Unmasking coordinated hate: Analysing hate speech on Spanish digital news media

Abstract

This study examines the characteristics and behaviours of accounts that propagate hate speech through their responses to articles posted on five leading digital news media in Spain on Platform X (previously Twitter). Using non-experimental quantitative research, we analysed 1345 hate-expressing messages from 173,449 user comments on content shared in five leading digital news media during January 2021. Network analysis, the Homophilic Exposure Index (HEI), regression analysis and the k-means algorithm were used to identify features that characterize accounts that disseminate low-intensity hate expressions in a coordinated manner, undermining the moderation efforts of digital news media. As a result, digital news media must develop strategies to reduce the presence of this type of expression and confront accounts that operate covertly in a coordinated manner, using Astroturfing to manipulate debates around the content published on X.

Keywords

Digital media digital news media features hate speech haters profile social media Twitter users X

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Abuín-Vences

Cuesta-Cambra

Niño-González

, et al. (2022) Hate speech analysis as a function of ideology: Emotional and cognitive effects. Comunicar 30(71): 37–48.

Alhazbi

(2020) Behavior-based machine learning approaches to identify state-sponsored trolls on Twitter. IEEE Access 8: 195132–195141.

Anderson

Brossard

Scheufele

, et al. (2014) The ‘Nasty effect’: Online incivility and risk perceptions of emerging technologies. Journal of Computer-mediated Communication 19(3): 373–387.

Arce-García

Menéndez-Menéndez

(2022) Inflaming public debate: a methodology to determine origin and characteristics of hate speech about sexual and gender diversity on Twitter. Profesional de la información 32(1) e320106. Available at: https://doi.org/10.3145/epi.2023.ene.06

Arce-García

Said-Hung

Mottareale-Calvanese

(2023) Tipos de campaña Astroturfing de contenidos desinformativos y polarizados en tiempos de pandemia en España. ICONO 14. Revista Científica De Comunicación Y Tecnologías Emergentes 21(1): 1890.

Barud

Olalekan

(2022) Detection of fake news and hate speech for Ethiopian languages: A systematic review of the approaches. Journal of Big Data 9(1): 66.

Bastian

Heymann

Jacomy

(2009) Gephi: An open source software for exploring and manipulating networks [Conference]. International AAAI Conference on Weblogs and Social Media, San Jose, CA, 17–20 May. Available at: http://www.aaai.org/ocs/index.php/ICWSM/09/paper/view/154

Benesch

Buerguer

Glavanic

, et al. (2018) Danguerous speech: A practical guide. Dangerous Speech Project. Available at: https://cutt.ly/ew8f9T7l

Bright

(2016) The social news gap: How news reading and news sharing diverge. Journal of Communication 66(3): 343–365.

10.

Cáceres-Zapatero

Brändle

Paz-Rebollo

(2023) Stances on hate speech: Population opinions and attitudes. Profesional De La Información 32(4): 1–14.

11.

CBS News (2022) Twitter and other social media sites slipped on removing hate speech in 2022, EU review says. MONEYWATCH–CBS NEWS, 24 November. Available at: https://cutt.ly/qw8whZVk

12.

Center for Countering Digital Hate (2023) X Content Moderation Failure. Available at: https://counterhate.com/wp-content/uploads/2023/09/230907-X-Content-Moderation-Report_final_CCDH.pdf

13.

Chadwick

(2017) The Hybrid Media System. Oxford: Oxford University Press.

14.

Culpeper

(2021) Impoliteness and hate speech: Compare and contrast. Journal of Pragmatics 179: 4–11.

15.

De Lucas

Römer

Izquierdo

, et al. (2022) Manual Para El Etiquetado De Mensajes De Odio. London: Figshare.

16.

Digital News Report (2020) Se debilita la confianza en los medios, resisten las marcas periodísticas y emerge el periodismo local [Trust in the media weakens, journalistic brands resist and local journalism emerges]. Digital News Report. Available at: https://www.digitalnewsreport.es/2020/se-debilita-la-confianza-en-los-medios-resisten-las-marcas-periodisticas-y-emerge-el-periodismo-local/

17.

Đorđević

(2020) The sociocognitive dimension of hate speech in readers’ comments on Serbian news websites. Discourse, Context & Media 33: 100366.

18.

Elmas

Overdorf

Aberer

(2021). Tactical Reframing of Online Disinformation Campaigns Against The Istanbul Convention. Proceedings of the ICWSM Workshops. Available at: https://doi.org/10.36190/2021.42

19.

Esau

(2021) Hate speech (Hate Speech/Incivility). DOCA. Available at: https://doi.org/10.34778/5a

20.

Flaxman

Goel

Rao

(2016) Filter bubbles, echo chambers, and online news consumption. Public Opinion Quarterly 80: 298–320.

