During the last few decades governments have operated in a challenging environment which increasingly calls for extended citizen participation. The aim of the article is to demonstrate that representative and participatory democracy are not two distinct realities, but that politicians’ opinions about their representative roles are associated with their attitudes about participatory democracy. To this end, the present paper links representative styles (partisan-delegate-trustee) with support for (1) the amount of citizen participation and (2) the type of citizen participation. Elected politicians traditionally perceive their representative roles either as ‘partisan’ (party-driven), ‘delegate’ (voter-driven) or ‘trustee’ (driven by their own judgement). We conducted a large-scale survey among Flemish (Belgium) local councillors (N = 791). We show the biggest differences in support are between ‘delegates’ and ‘partisans’. The first group seems to be more receptive to (far-reaching) citizen participation and we explain that by their general orientation towards citizens.
AndewegRB (2014) Roles in legislatures. In The Oxford Handbook of Legislative Studies. New York, NY: Oxford University Press, 267–286.
2.
AndewegRB (2015) The consequences of representatives’ role orientations: attitudes, behaviour, perceptions. In: Parliamentary Roles in Modern Legislatures. London: Routledge, 66–84.
3.
AndewegRBThomassenJJ (2005) Modes of political representation: toward a new typology. Legislative Studies Quarterly30(4): 507–528.
4.
BächtigerADryzekJSMansbridgeJ, et al. (2018) The Oxford Handbook of Deliberative Democracy. Oxford, UK: Oxford University Press.
5.
BedockCPiletJ-B (2020) Enraged, engaged, or both? A study of the determinants of support for consultative vs. binding mini-publics. Representation59: 1–21.
6.
BlomgrenMRozenbergO (2015) Parliamentary Roles in Modern Legislatures. London: Routledge.
7.
CaluwaertsDKernAReuchampsM, et al. (2020) Between party democracy and citizen democracy: explaining attitudes of flemish local chairs towards democratic innovations. Politics of the Low Countries2: 192.
8.
CloseCLegeinTLittleC (2022) Party organisation and the party-delegate style of representation. Party Politics30: 247.
9.
ColomboCKriesiH (2020) Referendums and direct democracy. In: RohrschneiderRThomassenJ (eds) The Oxford Handbook of Political Representation in Liberal Democracies. Oxford, UK: Oxford University Press.
10.
De CeuninckKVerhelstT (2021) Local State–Society Relations in Flanders (Belgium). In: TelesFGendźwiłłAStănușC, et al. (eds) Close Ties in European Local Governance: Linking Local State and Society. Cham: Springer International Publishing, 55–72.
11.
de VetBWautersB (2018) Follow the leader: testing a deductive approach for studying parliamentary party leadership roles. The Journal of Legislative Studies24(3): 359–372.
12.
De WinterLBaudewynsP (2015) Candidate centred campaigning in a party centred context: the case of Belgium. Electoral Studies39: 295–305.
13.
DentersBVollaardHvan de BovenkampH (2020) Innovating local representative democracy: how citizens evaluate new roles of elected and non-elected representatives. The Innovation Journal25(3): 1–21.
14.
DudzinskaAPoyetCCostaO, et al. (2014) Representational Roles. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
15.
EgnerBSweetingDKlokPJ (2013) Local Councillors in Europe. Wiesbaden: Springer VS.
16.
ElstubSEscobarO (2019) Handbook of Democratic Innovation and Governance. Cheltenham: Edward Elgar Publishing.
17.
EulauHWahlkeJCBuchananW, et al. (1959) The role of the representative: some empirical observations on the theory of Edmund Burke. American Political Science Review53(3): 742–756.
18.
FobéEBransMVancoppenolleD, et al. (2013) Institutionalized advisory systems: an analysis of member satisfaction of advice production and use across 9 strategic advisory councils in Flanders (Belgium). Policy and Society32(3): 225–240.
19.
FungA (2006) Varieties of participation in complex governance. Public Administration Review66: 66–75.
20.
GeldersDBransMMaesschalckJ, et al. (2010) Systematic evaluation of public participation projects: analytical framework and application based on two Belgian neighborhood watch projects. Government Information Quarterly27(2): 134–140.
21.
GherghinaSGeisselB (2020) Support for direct and deliberative models of democracy in the UK: understanding the difference. Political Research Exchange2(1): 1809474.
22.
GherghinaSPiletJ-B (2021) Do populist parties support referendums? A comparative analysis of election manifestos in Europe. Electoral Studies74: 102419.
23.
GherghinaSCloseCCarmanC (2022) Parliamentarians’ support for direct and deliberative democracy in Europe: an account of individual-level determinants. Comparative Politics55: 219.
24.
