For many criminologists, theory matters more than evidence in historical studies. But can historical criminology really proceed on this basis? In this article, we argue for the importance of primary research, that is, analysis of documents that originate in the period of interest. Using examples from archived documents in a study of women imprisoned in Malta during the 19th century, we address four issues related to history and theory: gaining perspective from unfamiliar places, finding the beginning of historical processes, making discoveries from details, and recovering the significance of forgotten practices. In this, we wish to join a conversation about historical evidence and genealogical accounts in prison history. We will also contribute to the significant, but relatively limited, literature on prisons for women in the 19th century.
Alford, C.F. ( 2000) ‘What Would it Matter if Everything Foucault said about Prison Were Wrong? Discipline and Punish after Twenty Years’, Theory and Society29: 125-46.
2.
Ariza, J. ( 2010) ‘Roadblocks on Crime Research Around the World: Doing Criminology in the Semi-periphery and the Periphery’, in C. Smith, S. Zheng and R. Barbaret (eds) Handbook on International Criminology. London: Routledge.
3.
Arnold, D. ( 2007) ‘India: The Contested Prison’, in F. Dikötter and I. Brown (eds) Cultures of Confinement: A History of the Prison in Africa, Asia and Latin America. London: Hurst.
4.
Bezzina, J. ( 1988) ‘Church and State in an Island Colony’, in V. Mallia-Milannes (ed.) The British Colonial Experience , 1800-1964, pp. 47-78. Malta: Minerva.
5.
Bosworth, M. .( 1996) ‘Resistance and Compliance in Women’s Prisons: Towards a Critique of Legitimacy’Critical Criminology7: 5-19.
6.
Bosworth, M. ( 2000) ‘Confining Femininity: A History of Gender, Power and Imprisonment’, Theoretical Criminology4: 265-84.
7.
Bosworth, M. ( 2001) ‘The Past as a Foreign Country? Some Methodological Implications of Doing Historical Criminology’, British Journal of Criminology41: 431-42.
8.
Bosworth, M. and E. Carrabine ( 2001) ‘Reassessing Resistance: Race, Gender and Sexuality in Prison’, Punishment and Society3: 501-15.
9.
Burke, P. ( 2005) History and Social Theory. Cambridge : Polity.
10.
Braithwaite, J. ( 2003) ‘What’s Wrong with the Sociology of Punishment?’ , Theoretical Criminology7: 5-28.
11.
Brown, M. ( 2002) ‘The Politics of Penal Excess and the Echo of Colonial Penality’, Punishment and Society4: 403-23.
12.
Brown, M. ( 2004) ‘Crime, Liberalism and the Empire: Governing the Mina Tribe of Northern India’Social and Legal Studies13: 191-218.
13.
Brown, M. ( 2005) ‘Colonial Histories and Theories of the Present: Some Reflections Upon Penal History and Theory’, in B. Godfrey and G .Dunstall (eds) Crime and Empire 1840-1940: Criminal Justice in Local and Global Context. Abingdon: Willan .
14.
Caimari, L. ( 1997) ‘Whose Criminals are these? Church, State and the Patronatos and the Rehabilitation of Female Convicts (Beunos Aires, 1890- 1940)’, The Americas54: 185-208.
15.
Campos, M.S.Z.( 1996) ‘Vicious Women, Virtuous Women: The Female Delinquent and the Santiago de Chile Correctional House, 1860-1900’, in R.D. Salvatore and C. Aguirre (eds) The Birth of the Prison in Latin America, pp. 78-100. Austin, TX: University of Texas Press.
16.
Cannadine, D. ( 2001) Ornamentalism: How the British Saw Their Empire. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
17.
Charitable Institutions (1831) Letters from the President of the Permanent Committee of Charitable Institutions . National Archives of Malta (CI No. 70).
18.
Charitable Institutions (1881) Register of References to the Comptroller of Charitable Institutions 1880-1881 , 12 September 1881 (CI No. 17).
19.
