This study explores young people’s perceptions of citizenship and recovery for individuals with severe mental health challenges using the story completion method. In this qualitative approach, participants were invited to complete an open-ended story stem about a fictional character, Billie, whose journey of recovery unfolds through their narratives. We analyzed 47 stories, with lengths ranging from 65 to 598 words (M = 253 words), applying both horizontal (thematic) and vertical (narrative progression) analyses. The findings reveal that participants often framed Billie’s recovery in terms of social roles—such as student, friend, or worker—emphasizing the fluctuating and relational nature of recovery. At the same time, the narratives also reflect societal expectations and implicit biases surrounding mental health and citizenship. Broader systemic factors, such as rights, resources, and societal responsibilities, were less frequently addressed. The results suggest that young people’s perspectives on mental health recovery are largely shaped by relational contexts but may lack a critical awareness of structural barriers to inclusive citizenship. This study underscores the potential of the story completion method as both a research tool and an educational intervention, fostering dialog on stigma, inclusion, and mental health recovery.
AnthonyWA (1993) Recovery from mental illness: The guiding vision of the mental health service system in the 1990s. Psychosocial Rehabilitation Journal16(4): 11–23.
2.
BauerLWienkeAFührerA (2024) Compassionate othering: The construction of refugee patients in medical students’ narratives – A qualitative study using story completion. BMC Medical Education24(1): 1–12.
3.
BeresfordPRoseD (2023) Decolonising global mental health: The role of mad studies. Global Mental Health10: e30.
4.
BoniAVelascoD (2020) Epistemic capabilities and epistemic injustice: What is the role of higher education in fostering epistemic contributions of marginalized knowledge producers?Global Justice: Theory Practice Rhetoric12(01): 1–26.
5.
BorgMDavidsonL (2008) The nature of recovery as lived in everyday experience. Journal of Mental Health17(2): 129–140.
6.
BraunVClarkeVHayfieldN, et al. (2019) Qualitative story completion: A method with exciting promise. In: LiamputtongP (ed.) Handbook of Research Methods in Health Social Sciences. Springer, pp.1479–1496.
7.
BrownCShayM (2021) From resilience to wellbeing: Identity-building as an alternative framework for schools’ role in promoting children’s mental health. Review of Education9(2): 599–634.
8.
ButlerCBeavisJAldallalF, et al. (2022) The social construction of gender variance in childhood, adolescence and parenthood: A story completion study. Journal of Family Therapy44(2): 264–278.
9.
ChaESKimKHErlenJA (2007) Translation of scales in cross-cultural research: Issues and techniques. Journal of Advanced Nursing58(4): 386–395.
10.
ClarkeVBraunVFrithH, et al. (2019) Editorial introduction to the special issue: using story completion methods in qualitative research. Qualitative Research in Psychology16(1): 1–20.
11.
ClarkeVHayfieldNMollerN, et al. (2017) Once upon a time. . .: Story completion methods. In: BraunPClarkeVGreyD (eds) Collecting Qualitative Data: A Practical Guide to Textual, Media and Virtual Techniques. Cambridge University Press, pp.45–70.
12.
ClaytonAMillerRGambinoM, et al. (2020) Structural barriers to citizenship: A mental health provider perspective. Community Mental Health Journal56: 32–41.
13.
CoganNAMacIntyreGStewartA, et al. (2021) “The biggest barrier is to inclusion itself”: The experience of citizenship for adults with mental health problems. Journal of Mental Health30(3): 358–365.
14.
DavidsonLHaglundKEStaynerDA, et al. (2001a) “It was just realizing . . . That life isn’t one big horror”: A qualitative study of supported socialization. Psychiatric Rehabilitation Journal24(3): 275–292.
15.
DavidsonLRoweMDiLeoP, et al. (2021) Recovery-oriented systems of care: A perspective on the past, present, and future. Alcohol Research: Current Reviews41(1): 09.
16.
DavidsonLStaynerDANickouC, et al. (2001b) “Simply to be let in”: Inclusion as a basis for recovery. Psychiatric Rehabilitation Journal24(4): 375–388.
17.
De MaeyerJDe RuysscherCVanderplasschenW (2024) Community adaptation. In: Maggino M (ed.) Encyclopedia of Quality of Life and Well-Being Research. Springer, pp.1149–1153.
18.
De RuysscherCTomlinsonPVanheuleS, et al. (2019) Questioning the professionalization of recovery: A collaborative exploration of a recovery process. Disability & Society34(5): 797–818.
19.
DesaiMUGuyKBrownM, et al. (2024) “That was a state of depression by itself dealing with society”: Atmospheric racism, mental health, and the Black and African American faith community. American Journal of Community Psychology73(1–2): 104–117.
20.
de Sousa SantosB (2024) The epistemologies of the south and the future of the university. Journal of Philosophy of Education58(2–3): 166–188.
21.
DriniEKentTFrithH (2023) “Disclosing the innermost part”: Exploring therapists’ constructions of shame using a story completion method. European Journal for Qualitative Research in Psychotherapy13: 18–32.
22.
