Strict and simultaneous space temperature and humidity controls are often required in many applications, such as hospitals, laboratories, cleanrooms for pharmaceutical and semiconductor manufacturing. The energy intensity in such applications can be up to 100 times than typical office buildings, mainly due to the improper system design and control. Although some uncertainty-based design methods have been developed for air-conditioning systems, most of the existing systems are designed based on a certain ventilation mode while neglecting the life-cycle performance of the components. This study, therefore, proposes a robust optimal design method for cleanroom air-conditioning systems, considering the uncertainties in design parameters for inputs and operation strategies as well as the life-cycle performance of components. An adaptive full-range decoupled ventilation strategy, which incorporated five operation modes, was adopted in the design optimization. Two maintenance modes were adopted and compared to consider the flexibility of maintenance. The proposed design method has been implemented and validated in the design optimization of an existing air-conditioning system. The results showed that, compared with the conventional design, up to 54% reduction of life-cycle costs and superior satisfaction of services could be achieved by using the proposed method.
Berkeley Lab. Labs21 benchmarking tool. Lab 21st century, https://lbt.i2sl.org/ (2019, accessed 6 January 2019).
3.
MathewP.An estimate of energy use in laboratories, cleanrooms, and data centers in New York. Lawrence Berkeley Natl Lab Report, Berkeley, US, 2008.
4.
MillsE.Energy efficiency in California laboratory-type facilities. Lawrence Berkeley Natl Lab Report, Berkeley, US, 1996.
5.
KircherKShiXPatilSZhangKM.Cleanroom energy efficiency strategies: modeling and simulation. Energy Build2010;
42: 282–289.
6.
McIlvaineRW.China is changing the world’s cleanroom industry. Clean Rooms2005;
19: 12–13.
7.
TschudiWXuT.Cleanroom energy benchmarking results. Lawrence Berkeley Natl Lab Report, Berkeley, US, 2001.
8.
ChenH-JWangDWPChenS-L.Optimization of an ice-storage air conditioning system using dynamic programming method. Appl Therm Eng2005;
25: 461–472.
9.
HuangPHuangGWangY.HVAC system design under peak load prediction uncertainty using multiple-criterion decision making technique. Energy Build2015;
91: 26–36.
10.
NemeCNadelSProctorJ.Energy savings potential from addressing residential air conditioner and heat pump installation problems.
Washington, DC:
American Council for an Energy-Efficient Economy, 1999.
11.
ZhuangCQWangSWShanK.Adaptive full-range decoupled ventilation strategy and air-conditioning systems for cleanrooms and buildings requiring strict humidity control and their performance evaluation. Energy2019;
168: 883–896.
12.
AktacirMABüyükalacaOBulutHYılmazT.Influence of different outdoor design conditions on design cooling load and design capacities of air conditioning equipments. Energy Convers Manag2008;
49: 1766–1773.
13.
LuY.Practical handbook of heating and air conditioning design.
Beijing, China:
China Build Ind Press, 2008.
14.
PhilipCHChowWK.Sizing of air-conditioning plant for commercial buildings in Hong Kong. Appl Energy2000;
66: 91–103.
15.
SunYGuLWuCFJAugenbroeG.Exploring HVAC system sizing under uncertainty. Energy Build2014;
81: 243–252.
16.
GangWJWangSWShanKGaoDC.Impacts of cooling load calculation uncertainties on the design optimization of building cooling systems. Energy Build2015;
94: 1–9.
17.
WalkerWEHarremoësPRotmansJ, et al.
Defining uncertainty: a conceptual basis for uncertainty management in model-based decision support. Integr Assess2003;
4: 5–17.
18.
ZhuangCQWangSWShanK.Probabilistic optimal design of cleanroom air-conditioning systems facilitating optimal ventilation control under uncertainties. Appl Energy2019;
253: 113576.
19.
ChengQWangSWYanCC.Robust optimal design of chilled water systems in buildings with quantified uncertainty and reliability for minimized life-cycle cost. Energy Build2016;
126: 159–169.
20.
ZhouSCuiWZhaoSZhuS.Operation analysis and performance prediction for a GSHP system compounded with domestic hot water (DHW) system. Energy Build2016;
119: 153–163.
21.
GriffithBLongNTorcelliniPJudkoffRCrawleyDRyanJ.Methodology for modeling building energy performance across the commercial sector.
Golden, CO:
National Renewable Energy Lab. (NREL), 2008.
22.