Chief Secretary to Government (1900) Superintendent to Chief Secretary to Government, 20 June. National Archives of Malta (CSG 01, file 8972).
20.
Clark, A. ( 2005) ‘Wild Workhouse Girls and the Liberal Imperial State in Mid-Nineteenth Century Ireland’, Journal of Social History39: 389-409.
21.
Collings, J.B.H. ( 1851) Reports of the Inspector, Superintendent, Deputy Superintendent and the Chaplain of the Corradino Prison. National Archives of Malta (GMR 64).
22.
Colony of Malta (1850) Blue Book . National Archives of Malta.
23.
Colony of Malta (1892) Malta Blue Book for the Year 1891. National Archives of Malta.
24.
Colony of Malta (1895) Blue Book for the Year 1894. National Archives of Malta.
Critien, A. ( 1940) A Convent and a Hospital of the Past. Malta: Empire.
27.
Damousi, J. ( 1997) Depraved and Disorderly: Female Convicts, Sexuality and Gender in Colonial Australia. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
28.
Daniels, K. ( 1998) Convict Women. St Leonards, Australia: Allen and Unwin.
29.
Dobash, R., R. Emerson Dobash and S. Gutteridge ( 1986) The Imprisonment of Women. Oxford: Basil Blackwell.
30.
Ferguson, N. ( 2003) Empire: How Britain Made the Modern World. London: Allen Lane.
31.
Foucault, M. ( 1977) Discipline and Punish: The Birth of the Prison. London: Allen Lane.
32.
Freedman, E. ( 1984) Their Sister’s Keepers: Women’s Prison Reform in America, 1830-1930. Ann Arbor, MI: University of Michigan Press.
33.
Garland, D. ( 1981) ‘The Birth of the Welfare Sanction’, British Journal of Law and Society8: 29-45.
34.
Garland, D. ( 1985) Punishment and Welfare: A History of Penal Strategies . Aldershot: Gower.
35.
Garland, D. ( 1990) Punishment and Modern Society: A Study in Social Theory . Oxford: Oxford University Press .
36.
Garland, D. ( 1997) ‘The Punitive Society: Penology, Criminology and the History of the Present’, Edinburgh Law Review1: 180-199.
37.
Garland, D. ( 2001) The Culture of Control: Crime and Social Order in Contemporary Society. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
38.
Garland, D. ( 2005) ‘Beyond the Culture of Control’, in M. Matravers (ed.) Managing Modernity: Politics and the Culture of Control. New York: Routledge.
39.
Gelsthorpe, L. ( 2005) ‘Back to Basics in Crime Control: Weaving in Women’ , in M. Matravers (ed.) Managing Modernity: Politics and the Culture of Control. New York: Routledge.
40.
Government Gazette (1831) Proclamation , 18 July, p. 1.
41.
Government Gazette (1895) Ordinance IX, 1 March, p. 8.
42.
Hannah-Moffat, H. ( 2001) Punishment in Disguise: Penal Governance and Federal Imprisonment of Women in Canada. Toronto: University of Toronto Press.
43.
Ignatieff, M. ( 1978) A Just Measure of Pain: The Penitentiary in the Industrial Revolution, 1750-1850. New York: Pantheon.
44.
Inglott, F. ( 1868) Inglott to Governor, 20 April. National Archives of Malta (CSG 01, file 2917).
45.
Knepper, P. ( 2008) ‘Rethinking the Racialization of Crime: The Significance of African-American Firsts’, Ethnic and Racial Studies31: 503-23.
46.
Loader, I. and R. Sparks ( 2005) ‘For an Historical Sociology of Crime Policy in England and Wales since 1968’, in M. Matravers (ed.) Managing Modernity: Politics and the Culture of Control. London: Routledge.
47.
Luddy, M. ( 1988) ‘Women and Charitable Organizations in Nineteenth Century Ireland’, Women’s Studies International Forum11: 301-5.
48.
Malcolm, A. ( 1897) Letters of an Invalid from Italy, Malta and the South of France. London: Clowes.
49.
