for African-American women wearing natural hair. International Journal of Fashion Design, Technology and Education8(1): 21–29.
22.
FearsLM (1998) Colorism of Black women in news editorial photos. Western Journal of Black Studies22(1): 30.
23.
FischerMJMasseyDSCharlesCZ, et al. (2003) The Source of the River: The Social Origins of Freshmen at America’s Selective Colleges and Universities. Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press.
24.
FrisbyCM (2006) “Shades of beauty”: examining the relationship of skin color to perceptions of physical attractiveness. Facial Plastic Surgery22(3): 175–179.
25.
FrisbyCM (2019) Black and beautiful: a content analysis and study of colorism and strides toward inclusivity in the cosmetic industry. Advances in Journalism and Communication7(2): 35.
GoldsmithAHHamiltonDDarityWJr (2006) Shades of discrimination: skin tone and wages. American Economic Review96(2): 242–245.
28.
HallRE (2018) The globalization of light skin colorism: from critical race to critical skin theory. American Behavioral Scientist62(14): 2133–2145.
29.
HallRE (2021) The Historical Globalization of Colorism. New York: Springer.
30.
HanB (2020) How do YouTubers make money? A lesson learned from the most subscribed YouTuber channels. International Journal of Business Information Systems33(1): 132–143.
31.
HarrisonMSThomasKM (2009) The hidden prejudice in selection: a research investigation on skin color bias. Journal of Applied Social Psychology39(1): 134–168.
32.
HerzogL (2021) Algorithmic bias and access to opportunities. In: VélizC (ed.) The Oxford Handbook of Digital Ethics. Oxford: Oxford Academic, pp. 413–432.
33.
HickmanCB (1997) The devil and the one drop rule: racial categories, African Americans, and the US census. Michigan Law Review95: 1161.
34.
HunterM (2019) Technologies of racial capital. Contexts18(4): 53–55.
35.
HunterM (2021) Colorism and the racial politics of beauty. In: CraigML (ed.) The Routledge Companion to Beauty Politics. London: Routledge, pp. 85–93.
JhaM (2016) The Global Beauty Industry: Colorism, Racism, and the National Body. London: Routledge.
38.
JuddCMWestfallJKennyDA (2012) Treating stimuli as a random factor in social psychology: a new and comprehensive solution to a pervasive but largely ignored problem. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology103(1): 54.
KeithVMHerringC (1991) Skin tone and stratification in the Black community. American Journal of Sociology97(3): 760–778.
41.
KerrAE (2005) The paper bag principle: of the myth and the motion of colorism. Journal of American Folklore118(469): 271–289.
42.
KhannaN (ed.) (2020) Whiter: Asian American Women on Skin Color and Colorism. New York: NYU Press.
43.
KojahSAZhangBZAreC, et al. (2025) “Dialing it Back”: shadowbanning, invisible digital labor, and how marginalized content creators attempt to mitigate the impacts of opaque platform governance. Proceedings of the ACM on Human-Computer Interaction9(1): 1–22.
44.
KolaI (2014) Response to Jouelzy’s “so over the natural hair community & texture discrimination,” Youtube.com. Available at: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=CVC8c7G0MHg (accessed 3 September 2025).
45.
LawsonCE (2020) Skin deep: callout strategies, influencers, and racism in the online beauty community. New Media & Society23(3): 596–612.
46.
LearyRV (2018) Colorism in media content: a qualitative study focusing on film and perception. Doctoral Dissertation, Regent University, Virginia, VA.
LoveTL (2025) The disaggregation of platform labor: theorizing skin tone work in the Black influencer beauty economy. Social Media + Society11(1): 20563051241310943.
50.
MasseyDSMartinJA (2003) The NIS skin color scale. Office of population research, Princeton University, Princeton, NJ, April.
51.
McCleary-GaddyATJamesD (2022) Skin tone, life satisfaction, and psychological distress among African Americans: the mediating effect of stigma consciousness. Journal of Health Psychology27(2): 422–431.
52.
MillsJTMillerDS (2024) The implication of colorism in popular media: A call for authentic representations to reduce skin tone discrimination. Journal of Colorism Studies, 5(1), pp.1–18
53.
MonkEPJr (2014) Skin tone stratification among Black Americans, 2001–2003. Social Forces92(4): 1313–1337.
54.
MonkEPJr (2021) Colorism and physical health: evidence from a national survey. Journal of Health and Social Behavior62(1): 37–52.
55.
MonkEPJrEspositoMHLeeH (2021) Beholding inequality: race, gender, and returns to physical attractiveness in the United States. American Journal of Sociology127(1): 194–241.
56.
NeilLMbilishakaA (2019) “Hey curlfriends!”: hair care and self-care messaging on YouTube by Black women natural hair vloggers. Journal of Black Studies50(2): 156–177.
57.
NiS (2023) Exploring the preferences of US YouTube users and factors related to YouTube uploader’s revenue. Studies in Social Science & Humanities2(1): 43–54.
58.
NobleSU (2018) Algorithms of Opression: How search engines reinforce racism. New York: New York University Press.
59.
OchoaMK (2025) Colorism in the Latina Community. In: FrancisLAGrayJ (eds) Feminists Talk Whiteness. London: Routledge, pp. 175–186.