PiperJE.Operations and maintenance manual for energy management.
London:
Routledge, 2016.
23.
BlahnikDECampTW.Aging assessment of essential HVAC chillers used in nuclear power plants.
Richland:
Pacific Northwest Lab., 1996.
24.
Robert MowrisPMJonesE, AR.Laboratory measurements of HVAC installation and maintenance faults. ASHRAE Trans2012;
118: 165–172.
25.
EleftheriadisGHamdyM.The impact of insulation and HVAC degradation on overall building energy performance: a case study. Buildings2018;
8: 23.
ISO 14644-1. Cleanrooms and associated controlled environments – part 1: classification of air cleanliness by particle concentration. Geneva: Int Organ Stand, 2015.
28.
MacdonaldIA. Quantifying the effects of uncertainty in building simulation. Doctorate thesis, University of Strathclyde, Glasgow, 2002.
29.
HeoYChoudharyRAugenbroeGA.Calibration of building energy models for retrofit analysis under uncertainty. Energy Build2012;
47: 550–560.
30.
HuangPWangYHuangGAugenbroeG.Investigation of the ageing effect on chiller plant maximum cooling capacity using Bayesian Markov Chain Monte Carlo method. J Build Perform Simul2016;
9: 529–541.
31.
De WitSAugenbroeG.Analysis of uncertainty in building design evaluations and its implications. Energy Build2002;
34: 951–958.
32.
KangJWangSW.Robust optimal design of distributed energy systems based on life-cycle performance analysis using a probabilistic approach considering uncertainties of design inputs and equipment degradations. Appl Energy2018;
231: 615–627.
33.
SteinM.Large sample properties of simulations using Latin hypercube sampling. Technometrics1987;
29: 143–151.
34.
ZhouXYanDJiangYShiX.Influence of asynchronous demand behavior on overcooling in multiple zone AC systems. Build Environ2016;
110: 65–75.
35.
HendronR.Building America performance analysis procedures for existing homes.
Golden, CO:
National renewable energy lab (NREL), 2006.
36.
Wang L and Hong T. Modeling and simulation of HVAC faulty operations and performance degradation due to maintenance issues. In: Proceedings of the 1st Asia conference of International Building Performance Simulation Association – Asim2012, Shanghai, China, 25-27 November 2012. https://www.ibpsa.org/proceedings/asim2012/0056.pdf (2012, accessed 31 December 2019).
37.
HuangPHuangGSunY.A robust design of nearly zero energy building systems considering performance degradation and maintenance. Energy2018;
163: 905–919.
38.
MossmanMJ.RSMeans mechanical cost data. Reed Construction Data Construction Publication Consultant, Kingston, 2008
39.
WuSClements-CroomeD.Ratio of operating and maintenance costs to initial costs of building services systems. Cost Eng2007;
49: 30–33.
40.
HangYDuLQuMPeetaS.Multi-objective optimization of integrated solar absorption cooling and heating systems for medium-sized office buildings. Renew Energy2013;
52: 67–78.
41.
AllouhiAKousksouTJamilAEl RhafikiTMouradYZeraouliY.Economic and environmental assessment of solar air-conditioning systems in Morocco. Renew Sustain Energy Rev2015;
50: 770–781.
42.
YangHZhouWLuLFangZ.Optimal sizing method for stand-alone hybrid solar–wind system with LPSP technology by using genetic algorithm. Sol Energy2008;
82: 354–367.
43.
ZhaoBWuJ.Numerical investigation of particle diffusion in a clean room. Indoor Built Environ2005;
14: 469–479.
44.
EkmekciogluDKeskinSS.Characterization of indoor air particulate matter in selected elementary schools in Istanbul, Turkey. Indoor Built Environ2007;
16: 169–176.
45.
RenJCaoS-J.Incorporating online monitoring data into fast prediction models towards the development of artificial intelligent ventilation systems. Sustain Cities Soc2019;
47: 101498.
46.
ZhuH-CYuCWCaoS-J.Ventilation online monitoring and control system from the perspectives of technology application. Indoor Built Environ. Epub ahead of print 4 October 2019. DOI: 10.1177/1420326X19878586
47.
WangSWSunZWSunYJZhuN.Online optimal ventilation control of building air-conditioning systems. Indoor Built Environ2011;
20: 129–136.
48.
RenCCaoS-J.Development and application of linear ventilation and temperature models for indoor environmental prediction and HVAC systems control. Sustain Cities Soc2019;
51: 101673.