FieldM (2022) Decolonizing healing through indigenous ways of knowing. In: WallaceMBazzulJHigginsM, et al. (eds) Reimagining Science Education in the Anthropocene. Palgrave Studies in Education and the Environment, pp.121–134.
23.
FrickerM (2007) Epistemic Injustice: Power and the Ethics of Knowing. Oxford University Press.
24.
FuentesKHsuSPatelS, et al. (2024) More than just double discrimination: A scoping review of the experiences and impact of ableism and racism in employment. Disability and Rehabilitation46(4): 650–671.
25.
GibsonNC (2021) Decolonizing Madness: The Psychiatric Writings of Frantz Fanon 1. In: LaubscherLHookDDesaiM (eds) Fanon, Phenomenology, and Psychology. Routledge, pp.23–47.
26.
HamerHPFinlaysonMWarrenH (2014) Insiders or outsiders? Mental health service users’ journeys towards full citizenship. International Journal of Mental Health Nursing23(3): 203–211.
27.
HarperAKriegelLMorrisC, et al. (2017) Finding citizenship: What works?American Journal of Psychiatric Rehabilitation20(3): 200–217.
28.
IsinEF (2002) Being Political: Genealogies of Citizenship. University of Minnesota Press.
29.
KalD (2013) Werken aan ruimte voor anders-zijn: Niches voor eigenwaarde en het besef van invloed. Maatwerk14(6): 2–4.
30.
Káplár-KodácsyKDornerH (2024) Creating reflective space for teachers in higher education: The use of story completion. International Journal for Academic Development1–15.
31.
KlevanTBankR-MBorgM, et al. (2021) Part I: Dynamics of recovery: A meta-synthesis exploring the nature of mental health and substance abuse recovery. International Journal of Environmental Research and Public Health18(15): 7761.
32.
KruithofKSuurmondJKalD, et al. (2021) Volunteer work with vulnerable persons in the community: A qualitative study of social inclusion. Journal of Social Work21(4): 696–712.
33.
LeamyMBirdVLe BoutillierC, et al. (2011) Conceptual framework for personal recovery in mental health: systematic review and narrative synthesis. British Journal of Psychiatry199(6): 445–452.
34.
LenetteC (2022) Cultural safety in participatory arts-based research: How can we do better?Journal of Participatory Research Methods3(1).
35.
LenetteCVaughanPBoydellK (2022) How can story completion be used in culturally safe ways?International Journal of Qualitative Methods21: 1–11.
36.
LevinL (2022) Perspective: Decolonizing postmodernist approaches to mental health discourse toward promoting epistemic justice. Frontiers in Psychiatry13: 980148.
37.
ListerR (2007) Inclusive citizenship: Realizing the potential1. Citizenship Studies11(1): 49–61.
38.
MacIntyreGCoganNStewartA, et al. (2022) Citizens defining citizenship: A model grounded in lived experience and its implications for research, policy and practice. Health & Social Care in the Community30(3): e695–e705.
39.
MacIntyreGCoganNAStewartAE, et al. (2019) What’s citizenship got to do with mental health? Rationale for inclusion of citizenship as part of a mental health strategy. Journal of Public Mental Health18(3): 157–161.
40.
McAdamsDPMcLeanKC (2013) Narrative identity. Current Directions in Psychological Science22(3): 233–238.
41.
McWadeB (2015) The neoliberal politics of recovery. Conference presentation, Making Sense of Mad Studies, Durham University.
42.
McWadeB (2016) Recovery-as-policy as a form of neoliberal state making. Intersectionalities: A Global Journal of Social Work Analysis, Research, Polity, and Practice5(3): 62–81.
43.
MeesN (2023) Frames en counterframes bij studenten over het leven van personen met schizofrenie: een impact op het herstelproces. [Frames and counterframes among students about the lives of persons with schizophrenia: An impact on the recovery process]. Master’s Thesis, Ghent University.
44.
MensahMOgbu-NwobodoLShimRS (2021) Racism and mental health equity: History repeating itself. Psychiatric Services72(9): 1091–1094.
45.
MillsC (2017) Global psychiatrization and psychic colonization: The coloniality of global mental health. In: MorrowMMalcoL (eds) Critical Inquiries for Social Justice in Mental Health. University of Toronto Press, pp.87–109.
46.
MoeyaertO (2023) The Billie project: Kwalitatief onderzoek naar de perceptie van jongeren over het leven van mensen met ernstige psychische problemen. [The Billie project: Qualitative research on the perceptions of youth about the lives of people with serious mental health problems]. Master’s Thesis, Ghent University.
47.
MollerNPClarkeVBraunV, et al. (2021) Qualitative story completion for counseling psychology research: A creative method to interrogate dominant discourses. Journal of Counseling Psychology68(3): 286–298.
48.
NessODavidsonLOuteJ, et al. (2021) Recovery, social inclusion, and the capability approach in mental health. In: Lester JN and O’Reilly M (eds) The Palgrave Encyclopedia of Critical Perspectives on Mental Health. Springer, pp.1–8.
49.
Nord-BaadeSNessOJensenCB, et al. (2024) Barriers and facilitators for social inclusion among people with concurrent mental health and substance use problems. A qualitative scoping review. PLoS One19(12): e0315758.
