Steering,Not Rowing? An Analysis of the Political Influence,the Role Perceptions,and the Behavior of Swiss City Councillors in Different Urban Governance Contexts
Restricted accessResearch articleFirst published online July, 2014
Steering,Not Rowing? An Analysis of the Political Influence,the Role Perceptions,and the Behavior of Swiss City Councillors in Different Urban Governance Contexts
In today’s cities, councillors see themselves increasingly confronted with new forms of political steering focusing more on interaction than on hierarchical decision making and blurring the lines between the public and private spheres. By embedding the concept of governance in a new institutionalist framework, the article investigates the implications of new models of urban governance on the identity, the notion of democracy, the perceptions, and the role behavior of city councillors. It tests two rival hypotheses—an optimistic versus a pessimistic perspective on governance and democracy—and thereby draws on multilevel analyses of a comprehensive survey of all city councillors in Switzerland.
BekkersVictorDijkstraGeskeEdwardsArthurFengerMenno. 2007a. Governance and the Democratic Deficit. Aldershot: Ashgate.
2.
BekkersVictorDijkstraGeskeEdwardsArthurFengerMenno. 2007b. “Governance and the Democratic Deficit: Introduction.” In Governance and the Democratic Deficit, edited by BekkersVictorDijkstraGeskeEdwardsArthurFengerMenno, 3–11. Aldershot: Ashgate.
3.
BenzArthur. 2004. “Einleitung: Governance—Modebegriff oder nützliches sozialwissenschaftliches Konzept?” [Introduction: Governance—Vogue expression or useful concept of the social sciences?]. In Governance—Regieren in komplexen Regelsystemen, edited by BenzArthur, 1–28. Wiesbaden, Germany: Verlag für Sozialwissenschaften.
4.
BogasonPeter. 2008. “Institutional Theory and Democracy.” In Debating Institutionalism, edited by PierreJonPetersB. GuyStokerGerry, 22–41. Manchester: Manchester Univ. Press.
5.
BogasonPeterMussoJuliet A.2006. “The Democratic Prospects of Network Governance.”American Review of Public Administration36 (1): 3–18.
6.
BützerMichael. 2005. “Direkte Demokratie in Schweizer Gemeinden: Institutioneller Ursprung und politische Praxis im Vergleich” [Direct Democracy in Swiss Municipalities: Institutional Origin and Political Practices]. In La démocratie comme idée directrice de l’ordre juridique suisse, edited by TschannenPierre, 33–52. Zürich, Switzerland: Schulthess.
7.
ClarkeMichaelStewartJohn. 1992. Citizens and Local Democracy: Empowerment: A Theme for the 1990s. Luton, UK: Local Government Management Board.
8.
DahlRobert A.1994. “A Democratic Dilemma: System Effectiveness versus Citizen Participation.”Political Science Quarterly109 (1): 23–34.
9.
DentersBasRoseLawrence E.2005. Comparing Local Governance. Trends and Developments. Houndmills: Palgrave Macmillan.
10.
DevecchiLineo. 2012. “Von politischen Grabenkämpfen zur kooperativen Planung” [From political trench warfare to cooperative planning]. disP—The Planning Review48 (4): 45–55.
11.
EgnerBjörnSweetingDavidKlokPieter-Jan, eds. 2013. Local Councillors in Europe. Wiesbaden, Germany: Springer VS.
12.
EldersveldSamuel J.LarsStrömbergWimDerksen. 1995. Local Elites in Western Democracies: A Comparative Analysis of Urban Political Leaders in the U.S., Sweden, and The Netherlands. Boulder: Westview Press.
13.
EulauHeinzPrewittKenneth. 1973. Labyrinths of Democracy: Adaptations, Linkages, Representation, and Policies in Urban Politics. Indianapolis: Bobbs-Merrill.
14.
FengerMennoBekkersVictor. 2007. “The Governance Concept in Public Administration.” In Governance and the Democratic Deficit, edited by BekkersVictorDijkstraGeskeEdwardsArthurFengerMenno, 13–33. Aldershot: Ashgate.
15.
FredericksonGeorge H.2005. “Whatever Happened to Public Administration? Governance, Governance Everywhere.” In The Oxford Handbook of Public Management, edited by FerlieEwanLynnLaurence E.Jr.PollittChristopher, 282–304. New York: Oxford Univ. Press.
HambletonRobin. 2005. “Leading Localities: Rethinking the Agenda.” In Urban Governance and Democracy: Leadership and Community Involvement, edited by HausMichaelHeineltHubertStewartMurray, 190–213. London: Routledge.
20.
