Telehealth has become increasingly routine within healthcare and has potential to reduce barriers to care, including for Indigenous populations. However, it is crucial for practitioners to first ensure that their telehealth practice is culturally safe. This review aims to describe the attributes of culturally safe telehealth consultations for Indigenous people as well as strategies that could promote cultural safety.
Methods
A scoping review was conducted on key features of cultural safety in telehealth for Indigenous people using the Johanna Briggs Institute (JBI) guidelines and PRISMA-ScR checklist. Five electronic databases were searched, and additional literature was identified through handsearching.
Results
A total of 649 articles were screened resulting in 17 articles included in the review. The central themes related to the provision of culturally safe telehealth refer to attributes of the practitioner: cultural and community knowledge, communication skills and the building and maintenance of patient–provider relationships. These practitioner attributes are modified and shaped by external environmental factors: technology, the availability of support staff and the telehealth setting.
Discussion
This review identified practitioner-led features which enhance cultural safety but also recognised the structural factors that can contribute, both positively and negatively, to the cultural safety of a telehealth interaction. For some individuals, telehealth is not a comfortable or acceptable form of care. However, if strategies are undertaken to make telehealth more culturally safe, it has the potential to increase opportunities for access to care and thus contribute towards reducing health inequalities faced by Indigenous peoples.
GajarawalaSNPelkowskiJN. Telehealth benefits and barriers. J Nurse Pract2021; 17: 218–221.
2.
SnoswellCCafferyLJHaydonHM, et al.Telehealth uptake in general practice as a result of the coronavirus (COVID-19) pandemic. Aust Health Rev2020; 44: 737–740.
MannDMChenJChunaraR, et al.COVID-19 transforms health care through telemedicine: evidence from the field. J Am Med Inform Assoc2020; 27: 1132–1135.
5.
ThomasEEHaydonHMMehrotraA, et al.Building on the momentum: sustaining telehealth beyond COVID-19. J Telemed Telecare2022; 28: 301–308.
6.
ChelbergGRButtenKMahoneyR. Culturally safe ehealth interventions with Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander people: protocol for a best practice framework. JMIR Res Protoc2022; 11: e34904.
7.
FienSDowsettCHunterCL, et al.Feasibility, satisfaction, acceptability and safety of telehealth for First Nations and culturally and linguistically diverse people: a scoping review. Public Health2022; 207: 119–126.
8.
ChangJELaiAYGuptaA, et al.Rapid transition to telehealth and the digital divide: implications for primary care access and equity in a post-COVID era. Milbank Q2021; 99: 340–368.
9.
Royal Australian College of General Practitioners. Guide to providing telephone and video consultations in general practice. East Melbourne, VIC: RACGP, 2020.
World Health Organisation. Consolidated telemedicine implementation guide. Geneva: World Health Organisation, 2022.
12.
Canadian Institute for Health Information. Measuring cultural safety in health systems. Ontario, Canada: Canadian Institute for Health Information, 2021.
13.
National Aboiriginal and Torres Strait Islander Health Worker Association. Cultural safety framework. Canberra, Australia: National Aboriginal and Torres Strait Health Workers Association Ltd, 2013.
14.
De ZilvaSWalkerTPalermoC, et al.Culturally safe health care practice for Indigenous peoples in Australia: a systematic meta-ethnographic review. J Health Serv Res Policy2022; 27: 74–84.
15.
DarrochFGilesASandersonP, et al.The United States does CAIR about cultural safety: examining cultural safety within Indigenous health contexts in Canada and the United States. J Transcult Nurs2017; 28: 269–277.
16.
KirmayerLJFungKRousseauC, et al.Guidelines for training in cultural psychiatry. Can J Psychiatry2021; 66: 195–246.
17.
WilsonDde la RondeSBrascoupéS, et al.Health professionals working with First Nations, Inuit, and Métis consensus guideline. J Obstet Gynaecol Can2013; 35: 550–553.
