There is growing interest in Family Navigation as an approach to improving access to care for children with autism spectrum disorder, yet little data exist on the implementation of Family Navigation. The aim of this study was to identify potential failures in implementing Family Navigation for children with autism spectrum disorder, using a failure modes and effects analysis. This mixed-methods study was set within a randomized controlled trial testing the effectiveness of Family Navigation in reducing the time from screening to diagnosis and treatment for autism spectrum disorder across three states. Using standard failure modes and effects analysis methodology, experts in Family Navigation for autism spectrum disorder (n = 9) rated potential failures in implementation on a 10-point scale in three categories: likelihood of the failure occurring, likelihood of not detecting the failure, and severity of failure. Ratings were then used to create a risk priority number for each failure. The failure modes and effects analysis detected five areas for potential “high priority” failures in implementation: (1) setting up community-based services, (2) initial family meeting, (3) training, (4) fidelity monitoring, and (5) attending testing appointments. Reasons for failure included families not receptive, scheduling, and insufficient training time. The process with the highest risk profile was “setting up community-based services.” Failure in “attending testing appointment” was rated as the most severe potential failure. A number of potential failures in Family Navigation implementation—along with strategies for mitigation—were identified. These data can guide those working to implement Family Navigation for children with autism spectrum disorder.
AbujudehHHDanielsonABrunoMA (2016) A patient-centered radiology quality process map: opportunities and solutions. American Journal of Roentgenology207(5): 940–946.
2.
AcharyaKMezaRMsallME (2017) Disparities in life course outcomes for transition-aged youth with disabilities. Pediatric Annals46(10): e371–e376.
3.
Ali-FaisalSFColellaTJFMedina-JaudesNet al. (2017) The effectiveness of patient navigation to improve healthcare utilization outcomes: a meta-analysis of randomized controlled trials. Patient Education and Counseling100(3): 436–448.
4.
AngellAMSolomonO (2017) “If I was a different ethnicity, would she treat me the same?”: Latino parents’ experiences obtaining autism services. Disability & Society32(8): 1142–1164.
5.
AshleyLArmitageGTaylorJ (2017) Recognising and referring children exposed to domestic abuse: a multi-professional, proactive systems-based evaluation using a modified Failure Mode and Effects Analysis (FMEA). Health & Social Care in the Community25(2): 690–699.
BenevidesTWCarrettaHJLaneSJ (2016) Unmet need for therapy among children with autism spectrum disorder: results from the 2005–2006 and 2009–2010 national survey of children with special health care needs. Maternal and Child Health Journal20(4): 878–888.
8.
BlakelyTJDziadoszGM (2008) The chronic care model for behavioral health care. Population Health Management11(6): 341–346.
BraunKLKagawa-SingerMHoldenAECet al. (2012) Cancer patient navigator tasks across the cancer care continuum. Journal of Health Care for the Poor and Underserved23(1): 398–413.
11.
Broder-FingertSWallsMAugustynMet al. (2018) A hybrid type I randomized effectiveness-implementation trial of patient navigation to improve access to services for children with autism spectrum disorder. BMC Psychiatry18(1): 79.
12.
BrysonSACorriganSKMcDonaldTPet al. (2008) Characteristics of children with autism spectrum disorders who received services through community mental health centers. Autism: The International Journal of Research and Practice12(1): 65–82.
13.
CarterAJEGouldJBVanberkelPet al. (2015) Offload zones to mitigate emergency medical services (EMS) offload delay in the emergency department: a process map and hazard analysis. Canadian Journal of Emergency Medicine17(6): 670–678.
ChamberlainPBrownCHSaldanaL (2011) Observational measure of implementation progress in community based settings: the stages of implementation completion (SIC). Implementation Science6: 116.
16.
ChambersDANortonWE (2016) The adaptome: advancing the science of intervention adaptation. American Journal of Preventive Medicine51(4Suppl. 2): S124–S131.
17.
ChiriGWarfieldME (2012) Unmet need and problems accessing core health care services for children with autism spectrum disorder. Maternal and Child Health Journal16(5): 1081–1091.
18.
ClarkJAParkerVABattagliaTAet al. (2014) Patterns of task and network actions performed by navigators to facilitate cancer care. Health Care Management Review39(2): 90–101.
