Improving fitness centre indoor environment comfort and health: A method for evaluating indoor environmental quality based on subjective and objective factors
Restricted accessResearch articleFirst published online June, 2025
Improving fitness centre indoor environment comfort and health: A method for evaluating indoor environmental quality based on subjective and objective factors
Compared to other indoor environments, indoor environments of fitness centre exhibit notable variations in heat, humidity and air quality. In this study, a 2-month field study was conducted on two fitness centres in a cold region of China. The results of this study revealed that fitness centres have high levels of indoor air pollutants, with significant variations in temperature and humidity. Moreover, the majority of individuals expressed dissatisfaction with the indoor environmental quality of fitness centres. The thermal comfort in fitness centres was closely associated with the ambient temperature and humidity. Amongst the pollutants affecting indoor air quality in fitness centres, carbon dioxide (CO2) was shown to produce the most significant impact, followed by formaldehyde (CH2O), total volatile organic compounds (TVOC) and particulate matter (PM2.5). In this study, a comprehensive evaluation model was developed to provide a reference for assessing the indoor environmental quality of fitness centres. The findings of this study can serve as a scientific foundation for the design and decoration of fitness centres, aiming to enhance the comfort and healthiness of the exercise environment.
CuiYBFanCLZhouXQLiL. Factor analysis and risk assessment of indoor environmental parameters and TSV in fitness centres under different zones, exercise intensities and times. Indoor Built Environ2024; 33: 1067–1086.
2.
ZhangDOrtizMABluyssenPM. A review on indoor environmental quality in sports facilities: indoor air quality and ventilation during a pandemic. Indoor Built Environ2023; 32: 831–851.
3.
LiuSZhouZHZhuYXLinBRZhaoHTDengZH. Study on human thermal comfort for indoor medium and high intensity exercises (in Chinese). Heat Ventil Air Condition2023; 53: 66–71+110.
4.
SlezakovaKPeixotoCOliveiraMDelerue-MatosCPereiraMDCMoraisS. Indoor particulate pollution in fitness centres with emphasis on ultrafine particles. Environ Pollut2017; 233: 180–193.
5.
HuesslerEMHüsingAVancraeyenestMJöckelKHSchröderB. Air quality in an air ventilated fitness centre reopening for pilot study during COVID-19 pandemic lockdown. Build Environ2022; 219: 109180.
6.
CalderAMMulliganHF. Measurement properties of instruments that assess inclusive access to fitness and recreational sports centres: a systematic review. Disabil Health J2014; 7: 26–35.
7.
OnchangRPanyakapoM. The physical environments and microbiological contamination in three different fitness centres and the participants’ expectations: measurement and analysis. Indoor Built Environ2014; 25: 213–228.
8.
GurrieriSDi MartinoRMRCamardaMFrancofonteV. Monitoring CO2 hazards of volcanic origin: a case study at the Island of Vulcano (Italy) during 2021–2022. Geosciences2023; 13: 266.
9.
CarapezzaMLTarchiniLAnconaCForastiereFRanaldiMRicciTSimoneGDMataloniFPagliucaNMBarberiF. Health impact of natural gas emission at Cava dei Selci residential zone (metropolitan city of Rome, Italy). Environ Geochem Health2022; 45: 707–729.
10.
WeiWLiYWangYChengSWangL. Characteristics of VOCs during haze and non-haze days in Beijing, China: concentration, chemical degradation and regional transport impact. Atmos Environ2018; 194: 134–145.
11.
HaoRSunJLLiuRZhaoHAYaoZWangHLHaoZP. Emission characteristics, environmental impact, and health risk assessment of volatile organic compounds (VOCs) during manicure processes. Sci Total Environ2024; 906: 167464.
12.
MaiJLYangWWZengYGuanYFChenSJ. Volatile organic compounds (VOCs) in residential indoor air during interior finish period: sources, variations, and health risks. Hyg Environ Health Adv2024; 9: 100087.
13.
ChoEYoonHChoY. Evaluation of the impact of intensive PM2.5 reduction policy in Seoul, South Korea using machine learning. Urban Clim2024; 53: 101778.
14.
HugSMHartigTHansmannRSeelandKHornungR. Restorative qualities of indoor and outdoor exercise settings as predictors of exercise frequency. Health Place2009; 15: 971–980.
15.
AndradeADominskiFHCoimbraDR. Scientific production on indoor air quality of environments used for physical exercise and sports practice: bibliometric analysis. J Environ Manag2017; 196: 188–200.
