‘Agree to disagree’: Reconciling an English teacher’s identity tensions in negotiating an educational reform through a community of practice perspective
Restricted accessResearch articleFirst published online November, 2025
‘Agree to disagree’: Reconciling an English teacher’s identity tensions in negotiating an educational reform through a community of practice perspective
Educational reforms often precipitate teacher tensions that subsequently impact teacher identity (re)construction. Adopting a community of practice (CoP) framework to examine identity-, belief- and emotion-inflected tensions, and drawing on data from five rounds of interviews, our longitudinal case study traced the identity reformation of an English teacher, Lee, as he negotiated an English for Academic Purposes (EAP) reform in China. We found that Lee’s constant teacher identity conflicts were intertwined with tensions that arose as he negotiated his (1) beliefs about students’ needs and acknowledgment of their language incompetency, and (2) reform-positive emotions and self-negative emotions. Our findings revealed, however, that these tensions were mediated through the assistance afforded by his CoP, which, on the one hand, effectively scaffolded community members’ teaching practices and helped ease the tensions that emerged but, on the other hand, created space for multiple voices to coexist, make adjustments, and thus subsequently achieve reconciliation. Highlighting the role of CoP in teacher development, our findings help advance the teacher identity research agenda by taking a holistic view on work-related tensions, and thus bear implications for educational reformers, teacher educators, and university administrators.
ArvajaM. (2018). Tensions and striving for coherence in an academic’s professional identity work. Teaching in Higher Education, 23, 291–306.
2.
BarcelosA.M.F. (2015). Unveiling the relationship between language learning beliefs, emotions and identities. Studies in Second Language Learning and Teaching, 5, 301–325.
3.
BartonD.TustingK. (2005). Beyond communities of practice: Language, power and social context. Cambridge University Press.
4.
BillotJ. (2010). The imagined and the real: Identifying the tensions for academic identity. Higher Education Research and Development, 29, 709–721.
5.
BlackledgeA.PavlenkoA. (2001). Negotiation of identities in multilingual contexts. The International Journal of Bilingualism, 5, 243–257.
6.
CampionG.C. (2016). ‘The learning never ends’: Exploring teachers’ views on the transition from General English to EAP. Journal of English for Academic Purposes, 23, 59–70.
7.
CaudleL.MoranM.J.HobbsM. (2014). The potential of communities of practice as contexts for the development of agentic teacher leaders: A three-year narrative of one early childhood teachers’ journey. Action in Teacher Education, 36, 45–60.
8.
ChenX. (2010). Identity construction and negotiation within and across school communities: The case of one English-as-a-new-language (ENL) student. Identity of Language, Identity and Education, 9, 163–179.
9.
CherkowskiS. (2018). Positive teacher leadership: Building mindsets and capacities to grow wellbeing. International Journal of Teacher Leadership, 9, 63–78.
10.
ClarkeM. (2008). Language teacher identities: Co-constructing discourse and community. Multilingual Matters.
11.
CreeseA. (2005). Mediating allegations of racism in a multiethnic London school: What speech communities and communities of practice can tell us about discourse and power. In BartonD.HamiltonM. (Eds.), Beyond communities of practice: Language, power, and social context (pp. 55–76). Cambridge University Press.
12.
CrossD.I.HongJ.Y. (2012). An ecological examination of teachers’ emotions in the school context. Teaching and Teacher Education, 28, 957–967.
13.
CrowtherF.FergusonM.HannL.2009. Developing teacher leaders: How teacher leadership enhances school success. Corwin Press.
14.
De CostaP.I.LeeJ.LiW. (Eds.) (2022). International students’ multilingual literacy practices: An asset-based approach to using semiotic resources. Multilingual Matters.
15.
DuffP.A. (2012). How to conduct case study research. In GassS.MackeyA. (Eds.), Research methodologies in second language acquisition (pp. 95–116). Wiley-Blackwell.
16.
DuffP.A. (2014). Case study research on language learning and use. Annual Review of Applied Linguistics, 34, 1–23.
17.
