‘Disturbing’ children’s YouTube genres and the algorithmic uncanny

Abstract

Since late 2017, journalists, advocacy groups, and policy-makers have expressed serious concerns about popular genres of video content on YouTube that target child viewers but which are not child-appropriate according to extant definitions and cultural expectations. This article combines a discourse and thematic analysis of 54 news articles and opinion pieces about ‘disturbing’ children’s genres on YouTube with textual analysis of the two genres at the centre of this reportage. The analysis illuminates why the formal, aesthetic, and thematic qualities of these particular child-oriented YouTube genres trouble existing cultural expectations around children’s media. I argue that the genres addressed in the reportage share a key quality that I refer to as the ‘algorithmic uncanny’: common semantic and syntactic features that foster among reporters a perception that algorithms have played a key role in not only distributing the content but in shaping its aesthetic and thematic agendas.

Keywords

Algorithmic uncanny children’s media family entertainment characters genre nursery rhymes reportage YouTube

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Altman

(1984) A semantic/syntactic approach to film genre. Cinema Journal 23(3): 6–18.

Anderson

(2019) Another video on YouTube for kids is going viral for all the wrong reasons. Mashable Australia, 19 July. Available at: https://mashable.com/article/billion-surprise-toys-youtube-kids-video-sick/ (accessed 1 December 2019).

Apelgren-Coleman

(2019) YouTube: the new children’s TV. The Media Online, 2 April. Available at: https://themediaonline.co.za/2019/04/youtube-the-new-childrens-tv/ (accessed 1 December 2019).

Arthurs

Drakopoulou

Gandini

(2018) Researching YouTube. Convergence 24(1): 3–15.

Australian Communications and Media Authority (2017) Children’s television viewing and multi-screen behaviour. ACMA report, Canberra, ACT, Australia. Available at: https://www.acma.gov.au/sites/default/files/2019-08/Childrens-television-viewing-and-multi-screen%20behaviour.pdf

Australian Government, Department of Communications and the Arts (2017) Australian and children’s screen content review consultation paper. Report with ACMA and Screen Australia, Canberra, ACT, Australia. Available at: https://www.communications.gov.au/sites/default/files/consultation/pdf/australian-and-childrens-screen-content-review-consultation-paper.docx.pdf?acsf_files_redirect

Balanzategui

(2020) Towards an understanding of children’s screen genres in the streaming video era: reflecting on shifting intersections between digital media and screen studies. NECSUS: European Journal of Media Studies, 1 December. Available at: https://necsus-ejms.org/towards-an-understanding-of-childrens-screen-genres-in-the-streaming-video-era-reflecting-on-shifting-intersections-between-digital-media-and-screen-studies/

Bell

(1968) A reinterpretation of the direction of effects in studies of socialization. Psychological Review 75: 81–95.

Berg

(2019) The highest-paid YouTube stars of 2019. Forbes, 18 December. Available at: https://www.forbes.com/sites/maddieberg/2019/12/18/the-highest-paid-youtube-stars-of-2019-the-kids-are-killing-it/#446f8a3338cd (accessed 19 December 2019).

10.

Billion Surprise Toys (2018) Fantasy cartoon refrigerator + more kids songs. YouTube.com, 24 March. Available at: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=aC_EcrxV20s (accessed 1 December 2019).

11.

Bridle

(2017) Something is wrong on the internet. Medium, 6 November. Available at: https://medium.com/@jamesbridle/something-is-wrong-on-the-internet-c39c471271d2 (accessed 1 December 2019).

12.

Buck

Lee

(2013) Frozen. California: Walt Disney Pictures.

13.

Buckingham

(1996) Moving Images: Understanding Children’s Emotional Responses to Television. Manchester: Manchester University Press.

14.

Buckingham

(2000) After the Death of Childhood: Growing Up in the Age of Electronic Media. Cambridge: Polity Press.

15.

Burgess

(2018) What fake Peppa Pig videos can teach us about trust. Keynote: Trust and its Discontents Workshop, Australian Academy of the Humanities, Melbourne, VIC, Australia, 28 September.

16.

Burroughs

(2017) YouTube kids: the app economy and mobile parenting. Social Media + Society 3: 1–8.

17.

Center for Digital Democracy (2018) Request to investigate Google’s YouTube online service and advertising practices for violating the Children’s Online Privacy Protection Act. Complaint to the US Federal Trade Commission, Washington, DC, April.

18.

