Body mass index (BMI) is increasingly recognized as an inadequate measure for determining obesity in children. Therefore, the aim within this study was to investigate other indirect methods of body fat assessment that could potentially be used in place of BMI. Twenty-four children (boys: 13.8 ± 0.8 yr; girls: 13.3 ± 0.5 yr) participated in this study. Measurements of BMI and waist-to-hip ratio (WHR) were obtained, along with percentage body fat (%BF) from skinfolds (SKF), bioelectrical impedance analysis (BIA) (arm-to-arm, leg-to-leg, arm-to-leg) and air displacement plethysmography (ADP). BMI was correlated with %BF from ADP (r = 0.45, p < 0.05), while WHR was not (r = 0.21, p > 0.05). %BF from the SKF method and all BIA methods demonstrated a significant relationship with ADP %BF (p < 0.05). The 95% limits of agreement (LoA) indicated that individual prediction errors between all BIA methods and ADP were large, while the SKF method showed strong agreement with ADP. The results of this study provide further evidence that the predictive accuracy of indirect methods for determining body fatness varies considerably with children. The findings are discussed in relation to the National Child Measurement Programme (NCMP), which is currently operating in primary schools in England.
Bland, J.M. and Altman, D.G. ( 1986) ‘Statistical Methods for Assessing Agreement between Two Methods of Clinical Measurement’, Lancet1: 307-10.
2.
Bosy-Westphal, A., Danielzik, S., Becker, C., Geisler, C., Onur, S., Korth, O., Buhrens, F. and Muller, M. ( 2005) ‘Need for Optimal Body Composition Data Using Air Displacement Plethysmography in Children and Adolescents’, Journal of Nutrition135: 2257-62.
3.
British Marketing Research Bureau (2007) Research into Parental Attitudes towards the Routine Measurement of Children’s Weight and Height. London: BMRB .
4.
Campos, P., Saguy, A., Ernsberger, P., Oliver, E. and Gaesser, G. ( 2006) ‘The Epidemic of Overweight and Obesity: Public Health Crisis or Moral Panic?’, International Journal of Epidemiology35: 69-72.
5.
Chan, Y., Leung, S., Lam, W., Peng, X. and Metreweli, C. ( 1998) ‘Body Fat Estimation in Children by Magnetic Resonance Imaging, Bioelectrical Impedance, Skinfold and Body Mass Index: A Pilot Study’, Journal of Pediatrics34: 22-8.
6.
Coalter, F. ( 2007) A Wider Social Role for Sport: Who’s Keeping the Score?London: Routledge.
7.
Cole, T., Bellizzi, M., Flegal, K. and Dietz, W. ( 2000) ‘Establishing a Standard Definition for Child Overweight and Obesity Worldwide: International Survey’, British Medical Journal320: 1240-3.
8.
Cross-Government Obesity Unit (2010) Healthy Weight, Healthy Lives: Two Years On. London: Cross-Government Obesity Unit.
9.
Crowther, R., Dinsdale, H., Rutter, H. and Kyffin, R. ( 2007) Analysis of the National Childhood Obesity Database 2005-06 . Oxford: South East Public Health Observatory.
10.
Davison, K. and Birch, L. ( 2001) ‘Weight Status, Parent Reaction, and Self-Concept in Five Year Old Girls’, Pediatrics107: 46-53.
11.
Department of Health (DoH) (2004) Choosing Health: Making Healthy Choices Easier. London : HMSO.
12.
Department of Health (2008) Healthy Weight, Healthy Lives: A Cross Governmental Strategy for England. London: DoH.
13.
Department of Health and Department for Children, Schools and Families (DfCSF) (2010) Healthy Weight, Healthy Lives: National Child Measurement Programme Guidance for Primary Care Trusts 2010/11. London: Cross-Government Obesity Unit.
Eisenmann, J., Heelan, K. and Welk, G. ( 2004) ‘Assessing Body Composition among 3-to-8 Year Old Children: Anthropometry, BIA and DXA’, Obesity Research12: 1633-40.
16.
Eston, R.G. ( 2002) ‘Editorial. Use of Body Mass Index (BMI) for Individual Counselling: The New Section Editor for Kinanthropometry is ‘‘Grade 1 Obese, Overweight’’ (BMI 27.3), But Dense and ‘‘Distinctly Muscular’’ (FFMI 23.1)!’, Journal of Sports Science20: 515-18.
