We investigate the bias of online ratings stemming from the personal interaction between sellers and buyers, and quantify its effect on ratings and consumer demand. Using data and text reviews from Airbnb in Barcelona, we develop a text analytic algorithm and semantic analysis to measure host kindness. To expose the bias, we exploit the rating of the listing’s location, which should not be influenced by host behavior. We find that kindness is positively related to the location’s rating and to the listing’s demand. Moreover, host kindness mitigates the negative impact of an inconvenient position on both the location score and the listing demand. We address endogeneity concerns by exploiting the shock to tourism caused by COVID-19.
AlsudaisA (2017) Quantifying the offline interactions between hosts and guests of Airbnb. In: Twenty-third Americas Conference on Information Systems, Boston.
2.
AnanthakrishnanUProserpioDSharmaS (2023) I hear you: does quality improve with customer voice?Marketing Science42(6): 1143–1161.
3.
ArchakNGhoseAIpeirotisPG (2011) Deriving the pricing power of product features by mining consumer reviews. Management Science57(8): 1485–1509.
4.
BaeSJLeeHSuhEK, et al. (2017) Shared experience in pretrip and experience sharing in posttrip: a survey of airbnb users. Information & management54(6): 714–727.
5.
BeckerCBradleyGTZantowK (2012) The underlying dimensions of tipping behavior: an exploration, confirmation, and predictive model. International Journal of Hospitality Management31(1): 247–256.
6.
BertrandMMullainathanS (2001) Do people mean what they say? Implications for subjective survey data. The American Economic Review91(2): 67–72.
7.
Boto-GarcíaD (2024) Illegal Airbnb properties and hosts’ professionalism. Tourism Economics. SAGE-Journals. Available at: https://doi.org/10.1177/13548166241281756, In press.
8.
Boto-GarcíaDLeoniV (2022) Exposure to COVID-19 and travel intentions: evidence from Spain. Tourism Economics28(6): 1499–1519.
9.
BridgesJVasquezC (2018) If nearly all Airbnb reviews are positive, does that make them meaningless?Current Issues in Tourism21(18): 2065–2083.
10.
BuzzacchiLMiloneFLPaolucciE, et al. (2023) How to react to a shock? Effects of airbnb hosts’ choices and market segmentation at the time of covid-19. Information & Management60: 103857.
11.
CaviqueMRibeiroRBatistaF, et al. (2022) Examining Airbnb guest satisfaction tendencies: a text mining approach. Current Issues in Tourism25(22): 3607–3622.
12.
ChenYXieJ (2008) Online consumer review: word-of-mouth as a new element of marketing communication mix. Management Science54(3): 477–491.
13.
ChengMJinX (2019) What do Airbnb users care about? an analysis of online review comments. International Journal of Hospitality Management76: 58–70.
14.
DellarocasCWoodCA (2008) The sound of silence in online feedback: estimating trading risks in the presence of reporting bias. Management Science54(3): 460–476.
15.
ErtEFleischerA (2019) The evolution of trust in Airbnb: a case of home rental. Annals of Tourism Research75: 279–287.
FradkinAGrewalEHoltzD (2021) Reciprocity and unveiling in two-sided reputation systems: evidence from an experiment on Airbnb. Marketing Science40(6): 1013–1029.
18.
FradkinAHoltzD (2023) Do Incentives to Review Help the Market? Evidence from a Field Experiment on Airbnb. Marketing Science42(5): 853–865.
19.
GoldfarbATuckerC (2019) Digital economics. Journal of Economic Literature57(1): 3–43.
20.
GunterUÖnderI (2018) Determinants of Airbnb demand in Vienna and their implications for the traditional accommodation industry. Tourism Economics24(3): 270–293.
21.
GuttentagDSmithSPotwarkaL, et al. (2018) Why tourists choose Airbnb: a motivation-based segmentation study. Journal of Travel Research57(3): 342–359.
22.
HuNZhangJPavlouPA (2009) Overcoming the j-shaped distribution of product reviews. Commununications of the ACM52(10): 144–147.
23.
