The aim of the study was to determine the relative effectiveness of compression therapies used in the treatment of venous leg ulcers. Randomized controlled trials (RCT) were sought using a search strategy that aimed to identify relevant RCT by searching eight electronic databases (including Medline, Embase and CINHAL), conference proceedings and hand searching key journals. In addition, citations within papers were scrutinized to identify any relevant studies. Suitability for inclusion in this review was determined by a critical appraisal of key determinants of the quality of the trials. Trials that included patients of mixed ulcer aetiology were excluded unless the results of patients with venous disease were reported separately. Data was extracted independently by two reviewers and synthesized quantitatively and qualitatively. Losses to follow-up/withdrawals were assumed to be failures of treatment.
A total of 132 articles were identified, and of these eight fulfilled the inclusion criteria. The remaining 126 trials were excluded due to trial design flaws, the inclusion of mixed/arterial aetiology ulcers or because they were non-RCT. Meta-analysis using a random-effects model showed the benefits of multi-layer and elastic compression bandages. It was concluded that more high-quality trials are required and that more emphasis should be placed on economic and quality of life data to try to ascertain the cost-effectiveness and utility of the treatment options available.
Charles H.Compression healing of venous ulcers. Nurs Times1992; 88(3): 52-52.
3.
Phillips T, Stanton B, Provan A, Lew R.A study of the impact of leg ulcers on quality of life: financial, social, and psychologic implications. J Am Acad Dermatol1994; 31: 49-53.
4.
Callam MJ, Ruckley CV, Harper DR, Dale JJ.Chronic ulceration of the leg: extent of the problem and provision of care. BMJ1985; 290: 1855-1856.
5.
Lees TA, Lambert D.Prevalence of lower limb ulceration in an urban health district. Br J Surg1992; 79(10): 1032-1034.
6.
Dale JJ.Chronic ulcers of the leg: a study of prevalence in a Scottish community. Health Bull1983; 41(6): 310-314.
7.
Andersson E, Hansson C, Swanbeck G.Leg and foot ulcer prevalence and investigation of the peripheral arterial and venous circulation in a randomized elderly population - an epidemiologic survey and clinical investigation. Acta Derm Venereol1993; 73: 57-61.
Bosanquet N.Costs of venous ulcers - from maintenance therapy to investment programs. Phlebology1992; 7: 44-46.
10.
Mulrow CD, Oxman AD, eds. Cochrane Collaboration Handbook (updated September 1997), 4th edition. Oxford: The Cochrane Collaboration. Update Software; 1997.
11.
CRD York. Undertaking systematic reviews of research on effectiveness: CRD guidelines for those carrying out or commissioning reviews. Report no. 4. York: Centre for Reviews and Dissemination, 1996: 10-10
12.
Ertl P.Incidence and aetiology of leg ulcers. Prof Nurse1991; 9: 190-196.
13.
Moffatt CJ, Dorman MC.Recurrence of leg ulcers within a community ulcer service. J Wound Care1995; 4: 57-61.
Moffatt C, O’Hare L.Graduated compression hosiery for venous leg ulceration. J Wound Care1995; 4: 459-462.
20.
Nelson EA.Compression bandages in the treatment of venous leg ulcers. J Wound Care1996; 5: 415-418.
21.
Thompson B, Hooper P, Powell R.Four-layer bandaging and healing rates of venous leg ulcers. J Wound Care1996; 5: 213-216.
22.
Erickson CA, Lanza DJ, Karp DLet al.Healing of venous ulcers in an ambulatory care program: the roles of chronic venous insufficiency and patient compliance. J Vasc Surg1995; 22(5): 629-636.
23.
Callam MJ, Ruckley CV.Hazards of compression treatment of the leg: an estimate from Scottish surgeons. BMJ1987; 295: 1382-1382.
24.
Edwards L, Moffatt C.The use of compression hosiery in the care of leg ulcers. Nursing Standard1996; 10(31): 53-56.
25.
Butson ARC.Intermittent pneumatic calf compression for prevention of deep venous thrombosis in general abdominal surgery. Am J Surg1981; 142: 525-527.
26.