16.
HuangXDChenGZhaoCPengYXGuoWZ. Post occupancy evaluation of indoor environmental quality of sports buildings at hot and humid climate from the perspective of exercisers. Build Environ2022; 226: 109760.
17.
AndradeADominskiFH. Indoor air quality of environments used for physical exercise and sports practice: systematic review. J Environ Manag2018; 206: 577–586.
18.
XuADongYSunYTDuanHQZhangRN. Thermal comfort performance prediction method using sports centre layout images in several cold cities based on CNN. Build Environ2023; 245: 110917.
19.
ZhangZFWangMWXuZYeYMChenSNPanYJChenJQ. The influence of community sports parks on residents’ subjective well-being: a case study of Zhuhai City, China. Habitat Int2021; 117: 102439.
20.
GuoTMHuSTLiuGD. Evaluation model of specific indoor environment overall comfort based on effective-function method. Energies2017; 10: 1634.
21.
AssimakopoulosMNDounisASpanouASantamourisM. Indoor air quality in a metropolitan area metro using fuzzy logic assessment system. Sci Total Environ2013; 449: 461–469.
22.
LiZZhangQWFanFShenSZ. A comprehensive comfort assessment method for indoor environmental quality in university open-plan offices in severe cold regions. Build Environ2021; 197: 107845.
23.
TangHDingYSingerB. Interactions and comprehensive effect of indoor environmental quality factors on occupant satisfaction. Build Environ2020; 167: 106462.
24.
LiCHBaiLHeZJWangYJ. Health risk assessment of heavy metals and poly-aromatic hydrocarbons in particulate matter adsorbed by indoor air purifiers. Indoor Built Environ2022; 31: 1594–1612.
25.
CuiYBaiLLiCHHeZJLiuXR. Assessment of heavy metal contamination levels and health risks in environmental media in the northeast region. Sustain Cities Soc2022; 80: 103796.
26.
MaoYDZhuKYZhengZMFangZS. Evaluation of the thermal comfort in different commercial buildings in Guangzhou. Indoor Built Environ2024; 33: 391–413.
27.
ASHRAE, ANSI/ASHRAE Standard 55-2020. Thermal environmental conditions for human occupancy. Atlanta, Georgia: ASHRAE, 2020.
28.
EN ISO 10551-2019. Ergonomics of the physical environment – subjective judgement scales for assessing physical environments. Brussels: European Committee for Standardization, 2019, pp.5–7.
29.
TaiCMTianGSLeiWJ. Measurement of indoor environmental parameters and analysis of the condensation phenomenon in urban utility tunnels. Indoor Built Environ2022; 31: 1091–1106.
30.
XiaYQXuTYShiCYTianLZhangTFukudaH. Research on indoor thermal comfort of traditional dwellings in Northeast Sichuan based on the thermal comfort evaluation model and EnergyPlus. Energy Rep2024; 12: 5234–5248.
31.
GB/T18883-2002. Indoor air quality standard. Beijing, China: China Standard Press, 2002.
32.
XiCHanLWangJQFengZBKumarPCaoSJ. How can greenery space mitigate urban heat island? An analysis of cooling effect, carbon sequestration, and nurturing cost at the street scale. J Clean Prod2023; 419: 138230.
33.
XiCDingJWWangJQFengZBCaoSJ. Nature-based solution of greenery configuration design by comprehensive benefit evaluation of microclimate environment and carbon sequestration. Energy Build2022; 270: 112264.
34.
PatialdSNazimMParwaz KhanAARaizadaPSinghPHussaiCMAsiriAM. Sustainable solutions for indoor pollution abatement during COVID phase: a critical study on current technologies & challenges. J Hazard Mater Adv2022; 7: 100097.
35.
Chandia-PobleteDCole-HunterTHaswellMHeeschKC. The influence of air pollution exposure on the short- and long-term health benefits associated with active mobility: a systematic review. Sci Total Environ2022; 850: 157978.
36.
SuiXMTianZJLiuHTChenHWangD. Field measurements on indoor air quality of a residential building in Xi'an under different ventilation modes in winter. J Build Eng2021; 42: 103040.
37.
ZhangJYWuLY. The influence of population movements on the urban relative humidity of Beijing during the Chinese Spring festival holiday. J Clean Prod2018; 170: 1508–1513.
38.