60.
PasqualeF (2015) The Black Box Society: The Secret Algorithms That Control Money and Information. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.
61.
PeissK (1998) Hope in a Jar: The Making of America’s Beauty Culture. New York: Macmillan.
62.
PerkinsRM (2014) The influence of colorism and hair texture bias on the professional and social lives of Black women student affairs professionals. Doctoral Dissertation, Louisiana State University and Agricultural & Mechanical College, Baton Rouge, LA.
63.
PinkstonTM (2015) Cues of colorism: the psychological, sociocultural, and developmental differences between light-skinned and dark-skinned African-Americans. Doctoral Dissertation, Georgia Southern University, Statesboro, GA.
64.
PuffS (2016) Difference, diversity, and the discourse (s) of Color: rereading colorism in the Black press. In: ArapoglouENymanJKalogerasY (eds) Racial and Ethnic Identities in the Media. London: Palgrave Macmillan, pp. 245–261.
65.
R Core Team (2021) R: A Language and Environment for Statistical Computing. Vienna: R Foundation for Statistical Computing. Available at: https://www.R-project.org/
66.
ReddyV (2021) Beauty, colorism, and anti-colorism in transnational India. In: CraigML (ed.) The Routledge Companion to Beauty Politics. London: Routledge, pp. 94–102.
67.
ReeceRL (2021) The missing social movement: colorism in Black America. Interface: A Journal for and about Social Movements13(2): 293–311.
68.
RiederBMatamoros-FernándezACorominaÒ (2018) From ranking algorithms to “ranking cultures” Investigating the modulation of visibility in YouTube search results. Convergence24(1): 50–68.
69.
RobinsonCL (2011) Hair as race: why “good hair” may be bad for Black females. Howard Journal of Communications22(4): 358–376.
70.
RooksNM (1996) Hair Raising: Beauty, Culture, and African American Women. New Brunswick, NJ: Rutgers University Press.
71.
RosarioRJMinorIRogersLO (2021) “Oh, you’re pretty for a dark-skinned girl”: Black adolescent girls’ identities and resistance to colorism. Journal of Adolescent Research36(5): 501–534.
72.
RussellKRussell-ColeKWilsonM, et al. (1993) The Color Complex: The Politics of Skin Color among African Americans. New York: Anchor Books.
73.
SingathiC (2020) Dark secrets behind light shades: Hollywood & modeling media. Dialogues@ RU99: 99–105.
74.
SobandeF (2017) Watching me watching you: Black women in Britain on YouTube. European Journal of Cultural Studies20(6): 655–671.
75.
SteeleCK (2016) Pride and prejudice: pervasiveness of colorism and the animated series proud family. Howard Journal of Communications27(1): 53–67.
76.
SteeleCK (2021) Digital Black feminism. In: SteeleCK (ed.) Digital Black Feminism. New York: New York University Press, pp. 139–160.
77.
StevensWE (2021) Blackfishing on Instagram: influencing and the commodification of Black urban aesthetics. Social Media + Society7(3): 20563051211038236.
78.
StevensWE (2022) Black Influencers: Interrogating the Racialization and Commodification of Digital Labor. Philadelphia, PA: Temple University.
79.
StinsonC (2022) Algorithms are not neutral: bias in collaborative filtering. AI and Ethics2(4): 763–770.
80.
Strmic-PawlHVGonlinVGarnerS (2021) Color in context: three angles on contemporary colorism. Sociology of Race and Ethnicity7(3): 289–303.
81.
TharpsLL (2016) Same Family, Different Colors: Confronting Colorism in America’s Diverse Families. Boston, MA: Beacon Press.
WalkerS (2007) Style and Status: Selling Beauty to African American Women, 1920-1975. Lexington, KY: University Press of Kentucky.
84.
WaltersK (2018) “They’ll go with the lighter”: tri-racial aesthetic labor in clothing retail. Sociology of Race and Ethnicity4(1): 128–141.
85.
WilliamsA (2024) Not My Type: Automating Sexual Racism in Online Dating. Redwood City, CA: Stanford University Press.
86.
WilsonA (2020) The popularity of Fenty Beauty and how it reflects the online beauty community. In: LittleCD (ed.) Makeup in the World of Beauty Vlogging: Community, Commerce, and Culture. Lanham, MD: Lexington Books, pp. 37–64.
87.
WilsonLT (2022) The relative importance of click-through rates (CTR) versus watch time for YouTube views. International Journal of Pervasive Computing and Communications19(4): 573–595.
88.
YoungCC (2021) Color me color struck: colorism in popular culture Vis À Vis the visual canon of Lupita Nyong’o, Robin Rihanna Fenty, and Serena Williams. In: FitzgeraldA (ed.) Women’s Lived Experiences of the Gender Gap: Gender Inequalities from Multiple Global Perspectives. Singapore: Springer, pp. 83–93.
89.
ZhouRKhemmaratSGaoL (2010) The impact of YouTube recommendation system on video views. In: Proceedings of the 10th ACM SIGCOMM conference on internet measurement, Melbourne, VIC, Australia, 1–3 November, pp. 404–410. New York: Association for Computing Machinery.