Chen

Chang

Yeh

(2017) Emotion classification of YouTube videos. Decision Support Systems 101: 40–50.

19.

ChuChu

(2013) Johny Johny Yes Papa nursery rhyme. YouTube.com, 2 August. Available at: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=olWG6jiMV0g (accessed 1 December 2019).

20.

Cobb

(2017) How YouTube’s obsession with coupling Elsa and Spider-Man descended into madness. News.com.au, 28 June. Available at: https://decider.com/2017/06/28/the-madness-of-elsa-and-spider-man-on-youtube/ (accessed 1 December 2019).

21.

Cohen

(2016) Top 100 most viewed YouTube channels worldwide: May 2016. TubeFilter, 28 June. Available at: https://www.tubefilter.com/2016/06/28/top-100-most-viewed-youtube-channels-worldwide-may-2016/ (accessed 1 December 2019).

22.

Craig

Cunningham

(2017) Toy unboxing: living in a(n unregulated) material world. Media International Australia 163(1): 77–86.

23.

Cunningham

Craig

Silver

(2016) YouTube, multichannel networks and the accelerated evolution of the new screen ecology. Convergence 22(4): 376–391.

24.

Dredge

(2015) Why YouTube is the new children’s TV . . . and why it matters. The Guardian, 20 November. Available at: https://www.theguardian.com/technology/2015/nov/19/youtube-is-the-new-childrens-tv-heres-why-that-matters (accessed 1 December 2019).

25.

Eickhoff

De Vries

(2010) Identifying suitable YouTube videos for children. In: Proceedings of networked and electronic media summit. Available at: https://ir.cwi.nl/pub/18690

26.

Elsa

(2017) A dangerous phenomenon on YouTube. GulfNews, 21 August. Available at: https://gulfnews.com/lifestyle/community/a-dangerous-phenomenon-on-youtube-1.2077692 (accessed 1 December 2019).

27.

Federal Trade Commission and the New York Attorny General (2019) Complaint for permanent injunction, civil penalties, and other equitable relief. Complaint filed in the United States District Court against Google LLC, and YouTube, LLC. Case No.,: 1:19-cv-2642. Filed 4 September. Available at: https://www.ftc.gov/system/files/documents/cases/youtube_complaint.pdf (accessed 1 December 2019).

28.

Feldman

(2018) The new meme is eating sugar and telling lies. New York Magazine, 28 August. Available at: nymag.com/intelligencer/2018/08/what-is-the-baby-meme-about-eating-sugar-and-telling-lies.html (accessed 1 December 2019).

29.

Gerardi

(2017) Take a trip to the automated hellscape of YouTube videos aimed at kids. AV Club, 6 November. Available at: https://www.avclub.com/take-a-trip-to-the-automated-hellscape-of-youtube-video-1820196139 (accessed 1 December 2019).

30.

Golin

Chester

(2015) Request for investigation into Google’s unfair and deceptive practices in connection with its YouTube Kids app. Letter to the US Federal Trade Commission, 19 May. Available at: https://commercialfreechildhood.org/wp-content/uploads/archive/FTC_youtube_update.pdf (accessed 1 December 2019).

31.

Grind

Schechner

McMillan

, et al. (2019) How Google interferes with its search algorithms and changes your results. The Wall Street Journal, 15 November. Available at: https://www.wsj.com/articles/how-google-interferes-with-its-search-algorithms-and-changes-your-results-11573823753 (accessed 15 October 2020).

32.

Gunter

McAleer

(1990) Children and Television: The One-Eyed Monster? London: Routledge.

33.

Gutelle

(2017) YouTube’s purge of inappropriate content aimed at kids spans tens of billions of views. TubeFilter, 20 November. Available at: https://www.tubefilter.com/2017/11/20/youtube-purge-kids-videos-billions-views/ (accessed 1 December 2019).

34.

(2018) YouTube as a global online video portal and an alternative to TV. In: Ha

(ed.) The Audience and Business of YouTube. Lanham, MD: Lexington Books, pp. 1–16.

35.

Hagi

(2018) The viral ‘Johny, Johny’ kids’ videos are a godforsaken nightmare. The Verge, 1 September. Available at: https://www.theverge.com/2018/9/1/17806772/johny-johny-telling-lies-yes-papa-refrigerator-meme-viral-video (accessed 1 December 2019).

36.

Hermansson

Zepernick

(2019) Children’s film and television: contexts and directions. In: Hermansson Zepernick (eds) The Palgrave Handbook of Children’s Film and Television. Cham: Palgrave Macmillan, pp. 1–33.