HambletonRobin. 2007. “New Leadership for Democratic Urban Space.” In Governing Cities in a Global Era: Urban Innovation, Competition, and Democratic Reform, edited by HambletonRobinGrossJill Simone, 163–76. Basingstoke: Palgrave Macmillan.
21.
HansenKarin. 2005. “Representative Government and Network Governance—In Need of ‘Co-governance’: Lessons from Local Decision Making on Public Schools in Denmark.”Scandinavian Political Studies28 (3): 219–37.
22.
HeadBrian W.2007. “Community Engagement: Participation on Whose Terms?”Australian Journal of Political Science42 (3): 441–54.
23.
HeineltHubert. 2004. “Governance auf lokaler Ebene” [Governance at the local level]. In Governance—Regieren in komplexen Regelsystemen, edited by BenzArthur, 29–44. Wiesbaden, Germany: Verlag für Sozialwissenschaften.
24.
HeineltHubert. 2008. Demokratie jenseits des Staates. Partizipatives Regieren und Governance [Democracy beyond the state. Participatory government and governance]. Baden-Baden, Germany: Nomos.
25.
HeineltHubert. 2012. “Councillors’ Notions of Democracy, and Their Role Perception and Behaviour in the Changing Context of Local Democracy.”Local Government Studies. Published electronically April12. doi:10.1080/03003930.2012.670746.
26.
HeldDavid. 2006. Models of Democracy. 3rd ed.Cambridge: Polity Press.
27.
HendriksCarolyn M.2009. “Deliberative Governance in the Context of Power.”Policy and Society28:173–84.
28.
JessopBob. 1994. “Post-fordism and the State.” In Post-fordism: A Reader, edited by AminAsh, 251–79. Oxford: Blackwell.
29.
JessopBob. 1998. The Rise of Governance and the Risk of Failure: The Case of Economic Development. Oxford: Basil Blackwell.
30.
JohnPeter. 2001. Local Governance in Western Europe. London: Sage.
31.
KerstingNorbertVetterAngelika. 2003. Reforming Local Government in Europe: Closing the Gap between Democracy and Efficiency. Opladen, Germany: Leske+Budrich.
32.
KickertWalter, ed. 2007. The Study of Public Management in Europe and the US: A Comparative Analysis of National Distinctiveness. London: Routledge.
33.
KlijnErik-HansKoppenjanJoop F. M.2002. “Rediscovering the Citizen: New Roles for Politicians in Interactive Policy Making.” In Public Participation and Innovations in Community Governance, edited by McLavertyPeter, 141–64. Aldershot: Ashgate.
34.
KlokPieter-JanDentersBas. 2005. “Urban Leadership and Community Involvement: An Institutional Analysis.” In Urban Governance and Democracy: Leadership and Community Involvement, edited by HausMichaelHeineltHubertStewartMurray, 40–64. London: Routledge.
35.
KooimanJan. 1993. “Social-Political Governance: Introduction.” In Modern Governance: New Government-Society Interactions, edited by KooimanJan, 1–8. London: Sage.
36.
KooimanJan. 2000. “Societal Governance: Levels, Modes, and Orders of Social-Political Interaction.” In Debating Governance: Authority, Steering, and Democracy, edited by PierreJon, 138–64. New York: Oxford Univ. Press.
37.
KüblerDanielHeineltHubert. 2005. “Metropolitan Governance, Democracy and the Dynamics of Place.” In Metropolitan Governance: Capacity, Democracy and the Dynamics of Place, edited by KüblerDanielHeineltHubert, 8–28. London: Routledge.
38.
KüblerDanielLadnerAndreas. 2003. “Local Government Reform in Switzerland. Morefor than by—But What about of?” In Reforming Local Government in Europe: Closing the Gap Between Democracy and Efficiency, edited by KerstingNorbertVetterAngelika, 137–55. Opladen, Germany: Leske+Budrich.
39.
KüblerDanielSchenkelWalterLerescheJean-Philippe. 2003. “Bright Lights, Big Cities? Metropolisation, Intergovernmental Relations, and the New Federal Urban Policy in Switzerland.”Swiss Political Science Review9 (1): 261–82.
40.
KüblerDanielSchwabBrigitte. 2007. “New Regionalism in Five Swiss Metropolitan Areas: An Assessment of Inclusiveness, Deliberation and Democratic Accountability.”European Journal of Political Research46:473–502.
41.
LadnerAndreas. 2001. “Gemeindereformen in der Schweiz: Strategien, Gemeinsamkeiten und Auslöser” [Local government reforms in Switzerland: Strat-egies, similarities and triggers]. Schweizerische Zeitschrift für Politikwissenschaft7 (3): 1–23.
