The current study examined the ways in which 14 art therapists and adult clients from the Ultra-Orthodox sector in Israel perceive mental health and mental health treatment. Semi-structured interviews were subjected to an interpretative phenomenological analysis to capture the meaning ascribed to the treatment and its challenges. Four themes emerged: the perception of mental health as related to the centrality of functioning, purposefulness, and emotional balance; the specific challenges of therapy, in terms of suspicion regarding treatment and difficulties in establishing intimacy and self-disclosure; the interplay between the worlds of therapy and religion; and the intersection of art and religion. The discussion centers on an interpretation of the findings in light of the ontological typology of individualism versus collectivism.
AlperinR. M. (2001).
Barriers to intimacy: An object relations perspective. Psychoanalytic Psychology,
18(1), 137–156. doi:10.1037/0736-9735.18.1.137
2.
AndersenR.OadesL.CaputiP. (2003).
The experience of recovery from schizophrenia: Towards an empirically validated stage model. Australian and New Zealand Journal of Psychiatry,
37(5), 586–594. doi:10.1046/j.1440-1614.2003.01234.x
AnoG. G.VasconcellesE. B. (2005).
Religious coping and psychological adjustment to stress: A meta-analysis. Journal of Clinical Psychology,
61(4), 461–480.
5.
AsnaaniA.HofmannS. G. (2012).
Collaboration in multicultural therapy: Establishing a strong therapeutic alliance across cultural lines. Journal of Clinical Psychology,
68(2), 187–197. doi:10.1002/jclp.21829
6.
BuchbinderE.ShoobT. (2013).
Essential partnership: Child welfare officers’ perceptions of cooperation with Rabbis in the Ultra-Orthodox Jewish community in Israel. Journal of Social Service Research,
39(2), 204–217. doi:10.1080/01488376.2012.745825
7.
BurlesonB. R.MortensonS. R. (2003).
Explaining cultural differences in evaluations of emotional support behaviors: Exploring the mediating influences of value systems and interaction goals. Communication Research,
30(2), 113–146. doi:10.1177/0093650202250873
8.
Coleman-BrueckheimerK.DeinS. (2011).
Health care behaviours and beliefs in Hasidic Jewish populations: A systematic review of the literature. Journal of Religion and Health,
50(2), 422–436. doi:10.1007/s10943-010-9448-2
9.
Czamanski-CohenJ.WeihsK. L. (2016).
The bodymind model: A platform for studying the mechanisms of change induced by art therapy. The Arts in Psychotherapy,
51, 63–71. doi:10.1016/j.aip.2016.08.006
10.
DienerE.OishiS.LucasR. E. (2003).
Personality, culture, and subjective well-being: Emotional and cognitive evaluations of life. Annual Review of Psychology,
54(1), 403–425. doi:10.1146/annurev.psych.54.101601.145056
11.
DwairyM. A. (2006). Counseling and psychotherapy with Arabs and Muslims: A culturally sensitive approach.
New York, NY:
Teachers College Press.
12.
ExlineJ. J.RoseE. (2005). Religious and spiritual struggles. In PaloutzianR. F.ParkC. L. (Eds.), Handbook for the psychology of religion (pp. 315–330).
New York, NY:
Guilford Press.
13.
FischerR.FerreiraM. C.AssmarE.RedfordP.HarbC.GlazerS.KärtnerJ. (2009).
Individualism-collectivism as descriptive norms development of a subjective norm approach to culture measurement. Journal of Cross-Cultural Psychology,
40(2), 187–213. doi:10.1177/0022022109332738
14.
FrankeW. (2007).
The death of God in Hegel and Nietzsche and the crisis of values in secular modernity and post-secular postmodernity. Religion and the Arts,
11(2), 214–241. doi:10.1163/156852907X199170
15.
FreundA.Band-Winterstein.T. (2013).
Between tradition and modernity: Social work-related change processes in the Jewish ultra-orthodox society in Israel. International Journal of Intercultural Relations.
37, 422–433. doi:10.1016/j.ijintrel.2012.10.003
16.
FuschP. I.NessL. R. (2015).
Are we there yet? Data saturation in qualitative research. The Qualitative Report,
20(9), 1408–1416. Retrieved from http://nsuworks.nova.edu/tqr/vol20/iss9/3
17.
GerberN.PotvinN.BlankC. A.BrylK. L. (2018).
Arts-based research approaches to studying mechanisms of change in the creative arts therapies. Frontiers in Psychology,
9. doi:10.3389/fpsyg.2018.02076
18.
GlobmanR.LifshitzH. (2004).
The attitudes of teachers in the ultra-Orthodox sector towards the integration of students with special needs in regular education. Megamot,
33(1), 718–788. [in Hebrew]
19.
