Against pacifist calls for peace at any price in Ukraine, Hans-Herbert Kögler argues that the west has a moral obligation to support Ukraine in its war against Russia. Kögler’s argument is well-made. However, he does not mention the war at all. This may be an oversight because while moral principles may be universal, in practice, the context defines how morals are applied. Drawing on Clausewitz’s concept of the Trinity, this response seeks to develop Kögler’s moral argument by examining the practical, military implications of the war. It argues that because the war is heavily urbanised, the west’s moral commitment is likely to be very deep and long.
AronR. (1976). Clausewitz: Philosopher of war. Routledge and Kegan Paul.
2.
AshworthG. (1991). War and the city. Routledge.
3.
ClausewitzC. V. (1989). On war (HowardM.ParetP., trans.). Princeton University Press.
4.
GatA. (2001). A history of military thought: From the enlightenment to the cold war. Oxford University Press.
5.
GlennR. (1996). Combat in hell. Rand Arroyo Centre.
6.
GrahamS. (2010). Cities under siege: The new military urbanism. Verso.
7.
HeuserB. (2002). Reading Clausewitz. Pimlico.
8.
HillsA. (2004). Future wars in cities: Re-thinking a liberal dilemma. Frank Cass.
9.
HowardM. (1983). Clausewitz. Oxford University press.
10.
KaldorM. (1998). New and old wars. Polity.
11.
KaldorM.SassenS. (Eds.). (2020). Introduction. In Cities at war: Global insecurity and urban resistance. Columbia Press.
12.
KilcullenD. (2013). Out of the mountains: The coming of age of the urban guerrilla. Hurst and Company.
13.
KingA. (2021). Urban warfare in the twenty-first century. Polity.
14.
KöglerH. H. (2023). Democracy or dictatorship: The moral call to defend Ukraine. European Journal of Social Theory, 29(4), 450–478.
15.
PalmgrenA. (2014). Visions of strategy: Following Clausewitz’s train of thought. National Defence University.
16.
ParetP. (2007). Clausewitz and the state: The man, his theories, and his times. Princeton University Press.
17.
StrachanH. (2013). The case of Clausewitz: Reading on war today. In The direction of war: Contemporary strategy in historical perspective. Cambridge University Press.
