Depression assessment in persons with dementia (PWD) often prioritizes caregiver report, with limited integration of self-report due to concerns about PWD insight.
Objective
This cross-sectional study examined discrepancies between self- and caregiver-reported depression in PWD and identified neuropsychiatric and diagnostic predictors of discordance.
Methods
402 PWD diagnosed with Alzheimer's disease (AD), behavioral variant frontotemporal dementia (bvFTD), semantic variant primary progressive aphasia (svPPA), or progressive supranuclear palsy (PSP) self-reported depression using the Geriatric Depression Scale (GDS), while caregivers completed the Neuropsychiatric Inventory (NPI). Discrepancies were categorized as Concordant (agreement), Discordant Type 1 (self-reported depression denied by caregiver), or Discordant Type 2 (caregiver-reported depression denied by PWD).
Results
One-third (33.8%) of dyads showed discrepancies: 66.2% were concordant, 10.2% Discordant Type 1, and 23.6% Discordant Type 2. PSPs had higher incidence of Type 1 discordance compared to AD (OR = 2.91, p < 0.05), while svPPAs were less likely to incur Type 2 discordance than AD (OR = 0.33, p < 0.01). Higher self-reported GDS Hopelessness, Withdrawal, and Worry predicted higher rates of Type 1 discordance, while lower Dysphoria predicted Type 2 discordance. Higher caregiver-reported NPI Apathy increased odds of Type 1 discordance (OR = 2.46, p < 0.05) and lower NPI Anxiety increased odds of Type 2 discordance (OR = 0.50, p < 0.01). Among cases with Type 1 discordance, caregivers often endorsed PWD apathy, irritability, agitation, or anxiety instead of depression.
Conclusions
Discrepancies in reporting depression in PWD can reflect underreporting by caregivers, not only denial by PWD. Integrating self-report, caregiver input, and clinical judgment may improve diagnostic accuracy for depression in PWD and improve care.
LeeBWangYCarlsonSA, et al.National, state-level, and county-level prevalence estimates of adults aged ≥18 years self-reporting a lifetime diagnosis of depression — United States, 2020. MMWR Morb Mortal Wkly Rep2023; 72: 644–650.
2.
American Psychiatry Association. Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders. Washington, DC: American Psychiatry Association, 2022.
3.
RovnerBWGermanPSBrantLJ, et al.Depression and mortality. JAMA1991; 265: 993–996.
4.
WilsonRSBennettDABieniasJL, et al.Cognitive activity and cognitive decline in a biracial community population. Neurology2003; 61: 812–816.
5.
EskaKGraesselEDonathC, et al.Predictors of institutionalization of dementia patients in mild and moderate stages: a 4-year prospective analysis. Dement Geriatr Cogn Dis Extra2013; 3: 426.
6.
WilsonRSBarnesLLMendes De LeonCF, et al.Depressive symptoms, cognitive decline, and risk of AD in older persons. Neurology2002; 59: 364–370.
7.
StewartR. Depressive symptoms and cognitive decline–disentangling the effect of affect. J Neurol Neurosurg Psychiatry2004; 75: 5.
8.
GaltsCPCBettioLEBJewettDC, et al.Depression in neurodegenerative diseases: common mechanisms and current treatment options. Neurosci Biobehav Rev2019; 102: 56–84.
9.
CollinsJDHenleySMDSuárez-GonzálezA. A systematic review of the prevalence of depression, anxiety, and apathy in frontotemporal dementia, atypical and young-onset Alzheimer’s disease, and inherited dementia. Int Psychogeriatr2023; 35: 457–476.
10.
KitchingD. Depression in dementia. Aust Prescr2015; 38: 209.
11.
HussainMKumarPKhanS, et al.Similarities between depression and neurodegenerative diseases: pathophysiology, challenges in diagnosis and treatment options. Cureus2020; 12: e11613.
12.
MuliyalaKPVargheseM. The complex relationship between depression and dementia. Ann Indian Acad Neurol2010; 13: S69–S73.
13.