LawaniAReedMRMarkT, et al. (2019) Reviews and price on online platforms: evidence from sentiment analysis of Airbnb reviews in Boston. Regional Science and Urban Economics75: 22–34.
24.
LeeNBollingerBStaelinR (2022) Vertical versus horizontal variance in online reviews and their impact on demand. Journal of Marketing Research60(1): 130–154.
25.
LeuthesserLKohliCSHarichKR (1995) Brand equity: the halo effect measure. European Journal of Marketing29: 57–66.
26.
LiangSSchuckertMLawR, et al. (2020) The importance of marketer-generated content to peer-to-peer property rental platforms: evidence from Airbnb. International Journal of Hospitality Management84: 102329.
27.
LindMVisentiniMMäntyläT, et al. (2017) Choice-supportive misremembering: a new taxonomy and review. Frontiers in Psychology8: 2062.
28.
Llaneza HesseCRaya VílchezJM (2022) The effect of COVID-19 on the peer-to-peer rental market. Tourism Economics28(1): 222–247.
29.
LvXLiuYXuS, et al. (2021) Welcoming host, cozy house? the impact of service attitude on sensory experience. International Journal of Hospitality Management95: 102949.
30.
MagnaniM (2020) The economic and behavioral consequences of online reviews. Journal of Economic Surveys34(2): 263–292.
31.
MagnussonE (2022) Unboxing the causal effect of ratings on product demand: evidence from Wayfair.com. The Journal of Industrial Economics70(3): 525–564.
32.
MakkarMYapS-FC (2022) Managing hearts and minds: romanticizing Airbnb experiences. Current Issues in Tourism25(21): 3461–3480.
33.
MiloneFLGunterUZekanB (2023) The pricing of European airbnb listings during the pandemic: a difference-in-differences approach employing COVID-19 response strategies as a continuous treatment. Tourism Management97: 104738.
34.
ModyMHanksL (2019) Consumption authenticity in the accommodations industry: the keys to brand love and brand loyalty for hotels and Airbnb. Journal of Travel Research59(1): 173–189.
35.
NicolauJLMellinasJPMartín-FuentesE (2020) The halo effect: a longitudinal approach. Annals of Tourism Research83: 102938.
36.
Nieto-GarcıaMMuñoz-GallegoPAVigliaG, et al. (2020) Be social! The impact of self-presentation on peer-to-peer accommodation revenue. Journal of Travel Research59(7): 1268–1281.
37.
ProserpioDXuWZervasG (2018) You get what you give: theory and evidence of reciprocity in the sharing economy. Quantitative Marketing and Economics16: 371–407.
38.
QuattroneGProserpioDQuerciaD, et al. (2016) Who benefits from the “sharing” economy of Airbnb? In: Proceedings of the 25th International Conference on World Wide Web, Montréal (Canada), April 11-15,2016, 1385–1394.
39.
ŠkareMSorianoDRPorada-RochońM (2021) Impact of COVID-19 on the travel and tourism industry. Technological Forecasting and Social Change163: 120469.
40.
SthapitEJimenez-BarretoJ (2018) Sharing in the host–guest relationship: perspectives on the Airbnb hospitality experience. Anatolia29(2): 282–284.
41.
TillquistK (2008) Capitalizing on Kindness: Why 21st Century Professionals Need to Be Nice. NJ: Career Press.
42.
WuDCZhongSQiuRTR, et al. (2022) Are customer reviews just reviews? Hotel forecasting using sentiment analysis. Tourism Economics28(3): 795–816.
43.
ZervasGProserpioDByersJ (2017) The rise of the sharing economy: estimating the impact of Airbnb on the hotel industry. Journal of Marketing Research54: 687–705.
44.
ZervasGProserpioDByersJ (2021) A first look at online reputation on Airbnb, where every stay is above average. Marketing Letters32: 1–16.
Supplementary Material
Please find the following supplemental material available below.
For Open Access articles published under a Creative Commons License, all supplemental material carries the same license as the article it is associated with.
For non-Open Access articles published, all supplemental material carries a non-exclusive license, and permission requests for re-use of supplemental material or any part of supplemental material shall be sent directly to the copyright owner as specified in the copyright notice associated with the article.