21.

Garland

Ghazi-Zahedi

Young

J-G

, et al. (2023) Impact and dynamics of hate and counter speech online. EPJ Data Science 12: 27.

22.

González-Aguilar

Segado Boj

Makhortykh

(2023) Populist right parties on TikTok: Spectacularization, personalization, and hate speech. Media and Communication 11(2): 232–240.

23.

Gottfried

Shearer

(2016) News Use across Social Media Platforms 2016. Journalism. Available at: http://www.journalism.org/2016/05/26/news-use-across-social-media-platforms-2016/

24.

Granovetter

(1973) The strength of weak ties. American Journal of Sociology 78: 1360–1380.

25.

Guess

Nyhan

Reifler

(2018) Selective exposure to misinformation: Evidence from the consumption of fake news during the 2016 U.S.Presidential campaign. European Research Council. Available at: https://cutt.ly/FOgUe1R

26.

Howard

Bolsover

Kollanyi

, et al. (2017) Junk news and bots during the US election: What were Michigan voters sharing over Twitter? [Conference]. Computational Propaganda Project-Oxford Internet Institute, 1–26 March, Oxford, United Kingdom. Available at: https://cutt.ly/kRihRoY

27.

Humanes

Valera-Ordaz

(2023) Partisanshipm, ideology, and selective exposure: A longitudinal analysis of media consumption in Spain (2008-2019). Media and Communication 11(2): 113–116.

28.

Karlsson

Couvering

Lindell

(2022) Publishing, sharing, and spreading online news: A case study of gatekeeping logics in the platform era. Nordicomreview 43: 190–213.

29.

Keller

Schoch

Stier

, et al. (2019) Political astroturfing on Twitter: How to coordinate a disinformation campaign. Political Communication 37: 256–280.

30.

Małecki

Kowal

Dobrowolska

, et al. (2021) Defining online hating and online haters. Frontiers in Psychology 12: 744614.

31.

Matamoros-Fernández

Farkas

(2021) Racism, hate speech, and social media: A systematic review and critique. Television & New Media 22(2): 205–224.

32.

Meese

Hurcombe

(2020) Facebook, News media and platform dependency: The institutional impacts of news distribution on social platforms. New Media & Society 23(8): 2367–2384.

33.

Molnar

(2021) The law of the jungle. The online hate-speech against the Roma in Romania. Victims & Offenders 16(8): 1108–1129.

34.

Obermaier

Schmuck

Saleem

(2021) I’ll be there for you? Effects of islamophobic online hate speech and counter speech on Muslim in-group bystanders' intention to intervene. New Media & Society 25(9): 2339–2358.

35.

Paasch-Colberg

Strippel

(2021) ‘The Boundaries are Blurry. . .’: How comment moderators in Germany see and respond to hate comments. Journalism Studies 23: 224–244.

36.

Padró-Solanet

Balcells

(2022) Media diet and polarisation: Evidence from Spain. South European Society and Politics 27(1): 75–95.

37.

Papcunová

Martončik

Fedáková

, et al. (2023) Hate speech operationalization: A preliminary examination of hate speech indicators and their structure. Complex & Intelligent Systems 9(3): 2827–2842.

38.

Pariser

(2011) The Filter Bubble. London: Penguin Books Ltd.

39.

Paz

Cáceres-Zapatero

Martín

(2021) Suscripción a la prensa digital como contención a los discursos de odio [Subscription to the digital press as a containment of hate speech]. Profesional De La Informacion 30(6): 1–13.

40.

Paz

Mayagoitia-Soria

González-Aguilar

J-M

(2021) From polarization to hate: Portrait of the Spanish political meme. Social Media + Society 7(4): 2920.

41.

Paz

Montero-Díaz

Moreno-Delgado

(2020) Hate speech: A systematized review. SAGE Open 10(4): 3022.

42.

Pelicon

Shekhar

Škrlj

, et al. (2021) Investigating cross-lingual training for offensive language detection. PeerJ 7: e559.

43.

Pérez

(2020) “Yo fui un bot”: las confesiones de un agente dedicado al engaño en Twitter [“I was a bot“: The confessions of an agent dedicated to deception On twitter]. El País, 21 May. Available at: https://cutt.ly/wRihXGu

44.

Rossini

(2022) Beyond incivility: Understanding patterns of uncivil and intolerant discourse in online political talk. Communication Research 49(3): 399–425.

45.

Russmann

Hess

(2023) The management of uncivil and hateful user comments in Austrian news media. Journalism Practice. Epub ahead of print 16 March. DOI: 10.1080/17512786.2023.2189152

46.