42.
LadnerAndreas. 2002. “Size and Direct Democracy at the Local Level: The Case of Switzerland.”Environment and Planning C: Government and Policy20:813–28.
43.
LadnerAndreas. 2005. “Switzerland: Reforming Small Autonomous Municipalities.” In Comparing Local Governance: Trends and Developments, edited by DentersBasRoseLawrence E., 139–54. Houndmills: Palgrave Macmillan.
44.
LadnerAndreasArnDanielFriederichUeliSteinerRetoWichtermannJürg. 2000. Gemeindereformen zwischen Handlungsfähigkeit und Legitimation [Local government reforms between authority and legitimation]. Bern, Switzerland: Institut für Politikwissenschaft und Institut für Organisation und Personal.
45.
LadnerAndreasSteinerReto. 2003. “Die Schweizer Gemeinden im Wandel: Konvergenz oder Divergenz?” [Swiss municipalities in change: Convergency or divergency?]. Swiss Political Science Review9 (1): 233–59.
46.
LijphartArend. 1999. Patterns of Democracy: Government Forms and Performance in Thirty-Six Countries. New Haven: Yale Univ. Press.
47.
LowndesVivien. 2009. “New Institutionalism and Urban Politics.” In Theories of Urban Politics, edited by DaviesJonathan S.ImbroscioDavid L., 2nd ed., 91–105. London: Sage.
48.
MarchJames G.OlsenJohan P.1984. “The New Institutionalism: Organizational Factors in Political Life.”American Political Science Review78 (3): 734–49.
49.
MarchJames G.OlsenJohan P.1989. Rediscovering Institutions: The Organizational Basis of Politics. New York: The Free Press.
50.
MarchJames G.OlsenJohan P.1996. “Institutional Perspectives on Political Institutions.”Governance: An International Journal of Policy and Administration9 (3): 247–64.
51.
MayntzRenate. 1998. New Challenges to Governance Theory. Florence, Italy: Robert Schuman Centre at the European University Institute.
52.
MayntzRenate. 2004. “Governance im modernen Staat” [Governance in the modern state]. In Governance—Regieren in komplexen Regelsystemen, edited by BenzArthur, 65–76. Wiesbaden, Germany: Verlag für Sozialwissenschaften.
53.
NyholmIngaHaveriArto. 2009. “Between Government and Governance: Local Solutions for Reconciling Representative Government and Network Governance.”Local Government Studies35 (1): 109–24.
54.
OffeClaus. 2008. “Governance—‘Empty Signifier’ oder sozialwissenschaftliches Forschungsprogramm?” [Governance—“empty signifier” or research programme of the social sciences?]. In Governance in einer sich wandelnden Welt, edited by SchuppertGunnar FolkeZürnMichael, 61–76. Wiesbaden, Germany: Verlag für Sozialwissenschaften.
55.
OsborneDavidGaeblerTed. 1992. Reinventing Government: How the Entrepreneurial Spirit Is Transforming the Public Sector. New York: Plume.
PapadopoulosYannis. 2003. “Cooperative Forms of Governance: Problems of Democratic Accountability in Complex Environments.”European Journal of Political Research42:473–501.
58.
PapadopoulosYannis. 2004. “Governance und Demokratie” [Governance and democracy]. In Governance—Regieren in komplexen Regelsystemen, edited by BenzArthur, 215–37. Wiesbaden, Germany: Verlag für Sozialwissenschaften.
59.
PierreJon. 1999. “Models of Urban Governance: The Institutional Dimension of Urban Politics.”Urban Affairs Review34 (3): 372–96.
60.
PierreJon. 2000a. “Conclusions: Governance beyond State Strength.” In Debating Governance: Authority, Steering, and Democracy, edited by PierreJon, 241–46. New York: Oxford Univ. Press.
61.
PierreJon, ed. 2000b. Debating Governance: Authority, Steering, and Democracy. New York: Oxford Univ. Press.
62.
PierreJon. 2011. The Politics of Urban Governance. Basingstoke: Palgrave Macmillan.
63.
PierreJon B.GuyPeters. 2000. Governance, Politics and the State. Basingstoke: Macmillan.
64.
PollittChristopher. 2003. The Essential Public Manager. Buckingham: Open Univ. Press.
65.
PollittChristopherBouckaertGeert. 2000. Public Management Reform: An International Comparison. New York: Oxford Univ. Press.
66.
RamirezPerezClementeAntoniaNavarroYanez J.ClarkTerry N.2008. “Mayors and Local Governing Coalitions in Democratic Countries: A Cross-national Comparison.”Local Government Studies34 (2): 147–78.
67.