18.
KildeaSStapletonHMurphyR, et al.The Murri clinic: a comparative retrospective study of an antenatal clinic developed for Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander women. BMC Pregnancy Childbirth2012; 12.
19.
MehusGBongoBAEngnesJI, et al.Exploring why and how encounters with the Norwegian health-care system can be considered culturally unsafe by North Sami-speaking patients and relatives: a qualitative study based on 11 interviews. Int J Circumpolar Health2019; 78: 1612703.
20.
JacklinKMHendersonRIGreenME, et al.Health care experiences of Indigenous people living with type 2 diabetes in Canada. Can Med Assoc J2017; 189: E106–E112.
21.
AndersonIRobsonBConnollyM, et al.Indigenous and tribal peoples’ health (The Lancet-Lowitja Institute Global Collaboration): a population study. Lancet2016; 388: 131–157.
22.
CafferyLJBradfordNKWickramasingheSI, et al.Outcomes of using telehealth for the provision of healthcare to Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander people: a systematic review. Aust N Z J Public Health2017; 41: 48–53.
23.
ThorpeAYashadhanaABilesB, et al.Indigenous health and connection to country. Oxford University Press, 2023.
24.
BrumptonKWardREvansR, et al.Assessing cultural safety in general practice consultations for indigenous patients: protocol for a mixed methods sequential embedded design study. BMC Med Educ2023; 23: 306.
25.
BrumptonKEvansRWardR, et al.A consistent definition of cultural safety within Australian health professional education: a scoping review. AlterNative2022; 18: 436–444.
26.
CurtisEJonesRTipene-LeachD, et al.Why cultural safety rather than cultural competency is required to achieve health equity: a literature review and recommended definition. Int J Equity Health2019; 18: 174.
Ruiz-CosignaniDChenYCheungG, et al.Adaptation models, barriers, and facilitators for cultural safety in telepsychiatry: a systematic scoping review. J Telemed Telecare2022: 1357633x211069664.
PetersMDJMarnieCTriccoAC, et al.Updated methodological guidance for the conduct of scoping reviews. JBI Evidence Synthesis2020; 18: 2119–2126.
35.
TriccoACLillieEZarinW, et al.PRISMA Extension for scoping reviews (PRISMA-ScR): checklist and explanation. Ann Intern Med2018; 169: 467–473.
36.
HadelerEGitlowHNouriK. Definitions, survey methods, and findings of patient satisfaction studies in teledermatology: a systematic review. Arch Dermatol Res2021; 313: 205–215.
37.
ParkYT. Emerging new era of mobile health technologies. Healthc Inform Res2016; 22: 253–254.
38.
RosenbaumL. Cursed by knowledge — building a culture of psychological safety. N Engl J Med2019; 380: 786–790.
39.
BraunVClarkeV. Using thematic analysis in psychology. Qual Res Psychol2006; 3: 77–101.
40.
BrooksEPNovinsDKMDNoeTP, et al.Reaching rural communities with culturally appropriate care: a model for adapting remote monitoring to American Indian veterans with posttraumatic stress disorder. Telemed e-Health2013; 19: 272–277.
41.
GoldinDMaltsevaTScaccianoceM, et al.Cultural and practical implications for psychiatric telehealth services: a response to COVID-19. J Transcult Nurs2021; 32: 186–190.
42.
GossCWRichardsonWJBDaileyN, et al.Rural American Indian and Alaska Native veterans’ telemental health: a model of culturally centered care. Psychol Serv2017; 14: 270–278.
43.
HiratsukaVDelafieldRStarksH, et al.Patient and provider perspectives on using telemedicine for chronic disease management among Native Hawaiian and Alaska Native people. Int J Circumpolar Health2013; 72: 21401.
44.
ShoreJHYellowleesPCaudillR, et al.Best practices in videoconferencing-based telemental health April 2018. Telemed J e-Health2018; 24: 827–832.