Scurr JH, Coleridge Smith PD, Hasty JH.Regimen for improved effectiveness of intermittent pneumatic compression in deep venous thrombosis prophylaxis. Surgery1987; 102: 816-820.
27.
Turpie AGG, Hirsh J, Gent M, Julian D, Johnson J.Prevention of deep vein thrombosis in potential neurosurgical patients. A randomized trial comparing graduated compression stockings alone or graduated compression stockings plus intermittent pneumatic compression with control. Arch Intern Med1989; 149: 679-681.
28.
Fentem PH.Defining the compression provided by hosiery and bandages. CARE Sci Pract1990; 8(2): 53-55.
Hofman D.Intermittent compression treatment for venous leg ulcers. J Wound Care1995; 4: 163-165.
31.
Franks PJ, Bosanquet N, Connolly M.Venous ulcer healing: effect of socioeconomic factors in London. J Epidemiol Community Health1995; 49: 385-388.
32.
Callam MJ, Harper DR, Dale JJet al.Lothian and Forth Valley leg ulcer healing trial. 1. Elastic versus nonelastic bandaging in the treatment of chronic leg ulceration. Phlebology1992; 7: 136-141.
33.
Begg C, Cho M, Eastwood S, Horton R, Moher D, Olkin I.Improving the quality of reporting of randomized controlled trials: the CONSORT statement. JAMA1996; 276: 637-639.
34.
Franks PJ, Oldroyd MI, Dickson D, Sharp EJ, Moffatt CJ.Risk factors for leg ulcer recurrence: a randomized trial of two types of compression stocking. Age Ageing1995; 24: 490-494.
35.
Nelson EA, Harper DR, Ruckley CV, Prescott RJ, Gibson B, Dale JJ.A randomized trial of single layer and multi-layer bandages in the treatment of chronic venous ulceration. Phlebology1995; 1 (suppl): 915-916.
36.
Callam MJ, Harper DR, Dale JJet al.Lothian and Forth Valley leg ulcer healing trial. 2. Knitted viscose dressing versus a hydrocellular dressing in the treatment of chronic leg ulceration. Phlebology1992; 7: 142-145.
37.
Kikta MJ, Schuler JJ, Meyer JPet al.A prospective, randomized trial of Unna’s boots versus hydroactive dressing in the treatment of venous stasis ulcers. J Vasc Surg1988; 7: 478-483.
38.
Cordts PR, Hanrahan LM, Rodriguez AAet al.A prospective, randomized trial of Unna’s boot versus Duoderm CGF hydroactive dressing plus compression in the management of venous leg ulcers [see comments]. J Vasc Surg1992; 15: 480-486.
39.
Rubin JR, Alexander J, Plecha EJ, Marman C.Unna’s boot vs polyurethane foam dressings for the treatment of venous ulceration. A randomized prospective study. Arch Surg1990; 125: 489-490.
40.
Travers JP, Dalziel KL, Makin GS.Assessment of a new one-layer adhesive bandaging method in maintaining prolonged limb compression and effects on venous ulcer healing. Phlebology1992; 7: 59-63.
41.
Blair SD, Wright DDI, Backhouse CM, Riddle E, Mccollum CN.Sustained compression and healing of chronic venous ulcers. BMJ1988; 297: 1159-1161.
42.
Samson RH.A prospective, randomized trial of unnas boot versus duoderm cgf hydroactive dressing plus compression in the management of venous leg ulcers. J Vasc Surg1992; 16: 500-501.
43.
Duby T, Hoffman D, Cameron J, Doblhoffbrown D, Cherry G, Ryan T.A randomized trial in the treatment of venous leg ulcers comparing short stretch bandages, 4 layer bandage system, and a long stretch paste bandage system. Wounds1993; 5: 276-279.
44.
Stegmann WAE, Hubner K, Deichmann B, Muller B.Wirksamkeit der 0-(b-hydroxyethyl)-rutoside bei der behandlung des venosen ulcus cruris. Therapiewoche1986; 36: 1828-1833.
45.
Allsup DJ.Use of the intermittent pneumatic compression device in venous ulcer disease. J Vasc Nurs1994; 12(4): 106-111.