17.
Eston, R.G., Rowlands, A.V., Charlsworth, S., Davis, A. and Hoppitt, T. ( 2005) ‘Prediction of DXA-Determined Whole Body Fat From Skinfolds: Importance of Including Skinfolds from the Thigh and Calf in Young Healthy Men and Women’, European Jounal of Clinical Nutrition59: 695-702.
18.
Fields, D. and Goran, M. ( 2000) ‘Body Composition Techniques and the Four-Compartment Model in Children’, Journal of Applied Physiology89: 613-20.
19.
Fields, D., Hunter, G. and Goran, M. ( 2000) ‘Validation of the BOD POD with Hydrostatic Weighing: Influence of Body Clothing’, International Journal of Obesity24: 200-5.
20.
Fields, D., Goran, M. and McCrory, M. ( 2002) ‘Body Composition Assessment via Air-Displacement Plethysmography in Adults and Children: A Review’, American Journal of Clinical Nutrition75: 453-67.
21.
Foresight (2007) Tackling Obesities: Future Choices - Modelling Future Trends in Obesity and the Impact on Health. London: Government Office for Science.
22.
Garn, S., Leonard, W. and Hawthorne, V. ( 1986) ‘Editorial: Three Limitations of the Body Mass Index’ , American Journal of Clinical Nutrition44: 996-7.
23.
Gately, P., Radley, D., Cooke, C., Carroll, S., Oldroyd, B., Truscott, J., Coward, W. and Wright, A. ( 2003) ‘Comparison of Body Composition Methods in Overweight and Obese Children’, Journal of Applied Physiology95: 2039-46.
24.
Goran, M., Driscoll, P., Johnson, R., Nagy, T. and Hunter, G. ( 1996) ‘Cross-Calibration of Body Composition Techniques Against Dual-Energy X-Ray Absorptiometry in Young Children’, American Journal of Clinical Nutrition63: 229-305.
25.
Hawes, M. and Martin, A. ( 2001) ‘Human Body Composition’, in R. G. Eston and T. Reilly (eds) Kinanthropometry and Exercise Physiology Laboratory Manual: Tests, Procedures and Data, vol. 1, Anthropometry, pp. 7-20. London: Routledge .
26.
Heyward, V. and Wagner, D. ( 2004) Applied Body Composition Assessment. Champaign, IL: Human Kinetics.
27.
Hill, A. ( 2007) ‘Obesity and Eating Disorders’, Obesity Reviews8(suppl.1): 151-5.
28.
Himes, J.H. ( 2009) ‘Challenges of Accurately Measuring and Using BMI and Other Indicators of Obesity in Children’, Pediatrics124: S3-22.
29.
Houtkooper, L.B., Going, S.B., Lohman, T.G., Roche, A.F. and Van Loan, M. ( 1992) ‘Bioelectrical Impedance Estimation of Fat Free Body Mass in Children and Youth: A Cross Validation Study’, Journal of Applied Physiology72: 366-73.
30.
Iuliano-Burns, S., Mirwald, R. and Bailey, D. ( 2001) ‘Timing and Magnitude of Peak Height Velocity and Peak Tissue Velocities For Early, Average, and Late Maturing Boys and Girls’, American Journal of Human Biology13: 1-8.
31.
Janssen, I., Katzmarzyk, P. and Ross, R. ( 2004) ‘Waist Circumference and Not Body Mass Index Explains Obesity Related Health Risk’, American Journal of Clinical Nutrition79: 379-84.
32.
Kirk, D. ( 2006) ‘The ‘‘Obesity Crisis’’ and School Physical Education’, Sport, Education and Society11: 121-33.
33.
Lake, J. ( 2009) ‘The Development of Surveillance and Screening for Childhood Obesity in the UK’, Critical Public Health19(1): 3-10.
34.
Lazarus, R., Baur, L., Webb, K. and Blyth, F. ( 1996) ‘Body Mass Index in Screening for Adiposity in Children and Adolescents: Systematic Evaluation Using Receiver Operating Characteristic Curves’, American Journal of Clinical Nutrition63: 500-6.
35.
Lemieux, S., Prud’homme, D., Bouchard, C., Tremblay, A. and Despres, J. ( 1996) ‘A Single Threshold Value of Waist Girth Identifies Normal Weight and Overweight Subjects with Excessive Adipose Tissue’ , American Journal of Clinical Nutrition64: 685-93.
