While data on perceived morbidity often correlate poorly with clinical morbidity, they can provide an indicator for how women’s concepts of health change in the context of larger transitions in gender and health systems. Drawing on multiple sources of data on perceived morbidity among women in a peri-urban settlement of Maharashtra, India, this article examines variations in women’s thresholds for articulating illness conditions. Data on women’s health were collected from married women aged 15–49, using four different instruments: focus group discussion guides; general illness narrative guidelines; individual open-ended questions about morbidity; and a highly structured checklist. Comparing the data and the assumptions underlying these instruments, the article identifies four different thresholds relating to situational, agency, prototypical and dimensional aspects of women’s experience and subsequent reporting of morbidity.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
Ashtekar, S., & Mankad, D. (2001). Who cares? Rural health practitioners in Maharashtra . Economic and Political Weekly, 3–10 February.
2.
Bang, R. A., & Bang, A. (1993). Why women hide them. Rural women’s viewpoints on reproductive tract infections . Manushi, 69, 27–30 .
3.
Bang, R. A., Bang, A. T., Baitule, M., Chadhury, Y., Sarmukaddam, S., & Tale, O. (1989). High prevalence of gynaecological diseases in rural Indian women . The Lancet, 14 January: 85–88 .
4.
Bhatia, J., & Cleland, J. (1995). Self-reported symptoms of gynaecological morbidity and their treatment in South India . Studies in Family Planning, 26(4), 203–216 .
5.
Bhatia, J., Cleland, J., Bhagawan, L., & Rao, N. S. N. (1997). Levels and determinants of gynaecological morbidity in a district of South India . Studies in Family Planning, 28(2), 95–103 .
6.
Bulut, A., Yolsal, N., Filipi, V., & Graham, W. (1995). In search of truth: Comparing alternative sources of information on reproductive tract infection . Reproductive Health Matters, 6, 31–39 .
7.
Caldwell, J., & Caldwell, P. (1993). Women’s position and child mortality and morbidity in less developed countries. In N. Federici, K. Mason, & S. Sogner (Eds.), Women’s position and demographic change(pp. 122–139). Oxford: Clarendon Press .
8.
Chatterji, S., Ustun, B., Sadana, R., Salomon, J., Mathers, C., & Murray, C. (2002). The conceptual basis for measuring and reporting on health. Global Programme on Evidence for Health Policy Discussion Paper No. 45. Geneva: World Health Organization .
9.
Correa, S., & Petchesky, R. (1994). Reproductive and sexual rights: A feminist perspective. In G. Sen, A. Germain, & L. Chen (Eds.), Population policies reconsidered. Health, empowerment, and rights, (pp. 107–120). Boston, MA: Harvard University Press .
10.
D’Andrade, R. (1995). The development of cognitive anthropology. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press .
11.
Das, V. (1994). Modernity and biography: Women’s lives in contemporary India . Thesis Eleven, 39: 52–62 .
12.
Dixon-Mueller, R., & Wasserheit, J. N. (1991). The culture of silence: Reproductive tract infections among women in the third world. New York: International Women’s Health Coalition .
13.
Ford Foundation. (1998). New Delhi Office:Reproductive health and population program. New Delhi: Policy report .
14.
Ginsburg, F., & Rapp, R. (1991). The politics of reproduction . Annual Reviews in Anthropology, 20, 311–343 .
15.
Hawkes, S., Morrison, L., Foster, S., Gausia, K. et al. (1999). Reproductive tract infections in women in low-income, low-prevalence situations: Assessment of syndromic management in Matlab, Bangladesh . The Lancet, 354(9192), 1776–1781 .
16.
International Institute for Population Sciences (IIPS). (1995). National Family Health Survey (NFHS-1), India, 1992–93: Maharashtra. Pune: Population Research Centre and Mumbai: International Institute for Population Sciences .
17.
International Institute for Population Sciences (IIPS) and ORC Macro. (2002). National Family Health Survey (NFHS-2), India, 1998–99: Maharashtra. Mumbai, India: International Institute for Population Sciences .
18.
Jeffrey, R., & Jeffrey, P. (1997). Population, gender and politics: Demographic change in rural north India. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press .
19.
Johansson, S. R. (1991). The health transition: The cultural inflation of morbidity during the decline of mortality . Health Transition Review, 1, 39–68 .
20.
Kalter, H. (1992). The validation of interviews for estimating morbidity . Health Policy and Planning, 7(1), 30–39 .
21.
Kamat, V. R. (1995). Reconsidering the popularity of primary health centres in India: A case study from rural Maharashtra . Social Science and Medicine, 41(1), 87–98 .
22.
Kamat, V. R., & Nichter, M. (1998). Pharmacies, selfmedication and pharmaceutical marketing in Bombay, India . Social Science and Medicine, 47(6), 779–794 .
23.
Kaufman, J., Liqin, Y., Tongyin, W., & Faulkner, A. (1999). A study of field-based methods for diagnosing reproductive tract infections in rural Yunnan Province, China . Studies in Family Planning, 30(2), 112–119 .
24.
Kielmann, K. (2000). Perceived morbidity and the dynamics of ‘women’s health’ in low-income areas of Maharashtra, India. PhD Dissertation, Johns Hopkins University School of Public Heath, Baltimore, MD.
25.
Kielmann, K. (2002). Theorising health in the context of transition: The dynamics of perceived morbidity in peri-urban Maharashtra, India . Medical Anthropology, 21(2), 157–205 .
26.
Kleinman, A. (1995) A critique of objectivity in international health. In A. Kleinman, Writing at the margins: Discourse between anthropology and medicine(pp. 69–94). Berkeley: University of California Press .