46.
Lapilli A, Alonzo U, Zendron R, Piccinni L.Alternative methods in the treatment of varicose ulcers and results. Minerva Cardioangiol1986; 34: 251-254.
47.
Davis LB, McCulloch JM, Neal MB.The effectiveness of Unna boot and semipermeable film versus Unna boot alone in the healing of venous ulcers. Ostomy Wound Manage1992; 38: 19-21.
48.
Warburg FE, Danielsen L, Madsen SMet al.Vein surgery with or without skin grafting versus conservative treatment for leg ulcers. A randomized prospective study. Acta Derm Venereol1994; 74: 307-309.
49.
Arnold TE, Stanley JC, Fellows EPet al.Prospective, multicenter study of managing lower extremity venous ulcers. Ann Vasc Surg1994; 8: 356-362.
50.
Williams C.Profore four-layer bandage system. B J Nursing1996; 5(17): 1075-1076.
51.
Charles H.Developing a leg ulcer management programme. Prof Nurse1996; 11(7): 475-477.
52.
Moffatt C, Franks F.The problem of recurrence in patients with leg ulceration. J Tissue Viabil1995; 5: 64-66.
53.
Queral LA, Criado FJ, Lilly MP, Rudolphi D.The role of sclerotherapy as an adjunct to Unna’s boot for treating venous ulcers: a prospective study. J Vasc Surg1990; 11: 572-575.
54.
Callam MJ, Haiart D, Farouk M, Brown D, Prescott RJ, Ruckley CV.Effect of time and posture on pressure profiles obtained by three different types of compression. Phlebology1991; 6: 79-84.
55.
Kristensen JK, Hein Sindrup J, Jelstrup Petersen L, Peters K, Danielsen L.A conventional compression bandage lacks effect on subcutaneous blood flow when walking and during passive dependence in chronic venous insufficiency. Acta Derm Venereol1991; 71: 450-451.
56.
Callam MJ, Harper DR, Dale JJ, Ruckley CV, Prescott RJ.A controlled trial of weekly ultrasound therapy in chronic leg ulceration. Lancet1987; ii: 204-205.
57.
Neumann HA, van den Broek MJ.A comparative clinical trial of graduated compression stockings and O-(beta-hydroxyethyl)-rutosides (HR) in the treatment of patients with chronic venous insufficiency. Z Lymphol1995; 19: 8-11.
58.
Hendricks WM, Swallow RT.Management of stasis leg ulcers with Unna’s boots versus elastic support stockings. J Am Acad Dermatol1985; 12: 90-98.
59.
Charles H.Compression healing of ulcers. J District Nurs1991; 10(3): 4-8.
60.
Tuxill W, Kenmore P.Bedford Leg Ulcer Project. Bedford: North Bedfordshire HA Community Health Services Unit, 1992.
61.
Pearce K.Show a leg. Health Serv J1996; 106: 190-196.
62.
Moffatt CJ, Oldroyd MI.A pioneering service to the community: the Riverside Community Leg Ulcer Project. Prof Nurse1994; 9: 486-497.
63.
Fletcher A, Cullum N, Sheldon TA.A systematic review of compression treatment for venous leg ulcers. BMJ1997; 315: 576-580.
64.
McHorney CA, Ware JE, Raczek AE.The MOS 36-item short-form health survey (SF-36) 1. Conceptual framework and item selection. Med Care1992; 30: 473-483.
65.
The Euroqol Group. Euroqol - a new facility for the measurement of health-related quality of life. Health Policy1990; 16: 199-208.
66.
Lindholm C, Bjellerup M, Christensen OB, Zederfeldt B.Quality of life in chronic leg ulcer patients. An assessment according to the Nottingham Health Profile. Acta Derm Venereol1993; 73: 440-443.
67.
Hamer C, Cullum NA, Roe BH.Patients’ perceptions of chronic leg ulcers. J Wound Care1994; 3: 99-101.
68.
Franks PJ, Moffatt CJ, Connolly Met al.Community leg ulcer clinics: effect on quality of life. Phlebology1994; 9: 83-86.