50.
Nord-BaadeSNessORoweM, et al. (2025) The mattering citizen: Young adults with mental illness and complex needs’ experiences and perceived opportunities of social inclusion. Frontiers in Psychology16: 1504767.
51.
OrangB (2024) Sylvia Wynter and the poetics of psychiatry. In: BleakleyANeilsonS (eds) Routledge Handbook of Medicine and Poetry. Routledge, pp.236–245.
52.
PolsJ (2006) Washing the citizen: Washing, cleanliness and citizenship in mental health care. Culture Medicine and Psychiatry30(1): 77–104.
53.
PonceANRoweM (2018) Citizenship and community mental health care. American Journal of Community Psychology61(1–2): 22–31.
54.
PongCYRobertsNJLumE (2024) The “what, why, and how?” of story completion in health services research: A scoping review. BMC Medical Research Methodology24(1): 159.
55.
PorterGTownsendJHampshireK (2012) Children and young people as producers of knowledge. Children’s Geographies10(2): 131–134.
56.
PouilleADe RuysscherCVander LaenenF, et al. (2023) “Watch out for the boogieman”: Stigma and substance use recovery among migrants and ethnic minorities. Journal of Community & Applied Social Psychology33(3): 571–586.
57.
Price-RobertsonRObradovicAMorganB (2017) Relational recovery: Beyond individualism in the recovery approach. Advances in Mental Health15(2): 108–120.
58.
QuinnNBromageBRoweM (2020) Collective citizenship: From citizenship and mental health to citizenship and solidarity. Social Policy and Administration54(3): 361–374.
59.
RoweM (2014) Citizenship & Mental Health. Oxford University Press.
60.
RoweMDavidsonL (2016) Recovering citizenship. Israel Journal of Psychiatry and Related Sciences53(1): 14–20.
61.
SalbuMØ (2023) Meeting Billie – en kvalitativ studie om unge norske menneskers forståelse av muligheter for bedring og samfunnsdeltagelse ved alvorlig psykisk lidelse. [Meeting Billie – A qualitative study on young Norwegian people’s understanding of opportunitites for improvement and social participation in serious mental illness]. Master’s thesis, University of Bergen, Bergen.
62.
SommerMBiongSBorgM, et al. (2021) Part II: Living life: A meta-synthesis exploring recovery as processual experiences. International Journal of Environmental Research and Public Health18(11): 6115.
63.
StuartSRTanseyLQuayleE (2017) What we talk about when we talk about recovery: A systematic review and best-fit framework synthesis of qualitative literature. Journal of Mental Health26(3): 291–304.
64.
TewJRamonSSladeM, et al. (2012) Social factors and recovery from mental health difficulties: A review of the evidence. British Journal of Social Work42(3): 443–460.
65.
TischnerI (2019) Tomorrow is the start of the rest of their life — So who cares about health? Exploring constructions of weight-loss motivations and health using story completion. Qualitative Research in Psychology16(1): 54–73.
66.
ToporABoeTDLarsenIB (2022) The lost social context of recovery psychiatrization of a social process. Frontiers in Sociology7: 832201.
67.
UrryKHunterSFeoR, et al. (2023) Qualitative story completion: Opportunities and considerations for health research. Qualitative Health Research33(4): 345–355.
68.
Van AudenhoveC (2017) De geestelijke gezondheidszorg: Een nieuwe mindset?Tijdschrift klinische psychologie47(1): 5–18.
69.
VandekinderenCRoetsGRooseR, et al. (2012) Rediscovering recovery: Reconceptualizing underlying assumptions of citizenship and interrelated notions of care and support. Science World Journal2012: 1–7.
70.
VandekinderenCRoetsGVan HoveG (2014) Untangling the nonrecyclable citizen: A critical reconceptualization of responsibility in recovery. Qualitative Health Research24(10): 1418–1430.
71.
VervlietMReynaertDVerelstA, et al. (2019) “If you can’t follow, you’re out.” the perspectives of people with mental health problems on citizenship. Applied Research in Quality of Life14: 891–908.
72.
VesethMSalbuMØNessO, et al. (2025) “Billie is ready for a new chapter in life”: Exploring constructions of schizophrenia recovery from the perspectives of Norwegian youth using story completion. Journal of Psychosocial Rehabilitation and Mental Health1–13.
73.
WhiteSC (2017) Relational wellbeing: Re-centring the politics of happiness, policy and the self. Policy and Politics45(2): 121–136.
74.
WilliamsTLLozano-SufrateguiLTomasoneJR (2022) Stories of physical activity and disability: Exploring sport and exercise students’ narrative imagination through story completion. Qualitative Research in Sport Exercise and Health14(5): 687–705.
Supplementary Material
Please find the following supplemental material available below.
For Open Access articles published under a Creative Commons License, all supplemental material carries the same license as the article it is associated with.
For non-Open Access articles published, all supplemental material carries a non-exclusive license, and permission requests for re-use of supplemental material or any part of supplemental material shall be sent directly to the copyright owner as specified in the copyright notice associated with the article.