37.

Hindustan Times (2019) YouTube creators fret over impact of new child protection rules. Hindustan Times, 15 September. Available at: https://www.hindustantimes.com/world-news/youtube-creators-fret-over-impact-of-new-child-protection-rules/story-HfjDJiO1OOYqst12SYI3bM.html (accessed 30 September 2021).

38.

Hotchkins

(2019) How a local video artist accidentally made a viral hit on kid’s YouTube. KQED Arts, 2 April. Available at: https://www.kqed.org/arts/13854122/kate-rhoades-kids-youtube-finger-family-song (accessed 1 December 2019).

39.

ITV (2017) YouTube moves to restrict inappropriate content from kids’ app. ITV Report, 10 November. Available at: https://www.itv.com/news/2017-11-10/youtube-moves-to-restrict-inappropriate-content-from-kids-app/ (accessed 1 December 2019).

40.

Katz

(2010) How children of immigrants use media to connect their families to the community. Journal of Children and Media 4: 298–315.

41.

Kimel

(2017) Drugs, rape, massacres: how AI is exposing children to the worst of humanity. Futurism, 14 November. Available at: https://futurism.com/drugs-rape-massacres-ai-exposing-children-worst-of-humanity (accessed 1 December 2019).

42.

Know Your Meme (2019) Johny Johny Yes Papa. Know Your Meme.com. Available at: https://knowyourmeme.com/memes/johny-johny-yes-papa (accessed 1 December 2019).

43.

Kutner

(2019) YouTube Kids’ videos: a gallery of creepy. Book and Film Globe, 6 August. Available at: https://bookandfilmglobe.com/education/youtube-kids-videos-a-gallery-of-creepy/ (accessed 1 December 2019).

44.

Lewis

(2019) Horrified mom discovers suicide instructions in video on YouTube and YouTube Kids. CBS News, 23 February. Available at: https://www.cbsnews.com/news/youtube-kids-inappropriate-horrified-mom-discovers-suicide-instructions-in-video-on-youtube-and-youtube-kids/ (accessed 1 December 2019).

45.

Linn

(2001) The trouble with Telebubbies. The American Prospect, 16 November. Available at: https://prospect.org/culture/trouble-teletubbies/ (accessed 27 October 2020).

46.

McDonnell

(2006) Honey, We Lost the Kids: Re-Thinking Childhood in the Multimedia Age. North Melbourne, VIC, Australia: Pluto Press.

47.

Madrigal

(2018) The dangers of YouTube. The Atlantic, November. Available at: https://www.theatlantic.com/magazine/archive/2018/11/raised-by-youtube/570838/ (accessed 1 December 2019).

48.

Marenko

Van Allen

(2016) Animistic design: how to reimagine digital interaction between the human and the nonhuman. Digital Creativity 27(1): 52–70.

49.

Marsh

(2016) Unboxing videos: co-construction of the child as cyberflâneur. Discourse 37: 369–380.

50.

Messenger-Davies

(2001) Studying children’s television. In: Creeber

(ed.) The Television Genre Book. London: British Film Institute, pp. 96–102.

51.

Neilan

(2018) Surely the large-headed baby and his talking refrigerator are the worst thing on YouTube. AV Club, 29 August. Available at: https://news.avclub.com/maybe-just-don-t-show-your-kids-shit-like-this-1828685683 (accessed 1 December 2019).

52.

Nicoll

Nansen

(2018) Mimetic production in YouTube toy unboxing videos. Social Media + Society 4: 1–12.

53.

Ofcom (2019) Children and parents: media use and attitudes report 2018. Annual report, London. Available at: https://www.ofcom.org.uk/research-and-data/media-literacy-research/childrens/children-and-parents-media-use-and-attitudes-report-2018

54.

Orphanides

(2018) Children’s YouTube is still churning out blood, suicide and cannibalism. Wired, 23 March. Available at: https://www.wired.co.uk/article/youtube-for-kids-videos-problems-algorithm-recommend (accessed 1 December 2019).

55.

Papadamou

Papasavva

Zannettou

, et al. (2020) Disturbed YouTube for kids: characterizing and detecting inappropriate videos targeting young children. In: Proceedings of the 14th international AAAI conference on web and social media, pp. 522–533. Available at: https://ojs.aaai.org//index.php/ICWSM/article/view/7320/7174

56.

