Review : The Sick Building Syndrome: Where Are We in 1992?

Abstract

Independent epidemiological studies in the UK, Denmark, Holland, Sweden and Germany have identified a group of common symptoms that are tempo rarily related to occupancy of office buildings. The principal symptoms are lethargy, headache, blocked nose and dry eyes, throat and skin. The average number of work-related symptoms per building occupant (the building symp tom index) varies widely between buildings in all these studies. In general, air-conditioned buildings are sicker than naturally ventilated ones, despite indoor environments that conform more closely to environmental comfort standards. Sicker buildings are assessed by their occupants as drier and stuffier than healthier buildings, however, the sensation of dryness relates to increased temperature rather than water content of the air, and stuffiness does not relate to the air change rates. There is an association between the presence of humid ifiers and chillers and sicker buildings. It is likely that either soluble products from micro-organisms, or the biocides used to control them, are the link between symptoms and air-conditioning. Control over the indoor environ ment depends on better design, and improved training, supervision and work practices of those maintaining the building plant.

Keywords

Sick building syndrome Epidemiology Humidifiers Chillers Temperature Stress Microbial contamination

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Finnegan MJ , Pickering Cac , Burge PS : Sick building syndrome; Prevalence studies. Br Med J 1984; 289:1573-1575.

Burge PS , Hedge A. , Wilson S, Harris Bass J, Robertson AS: Sick building syndrome; A study of 4,373 office workers . Ann Occup Hyg 1987;31:493-504.

Skov P. , Valbjorn O. : The sick building syndrome in the office environment; The Danish town hall study. Environ Int 1987 ;13:339-349.

Preller L. , Zweers T. , Boleij Jsm , Brunekreef B. : Gezondheidsklachten en klachten over het binnenklimaat in kantoorgebouwen . Amsterdam, Directoraat-Generaal van der Arbeid, 1990, p 83.

Stenberg B. , Mild KH , Sandstrom M. , Lonnberg G. , Wall S. , Sundell J. , Zingmark PA : The office illness project in northern Sweden. 1. A prevalence study of sick building syndrome related to demographic data, work characteristics and building factors. Indoor Air 90 1990 ;4:627-632.

Kroling P. : Gesundheit Haustechnik Bauphysik Umwelttechnik 1987;108:121-131.

Kroling P. : Health and well-being disorders in air-conditioned buildings; comparative investigations of the building illness syndrome. Energy Buildings 1988; 11:277-282.

Anderson I. , Lundquist GR , Proctor DF : Human perception of humidity under four controlled conditions. Arch Environ Health 1973; 26:22-27.

Menzies RI , Tamblyn RM , Tamblyn RT , Farant JP , Hanley J. , Spitzer WO : Sick building syndrome: The effect of changes in ventilation rates on symptom prevalence. The evaluation of a double-blind experimental approach. Indoor Air 90 1990; 1:519-524.

10.

Gorman RW , Wallingford KM : The NIOSH approach to conducting indoor air quality investigations in office buildings; in Nagda NL , Harper JP (eds): Design and Protocol for Monitoring Indoor Air Quality. ASTM STP 1002. Philadelphia, American Society for Testing and Materials, 1989, pp 63-72.

11.

American Society of Heating , Refrigeration and Air Conditioning Engineers. Atlanta, American National Standard Ventilation for Acceptable Indoor Air Quality 62, 1981.

12.

Burge PS , Jones P. , Robertson AS : Sick buidling syndrome: Environmental comparisons of sick and healthy buildings . Indoor Air 90 1990;1: 479-483.

13.

Robertson AS , Burge PS , Wieland GA , Car-malt MHB: Extrinsic allergic alveolitis caused by a cold-water humidifier . Thorax 1987;42: 32-37.

14.

Clark EG : Risk of isothiazolinones. J Soc Occup Med 1987;37:30-31.

15.

Burge HA : Indoor sources of indoor air microbes; in Gammage R, Kaye S, Jacobs V (eds): Indoor Air and Human Health. Chelsea, Lewis, 1984.

16.

Harrison J. , Pickering Cac , Faragher EB , Austwick Pkc : An investigation of the relationship between microbial and particulate indoor air pollution and the sick building syndrome . Indoor Air 90 1990; 1:149-154.

17.

Harrison J. , Pickering Cac , Finnegan MJ , Austwick Pkc : The sick building syndrome, further prevalence studies and investigation of possible causes. Indoor Air 87 1987 ;2:487-491.

18.

Reinikainen LM , Jaakkola Jjk , Helenius T. , Seppnen O. : The effect of air humidification on symptoms and environmental complaints in office workers. A six-period cross-over study . Indoor Air 90 1990;1:775-780.

19.

Jaakkola Jjk , Heinonen OP , Seppnen O. : Sick building syndrome, sensation of dryness and thermal comfort in relation to room temperature in an office building: Need for individual control of temperature. Environ Int 1989; 15: 163-168.

20.

CIBS Guide , vol A, section A1 - Environmental Comfort. London, Charted Institute of Building Services, 1976.

21.

Robertson AS , Burge PS , Hedge A. , Wilson S. , Harris-Bass J. : The relationship between passive cigarette smoke exposure in office workers and the symptoms of building sickness; in Perry R , Kirk P (eds): Indoor and Ambient Air Quality. London, Selper, 1988, pp 320-326.

22.

Leinster P. , Raw G. , Thomson N. , Leaman A. , Whitehead C. , Pickering Cac , Burge PS : A modular longitudinal approach to the investigation of sick building syndrome. Indoor Air 90 1990;1:287-292.

23.

Hedge A. , Erickson WA , Rubin G. : Relationship between occupational and personal factors and sick building syndrome symptoms in air-conditioned offices. Am J Public Health, in press.

24.

Nilsen A. : Facial rash in visual display unit operators. Contact Dermatitis 1982;8:25-28.

25.

Hedge A. , Burge PS , Robertson AS , Wilson S. , Harris-Bass J: Work-related illness in offices: A proposed model of the sick building syndrome. Environ Int 1989;15:143-158.