Evidence-based medicine (EBM) emerged relatively recently to describe the explicit process of applying research evidence to medical practice. The movement was high profile, yet not overly successful: many clinicians do not use up-to-date evidence in their everyday work. This article shows how a social movement perspective can be used to analyse the emergence of EBM and shed light on power struggles between segments of the medical profession. It draws on Blumer's (1951) essay on social movements to demonstrate the continued salience of this approach. The article also presents empirical data from a qualitative study of English and American surgeons to illustrate how EBM provides a focus for segmental conflict within medical practice between `art' and `science', `practice' and `evidence'. Together these data and the social movements perspective provide insight into the dynamics of this struggle and help to explain why clinicians continue to resist EBM.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
Balint, M. (1961). The other part of medicine . The Lancet, 1, 40 .
2.
Barley, S. (1996). Technicians in the workplace: Ethnographic evidence for bringing work into organization studies . Administrative Science Quarterly, 41, 404-401 .
3.
Battista, R. and Hodge, M. (1993). Clinical practice guidelines: Between science and art . Canadian Medical Association Journal, 148(3), 385-389 .
4.
Benford, R. and Hunt, S. (1992). Dramaturgy and social movements: The social construction and communication of power . Sociological Inquiry, 62(1), 36-55 .
5.
Blavias, J. (1995). Seeking truth . Neurourology and Urodynamics, 14, 1-2 .
6.
Reprinted in 1995 in S.M. Lyman (Ed.), Social movements: critiques, concepts and case studies, pp. 60-83. London: Macmillan .
7.
Bucher, R. (1962). Pathology: A study of social movements within a profession . Social Problems, 10(1), 40-51 .
8.
Bucher, R. and Stelling, J. (1969). Characteristics of professional organizations . Journal of Health and Social Behaviour, 10, 3-15 .
9.
Bucher, R. and Strauss, A. (1960). Professions in process . American Journal of Sociology, 66(4), 325-334 .
10.
Charlton, B. (1991). Medical practice and the double blind, randomised controlled trial . British Journal of General Practice, 41, 335-336 .
11.
Cochrane, A. (1972). Effectiveness and efficiency: Random reflections on health services. London: Nuffield Provincial Hospitals Trust .
12.
Davis, P. and Howden-Chapman, P. (1996). Translating research findings into health policy . Social Science and Medicine, 43, 865-872 .
13.
Delamothe, T. (1993). Wanted: Guidelines that doctors will follow . British Medical Journal, 307, 218 .
14.
Dingwall, R., Murphy, E., Watson, P., Greatbatch, D. and Parker, S. (1998). Catching goldfish: Quality in qualitative research . Journal of Health Services Research and Policy, 3, 167-172 .
15.
Evidence-Based Medicine Working Group. (1992). Evidence based medicine: A new approach to teaching the practice of medicine . Journal of the American Medical Association, 268, 2420-2425 .
16.
Fine, G. (1996). Justifying work: Occupations rhetorics as resources in restaurant kitchens . Administrative Science Quarterly, 41, 90-116 .
17.
Fletcher, R., Fletcher, S. and Wagner, E. (1982). Clinical epidemiology - the essentials. Baltimore, MD: Williams & Wilkins .
18.
Freidson, E. (1986). Professional powers: A study of the institutionalisation of formal knowledge. Chicago, IL: University of Chicago Press .
19.
Freidson, E. (1988). Profession of medicine. Chicago, IL: University of Chicago Press .
20.
Giddens, A. (1985). The nation state and violence. Cambridge: Polity Press .
21.
Grimley Evans, J. (1995). Evidence-based and evidence-biased medicine . Age and Ageing, 24, 461-463 .
22.
Haines, A. and Jones, R. (1994). Implementing the findings of research . British Medical Journal, 308, 1488-1492 .
23.
Halpern, S. (1990). Medicalization as professional process: Postwar trends in pediatrics . Journal of Health and Social Behaviour, 31, 28-42 .
24.
Hammersley, M. (1989). The dilemma of qualitative method: Herbert Blumer and the Chicago tradition. London: Routledge .
25.
Harrison, S. (1996). Implementing the results of research and development in clinical and managerial practice. In M. Baker and S. Kirk (Eds.), Research and development for the NHS: Evidence, evaluation and effectiveness, pp. 103-114. Oxford: Radcliffe Medical Press .
26.
Heberle, R. (1951). Social movements: An introduction to political sociology. New York: Appleton-Century Crofts .
27.
Holdsworth, G. and Crampin, M. (1996). Letter . Health Economics, 5, 271-272 .
28.
Hopkins, A. (1995). Some reservations about clinical guidelines . Archives of Disease in Childhood, 72, 70-75 .
29.
Jamous, H. and Peloille, B. (1970). Changes in the French university-hospital system. In J. Jackson (Ed.), Professions and professionalisation, pp. 111-153. London: Cambridge University Press .
30.
Knafl, K. and Burkett, G. (1975). Professional socialization in a surgical specialty: Acquiring medical judgement . Social Science and Medicine, 9, 397-404 .
Naylor, D. (1995). Grey zones of clinical practice: Some limits to evidence-based medicine . The Lancet, 345, 840-842 .
33.
Nyiri, J. and Smith, B. (1988). Practical knowledge: Outlines of a theory of traditions and skills. London: Croom Helm .
34.
Oakeshott, M. (1991). Rationalism in politics and other essays. Indianapolis, IN: Liberty Press .
35.
Pawluch, D. (1983). Transitions in pediatrics: A segmental analysis . Social Problems, 30(4), 449-465 .
36.
Polyani, M. (1961). Knowing and being. In M. Green (Ed.), Essays by Michael Polyani, pp. 123-135. London: RKP .
37.
Pope, C. (2002). Contigency in everyday surgical work . Sociology of Health and Illness, 24(4), 369-384 .
38.
Rosen, R. (2000). Applying research to health care policy and practice: Medical and managerial views on effectiveness and the role of research . Journal of Health Services Research and Policy, 5(2), 103-108 .
39.
Rosenberg, W. and Donald, A. (1995). Evidence-based medicine: An approach to clinical problem solving . British Medical Journal, 310, 1122-1126 .
40.
Russell, R. (1996). Surgical research [letter] . The Lancet, 347, 1480 .
41.
Ryle, G. (1945). Knowing how and knowing that . Proceedings of the Aristotelian Society, XLVI, 1-16 .
42.
Sackett, D. and Haynes, R. (1995). On the need for evidence based medicine . Evidence-based Medicine, 1(1), 5-6 .
43.
and as W. Rosenberg and D. Sackett (1996) Therapie, 51(3), 212-217 .
44.
Sackett, D., Haynes, R.B., Guyatt, G. and Tugwell, P. (1991 [1985]). Clinical epidemiology: A basic science for clinical medicine, 2nd edn. London: Little Brown .
45.
Salomon, A. (1946). The religion of progress . Social Research, 13(4), 441-462 .
46.
Snow, D. and Benford, R. (1988). Ideology, frame resonance and participant mobilisation . International Social Movement Research, 1, 197-217 .
47.
Sullivan, F. and MacNaughton, R. (1996). Evidence in consultations: Interpreted and individualised . The Lancet, 348, 941-943 .
48.
Willis, E. and White, K. (1999). Evidence based medicine and the sociology of medical knowledge . Paper presented to BSA Medical Sociology Conference, York, UK, September.
49.
Wood, M., Ferlie, E. and Fitzgerald, L. (1998). Achieving clinical behaviour change: A case of becoming indeterminate . Social Science and Medicine, 47, 1729-1738 .
