Thinking Ahead to Mixed-Member Proportional Representation

Abstract

When New Zealand's voters in 1993 approved the transformation of the nation's electoral system in 1996 from first-past-the-post to mixed-member proportional representation they brought about fundamental changes to the tactics, organization and technologies used by parties in their electoral campaigns, since parties' appeals and the techniques for conveying them reflect the constraints of the electoral law within which they occur. New Zealand's political practitioners, during the current 3-year interregnum between the old and the new system, have begun to contemplate those changes and a variety of alternative avenues for maximizing electoral gain. This essay, drawing from interviews with 18 individuals at the centre of electoral politics in New Zealand, examines the implications of the switch to mixed-member proportional representation on marginal seats, targeting, issue constituencies, mass media appeals and other aspects of electoral campaigns.

Keywords

campaigns first-past-the-post mixed-member proportional representation New Zealand referendum

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Denemark, David (1991) `Electoral Instability and the Modern Campaign: New Zealand Labour in 1987', Australian Journal of Political Science 26: 260-276.

Denemark, David (1992) `New Zealand: The 1987 Campaign', in Shaun Bowler and David Farrell (eds) Electoral Strategies and Political Marketing, pp. 163-182. London: Macmillan.

Denemark, David (1994) `Programmatic Intransigence and the Limits of the Modern Campaign: New Zealand Labour in 1990', Political Science 46: 22-239.

Duverger, Maurice (1955) Political Parties. London: Methuen.

Gustafson, Barry (1993) `Regeneration, Rejection or Realignment: New Zealand Political Parties in the 1990s', in Gary R. Hawke (ed.) Changing Politics? The Electoral Referendum 1993, pp. 68-6102. Wellington: Institute of Policy Studies.

Katz, Richard S. (1980) A Theory of Parties and Electoral Systems. Baltimore, MD: Johns Hopkins University Press.

Kirchheimer, Otto (1966) `The Transformation of the West European Party Systems', in Joseph LaPalombara and Myron Weiner (eds) Political Parties and Political Development, pp. 177-200. Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press.

Lamare, James and Jack Vowles (1995) `The Limits of Social Choice Theory: Electoral System Change in New Zealand', paper presented to the Annual Conference of the Australasian Political Studies Association, Melbourne, September.

Levine, Stephen and Nigel Roberts (1993) `The Referendum Results: “The People Screamed” ', in Alan McRobie (ed.) Taking it to the People? The New Zealand Electoral Referendum Debate, pp. 57-567. Christchurch: Hazard Press.

10.

Lijphart, Arend (1987) `The Demise of the Last Westminster System? Comments on the Report of New Zealand's Royal Commission on the Electoral System', Electoral Studies 6: 97-9103.

11.

Mackerras, Malcolm (1994) `Reform of New Zealand's Voting System, 1985-1996', Representation 32: 36-340.

12.

Mackerras, Malcolm (1995) `For the Sake of Democracy, New Zealand Must Respect Referendum Results', The Australian, 28 November.

13.

McRobie, Alan (1993a) `Introduction', in Alan McRobie (ed.) Taking it to the People? The New Zealand Electoral Referendum Debate, pp. 9-913. Christchurch: Hazard Press.

14.

McRobie, Alan (1993b) `Electoral Districts under MMP: One Possible Electoral Map', in Gary R. Hawke (ed.) Changing Politics? The Electoral Referendum 1993, pp. 9-939. Wellington: Institute of Policy Studies.

15.

Vowles, Jack (1989) `Playing Games with Electorates: New Zealand's Political Ecology in 1987', Political Science 41: 18-134.