FloresM.A. (2005). Teachers’ views on recent curriculum changes: Tensions and challenges. The Curriculum Journal, 16, 401–413.
18.
FracchiollaC.PrefontaineB.HinkoK. (2020). Community of practice: A framework for understanding identity development within informal physics programs. Physical Review Physics Education Research, 16, 20115.
19.
FullerA. (2007). Critiquing theories of learning and communities of practice. In HughesJ.JewsonN.UnwinL. (Eds.), Communities of practice: Critical perspectives (pp. 17–29). Routledge.
20.
GaoY. (2018). ‘The end is far away’: Sources of confusions of foreign language teachers in transition to EAP and the solutions. Foreign Language Education in China, 1, 73–80.
21.
GaoY. (2019). Identity construction and emotion change in EAP teachers’ professional development: A dialogic theory perspective. Chinese Journal of ESP, 1, 1–9.
22.
GaoY.CuiY. (2021). To arrive where you are: A metaphorical analysis of teacher identity change in EAP reform. Teaching and Teacher Education, 104, 103374.
23.
GuskeyT.R. (1986). Staff development and the process of change. Educational Researcher, 15, 5–12.
24.
HiverP.Al-HoorieA.H. (2016). Putting complexity theory into practice: A dynamic ensemble for second language research. The Modern Language Journal, 100, 741–756.
25.
HoE.C.YanX. (2021). Using community of practice to characterize collaborative essay prompt writing and its role in developing language assessment literacy for pre-service language teachers. System, 101, 102569.
26.
HökkäP.VähäsantanenK.MahlakaartoS. (2017). Teacher educators’ collective professional agency and identity: Transforming marginality to strength. Teaching and Teacher Education, 63, 36–46.
27.
JewsonN. (2007). Cultivating network analysis: Rethinking the concept of ‘community’ within ‘communities of practice’. In HughesJ.JewsonN.UnwinL. (Eds.), Communities of practice (pp. 68–82). Routledge.
28.
JohnstonD.H. (2016). ‘Sitting alone in the staffroom contemplating my future’: Communities of practice, legitimate peripheral participation and student teachers’ experiences of problematic school placements as guests. Cambridge Journal of Education, 46, 533–551.
29.
KalajaP.BarcelosA.M.F.AroM.Ruobotie-LyhtyM. (2015). Beliefs, agency and identity in foreign language learning and teaching. Palgrave Macmillan.
30.
LaveJ.WengerE. (1991). Situated learning: Legitimate peripheral participation. Cambridge University Press.
31.
LiW. (2020). Unpacking the complexities of teacher identity: Narratives of two Chinese teachers of English in China. Language Teaching Research. Epub ahead of print 17April2020. DOI: 10.1177/1362168820910955.
32.
Liebech-LienB. (2021). Teacher teams: A support or a barrier to practicing cooperative learning?Teaching and Teacher Education, 106, 103453.
33.
MahmoudD.A. (2019). The role of emotions and beliefs in developing language teacher’s professional identity (Unpublished MA thesis). The American University in Cairo, Cairo, Egypt.
34.
Ministry of Education (2017). Guidelines for college English teaching. Ministry of Education of the People’s Republic of China.
35.
MoateJ.Ruohotie-LyhtyM. (2014). Identity, agency and community: Reconsidering the pedagogic responsibilities of teacher education. British Journal of Educational Studies, 62, 249–264.
36.
MoosL. (2005). How do schools bridge the gap between external demands for accountability and the need for internal trust?Journal of Educational Change, 6, 307–328.
37.
MoritaN. (2004). Negotiating participation and identity in second language academic communities. TESOL Quarterly, 38, 573–603.
38.
PillenM.BeijaardD.den BrokP. (2013). Professional identity tensions of beginning teachers. Teachers and Teaching: Theory and Practice, 19, 660–678.
39.
PyhältöK.PietarinenJ.SoiniT. (2015). Teachers’ professional agency and learning: From adaption to active modification in the teacher community. Teachers and Teaching: Theory and Practice, 21, 811–830.
40.
RaoX. (2018). University English for academic purposes in China: A phenomenological interview study. Springer.