27.
Koenig, M., Jejeebhoy, S., Singh, S., & Sridhar, S. (1998). Investigating women’s gynaecological morbidity in India: Not just another KAP survey . Reproductive Health Matters, 6(11), 84–96 .
28.
Kumar, A., & Vlassoff, C. (1997). Gender relations and education of girls in two Indian communities: Implications for decisions about childbearing . Reproductive Health Matters, 10, 139–150 .
29.
Kumar, R. M. M., Singh, A., & Kaur, M. (1994). Reproductive health behaviour of rural women . Journal of the Indian Medical Association, 93(4), 129–131 .
30.
Latha, K., Kanani, S. J., & Maitra, N. (1997). Prevalence of clinically detectable gynecological morbidity in India: Results of four community based studies . Journal of Family Welfare, 43(4), 8–16 .
31.
Lindenbaum, S., Chakraborty, M., & Elias, M. (1985). The influence of maternal education on infant and child mortality in Bangladesh. Dhaka, Bangladesh: ICDDR Special Publication No. 23.
32.
Morsy, S. (1998). Not only women: Science as resistance in open door Egypt. In M. Lock & P. Kaufert (Eds.), Pragmatic women and body politics(77–97). Cambridge: Cambridge University Press .
33.
Murray, C., & Chen, L. (1992). Understanding morbidity change . Population and Development Review, 18(3), 481–503 .
34.
Murray, C., & Lopez, A. (1998). Quantifying the health risks of sex and reproduction: Implications of alternative definitions. In C. Murray & A. Lopez (Eds.), Health dimensions of sex and reproduction(pp. 1–17). Geneva: WHO .
35.
Oomman, N. M. (1996). Poverty and pathology:Comparing rural Rajasthani women’s ethnomedical models with biomedical models of reproductive morbidity: Implications for women’s health in India. Dissertation Thesis submitted to the School of Hygiene and Public Health of the Johns Hopkins University, Baltimore, MD.
36.
O’Toole Erwin, J. (1993). Reproductive tract infections among women in Ado-Ekiti, Nigeria: Symptoms recognition, perceived causes and treatment choices . Health Transition Review, 3(Suppl.), 135–149 .
37.
Population Council. (1996). Research related to the assessment and management of reproductive tract infections and sexually transmitted diseases in the Indian context . Report on a workshop, 15–17 October, India International Centre, 40 Lodi Estate, New Delhi.
38.
Ravindran, T. K. S. (1999). Female autonomy in Tamil Nadu: Unravelling the complexities . Economic and Political Weekly, 17–24 April, 34–44 .
39.
Ronsmans, C., Achadi, E., Cohen, S., & Zazri, A. (1997). Women’s recall of obstetric complications in South Kalimantan, Indonesia . Studies in Family Planning, 29(3), 203–214 .
40.
Sadana, R. (2000). Measuring reproductive health: Review of community-based approaches to assessing morbidity . Bulletin of the World Health Organization, 79(5), 640–654 .
41.
Sadana, R. (2002). Definition and measurement of reproductive health . Bulletin of the World Health Organization, 80(5), 407–409 .
42.
Sen, G. (1999). Southern feminist perspectives on population and reproductive rights: Continuing challenges . Development, 42(1), 25–28 .
43.
Singh, J. (1998) Marriage in transition . Guru Nanak Journal of Sociology, 19(1), 25–66 .
44.
Sugar, A. J., Kleinman, A., & Heggenhougen, K. (1995). Development’s ‘downside’: Social and psychological pathology in countries undergoing social change . Health Transition Review, 1(2), 211–220 .
45.
Vishwanath, S., Talwar, V., Prasad, R., Coyaji, K., Elias, C., & DeZoysa, I. (2000). Syndromic management of vaginal discharge among women in a reproductive health clinic in India . Sexually Transmitted Infections, 76, 303–306 .
46.
Vlassoff, C. (1991). Progress and stagnation: Changes in fertility and women’s position in an Indian village . Population Studies, 46, 195–212 .
47.
Vlassoff, C. (1996). Against the odds: The changing impact of schooling on female autonomy and fertility in an Indian village. In R. Jeffrey & A. Basu (Eds.), Girls’ schooling, women’s autonomy and fertility change in South Asia(pp. 218–234). Thousand Oaks, CA: Sage Publications .
48.
Wasserheit, J. N. (1992). Epidemiological synergy relationships between human immunodeficiency virus infection and other sexually transmitted diseases . Sexually Transmitted Diseases, 19, 61–77 .
49.
Wasserheit, J. N., Harris, J. R., Chakraborty, J., Kay, B. A., & Mason, K. J. (1989). Reproductive tract infections in a family planning population in rural Bangladesh . Studies in Family Planning, 20(2), 69–80 .
50.
Winkvist, A., & Akhtar, F. (1997). Images of health and health care options among low income women in Punjab, Pakistan . Social Science and Medicine, 45(10), 1483–1491 .
51.
Younis, N., Khattab, H., Zurayk, H., El-Mouelhy, M., Fadle Amin, M., & Farag, A. M. (1993). A community study of gynaecological and related morbidities in rural Egypt . Studies in Family Planning, 24(3), 175–186 .
52.
Zurayk, H., Khattab, H., Younis, N., El-Mouelhy, M., & Fadle, M. (1993). Concepts and measures of reproductive morbidity . Health Transition Review, 3(1), 17–40 .
53.
Zurayk, H., Khattab, H., Younis, N., Kamal, O., & El-Helw, M. (1995). Comparing women’s reports with medical diagnoses of reproductive morbidity conditions in rural Egypt . Studies in Family Planning, 26(1), 14–21 .