19.
DamelioR (2011) The Basics of Process Mapping. 2nd ed.Boca Raton, FL: CRC Press.
20.
DamschroderLJAronDCKeithREet al. (2009) Fostering implementation of health services research findings into practice: a consolidated framework for advancing implementation science. Implementation Science4(1): 50.
21.
DembyHGregoryABroussardMet al. (2014) Implementation lessons: the importance of assessing organizational “fit” and external factors when implementing Evidence-Based Teen Pregnancy Prevention Programs. Journal of Adolescent Health54(3 Suppl.): S37–S44.
22.
DonelanKMailhotJRDutwinDet al. (2011) Patient perspectives of clinical care and patient navigation in follow-up of abnormal mammography. Journal of General Internal Medicine26(2): 116–122.
23.
EsparzaA (2013) Patient navigation and the American Cancer Society. Seminars in Oncology Nursing29(2): 91–96.
24.
FaerberAEHorvathRStillmanCet al. (2015) Development and pilot feasibility study of a health information technology tool to calculate mortality risk for patients with asymptomatic carotid stenosis: the Carotid Risk Assessment Tool (CARAT). BMC Medical Informatics and Decision Making15: 20.
FeinbergEAbufheleMSandlerJet al. (2016) Reducing disparities in timely autism diagnosis through family navigation: results from a randomized pilot trial. Psychiatric Services67(8): 912–915.
29.
FeinbergEAugustynMFitzgeraldEet al. (2014) Improving maternal mental health after a child’s diagnosis of autism spectrum disorder: results from a randomized clinical trial. JAMA Pediatrics168(1): 40–46.
30.
FeinbergESilversteinMFerreira-CesarZ (2013) Integrating mental health services for mothers of children with autism. Psychiatric Services64(9): 930–930.
31.
FreemanHP (2006) Patient navigation: a community based strategy to reduce cancer disparities. Journal of Urban Health83(2): 139–141.
32.
FreundKMBattagliaTACalhounEet al. (2014) Impact of patient navigation on timely cancer care: the Patient Navigation Research Program. Journal of the National Cancer Institute106(6): dju115.
33.
GleasonMCicuttoLHaas-HowardCet al. (2016) Leveraging partnerships: families, schools, and providers working together to improve asthma management. Current Allergy and Asthma Reports16(10): 74.
34.
GunnCMClarkJABattagliaTAet al. (2014) An assessment of patient navigator activities in breast cancer patient navigation programs using a nine-principle framework. Health Services Research49(5): 1555–1577.
35.
HedlundNRisendalBCPaulsHet al. (2014) Dissemination of patient navigation programs across the United States. Journal of Public Health Management and Practice20(4): E15–E24.
36.
HosoyaKMochinagaSEmotoAet al. (2015) Failure mode and effects analysis of medication adherence in patients with chronic myeloid leukemia. International Journal of Clinical Oncology20(6): 1203–1210.
37.
HuynhNSnyderRVidalJMet al. (2016) Assessment of the nurse medication administration workflow process. Journal of Healthcare Engineering2016: 6823185.
KeithRECrossonJCO’MalleyASet al. (2017) Using the Consolidated Framework for Implementation Research (CFIR) to produce actionable findings: a rapid-cycle evaluation approach to improving implementation. Implementation Science12(1): 15.
42.
KlinAWetherbyAMWoodsJet al. (2015) Toward innovative, cost-effective, and systemic solutions to improve outcomes and well-being of military families affected by autism spectrum disorder. The Yale Journal of Biology and Medicine88(1): 73–79.
43.
KoesterKAMorewitzMPearsonCet al. (2014) Patient navigation facilitates medical and social services engagement among HIV-infected individuals leaving jail and returning to the community. AIDS Patient Care and STDs28(2): 82–90.
44.
LewisCCStanickCFMartinezRGet al. (2015) The Society for Implementation Research Collaboration Instrument Review Project: a methodology to promote rigorous evaluation. Implementation Science10(1): 2.
45.
LinsCGerkaALüpkesCet al. (2018) Enhancing safety of artificially ventilated patients using ambient process analysis. Studies in Health Technology and Informatics247: 316–320.
46.