Malta Government (1851) Regulations for the Government Charitable Institutions of the Islands of Malta and Gozo . National Library of Malta.
50.
Malta Government (1881) Reports of Inspections held by the Comptroller to the Several Charitable Institutions 1881-3. National Archives of Malta, Charitable Institutions (No.183).
51.
Marchant, G. ( 1859) Marchant to Duke of Newcastle, despatch of 16 July. National Archives of Malta (GOV 1. 3.9).
52.
Martin, R.M. ( 1837) History of the British Possessions in the Mediterranean . London: Whittaker and Co.
53.
Melossi, D. ( 2001) ‘The Cultural Embeddedness of Social Control: Reflections on the Comparison of Italian and North-American Cultures Concerning Punishment’ , Theoretical Criminology5: 403-24.
54.
O’Brien, P. ( 1982) The Promise of Punishment: Prisons in Nineteenth Century France. Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press.
55.
Pulius, A. ( 1871a) Pulius to Acting CSG, 15 October. National Archives of Malta. Letters to Government March 1869 to January 1872. Charitable Institutions (No. 61).
56.
Pulius, A. ( 1871b) Pulius to CSG, 11 October. National Archives of Malta (CSG 01, file 11461).
57.
Rafter, N. ( 1985) ‘Gender, Prison and Prison History’, Social Science History9: 233-47.
58.
Rafter, N. ( 1992) Partial Justice: Women, Prisons and Social Control. New Brunswick, NJ: Transaction.
59.
Reid, K. ( 1997) ‘"Contumacious, Ungovernable and Incorrigible": Convict Women and Workplace Resistance, Van Diemen’s Land, 1820-1839’ , in I. Duffield and J. Bradley (eds) Representing Convicts: New Perspectives on Convict Forced Labour Migration. Leicester : Leicester University Press.
60.
Richardson, J. ( 1825) Report Respecting the Courts and Administration of the Law at Malta. National Archives, Kew (CO 158/54).
61.
Rothman, D. ( 1971) The Discovery of the Asylum. Boston, MA: Little Brown. Sengoopta, C. ( 2003) Imprint of the Raj: How Fingerprinting was Born in Colonial India. London: Macmillan.
62.
Scicluna, S. and P. Knepper ( 2008) ‘Prisoners of the Sun: The British Empire and Imprisonment in Early Nineteenth Century Malta’, British Journal of Criminology48: 502-21.
63.
Strange, C. ( 1985) ‘The Criminal and the Fallen of their Sex: The Establishment of Canada’s First Women’s Prison, 1874-1901’, Canadian Journal of Women and the Law1: 79-92.
64.
Svensson, K. ( 2003) ‘Social Work in the Criminal Justice System: An Ambiguous Exercise of Caring Power’, Journal of Scandinavian Studies in Criminology and Crime Prevention4: 84-100.
65.
Trombetta, S. ( 2002) ‘Public Vices, Private Remedies in Nineteenth Century Italy: Giulia Falletti di Barolo Colbert and Le Forzate’, Journal of Modern Italian Studies7: 56-73.
66.
Turnton, R. ( 1912) Report on Civil Prisons. National Archives of Malta (GMR 731).
67.
Van Drenth, A. and F. de Haan ( 1999) The Rise of Caring Power: Elizabeth Fry and Josephine Butler in Britain and the Netherlands. Amsterdam: Amsterdam University Press.
68.
Vignet, M. ( 1880) Vignet to comptroller, 4 October. National Archives of Malta (CSG 01, file 6688).
69.
Zedner, L. ( 1991) ‘Women, Crime and Penal Responses: A Historical Account’, Crime and Justice14: 307-62.
70.
Zedner, L. ( 1994) Women, Crime and Custody in Victorian England. Oxford: Clarendon Press.
71.
Zedner, L. ( 1998) ‘Wayward Sisters: The Prison for Women’, N. Morris and D. Rothman (eds) The Oxford History of the Prison, pp. 295-324. Oxford : Oxford University Press.