GallagherDKissALanctotK, et al.Depression and risk of Alzheimer dementia: a longitudinal analysis to determine predictors of increased risk among older adults with depression. Am J Geriatr Psychiatry2018; 26: 819–827.
14.
IsmailZGatchelJBatemanDR, et al.Affective and emotional dysregulation as pre-dementia risk markers: exploring the mild behavioral impairment symptoms of depression, anxiety, irritability, and euphoria. Int Psychogeriatr2018; 30: 185–196.
15.
Prado-JeanACouratierPDruet-CabanacM, et al.Specific psychological and behavioral symptoms of depression in patients with dementia. Int J Geriatr Psychiatry2010; 25: 1065–1072.
16.
CerejeiraJLagartoLMukaetova-LadinskaEB. Behavioral and psychological symptoms of dementia. Front Neurol2012; 3: 73.
17.
SilvaMRMoserDPflügerM, et al.Self-reported and informant-reported memory functioning and awareness in patients with mild cognitive impairment and Alzheimeŕs disease. Neuropsychiatr2016; 30: 103.
18.
CummingsJ. The Neuropsychiatric Inventory: development and applications. J Geriatr Psychiatry Neurol2020; 33: 73–84.
19.
AlexopoulosGSAbramsRCYoungRC, et al.Cornell scale for depression in dementia. Biol Psychiatry1988; 23: 271–284.
20.
HorningSMMelroseRSultzerD. Insight in Alzheimer’s disease and its relation to psychiatric and behavioral disturbances. Int J Geriatr Psychiatry2014; 29: 77–84.
21.
SnowALGrahamDPMolinariVA, et al.Factors affecting deficit awareness in persons with dementia. Dement Geriatr Cogn Disord2005; 20: 133–139.
22.
GoldDRosowskyEPiryatinskyI, et al.Comparing patient and informant ratings of depressive symptoms in various stages of Alzheimer’s disease. Neuropsychology2020; 34: 535–550.
23.
LogsdonRGGibbonsLEMcCurrySM, et al.Assessing quality of life in older adults with cognitive impairment. Psychosom Med2002; 64: 510–519.
24.
MolonySLKolanowskiAVan HaitsmaK, et al.Person-centered assessment and care planning. Gerontologist2018; 58: S32–S47.
25.
StarksteinSEJorgeRMizrahiR, et al.A prospective longitudinal study of apathy in Alzheimer’s disease. J Neurol Neurosurg Psychiatry2006; 77: 8–11.
26.
ReadyREOttBRGraceJ. Patient versus informant perspectives of quality of life in mild cognitive impairment and Alzheimer’s disease. Int J Geriatr Psychiatry2004; 19: 256–265.
27.
McKhannGMAlbertMSSperlingRA. Changing diagnostic concepts of Alzheimer’s disease. In: CarrilloMCHampelH (eds) Alzheimer’s disease: modernizing concept, biological diagnosis and therapy, advances in biological psychiatry. Basel, Switzerland: S.Karger AG, 2012, Vol 28, pp.115–121.
28.
RascovskyKHodgesJRKnopmanD, et al.Sensitivity of revised diagnostic criteria for the behavioural variant of frontotemporal dementia. Brain2011; 134: 2456–2477.
29.
Gorno-TempiniMLHillisAEWeintraubS, et al.Classification of primary progressive aphasia and its variants. Neurology2011; 76: 1006.
30.
HöglingerGURespondekGStamelouM, et al.Clinical diagnosis of progressive supranuclear palsy: the movement disorder society criteria. Mov Disord2017; 32: 853–864.
31.
YesavageJABrinkTLRoseTL, et al.Development and validation of a geriatric depression screening scale: a preliminary report. J Psychiatr Res1982; 17: 37–49.
32.
StilesPGMcGarrahanJF. The Geriatric Depression Scale: a comprehensive review. J Clin Geropsychol1998; 4: 89–110.
33.
LavretskyHKumarA. Clinically significant non-major depression: old concepts, new insights. Am J Geriatr Psychiatry2002; 10: 239–255.
34.
AdamsKBMattoHCSandersS. Confirmatory factor analysis of the Geriatric Depression Scale. Gerontologist2004; 44: 818–826.
35.