HuangSDSongSJNielsenCPZhangYQXiongJYWeschlerLBXieSDLiJ. Residential building materials: an important source of ambient formaldehyde in mainland China. Env Int2022; 158: 106909.
39.
LiCHBaiLWangHLiGMCuiYB. Characteristics of indoor and outdoor Polycyclic Aromatic Hydrocarbons (PAHs) pollution in TSP in rural northeast China: a case study of heating and non-heating periods. J Env Health Sci Eng2022; 20: 899–913.
40.
JinHYChenXHZhongRDLiuMY. Influence and prediction of PM2.5 through multiple environmental variables in China. Sci Total Environ2022; 849: 157910.
41.
HuangHMWangZWDaiCHGuoJZhangXS. Volatile organic compounds emission in the rubber products manufacturing processes. Environ Res2022; 212: 113485.
42.
FangZSZhangPWuPHLiLZhengZM. Effects of different metabolic rates on thermal comfort in a warmer thermal environment. J Build Eng2023; 80: 108030.
43.
AvciABBalciGABasaranT. Optimizing thermal comfort in physical exercise spaces: a study of spatial and thermal factors. Energy Build2024; 303: 113782.
44.
LiuGChenHZYuanYSongCG. Indoor thermal environment and human health: a systematic review. Renew Sustain Energy Rev2024; 191: 114164.
45.
HamanFPéronnetFKennyGPMassicotteDLavoieCWeberJM. Partitioning oxidative fuels during cold exposure in humans: muscle glycogen becomes dominant as shivering intensifies. J Physiol2005; 566: 247–256.
46.
MavrogianniAJohnsonFUcciMMarmotAWardleJOreszczynTSummerfieldA. Historic variations in winter indoor domestic temperatures and potential implications for body weight gain. Indoor Built Environ2011; 22: 360–375.
47.
ThamSThompsonRLandegOMurrayKAWaiteT. Indoor temperature and health: a global systematic review. Pub Health2020; 179: 9–17.
American College of Sports Medicine. ACSM's health/fitness facility standards and guidelines. 5th Edition. Illinois, USA: Human Kinetics, 2012.
50.
LuDJShenYL. Research and analysis of body-building environment of gymnasium (in Chinese). Sports Sci2012; 33: 9–17.
51.
YangYQLiuYM. The effect of gym environment on human body (in Chinese). J Lanzhou Jiaotong Univy2017; 36: 73–79.
52.
ChenFYFuMLiYYShenSFYangJWengWG. A numerical tool for assessing human thermal safety and thermal comfort in cold-weather activities. Int J Biometeorol2023; 67: 377–388.
53.
WangCQLiCXieLWangXRChangLWangXMLiHXLiuYQ. Thermal environment and thermal comfort in metro systems: a case study in severe cold region of China. Build Environ2023; 227: 109758.
54.
DávilaJSGrigolettiGCFariaMRGoboJPA. The thermal comfort of pedestrians in a humid subtropical climate according to different thermal perception ratings. Int J Biometeorol2024; 68: 675–690.
55.
PeiJJQuMNSunLYWangXYYinYH. The relationship between indoor air quality (IAQ) and perceived air quality (PAQ) – a review and case analysis of Chinese residential environment. Energy Built Environ2022; 5: 230–243.
56.
WolkofPWilkinsCKClausenPANielsenGD. Organic compounds in office environments–sensory irritation, odor, measurements and the role of reactive chemistry. Indoor air2006; 16: 7–19.
57.
LiHQFangCHYShiWXGurusamySLiSZKrishnanMNGeorgeS. Size and site dependent biological hazard potential of particulate matters collected from different heights at the vicinity of a building construction. Toxicol Lett2015; 238: 20–29.
58.
ChenXCLuoQWangDHGaoJJWeiZWangZJZhouHDMazumderA. Simultaneous assessments of occurrence, ecological, human health, and organoleptic hazards for 77 VOCs in typical drinking water sources from 5 major river basins, China. Environl Pollut2015; 206: 64–72.
59.
GuanYXiaoYRongBKangLZhangNNChuCJ. Heterogeneity and typology of the city-level synergy between CO2 emission, PM2.5, and ozone pollution in China. J Clean Prodn2023; 405: 136871.
60.
DeveauMWilleSM. Derivation and application of indoor air screening values for inhalation exposure to semi-volatile organic compounds. Regul Toxicol Pharmacol2023; 143: 105463.