HeineltH (2013) Councillors’ notions of democracy, and their role perception and behaviour in the changing context of local democracy. Local Government Studies39(5): 640–660.
25.
HolmbergS (1989) Political representation in Sweden. Scandinavian Political Studies12(1): 1–36.
26.
JanssenCChiruMDe WinterL (2019) Between parties and voters: candidates’ role conception in the Belgian partitocracy. In: VandeleeneADe WinterLBaudewynsP (eds) Candidates, Parties and Voters in the Belgian Partitocracy. Springer, 313–339.
27.
JuniusNMatthieuJCaluwaertsD, et al. (2020) Is it interests, ideas or institutions? Explaining elected representatives’ positions toward democratic innovations in 15 European Countries. Frontiers in Political Science2: 9.
28.
KarlssonM (2012) Participatory initiatives and political representation: the case of local councillors in Sweden. Local Government Studies38(6): 795–815.
29.
KoskimaaVRapeliLHimmelroosS (2024) Decision-makers, advisers or educable subjects? Policymakers’ perceptions of citizen participation in a Nordic democracy. Governance37(1): 261–279.
30.
KriesiH (2006) Role of the political elite in Swiss direct-democratic votes. Party Politics12(5): 599–622.
31.
KuhlmannSWollmannH (2011) The evaluation of institutional reforms at sub-national government levels: a still neglected research agenda. Local Government Studies37(5): 479–494.
32.
LunaJPRodríguezRPRosenblattF, et al. (2021) Political parties, diminished subtypes, and democracy. Party Politics27(2): 294–307.
33.
MichelsA (2012) Citizen participation in local policy making: design and democracy. International Journal of Public Administration35(4): 285–292.
34.
ÖnnudóttirEH (2016) Political parties and styles of representation. Party Politics22(6): 732–745.
35.
PitkinHF (1967) The Concept of Representation. Berkeley: University of California Press.
36.
PitkinHF (2004) Representation and democracy: uneasy alliance. Scandinavian Political Studies27(3): 335–342.
37.
PutG-JMaddensBSmuldersJ (2015) Buying local votes: the effect of individual campaign spending under a semi-open pr system in the Belgian local elections. Local Government Studies41(1): 137–155.
38.
QvortrupM (2005) A Comparative Study of Referendums: Government by the People. Oxford: Manchester University Press.
39.
Radzik-MaruszakKHaveriA (2020) Mixed responses: councillors’ attitudes towards citizens’ participation. The Innovation Journal25(3): 1–23.
40.
RehfeldA (2009) Representation rethought: on trustees, delegates, and gyroscopes in the study of political representation and democracy. American Political Science Review103(2): 214–230.
41.
RohrschneiderRThomassenJ (2020) The Oxford handbook of political representation in liberal democracies. Oxford, UK: Oxford University Press.
42.
RyanM (2014) Advancing Comparison of Democratic Innovations: A Medium-N Fuzzy-Set Qualitative Comparative Analysis of Participatory Budgeting. UK: University of Southampton.
43.
SearingD (1991) Roles, rules, and rationality in the new institutionalism. American Political Science Review85(4): 1239–1260.
44.
SheedyAMacKinnonMPPitreS, et al. (2008) Handbook on Citizen Engagement: Beyond Consultation.
45.
SteyversK (2022) Belgium: between national barometer and local atmosphere. In: The Routledge Handbook of Local Elections and Voting in Europe. Abingdon, Oxon: Routledge, 114–125.
46.
Van DammeJJacquetVSchiffinoN, et al. (2017) Public consultation and participation in Belgium: directly engaging citizens beyond the ballot box?Policy analysis in Belgium215: 215–234.
47.
VerhelstTReynaertHSteyversK (2011) Foundation or fragment of local democracy? Empirically assessing the roles of local councillors in Belgian governance. Lex localis9(2): 103.
48.
VerhelstTReynaertHSteyversK, et al. (2014) Political representation in local governance: a survey analysis of councillor attitudes and behaviour in Belgium. Acta Politica49: 144–173.
49.
WernerHMarienS (2022) Process vs. outcome? How to evaluate the effects of participatory processes on legitimacy perceptions. British Journal of Political Science52(1): 429–436.
50.
ZittelT (2012) Legislators and their representational roles: strategic choices or habits of the heart. In: Parliamentary Roles in Modern Legislatures. London: Routledge. 101–121.
Supplementary Material
Please find the following supplemental material available below.
For Open Access articles published under a Creative Commons License, all supplemental material carries the same license as the article it is associated with.
For non-Open Access articles published, all supplemental material carries a non-exclusive license, and permission requests for re-use of supplemental material or any part of supplemental material shall be sent directly to the copyright owner as specified in the copyright notice associated with the article.