Parker

(2020) YouTube COPPA changes result in videos with violence, gore, and strong language being labelled ‘made for kids’. Reclaim the Net, 9 January. Available at: https://reclaimthenet.org/youtube-coppa-changes-violent-videos-made-for-kids/ (accessed 15 January 2020).

57.

Pasquale

(2015) Black Box Society. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.

58.

Popper

(2017) YouTube says it will crack down on bizarre videos targeting children. The Verge, 9 November. Available at: https://www.theverge.com/2017/11/9/16629788/youtube-kids-distrubing-inappropriate-flag-age-restrict (accessed 1 December 2019).

59.

Potter

(2015) Creativity, Culture and Commerce: Producing Australian Children’s Television with Public Value. Bristol: Intellect.

60.

Potter

(2017) Regulating contemporary children’s television: how digitisation is re-shaping compliance norms and production practices. Media International Australia 163(1): 20–30.

61.

Reynolds

(2017) Creeps and sadists manipulate YouTube Kids algorithm to get access to children. PJ Media, 12 December. Available at: https://pjmedia.com/parenting/creeps-sadists-game-youtube-kids-algorithm-get-access-children/ (accessed 1 December 2019).

62.

Robertson

(2017) What makes YouTube’s surreal kids’ videos so creepy? The Verge, 21 November. Available at: https://www.theverge.com/culture/2017/11/21/16685874/kids-youtube-video-elsagate-creepiness-psychology (accessed 1 December 2019).

63.

Romano

(2018) ‘Johny Johny Yes Papa’: the meme born from YouTube’s hellscape of kids’ videos, explained. Vox, 31 August. Available at: https://www.vox.com/2018/8/31/17799244/johny-johny-yes-papa-video-meme-youtube-kids-videos (accessed 1 December 2019).

64.

Rubin

(2018) The world of kids on YouTube is wild, weird, and almost entirely unregulated. Quartz, 21 December. Available at: https://qz.com/1500662/the-world-of-kids-on-youtube-is-wild-weird-and-almost-entirely-unregulated/ (accessed 1 December 2019).

65.

Satherely

(2017) Elsagate: the disturbing YouTube trend that might be terrifying your children. Newshub, 24 November. Available at: https://www.mediaworks.co.nz/home.html (accessed 1 December 2019).

66.

Sommer

(2019) ‘Johnny Johnny Yes Papa’ is nightmare meme fuel – and big business. The Daily Beast, 14 March. Available at: https://www.thedailybeast.com/johnny-johnny-yes-papa-is-nightmare-meme-fueland-big-business (accessed 1 December 2019).

67.

Statista (2019) Most popular YouTube channels as of September 2019, ranked by number of subscribers (in millions). Available at: https://www.statista.com/statistics/277758/most-popular-youtube-channels-ranked-by-subscribers/ (accessed 1 December 2019).

68.

Sung

(2018) ‘Johny Johny Yes Papa’ is just one of many terrifying YouTube videos made for kids. Mashable, 28 August. Available at: https://mashable.com/article/johny-johny-yes-papa-youtube-kids-videos/ (accessed 1 December 2019).

69.

Van den Bulck

Custers

Nelissen

(2016) The child-effect in the new media environment: challenges and opportunities for communication research. Journal of Children and Media 10(2): 30–38.

70.

Warburton

Braunstein

(eds) (2012) Growing Up Fast and Furious. Sydney, NSW, Australia: The Federation Press.

71.

Webs & Tiaras – Toy Monster Compilations (2016) Frozen Elsa GUMMY TONGUE PRANK! w- Spiderman vs Joker Bad Baby Hulk Gumball - Superheroes IRL. YouTube.com. Available at: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=aOi-ukb9TvY&has_verified=1 (accessed 1 December 2019).

72.

YouTube (2019) An update on kids and data protection on YouTube. YouTube Official Blog, 4 September. Available at: https://youtube.googleblog.com/2019/09/an-update-on-kids.html (accessed 1 December 2019).

73.

YouTube Help (2019) Expanding YouTube’s child safety policies. YouTube Help, 31 October. Available at: https://support.google.com/youtube/thread/12506319?hl=en

Supplementary Material

Please find the following supplemental material available below.

For Open Access articles published under a Creative Commons License, all supplemental material carries the same license as the article it is associated with.

For non-Open Access articles published, all supplemental material carries a non-exclusive license, and permission requests for re-use of supplemental material or any part of supplemental material shall be sent directly to the copyright owner as specified in the copyright notice associated with the article.

0.00 MB

0.03 MB

0.02 MB