LockeJBeidasRSMarcusSet al. (2016) A mixed methods study of individual and organizational factors that affect implementation of interventions for children with autism in public schools. Implementation Science11: 135.
47.
MacDonaldMPaulyBWongGet al. (2016) Supporting successful implementation of public health interventions: protocol for a realist synthesis. Systematic Reviews5: 54.
48.
MadisonD (2005) Process Mapping, Process Improvement, and Process Management: A Practical Guide for Enhancing Work and Information Flow. Chico, CA: Paton Professional.
49.
MandellDSWigginsLDCarpenterLAet al. (2009) Racial/ethnic disparities in the identification of children with autism spectrum disorders. American Journal of Public Health99(3): 493–498.
50.
MangerRPPaxtonABPawlickiTet al. (2015) Failure mode and effects analysis and fault tree analysis of surface image guided cranial radiosurgery. Medical Physics42(5): 2449–2461.
51.
MarkoulakisRTurnerMWicikKet al. (2018) Exploring peer support needs of caregivers for youth with mental illness or addictions concerns in family navigation services. Community Mental Health Journal54(5): 555–561.
52.
MarkoulakisRWeingustSFootJet al. (2016) The Family Navigation Project: an innovation in working with families to match mental health services with their youth’s needs. Canadian Journal of Community Mental Health35(1): 63–66.
53.
MarshallJKMbahOMFordJGet al. (2016) Effect of patient navigation on breast cancer screening among African American Medicare beneficiaries: a randomized controlled trial. Journal of General Internal Medicine31(1): 68–76.
54.
MartinKOsterlingM (2013) Value Stream Mapping: How to Visualize Work and Align Leadership for Organizational Transformation. New York: McGraw-Hill.
55.
MayCRJohnsonMFinchT (2016) Implementation, context and complexity. Implementation Science11: 141.
56.
MyersNALAlolayanYSmithKet al. (2015) A potential role for family members in mental health care delivery: the family community navigation specialist. Psychiatric Services66(6): 653–655.
57.
National Institutes of Health (2017) PAR-17-265: initiation of a mental health family navigator model to promote early access, engagement and coordination of needed mental health services for children and adolescents, May. Available at: https://grants.nih.gov/grants/guide/pa-files/PAR-17-265.html (accessed 19 July 2018).
58.
NetaGGlasgowRECarpenterCRet al. (2015) A framework for enhancing the value of research for dissemination and implementation. American Journal of Public Health105(1): 49–57.
59.
ParikhCKurzius-SpencerMMastergeorgeAMet al. (2018) Characterizing health disparities in the age of autism diagnosis in a study of 8-year-old children. Journal of Autism and Developmental Disorders48(7): 2396–2407.
60.
ParkerVAClarkJALeysonJet al. (2010) Patient navigation: development of a protocol for describing what navigators do. Health Services Research45(2): 514–531.
61.
PaskettEDHarropJPWellsKJ (2011) Patient navigation: an update on the state of the science. CA: A Cancer Journal for Clinicians61(4): 237–249.
62.
PeavyKMGuydishJManuelJKet al. (2014) Treatment adherence and competency ratings among therapists, supervisors, study-related raters and external raters in a clinical trial of a 12-step facilitation for stimulant users. Journal of Substance Abuse Treatment47(3): 222–228.
63.
PerkinsR (2015) Understanding the impact of patient navigation. Journal of Women’s Health24(7): 544–545.
64.
PfadenhauerLMGerhardusAMozygembaKet al. (2017) Making sense of complexity in context and implementation: the Context and Implementation of Complex Interventions (CICI) framework. Implementation Science12: 21.
65.
PojasekRB (2013) Lean, six sigma, and the systems approach: management initiatives for process improvement. Environmental Quality Management13(2): 85–92.
66.
PowellBJWaltzTJChinmanMJet al. (2015) A refined compilation of implementation strategies: results from the Expert Recommendations for Implementing Change (ERIC) project. Implementation Science10: 21.
67.
ProctorEKPowellBJBaumannAAet al. (2012) Writing implementation research grant proposals: ten key ingredients. Implementation Science7: 96.
68.
RamachandranAFreundKMBakSMet al. (2015) Multiple barriers delay care among women with abnormal cancer screening despite patient navigation. Journal of Women’s Health24(1): 30–36.
