Sage Journals: Discover world-class research

Abstract

This article describes users’ responses to human-like characteristics of two health promotion IVR systems. We conducted a qualitative evaluation of two systems that promoted physical activity and healthy dietary behavior respectively. Two themes that emerged dealt with favorable responses of the users to the machine’s intrinsic qualities of being insentient and non-judgmental, and the users’ precarious sensitivity to certain human-like characteristics of the systems, namely, the content of the scripts and the recorded human voice. The article suggests that design factors that are intended to enhance human-like characteristics of these applications elicit both positive and negative responses. Thus, even though many users enjoyed and appreciated the human-like performance of the machine, some who were more sensitive about their exercise or dietary behavior preferred a non-affective response by these systems, i.e. they preferred the system to behave like a ‘machine’ (without emotions) rather than a ‘person’.

Keywords

affective computing anthropomorphism health promotion human-computer interaction qualitative evaluation

References

Warner Slack . Cybermedicine: How Computing Empowers Doctors and Patients for Better Health Care. San Francisco: Jossey-Bass , 2001.

Skinner C S , Siegfried J C , Legler M C , Strecher V J. The potential of computers in patient education . Patient Education and Counseling 1993; 22; 22-34 .

Friedman R , Stollerman J , Mahoney D , Rozenblyum L. The virtual visit: using telecommunications technology to take care of patients . Journal of the American Medical Informatics Association 1997; 4; 413-425 .

Friedman R. Automated telephone conversations to assess health behavior and deliver behavioral interventions . Journal of Medical Systems 1998; 22; 95-102 .

Revere D , Dunbar P. Review of computer-generated outpatient health behavior interventions: clinical encounters ‘in absentia’ . Journal of the American Medical Informatics Association 2001; 8; 62-79 .

Picard R. Affective Computing. Cambridge, MA: MIT Press , 2000.

Lisetti C L , Nasoz F , Lerouge C , Ozyer O , Alvarez K. Developing multimodal intelligent affective interfaces for tele-home health care . International Journal of Human-Computer Studies 2003; 59; 245-255 .

Koda T , Maes P. Agents with faces: the effects of personification . Proceedings of Human-Computer Interaction, 1996, London.

King W J , Ohya J. The representation of agents: anthropomorphism, agency, and intelligence . Proceedings of Human-Computer Interaction, 1996, London.

10.

Shankararaman V ed. Proceedings of the Workshop on Agents in Health Care. 4th International Conference on Autonomous Agents, 2000, Barcelona.

11.

Corts U , Fox F , Moreno A. Proceedings of the Workshop on Agent Applications in Health Care. 15th European Conference on Artificial Intelligence, 2002, Lyon.

12.

Bickmore T , Gruber A , Picard R. Establishing the computer-patient working alliance in automated health behavior interventions . Patient Education and Counseling 2005; in press.

13.

Don A. Anthropomorphism: from Eliza to Terminator 2 . Paper presented at CHI, 3-7 May 1992.

14.

Weizenbaum, J. ELIZA - a computer program for the study of natural language communication between man and machine . Communications of the Association for Computing Machinery 1965; 9(1); 36-45 .

15.

Laurel B. Interface agents: metaphors with character. In The Art of Human-Computer Interface Design. Reading, MA: Addison-Wesley , 1990.

16.

Turner C , Ku L , Rogers S M , Lindberg L D , Pleck J H. Adolescent sexual behavior, drug use, and violence: increased reporting with computer survey technology . Science 1998; 280; 867-873 .

17.

Gerbert B , Bronstone A , Pantilat S , McPhee S , Allerton M , Moe, J. When asked, patients tell: disclosure of sensitive health-risk behaviors . Medical Care 1999; 37; 104-111 .

18.

Farzanfar R , Frishkopf S , Migneault J , Friedman R. Telephone-Linked Care for Physical Activity (TLC-PA): a qualitative evaluation of the use patterns of an information technology program for patients . Journal of Biomedical Informatics 2005; 38; 220-228 .

19.

Delichatsios H K , Friedman R H , Glanz K , Tennstedt S , Smigelski C , Pinto B M , Kelley H , Gillman M W. Randomized trial of a ‘talking computer’ to improve adults’ eating habits . American Journal of Health Promotion 2000; 15; 215-224 .

20.

Pinto B M , Friedman R , Marcus B H , Kelley H , Tennstedt S , Gillman M W. Effects of a computer-based, telephone-counseling system on physical activity . American Journal of Preventive Medicine 2002; 23; 113-120 .

21.

Ramelson H , Friedman R , Ockene J. An automated telephone-based smoking cessation education and counseling system . Patient Education and Counseling 1999; 36; 131-143 .

22.

Friedman R , Kazis L , Jette A , Smith M B , Stollerman J , Togerson J , Carey K. A telecommunications system for monitoring and counseling patients with hypertension: impact on medication adherence and blood pressure control . American Journal of Hypertension 1996; 2; 285-292 .

23.

Farzanfar R , Locke S E , Vachon L , Charbonneau A M , Friedman R H. Computer telephony to improve adherence to antidepressants and clinical visits . Annals of Behavioral Medicine Annual Meeting 2003; 25; S161-S161 .

24.

Pate R R , Pratt M , Blair S N , et al. Physical activity and public health: a recommendation from the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention and the American College of Sports Medicine . Journal of the American Medical Association 1995; 273; 402-407 .