45.
ShoreJHBrooksESavinD, et al.Acceptability of telepsychiatry in American Indians. Telemed J e-Health2008; 14: 461–466.
46.
ShoreJHSavinDMNovinsD, et al.Cultural aspects of telepsychiatry. J Telemed Telecare2006; 12: 116–121.
47.
ShoreJHMansonSM. Telepsychiatric care of American Indian veterans with post-traumatic stress disorder: bridging gaps in geography, organizations, and culture. Telemed J e-Health2004; 10: S-64-69.
48.
WhealinJMYonedaACNelsonD, et al.Culturally adapted family intervention for rural pacific island veterans with PTSD. Psychol Serv2017; 14: 295–306.
49.
AroraSKurjiAKTennantMT. Dismantling sociocultural barriers to eye care with tele-ophthalmology: lessons from an Alberta Cree community. Clin Invest Med2013; 36: E57–E63.
50.
GibsonKO'DonnellSCoulsonH, et al.Mental health professionals’ perspectives of telemental health with remote and rural First Nations communities. J Telemed Telecare2011; 17: 263–267.
51.
GibsonKLCoulsonHMilesR, et al.Conversations on telemental health: listening to remote and rural First Nations communities. Rural Remote Health2011; 11: 1656.
52.
MaarMABeaudinVYeatesK, et al.Wise practices for cultural safety in electronic health research and clinical trials with indigenous people: secondary analysis of a randomized clinical trial. J Med Internet Res2019; 21: e14203.
53.
ShangZArnaertAHindleY, et al.Experiences of psychiatrists and support staff providing telemental health services to Indigenous peoples of Northern Quebec. BMC Health Serv Res2021; 21: 85.
54.
CafferyLJBradfordNKSmithAC, et al.How telehealth facilitates the provision of culturally appropriate healthcare for Indigenous Australians. J Telemed Telecare2018; 24: 676–682.
55.
HoustonALawsRAskewD, et al.Exploring the cultural appropriateness and usefulness of a mHealth promotion program for infant feeding in an Urban Aboriginal Health Service: a qualitative study. Aust Indig HealthBulletin2017; 17: 1–9.
56.
MooiJKWhopLJValeryPC, et al.Teleoncology for Indigenous patients: the responses of patients and health workers. Aust J Rural Health2012; 20: 265–269.
57.
BhaskarSBradleySChattuVK, et al.Telemedicine across the globe-position paper from the COVID-19 pandemic health system resilience PROGRAM (REPROGRAM) international consortium (Part 1). Front Public Health2020; 8: 556720.
58.
BarryMJEdgman-LevitanS. Shared decision making — the pinnacle of patient-centered care. N Engl J Med2012; 366: 780–781.
59.
LaiGCTaylorEVHaighMM, et al.Factors affecting the retention of Indigenous Australians in the health workforce: a systematic review. Int J Environ Res Public Health2018; 15: 914.
60.
AbbottPDaveDGordonE, et al.What do GPs need to work more effectively with Aboriginal patients? Views of Aboriginal cultural mentors and health workers. Aust Fam Physician2014; 43: 58–63.
61.
AspinCBrownNJowseyT, et al.Strategic approaches to enhanced health service delivery for Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander people with chronic illness: a qualitative study. BMC Health Serv Res2012; 12: 143.
62.
ChakanyukaCBacsuJDRDesRochesA, et al.Indigenous-specific cultural safety within health and dementia care: a scoping review of reviews. Soc Sci Med2022; 293: 114658.
Supplementary Material
Please find the following supplemental material available below.
For Open Access articles published under a Creative Commons License, all supplemental material carries the same license as the article it is associated with.
For non-Open Access articles published, all supplemental material carries a non-exclusive license, and permission requests for re-use of supplemental material or any part of supplemental material shall be sent directly to the copyright owner as specified in the copyright notice associated with the article.