69.
RienziLBarianiFDalla ZorzaMet al. (2015) Failure mode and effects analysis of witnessing protocols for ensuring traceability during IVF. Reproductive BioMedicine Online31(4): 516–522.
70.
RohanEASlotmanBDeGroffAet al. (2016) Refining the patient navigation role in a colorectal cancer screening program: results from an intervention study. Journal of the National Comprehensive Cancer Network14(11): 1371–1378.
71.
SaldanaLChamberlainPWangWet al. (2012) Predicting program start-up using the stages of implementation measure. Administration and Policy in Mental Health39(6): 419–425.
72.
ShattuckPTGrosseSD (2007) Issues related to the diagnosis and treatment of autism spectrum disorders. Mental Retardation and Developmental Disabilities Research Reviews13(2): 129–135.
73.
SheblNAFranklinBDBarberN (2012) Failure mode and effects analysis outputs: are they valid?BMC Health Services Research12(1): 150.
74.
SineathALambertLVergaCet al. (2017) Monitoring intervention fidelity of a lifestyle behavioral intervention delivered through telehealth. MHealth3: 35.
SorrentinoP (2016) Use of failure mode and effects analysis to improve emergency department handoff processes. Clinical Nurse Specialist30(1): 28–37.
77.
St AmantHGSchragerSMPeña-RicardoCet al. (2018) Language barriers impact access to services for children with autism spectrum disorders. Journal of Autism and Developmental Disorders48(2): 333–340.
78.
StahmerACReedSLeeEet al. (2015) Training teachers to use evidence-based practices for autism: examining procedural implementation fidelity. Psychology in the Schools52(2): 181–195.
79.
TerezakisSAPronovostPHarrisKet al. (2011) Safety strategies in an academic radiation oncology department and recommendations for action. Joint Commission Journal on Quality and Patient Safety37(7): 291–299.
80.
ThomasKCEllisARMcLaurinCet al. (2007) Access to care for autism-related services. Journal of Autism and Developmental Disorders37(10): 1902–1912.
81.
VaismoradiMTurunenHBondasT (2013) Content analysis and thematic analysis: implications for conducting a qualitative descriptive study. Nursing & Health Sciences15(3): 398–405.
82.
ValaitisRKCarterNLamAet al. (2017) Implementation and maintenance of patient navigation programs linking primary care with community-based health and social services: a scoping literature review. BMC Health Services Research17(1): 116.
83.
WalshKEMazorKMRoblinDet al. (2013) Multisite parent-centered risk assessment to reduce pediatric oral chemotherapy errors. Journal of Oncology Practice9(1): e1–e7.
84.
WillisG (1992) Failure modes and effects analysis in clinical engineering. Journal of Clinical Engineering17(1): 59–63.
85.
WoodJJMcLeodBDKlebanoffSet al. (2015) Toward the implementation of evidence-based interventions for youth with autism spectrum disorders in schools and community agencies. Behavior Therapy46(1): 83–95.
86.
YarmohammadianMHAbadiTNBTofighiSet al. (2014) Performance improvement through proactive risk assessment: using failure modes and effects analysis. Journal of Education and Health Promotion3: 28.
87.
YatesBCSchumacherKLNormanJEet al. (2013) Intervention fidelity in a translational study: lessons learned. Research and Theory for Nursing Practice27(2): 131–148.
88.
YinglingMEHockRMBellBA (2018) Time-lag between diagnosis of autism spectrum disorder and onset of publicly-funded early intensive behavioral intervention: do race-ethnicity and neighborhood matter?Journal of Autism and Developmental Disorders48(2): 561–571.
89.
YousefinezhadiTJannesar NobariFABehzadi GoodariFet al. (2016) A case study on improving intensive care unit (ICU) services reliability: by using process failure mode and effects analysis (PFMEA). Global Journal of Health Science8(9): 52635.
Supplementary Material
Please find the following supplemental material available below.
For Open Access articles published under a Creative Commons License, all supplemental material carries the same license as the article it is associated with.
For non-Open Access articles published, all supplemental material carries a non-exclusive license, and permission requests for re-use of supplemental material or any part of supplemental material shall be sent directly to the copyright owner as specified in the copyright notice associated with the article.