GolafshaniN. (2003).
Understanding reliability and validity in qualitative research. The Qualitative Report,
8(4), 597–606.
20.
GreenE. G.DeschampsJ. C.PaezD. (2005).
Variation of individualism and collectivism within and between 20 countries: A typological analysis. Journal of Cross-Cultural Psychology,
36(3), 321–339. doi:10.1177/0022022104273654
Greenberg, D., & Witztum, E. (2013). Challenges and conflicts in the delivery of mental health services to ultra-orthodox Jews. Asian Journal of Psychiatry, 6(1), 71–73.
23.
GreenbergD.WitztumE. (2001). Sanity and sanctity: Mental health among the Ultra-Orthodox in Jerusalem.
London, UK:
Yale University Press.
24.
GubiP. M. (2001).
An exploration of the use of Christian prayer in mainstream counselling. British Journal of Guidance and Counselling,
29(4), 425–434. doi:10.1080/03069880120085974
25.
HendersonC.Evans-LackoS.ThornicroftG. (2013).
Mental illness stigma, help seeking, and public health programs. American Journal of Public Health,
103(5), 777–780. doi:10.2105/AJPH.2012.301056
26.
HessE.PitariuH. (2011).
Psychotherapy of ultra-orthodox Jews in Israel: A qualitative assessment of conflicts and reconciliations. Europe’s Journal of Psychology,
7(3), 502–533. doi:10.5964/ejop.v7i3.146
27.
HolmesR. (2012). Children’s play preferences in the Pacific Rim: Then and now. In CohenL.Waite-StupianskyS. (Eds.), Play: A polyphony of research, theories and issues (pp. 27–66).
Lanham, MD:
University Press of America.
28.
HuppertJ. D.SievJ.KushnerE. S. (2007).
When religion and obsessive–compulsive disorder collide: Treating scrupulosity in ultra‐orthodox Jews. Journal of Clinical Psychology,
63(10), 925–941. doi:10.1002/jclp.20404
KirmayerL. J. (2007).
Psychotherapy and the cultural concept of the person. Transcultural Psychiatry,
44(2), 232–257. doi:10.1177/1363461506070794
31.
KitayamaS.MarkusH. R.KurokawaM. (2000).
Culture, emotion, and well-being: Good feelings in Japan and the United States. Cognition & Emotion,
14(1), 93–124. doi:10.1080/026999300379003
32.
KoenigH. G. (2008).
Religion and mental health: What should psychiatrists do?Psychiatric Bulletin,
32(6), 201–203.
33.
KozukiY.KennedyM. G. (2004).
Cultural incommensurability in psychodynamic psychotherapy in Western and Japanese traditions. Journal of Nursing Scholarship,
36(1), 30–38.
34.
LevineL. I. (2002). Art, architecture, and archeology. In GoodmanM. (Ed.), The Oxford handbook of Jewish studies (pp. 824–851).
Oxford, UK:
Oxford University Press.
35.
LightmanE. S.ShorR. (2002).
Askanim: Informal helpers and cultural brokers as a bridge to secular helpers for the Ultra-Orthodox Jewish communities of Israel and Canada. Families in Society: The Journal of Contemporary Human Services,
83, 315–324. doi:10.1606/1044-3894.26
36.
LittlewoodR. (2000). Towards an intercultural therapy inKareemJ.LittlewoodR. (Eds.), Intercultural therapy: Themes, interpretations and practice (pp. 3–13).
Oxford, UK:
Blackwell Science.
37.
LoewenthalK. M. (1995). Mental health and religion.
London, UK:
Chapman & Hall.
38.
LoewenthalK. M. (2006a). Orthodox Judaism: Features and issues for psychotherapy. In E. T. Dowd & S. L. Nielsen (Eds.), The psychologies in religion: Working with the religious client (pp. 203–217). London, UK: Springer.
39.
LoewenthalK. M. (2006b).
Strictly orthodox Jews and their relations with psychotherapy and psychiatry. World Cultural Psychiatry Research Review,
1, 128–132.
40.
MatsumotoD.YooS. H.FontaineJ.Anguas-WongA. M.ArriolaM.AtacaB., … GsorriE. (2008).
Mapping expressive differences around the world the relationship between emotional display rules and individualism versus collectivism. Journal of Cross-Cultural Psychology,
39(1), 55–74. doi:10.1177/0022022107311854
41.
Mocan-AydinG. (2000).
Western models of counseling and psychotherapy within Turkey: Crossing cultural boundaries. The Counseling Psychologist,
28(2), 281–298. doi:10.1177/0011000000282007
42.
O’ReillyM.ParkerN. (2013). “
Unsatisfactory saturation”: A critical exploration of the notion of saturated sample sizes in qualitative research. Qualitative Research,
13(2), 190–197. doi:10.1177/1468794112446106
43.