Said-Hung

Moreno-López

Mottareale-Calvanese

(2023) Promotion of hate speech by Spanish political actors on Twitter. Policy & Internet 15(4): 665–686.

47.

Sánchez

Campo-Archbold

Rozo

, et al. (2022) On the power of social networks to analyze threatening trends. IEEE Internet Computing 26: 19–26.

48.

Sellars

(2016) Defining Hate Speech. Berkman Klein Center Research Publication No. 2016-20. Available at: https://papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=2882244

49.

Sorensen

Andrews

Drennan

(2017) Using social media posts as resources for engaging in value co-creation: The case for social media-based cause brand communities. Journal of Service Theory and Practice 27(4): 898–922.

50.

Sprejer

Margetts

Oliveira

, et al. (2023) An actor-based approach to understanding radical right viral tweets in the UK. Journal of Policing, Intelligence and Counter Terrorism 18(2): 139–157.

51.

Statista (2020a) Ranking de los 10 medios de comunicación con más seguidores en Twitter en España en abril de 2020 [Ranking of the 10 media outlets with the most followers on Twitter in Spain in April 2020]. Statista. Available at: https://es.statista.com/estadisticas/518802/Twitter-perfiles-de-medios-de-comunicacion-con-mas-seguidos-en-espana/

52.

Statista (2020b) Páginas oficiales de medios de comunicación más populares en Facebook en España en abril de 2020, por número de seguidores. Statista. Available at: https://es.statista.com/estadisticas/518580/paginas-de-medios-de-comunicacion-de-Facebook-con-mas-seguidores-en-espana/#statisticContainer

53.

Statista (2020c) Ranking de las principales marcas de medios de comunicación online según el porcentaje de población que las usaba de forma semanal en España en 2020 [Ranking of the main online media brands according to the percentage of the population that used them weekly in Spain in 2020]. Statista. Available at: https://es.statista.com/estadisticas/670743/principales-medios-online-porcentaje-de-usuarios-semanales-espana/r

54.

Struck

(2019) Digitale vorwärtspanik. Monatsschrift Fur Kriminologie Und Strafrechtsreform 102(1): 54–64.

55.

Swart

Peters

Broersma

(2019) Sharing and discussing news in private social media groups. Digital Journalism 7: 187–205.

56.

Tayie

Tejedor

Pulido

(2023) News literacy and online news between Egyptian and Spanish youth: Fake news, hate speech and trust in the media. Comunicar 31(74): 73–87.

57.

Thorley

Saltman

(2023) GIFCT tech trials: Combining behavioural signals to surface terrorist and violent extremist content online. Studies in Conflict & Terrorism. Epub ahead of print 19 June 2023. DOI: https://doi.org/10.1080/1057610x.2023.2222901.

58.

Van-der-Linden

Maibach

Cook

, et al. (2017) Inoculating against misinformation. Science 358(6367): 1141–1142.

59.

Vidgen

(2019) Tweeting Islamophobia. Doctoral Thesis, Oxford University Research Archive, University of Oxford. Available at: https://ora.ox.ac.uk/objects/uuid:3c32d29d-e2e4-4913-abf8-2a28886f55a7

60.

Vidgen

Yasseri

(2020) Detecting weak and strong Islamophobic hate speech on social media. Journal of Information Technology & Politics 17(1): 66–78.

61.

Williams

(2011) Data Mining with Rattle and R: the Art of Excavating Data for Knowledge Discovery. New York: Springer.

62.

Williams

(2021) The Science of Hate. London: Faber & Faber.

63.

Wintterlin

Schatto - Eckrodt

Frischlich

, et al. (2020) How to cope with dark participation: Moderation practices in German newsrooms. Digital Journalism 8(7): 904–924.

64.

Wolfgang

McConnel

Blackburn

(2020) Commenters as a threat to journalism? How comment moderators perceive the role of the audience. Digital Journalism 8: 925–944.

65.

X Help Center (2023) Hateful Conduct. Available at: https://help.twitter.com/en/rules-and-policies/hateful-conduct-policy

66.

Zerback

Töpfl

(2021) Forged examples as disinformation: The biasing effects of political astroturfing comments on public opinion perceptions and how to prevent them. Political Psychology 43(3): 399–418.

67.

Zhao

Sano

, et al. (2020) Fake news propagates differently from real news even at early stages of spreading. EPJ Data Science 9(7): 1–14.

68.

Zheng

Xue

Hao

, et al. (2017) Smoke screener or straight shooter: Detecting elite sybil attack. Social and Information Networks. Available at: https://arxiv.org/abs/1709.06916

69.

Ziegele

Koehler

Weber

(2018) Socially destructive? Effects of negative and hateful user comments on readers’ donation behavior toward refugees and homeless persons. Journal of Broadcasting & Electronic Media 62(4): 636–653.