41.
RuanX.ZhengX.ToomA. (2020). From perceived discrepancies to intentional efforts: Understanding English department teachers’ agency in classroom instruction in a changing curricular landscape. Teaching and Teacher Education, 92, 103074.
42.
Ruohotie-LyhtyM.MoateJ. (2016). Who and how? Preservice teachers as active agents developing professional identities. Teaching and Teacher Education, 55, 318–327.
43.
Ruohotie-LyhtyM.AragãoR.C.Pitkänen-HuhtaA. (2021). Language teacher identities as socio-politically situated construction: Finnish and Brazilian student teachers’ visualisations of their professional futures. Teaching and Teacher Education, 100, 103270.
44.
ShiL.YangL. (2014). A community of practice of teaching English writing in a Chinese university. System, 42, 133–142.
45.
TaoJ.GaoX. (2017). Teacher agency and identity commitment in curricular reform. Teaching and Teacher Education, 63, 346–355.
46.
TaoJ.GaoX. (2018). Identity constructions of ESP teachers in a Chinese university. English for Specific Purposes, 49, 1–13.
47.
TengF. (2019). Autonomy, agency, and identity in teaching and learning English as a foreign language. Springer.
48.
ToomA.PietarinenJ.SoiniT.PyhältöK. (2017). How does the learning environment in teacher education cultivate first year student teachers’ sense of professional agency in the professional community?Teaching and Teacher Education, 63, 126–136.
49.
VähäsantanenK. (2015). Professional agency in the stream of change: Understanding educational change and teachers’ professional identities. Teaching and Teacher Education, 47, 1–12.
50.
VähäsantanenK.HökkäP.EteläpeltoA.Rasku-PuttonenH.LittletonK. (2008). Teachers’ professional identity negotiations in two different work organisations. Vocations and Learning, 1, 131–148.
51.
van LierL. (2005). Case study. In HinkelE. (Ed.), Handbook of research in second language teaching and learning (pp. 195–208). Lawrence Erlbaum.
52.
van WaesS.van den BosscheP.MoolenaarN.M.De MaeyerVan PetegemP. (2015). Know-who? Linking faculty’s networks to stages of instructional development. Higher Education, 70, 807–826.
53.
VargheseM.MorganB.JohnstonB.JohnsonK.A. (2005). Theorizing language teacher identity: Three perspectives and beyond. Journal of Language, Identity, and Education, 4, 21–44.
54.
WangS. (2018). Enhancing and improving college English teaching in the process of building first-class universities. China University Teaching, 10, 15–18.
55.
WenQ. (2019). Language teachers’ professional learning in China. In BarkhuizenG. (Ed.), Qualitative research topics in language teacher education (pp. 39–43). Routledge.
56.
WengerE. (1998). Communities of practice: Learning, meaning, and identity. Cambridge University Press.
57.
WengerE. (2010). Communities of practice and social learning systems: The career of a concept. In BlackmoreC. (Ed.), Social learning systems and community of practice (pp. 179–198). Springer.
58.
WengerE.McDermottR.A.SnyderW. (2002). Cultivating communities of practice: A guide to managing knowledge. Harvard Business Press.
59.
WhitchurchC. (2008). Beyond administration and management: Reconstructing the identities of professional staff in UK higher education. Journal of Higher Education Policy and Management, 30, 375–386.
60.
WilliamsJ. (2010). Constructing a new professional identity: Career change into teaching. Teaching and Teacher Education, 26, 639–647.
61.
WuH.D.BadgerR.G. (2009). In a strange and uncharted land: ESP teachers’ strategies for dealing with unpredicted problems in subject knowledge during class. English for Specific Purposes, 28, 19–32.
62.
WuZ.ChenJ. (2018). Teachers’ emotional experience: Insights from Hong Kong primary schools. Asia Pacific Education Review, 19, 531–541.
63.
YuanR. (2020). Novice nontraditional teacher educators’ identity (re) construction in higher education: A Hong Kong perspective. International Journal of Educational Research, 99, 101508.