PargamentK. I.KoenigH. G.TarakeshwarN.HahnJ. (2004).
Religious coping methods as predictors of psychological, physical and spiritual outcomes among medically ill elderly patients: A two-year longitudinal study. Journal of Health Psychology,
9(6), 713–730. doi: 10.1177/1359105304045366
44.
PargamentK. I.SaundersS. M. (2007).
Introduction to the special issue on spirituality and psychotherapy. Journal of Clinical Psychology,
63(10), 903–907. doi:10.1002/jclp.20405
45.
PearceM. J.KoenigH. G.RobinsC. J.NelsonB.ShawS. F.CohenH. J.KingM. B. (2015).
Religiously integrated cognitive behavioral therapy: A new method of treatment for major depression in patients with chronic medical illness. Psychotherapy,
52(1), 56–66. doi:10.1037/a0036448
46.
PirutinskyS.RosenD. D.SafranR. S.RosmarinD. H. (2010).
Do medical models of mental illness relate to increased or decreased stigmatization of mental illness among orthodox Jews?The Journal of Nervous and Mental Disease,
198(7), 508–512. doi:10.1097/NMD.0b013e3181e07d99
47.
PirutinskyS.RosmarinD. H.PargamentK. I.MidlarskyE. (2011).
Does negative religious coping accompany, precede, or follow depression among Orthodox Jews?Journal of Affective Disorders,
132(3), 401–405. doi:10.1016/j.jad.2011.03.015
48.
PopovskyM. A. (2010).
Special issues in the care of ultra-orthodox Jewish psychiatric in-patients. Transcultural Psychiatry,
47(4), 647–672. doi:10.1177/1363461510383747
49.
Raphael, M. (2009). Judaism and the visual image: a Jewish theology of art. London, UK: Continuum International Publishing.
50.
Rosen, D. D., Greenberg, D., Schmeidler, J., & Shefler, G. (2008). Stigma of mental illness, religious change, and explanatory models of mental illness among Jewish patients at a mental-health clinic in North Jerusalem. Mental Health, Religion and Culture, 11(2), 193–209.
51.
RüschN.AngermeyerM. C.CorriganP. W. (2005).
Mental illness stigma: Concepts, consequences, and initiatives to reduce stigma. European Psychiatry,
20(8), 529–539. doi:10.1016/j.eurpsy.2005.04.004
52.
Struch, N. Shreshbashki, Y. Bidni-Orbach, A. Lachman, M. Zahavi, T., & Sagiv, N. (2007). Stigma, discrimination and mental health in Israel: Stigma towards people with a psychiatric illness and towards mental health care. Jerusalem: Myers-Joint-Brookdale Institute (in Hebrew).
53.
SatoT. (2001).
Autonomy and relatedness in psychopathology and treatment: A cross-cultural formulation. Genetic, Social, and General Psychology Monographs,
127(1), 89–127. doi:f430c5792cb65ebbfc073e6fd3f02d31.pdf
SueD. W.SueD. (2003). Counseling the culturally different: Theory and practice (4th ed.).
New York, NY:
Wiley.
56.
TriandisH. C. (2005). Issues in individualism and collectivism research. In SorrentinoR. M.CohenD.OlsonJ. M.ZannaM. P. (Eds.), Culture and social behavior: The Tenth Ontario Symposium (pp. 207–226).
Hillsdale, NJ:
Lawrence Erlbaum.
57.
WeaverA. J.PargamentK. I.FlannellyK. J.OppenheimerJ. E. (2006).
Trends in the scientific study of religion, spirituality, and health: 1965–2000. Journal of Religion and Health,
45, 208–214. doi:10.1007/s10943-006-9011-3
58.
WeismanA. (2005).
Integrating culturally based approaches with existing interventions for Hispanic/Latino families coping with schizophrenia. Psychotherapy: Theory, Research, Practice, Training,
42(2), 178–197.
59.
WeissP.ShorR.Hadas‐LidorN. (2013).
Cultural aspects within caregiver interactions of ultra‐Orthodox Jewish women and their family members with mental illness. American Journal of Orthopsychiatry,
83(4), 520–527. doi:10.1111/ajop.12045
60.
WheltonW. J. (2004).
Emotional processes in psychotherapy: Evidence across therapeutic modalities. Clinical Psychology and Psychotherapy,
11, 58–71. doi:10.1002/cpp.392
61.
ZoharA. H.GoldmanE.CalamaryR.MashiahM. (2005).
Religiosity and obsessive-compulsive behavior in Israeli Jews. Behaviour Research and Therapy,
43(7), 857–868. doi:10.1016/j.brat.2004.06.009