RaoNirmala. 1998. “Representation in Local Politics: A Reconsideration and Some New Evidence.”Political Studies46:19–35.
68.
RhodesRoderick A. W.1997. Understanding Governance: Policy Networks, Governance, Reflexivity and Accountability. Buckingham: Open Univ. Press.
69.
ScharpfFritz W.1993. “Versuch über Demokratie im verhandelnden Staat” [Essay on democracy in the negotiating state]. In Verhandlungsdemokratie, Interessenvermittlung, Regierbarkeit, edited by CzadaRolandSchmidtManfred G., 25–50. Opladen, Germany: Westdeutscher Verlag.
SharpeLaurence J.1962. “Elected Representatives in Local Government.”British Journal of Sociology13:189–208.
72.
SkelcherChrisKlijnErik-HansKüblerDanielSørensenEvaSullivanHelen. 2011. “Explaining the Democratic Anchorage of Governance Networks: Evidence from Four European Countries.”Administrative Theory & Praxis33 (1): 7–38.
73.
SomervillePeter. 2005. “Community Governance and Democracy.”Policy & Politics33 (1): 117–44.
74.
SørensenEva. 2006. “Metagovernance: The Changing Role of Politicians in Processes of Democratic Governance.”American Review of Public Administration36 (1): 98–114.
75.
SørensenEvaTorfingJacob. 2005. “The Democratic Anchorage of Governance Networks.”Scandinavian Political Studies28 (3): 195–218.
76.
SørensenEvaTorfingJacob. 2007a. “Theoretical Approaches to Democratic Network Governance.” In Theories of Democratic Network Governance, edited by SørensenEvaTorfingJacob, 233–46. Basingstoke: Palgrave Macmillan.
77.
SørensenEvaTorfingJacob. 2007b. “Theoretical Approaches to Governance Network Dynamics.” In Theories of Democratic Network Governance, edited by SørensenEvaTorfingJacob, 25–42. Basingstoke: Palgrave Macmillan.
78.
SørensenEvaTorfingJacob. 2009. “Making Governance Networks Effective and Democratic through Metagovernance.”Public Administration87 (2): 234–58.
79.
SørensenEvaTriantafillouPeter, eds. 2009. The Politics of Self-Governance. Farnham, UK: Ashgate.
80.
SteinerReto. 2000. New Public Management in den Schweizer Gemeinden. Based on the Research Project “Gemeindereformen zwischen Handlungsfähigkeit und Legitimation.” www.iop.unibe.ch (accessed November 2008).
81.
SteinerRetoLadnerAndreas. 2006. “Die Schweizer Gemeinden im Fokus—Ergebnisse der Gemeindebefragung 2005” [The Swiss municipalities under scrutiny—Results of the Swiss Municipality Survey 2005]. In Perspektiven für Gemeindefinanzen, edited by GlatthardAlexanderIschUlrich, 8–34. Bern, Switzerland: ESG.
82.
StokerGerry. 1998a. “Governance as Theory: Five Propositions.”International Social Science Journal50:17–28.
83.
StokerGerry. 1998b. “Public-Private Partnerships and Urban Governance.” In Partnerships in Urban Governance: European and American Experience, edited by PierreJon, 34–51. London: Macmillan.
84.
StoneClarence N.1993. “Urban Regimes and the Capacity to Govern: A Political Economy Approach.”Journal of Urban Affairs15 (1): 1–28.
85.
van der HeidenNicoPaulKrummenacher. 2011. “Bringing the Backstage to the Front: The Role of Citizen Forums in Local Development Planning in Switzerland.” In Interactive Policy Making, Metagovernance and Democracy, edited by TorfingJacobTriantafillouPeter, 227–42. Essex: ECPR Press.
86.
WahlkeJohn C.EulauHeinzBuchananWilliamFergusonLeroy C.1962. The Legislative System: Explorations in Legislative Behaviour. New York: Wiley.
87.
WidmerThomasRieder.Stefan2007. “Kantone im Wandel. Reformaktivitäten der Schweizer Kantone zwischen 1990 and 1999: Ursachen, Ausgestaltung und Konsequenzen” [Cantons in change. Reform activities of the Swiss cantons between 1990 and 1999: Causes, configurations and consequences]. Bern, Switzerland: Haupt.
88.
WidmerThomasRüeggErwin. 2005. “Konsequenzen von Staatsformen für die demokratische Steuerungsfähigkeit. Vergleichende Analysen zu vier Schweizer Kantonen” [Consequences of Different Systems of Government on the Democratic Steering Capacity. Comparative Analyses of Four Swiss Cantons]. Politische Vierteljahresschrift46:86–109.