36.
Lohman, T. ( 1989) ‘Assessment of Body Composition in Children’ , Pediatric Exercise Science1: 19-30.
37.
Neumark-Sztainer, D., Levine, M., Paxton, S., Smolak, L., Piran, N. and Wertheim, E. ( 2006) ‘Prevention of Body Dissatisfaction and Disordered Eating: What Next?’, Eating Disorders14: 265-85.
38.
Nihiser, A., Lee, S., Wechsler, H., McKenna, M., Odom, E., Reinold, C., Thompson, D. and Grummer-Strawn, L. ( 2007) ‘Body Mass Index Measurement in Schools’, Journal of School Health77: 651-723.
39.
Marfell-Jones, M., Olds, T., Stewart, A. and Carter, L. ( 2006) International Standards for Anthropometric Assessment . Potchefstroom, South Africa: International Society for the Advancement of Kinanthropometry.
40.
Parker, L., Reilly, J., Slater, C., Wells, J. and Pitsiladis, Y. ( 2003) ‘Validity of Six Field and Laboratory Methods for Measurement of Body Composition in Boys’, Obesity Research11: 852-8.
41.
Prentice, A. and Jebb, S. ( 2001) ‘Beyond Body Mass Index’, Obesity Review2: 141-7.
42.
Roche, A. ( 1979) ‘Secular Trends in Human Growth, Maturation, and Development’, Monographs of the Society for Research in Child Development44: 1-120.
43.
Sarría, A., Moreno, L.A., García-Llop, L.A., Fleta, J., Morellón, M.P. and Bueno, M. ( 2001) ‘Body Mass Index, Triceps Skinfold and Waist Circumference in Screening for Adiposity in Male Children and Adolescents’, Acta Paediatrica90: 387-92.
44.
Slaughter, M., Lohman, T., Boileau, R., Horswill, C., Stillman, R., VanLoan, M. and Bemben, D. ( 1988) ‘Skinfold Equations for Estimation of Body Fatness in Children and Youth’, Human Biology60: 709-23.
45.
Smalley, K., Knerr, A., Kendrick, Z., Colliver, J. and Owen, O. ( 1990) ‘Reassessment of Body Mass Indices’, American Journal of Clinical Nutrition52: 405-8.
46.
Taylor, R., Jones, I., Williams, S. and Goulding, A. ( 2000) ‘Evaluation of Waist Circumference, Waist-to-Hip Ratio, and the Conicity Index as Screening Tools for High Trunk Fat Mass, as Measured by Dual-Energy X-Ray Absorptiometry, in Children Aged 3-19 y’ , American Journal of Clinical Nutrition72: 490-5.
47.
The Sun (2010) ‘3st 11lbs and the NHS Branded her FAT’, (19 Feb.). URL (consulted Feb. 2010): http://thesun.co.uk/so/homepage/news/2859929/Fury-at-verdict-on-Lucy-5.html
48.
Treuth, M., Butte, N., Wong, W. and Ellis, K. ( 2001) ‘Body Composition in Prepubertal Girls: Comparison of Six Methods’, International Journal of Obesity25: 1352-9.
49.
Ulijaszek, S.J. and Kerr, D.A. ( 1999) ‘Anthropometric Measurement Error and the Assessment of Nutritional Status’, British Journal of Nutrition82: 165-72.
50.
Westwood, M., Fayter, D., Hartley, S., Rithalia, A., Butler, G., Glasziou, P., Bland, M., Nixon, J., Stirk, L. and Rudolf, M. ( 2007) ‘Childhood Obesity: Should Primary School Children be Routinely Screened? A Systematic Review and Discussion of the Evidence’ , Archives of Disease in Childhood92(5): 416-22.
51.
Winsley, R., Fulford, J., MacLeod, K., Ramos-Ibanez, N., Williams, C. and Armstrong, N. ( 2005) ‘Prediction of Visceral Adipose Tissue Using Air Displacement Plethysmography in Children’, Obesity Research13: 2048-51.
52.
Zhu, S., Wang, Z., Heshka, S., Heo, M., Faith, M. and Heymsfield, S. ( 2002) ‘Waist Circumference and Obesity Associated Risk Factors among Whites in the Third National Health and Nutrition Examination Survey: Clinical Action Thresholds’, American Journal of Clinical Nutrition76: 743-9.
