Sensemaking in an online community after financial loss: Enterprising Jamaican investors and the fall of a financial messiah

Abstract

Online communities are popular sites for collective sensemaking. This study explores sensemaking in one such community following the closure of Olint Corp, a highly successful Jamaican investment club. After Olint’s disbanding, Jamaicans reconnected through online communities to make sense of their financial losses, to make sense of Olint – seen variously as an altruistic endeavour, a global currency trader, or Ponzi scheme – and to make sense of themselves as enterprising investors. This narrative inquiry unveils their rich, multi-voiced, fragmented storying of Olint and its founder, once praised as a ‘financial messiah’.

Keywords

Enterprising investors Jamaica narrative online communities Ponzi schemes sensemaking speculation

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Abolafia

(2010) Narrative construction as sensemaking: how a central bank thinks. Organization Studies 31(3): 349–367.

Austin

(2004) ‘In God we trust’: the cultural and social impact of affinity fraud in the African American church, University of Maryland Law Journal of Race, Religion, Gender and Class 4: 365–409.

Bank of Jamaica (2015) Commercial banks weighted deposit rates. Available at: http://boj.org.jm/statistics/econdata/stats_list.php?type=5

Berger

Messerschmidt

(2009) Babbling before banking? Online communities and pre-purchase information seeking. International Journal of Bank Marketing 27: 446–466.

Boje

(2001) Narrative Methods for Organizational & Communication Research. London: SAGE.

Brown

Gabriel

Gherardi

(2009) Storytelling and change. Organization 16: 323–333.

Brownlow

O’Dell

(2002) Ethical issues for qualitative research in on-line communities. Disability & Society 17: 685–694.

Campbell

Fletcher

Greenhill

(2009) Conflict and identity shape shifting in an online financial community. Information Systems Journal 19: 461–478.

Caribbean Policy Research Institute (CaPRI) (2007) Taking Responsibility: The Jamaican Economy since Independence. Kingston, Jamaica: CaPRI.

10.

Caribbean Policy Research Institute (CaPRI) (2008) Investigating Informal Investment Schemes in Jamaica. Kingston, Jamaica: CaPRI.

11.

Carvajal

Monroe

Pattillo

. (2009) Ponzi Schemes in the Caribbean. Washington, DC: International Monetary Fund.

12.

Cox

(1997) Into the age of miracles: culture, religion, and the market revolution. World Policy Journal 14: 87–95.

13.

Dawes

(2004) Rescuing Jamaica. Daily Gleaner, 23 October. Available at: http://jamaica-gleaner.com/gleaner/20041023/mind/mind1.html

14.

Ennis

(2007) Ennis says Olint raid was vulgar abuse of state power. Jamaica Observer, 24 January, p. 1.

15.

Espeut

(2011) Lessons from Olint. Daily Gleaner, 19 August. Available at: http://jamaica-gleaner.com/gleaner/20110819/cleisure/cleisure2.html

16.

Financial Services Commission (FSC) (2006) FSC Cease & Desist Order. Kingston, Jamaica: FSC.

17.

French

Kneale

(2009) Excessive Financialisation: Insuring Lifestyles, Enlivening Subjects, and Everyday Spaces of Biosocial Excess. Environment and Planning D: Society and Space. 27: 1030–53.

18.

Gayle

(2002) The impact of financial services globalization upon the Caribbean common market. The Review of Policy Research 19: 107–129.

19.

Hall

(2010) Oh God! Oh no! Olint! Sunday Gleaner, 22 August. Available at: http://jamaica-gleaner.com/gleaner/20100822/lead/lead2.html

20.

Herrmann

(2007) Stockholders in cyberspace: Weick’s sensemaking online. Journal of Business Communication 44: 13–35.

21.

Hull

James

(2012) Popular economies in South Africa. Africa – Journal of the International African Institute 82: 1–19.

22.

Hunt

(2000) Globalisation and the impact of the health and wealth gospel. Journal of Contemporary Religion 15: 331–347.

23.

Investforlife (2008a) About us – rules, Investforlife – Real Investments for Life. Available at: http://investforlife.wordpress.com/about/

24.

Investforlife (2008b) Olint local offices closed. Investforlife – Real Investments for Life. Available at: http://investforlife.wordpress.com/2008/07/14/olint-office-closed/

25.

Krige

(2012) Fields of dreams, fields of schemes: Ponzi finance and multi-level marketing in South Africa. Africa – Journal of the International African Institute 82: 69–92.

26.

KYC News (2008) The pen is mightier than the fraud. Offshore Alert, 31 October, p. 141.

27.

Langley

(2007) Uncertain subjects of Anglo-American financialization. Cultural Critique 65: 67–91.

28.

Martin

(2002) Financialization of Daily Life. Philadelphia, PA: Temple University Press.

29.

Meagher

(2009) Trading on faith. Journal of Modern African Studies 47: 397–423.

30.

Meikle

(2006) Be careful of your greed, Lee Chin warns investors. Jamaica Observer, 29 September. Available at: http://jamaica-gleaner.com/gleaner/20060929/business/business7.html

31.

National Integrity Action (NIA) (2013) The cost of corruption: Jamaica’s barrier to prosperity. NIA (producer), Video recording. Available at: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=PEZnDCMvjO8

32.

Olint

TCI

(2008) Private Club Member Agreement. Turks and Caicos: Olint TCI Corporation; Hallmark Bank & Trust Ltd.

33.

Preda

(2009) Framing Finance. Chicago, IL: University of Chicago Press.

34.

Reid

(2009) ‘I believed in David’ – Olint investors losing hope. Sunday Gleaner, 8 February. Available at: http://jamaica-gleaner.com/gleaner/20090208/news/news1.html

35.

Sproull

Arriaga

(2008) Online communities. In: Bidgoli

(ed.) Handbook of Computer Networks, vol. 3. Hoboken, NJ: John Wiley & Sons, pp. 898–914.

36.

Stone

(1985) Class, State and Democracy in Jamaica. New York: Blackett Publishers.

37.

Stone

(1994) The Stone Columns: The Last Year’s Work. Kingston, JA: Sangsters.

38.

Tarim

(2012) Storytelling and structural incoherence in financial markets. Journal of Interdisciplinary Economics 24(2): 115–144.

39.

US District Court (2011) United States of America v. David A. Smith. Case No.6:10-cr, 28 March, US District Court Middle District of Florida, Orlando, FL.

40.

Weger

Aakhus

(2003) Arguing in internet chat rooms. Argumentation and Advocacy 40: 23–29.

41.

Weick

(1993) The collapse of sensemaking in organizations: the Mann Gulch disaster. Administrative Science Quarterly 38: 628–652.

42.

Weick

(1995) Sensemaking in Organizations. Thousand Oaks, CA: SAGE.

43.

Whittle

Mueller

(2011) Bankers in the dock: moral storytelling in action. Human Relations 65: 111–139.