Effectiveness of telemonitoring-enhanced support over structured telephone support in reducing heart failure-related healthcare utilization in a multi-ethnic Asian setting

Abstract

Aims

Our study aimed to compare the effectiveness of telemonitoring over structured telephone support in reducing heart failure-related healthcare utilization.

Methods

This was a non-randomised controlled study comparing 150 recently discharged heart failure patients enrolled into telemonitoring and 55 patients who only received structured telephone support after rejecting telemonitoring. Patient activation, knowledge and self-management levels were measured at baseline and the one year upon programme completion using the Patient Activation Measure, the Dutch Heart Failure Knowledge Scale and the Self-Care of Heart Failure Index respectively. Differences in heart failure-related and all-cause hospitalization rates, total bed days and mortality rates at 180 days and at one year, knowledge and self-management scores and total cost of care between groups at one year were analysed.

Results

Average age of telemonitoring was 57.9 years and 63.9 years for structured telephone support. Significant difference in adjusted 180-day all-cause bed days (telemonitoring: five days versus structured telephone support: 9.8 days), heart failure-related bed days (telemonitoring: 1.2 days versus structured telephone support: six days) and adjusted one-year heart failure-related bed days (telemonitoring: 2.2 days versus structured telephone support: 6.6 days) were observed. Telemonitoring was associated with reduced all-cause one-year mortality (hazard ratio 0.32, p = 0.02). Estimated mean maintenance and confidence scores were significantly higher in the telemonitoring group at one year. No differences in all-cause and HF-related readmission rates and knowledge levels were observed. The one-year total cost of care was predicted to be Singapore dollars (SG$) 2774.4 lower (p = 0.07) in telemonitoring.

Conclusion

In conclusion, telemonitoring was associated with lower all-cause and heart failure-related total bed days at 180 days, lower heart failure-related total bed days and total cost of care at one year as compared with structured telephone support.