25.

Pearson T A , Brown W V , Donato K. et al. Lipids, Workshop IV . Circulation 1993; 88; 1397-1401 .

26.

Prochaska J O , DiClemente C C. Stages and processes of self-change in smoking: towards an integrative model of change . Journal of Consulting and Clinical Psychology 1983; 51; 390-395 .

27.

Bandura A. Self-efficacy: toward a unifying theory of behavioral change . Psychology Review 1977; 84; 191-215 .

28.

Glanz K , Shigaki D , Farzanfar R , Pinto B , Kaplan B , Friedman R. Participant reactions to a computerized telephone system for nutrition and exercise counseling . Patient Education & Counseling 2003; 49; 157-163 .

29.

Glaser B , Strauss A. The Discovery of Grounded Theory: Strategies of Qualitative Research. London: Wiedenfield & Nicholson , 1967.

30.

Patton M Q. Qualitative Evaluation and Research Methods. London: Sage , 1990.

31.

Strauss A. Qualitative Analysis for Social Scientists. New York: Cambridge University Press , 1987.

32.

Strauss A , Corbin J. Basics of Qualitative Research: Grounded Theory Procedures and Techniques. New York: Wiley , 1984.

33.

Farzanfar R , Frishkopf S , Friedman R , Ludena K. Evaluating an automated mental health care system: making meaning of human-computer interaction . Computers in Human Behavior, in press.

34.

Nass C , Moon Y. Machines and mindlessness: social responses to computers . Journal of Social Issues 2000; 56; 81-103 .

35.

Nass C , Moon Y , Green N. Are machines gender neutral? Gender-stereotypic responses to computers with voices . Journal of Applied Social Psychology 1997; 27; 864-876 .

36.

Lee E J , Nass C , Brave S. Can computer-generated speech have gender? An experimental test of gender stereotype. CHI 2000 Extended Abstracts 289-290. New York: ACM , 2000.

37.

Turner C F , Ku L , Rogers S M , Lindberg L D , Pleck J H , Sonenstein F L. Adolescent sexual behavior, drug use and violence: increased reporting with computer survey technology . Science 1998; 280; 867-873 .

38.

Tourangeau R , Couper M P , Steiger D M. Humanizing self-administered surveys: experiments on social presence in web and IVR surveys . Computers in Human Behavior 2003; 19; 1-24 .

39.

Couper M P , Singer E , Tourangeau R. Does voice matter? An Interactive Voice Response (IVR) experiment . Journal of Official Statistics 2004; 20; 551-570 .

40.

Scheibe K E , Erwin M. The computer as alter . Journal of Social Psychology 1979; 108; 103-109 .

41.

Turkle S. Life on the Screen: Identity in the Age of the Internet.. New York: Simon & Schuster , 1995.

42.

Turkle S. Computers and the Human Spirit. New York: Simon & Schuster , 1984.

43.

Reeves B , Nass C. The Media Equation: How People Treat Computers, Television, and New Media Like Real People and Places. New York: Cambridge University Press , 1996.

44.

Nass C , Fogg B J , Moon Y. Can computers be teammates ? International Journal of Human-Computer Studies 1996; 669-678 .

45.

Nass C , Steuer J , Henriksen L , Dryer C. Machines, social and ethopoeia: performance assessments of computers subsequent to self-or other-evaluations . International Journal of Human-Computer Studies 1994; 40; 543-562 .

46.

Moon Y. How ‘real’ are computer personalities? Psychological responses to personality types in human-computer interaction . Communication Research 1996; 23; 651-674 .

47.

Nass C , Gong L. Speech interfaces from an evolutionary perspective: social psychological research and design implications . Communications of the ACM 2000; 43; 36-43 .

48.

Reid, A A L. Comparing telephone with face-to-face contact. In Ithiel de Sola Pool ed. The Social Impact of the Telephone. Cambridge, MA: MIT Press , 1977.

49.

Rutter D R. Communicating by Telephone. Oxford: Pergamon , 1987.

50.

Chery C. On communication, ancient and modern. In Potter D , Sarre P eds Dimensions of Society: A Reader. London: University of London Press , 1974.

51.

Ihde D. Technology and the Lifeworld: from Garden to Eden. Bloomington, IN: Indiana University Press , 1990.

52.

Lisetti C L , LeRouge C. Affective computing in tele-home health . In Proceedings of the 37th Hawaii International Conference on System Sciences, 2004.

53.

Prendinger H , Mayer S , Mori J , Ishizuka M. Personal effect revisited: using bio-signals to measure and reflect the impact of character-based interfaces . Proceedings of Intelligent Virtual Agents 2003; 283-301 .

54.

Prendinger H , Ishizuka M eds. Life-Like Characters: Tools, Affective Functions, and Applications. Berlin: Springer , 2004.

55.

Weizenbaum J. Computer Power and Human Reason. San Francisco, CA: Freeman , 1976.

56.

Dreyfus H. Mind Over Machine. New York: Free , 1986.

57.

Dreyfus H. What Computers Still Can’t Do: A Critique of Artificial Reason. Cambridge, MA: MIT Press , 1992.

58.

Schneiderman B. Designing the User Interface: Strategies for Effective Human-Computer Interaction. Reading, MA: Addison-Wesley , 1998.

When computers should remain computers: a qualitative look at the humanization of health care technology

Abstract

Keywords

References