CummingsJ. The Neuropsychiatric Inventory: development and applications. J Geriatr Psychiatry Neurol2020; 33: 73–84.
MiyagawaTBrushaberDSyrjanenJ, et al.Use of the CDR® plus NACC FTLD in mild FTLD: data from the ARTFL/LEFFTDS consortium. Alzheimers Dement2020; 16: 79–90.
38.
BurkeADGoldfarbDBollamP, et al.Diagnosing and treating depression in patients with Alzheimer’s disease. Neurol Ther2019; 8: 325–350.
39.
SilvaMRMoserDPflügerM, et al.Self-reported and informant-reported memory functioning and awareness in patients with mild cognitive impairment and Alzheimeŕs disease. Neuropsychiatr2016; 30: 103–112.
40.
SollbergerMRosenHJShany-UrT, et al.Neural substrates of socioemotional self-awareness in neurodegenerative disease. Brain Behav2014; 4: 201–214.
41.
Shany-UrTRankinKP. Personality and social cognition in neurodegenerative disease. Curr Opin Neurol2011; 24: 550–555.
42.
ToussaintLWebbJR. Gender differences in the relationship between empathy and forgiveness. J Soc Psychol2005; 145: 673.
43.
Christov-MooreLSimpsonEACoudéG, et al.Empathy: gender effects in brain and behavior. Neurosci Biobehav Rev2014; 46: 604.
44.
HagenDGoldmannE. Gender differences in depression across Europe: a systematic review of cross-national studies. Eur J Public Health2019; 29: ckz186.596.
45.
MarshallGADonovanNJLoriusN, et al.Apathy is associated with increased amyloid burden in mild cognitive impairment. J Neuropsychiatry Clin Neurosci2013; 25: 302–307.
46.
HarringtonKDLimYYGouldE, et al.Amyloid-beta and depression in healthy older adults: a systematic review. Aust N Z J Psychiatry2015; 49: 36–46.
47.
LanctôtKLIsmailZBawaKK, et al.Distinguishing apathy from depression: a review differentiating the behavioral, neuroanatomic, and treatment-related aspects of apathy from depression in neurocognitive disorders. Int J Geriatr Psychiatry2023; 38: e5882.
48.
American Psychiatric Association. Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders. Washington, DC: American Psychiatric Association, 2013.
49.
KlarVSAngYSLockwoodP, et al.Assessment of apathy in neurological patients using the Apathy Motivation Index caregiver version. J Neuropsychol2022; 16: 236–258.
50.
MorrellLCamicPMGenisM. Factors associated with informant-reported cognitive decline in older adults: a systemised literature review. Dementia2019; 18: 2760–2784.
51.
ShdoSMRanasingheKGSturmVE, et al.Depressive symptom profiles predict specific neurodegenerative disease syndromes in early stages. Front Neurol2020; 11: 484161.
52.
MiguelCHarrerMKaryotakiE, et al.Self-reports vs clinician ratings of efficacies of psychotherapies for depression: a meta-analysis of randomized trials. Epidemiol Psychiatr Sci2025; 34: e15.
53.
McDade-MontezEAWatsonDO’HaraMW, et al.The effect of symptom visibility on informant reporting. Psychol Aging2008; 23: 940–946.
54.
PerlisRHFavaMTrivediMH, et al.Irritability is associated with anxiety and greater severity, but not bipolar spectrum features, in major depressive disorder. Acta Psychiatr Scand2009; 119: 282–289.
55.
BaqueroMMartínN. Depressive symptoms in neurodegenerative diseases. World J Clin Cases2015; 3: 682–693.
56.
LevyMLCummingsJLFairbanksLA, et al.Apathy is not depression. J Neuropsychiatry Clin Neurosci1998; 10: 314–319.
57.
ChemerinskiEPetraccaGSabeL, et al.The specificity of depressive symptoms in patients with Alzheimer’s disease. Am J Psychiatry2001; 158: 68–72.
58.
YesavageJABrinkTLRoseTL, et al.Development and validation of a geriatric depression screening scale: a preliminary report. J Psychiatr Res1982; 17: 37–49.
