This article investigates why state authorities criminalize acts of solidarity with migrants and refugees, focusing on Greece and application of the theory of ‘enemy under-criminalization’. This concept extends Stumpf's crimmigration's emphasis on the fusion of criminal and immigration law, illustrating how legal and social hierarchies produce a distinct legal space that diverges from normative legal principles. Applying this concept to Greece's exclusionary legal framework and recent cases, it demonstrates how the state criminalizes individuals and organizations assisting migrants. The central argument is that solidarity is treated with hostility because of its association with the ‘enemy’ (irregular migrants and refugees) and its potential to expose illicit tactics used by the Greek state to control immigration. Ultimately, the article argues that these actions operate outside the rule of law, using punitive measures that bypass traditional legal safeguards, undermine humanitarian efforts, and raise concerns about the erosion of rights and the role of law in perpetuating exclusion.
AnagnostouD (2024) Differentiation and the unpicking of the EU's asylum system from within: Greek perceptions and policies before and after the 2015 migration crisis. In: BátoraJFossumJE (eds) Differentiation and Dominance in Europe’s Poly-Crises. London: Routledge, pp. 158–183.
BosworthMFiliA (2016) Immigration detention in Greece and the UK. In: FurmanREppsDLamphearG (eds) Detaining the Immigrant Other: Global and Transnational Issues. New York, NY: Oxford University Press, pp. 79–90.
9.
CarreraSVosyliuteLSmialowskiS, et al. (2018) Fit for purpose? The facilitation directive and the criminalization of humanitarian assistance to irregular migrants: 2018 update. Report, Policy Department for Citizen’s Rights and Constitutional Affairs, Brussels. Available at: http://www. europarl.europa.eu/RegData/etudes/STUD/2018/608838/IPOL_STU(2018)608838_EN.pdf (accessed 4th December 2024).
10.
ChatzinikolaouN (2020) Crimmigration in Greece: a story of exceptional derogations from the rule of law within a permanent situation of emergency. In: GattaGLMitsilegasVZiruliaS (eds) Controlling Immigration Through Criminal Law: European and Comparative Perspectives on ‘Crimmigration’. Oxford: Bloomsbury, pp. 165–191.
11.
CusumanoEVillaM (2021) From “angels” to “vice smugglers”: the criminalization of sea rescue NGOs in Italy. European Journal on Criminal Policy and Research27: 23–40.
12.
DaduscDMuduP (2022) Care without control: the humanitarian industrial complex and the criminalisation of solidarity. Geopolitics27(4): 1205–1230.
13.
De GenovaNRoyA (2020) Practices of illegalisation. Antipode52(2): 352–364.
14.
De GiorgiA (2006) Re-Thinking the Political Economy of Punishment: Perspectives on Post-Fordism and Penal Politics. Aldershot: Ashgate.
15.
DíezCGJ (2008) Enemy combatants versus enemy criminal law: an introduction to the European debate regarding enemy criminal law and its relevance to the Anglo-American discussion on the legal status of unlawful enemy combatants.New Criminal Law Review 11(4): 529–562.
16.
DupuyKFransenLPrakashA (2021) Restricting NGOs: from pushback to accommodation. Global Policy12: 5–10.
European Commission. (2020) Communication from the Commission. Guidance on the implementation of EU rules on definition and prevention of the facilitation of unauthorised entry, transit and residence. Available at: https://eur-lex.europa.eu/legal-content/EL/TXT/?uri=CELEX%3A52020XC1001%2801%29 (accessed 4th December 2024).
HänselVMoloneyRFirlaD, et al. (2020) Incarcerating the Marginalised: The Fight Against Alleged ‘Smugglers’ on the Greek Hotspot Islands. Munich: bordermonitoring.
KaramanidouLKasparekB (2022) From exception to extra-legal normality: pushbacks and racist state violence against people crossing the Greek–Turkish land border. State Crime Journal11: 12.
39.
KarydisV (2016) Immigrants and moral panics in Greece. In: GasparinatouM (ed.) Crime and Penality in Times of Crisis: Essays in Honor of Professor Nestor Kourakis. Athens: Sakkoulas, pp. 1629–1648.
40.
KourakisF (2025) From ‘crimmigration’ to ‘enemy under-criminalization’: the Greek case of immigration control. The Greek Review of Social Research, 164: 31–56.
41.
KoutrolikouP (2016) Governmentalities of urban crises in inner-city Athens, Greece. Antipode48(1): 172–192.
42.
KrasmannS (2007) The enemy on the border: critique of a programme in favour of a preventive state. Punishment & Society9(3): 301–318.
PintoM (2018) Awakening the leviathan through human rights law-how human rights bodies trigger the application of criminal law. Utrecht Journal of International and European Law34: 161.
48.
ReißigA (2022) Where the law loses its function: the contested politics of visibility surrounding pushbacks at the EU border in Greece. Crimmigratie & Recht, Aflevering 2.
49.
Reporters Without Borders (2023) World rankings. Available at: https://rsf.org/en/index (accessed 4th December 2024).
50.
RodrikD (2021) Solidarity at the border: how the EU and US criminalize aid to migrants. Berkeley Journal of International Law39: 81.
51.
SchackLWitcherA (2020) Hostile hospitality and the criminalization of civil society actors aiding border crossers in Greece. Environment and Planning D: Society and Space39(3): 477–495.
52.
SpaldingA (2022) The Treatment of Immigrants in the European Court of Human Rights: Moving Beyond Criminalisation. Oxford: Bloomsbury.
53.
StumpfJ (2006) The crimmigration crisis: immigrants, crime, and sovereign power. American University Law Review56: 367.
54.
TazzioliM (2018) Crimes of solidarity: migration and containment through rescue. Radical Philosophy2(1): 4–10.
55.
TriandafyllidouAKoukiH (2014) Naturalizing racism in the centre of Athens in May 2011: lessons from Greece. Journal of Immigrant & Refugee Studies12(4): 418–436.
56.
TsoulfidisLAlexiouCTsalikiP (2016) The Greek economic crisis: causes and alternative policies. Review of Political Economy28(3): 380–396.
